Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think councils should move people to smaller properties when kids move out?

417 replies

Faithin · 27/09/2022 16:20

There's a huge lack of 3 bedroom social housing where I live (and everywhere I think?)
a lot of the people living in the 3 bed places are usually just 1 or 2 adults as the kids have grown up and moved out. Meanwhile there's lots of young families overcrowded in 1 and 2 bed flats with no garden etc
aibu to think those that actually need the space should be in the houses and those who don't should be made to downsize?
as the waiting list is so long, what tends to happen is peoples children are in their teens by the time they are moved into a 3 bed property, the grow up and leave within a couple of years and the parents stay, so the vast majority are under-occupied.

OP posts:
YellowTreeHouse · 27/09/2022 17:58

YANBU. It is not their property and they are being unbelievably selfish staying in them.

As soon as their kids are gone they should be made to relocate.

Lucyshavingaparty · 27/09/2022 17:58

I wonder what the bank would say to me if I missed a payment and I told them they couldn't repossess because I like gardening and I need to use the spare room for visitors. Similarly, I wonder what a landlord who had asked me to move would say in a similar scenario. Why should social tenants have the luxury of a social network etc... when no one else does, unless you pay through the nose for it? Also, people saying 'just build more houses' have failed to consider the impact on the environment. I'm afraid more houses is the last thing we need.

Tumbleweed101 · 27/09/2022 17:58

Assured tenancies are given to ensure there are stable communities where children can grow up in one place and older people have the benefit of friends and neighbours they can trust.

Transient communities generally dont care so much for their properties or neighbours. The housing stock would soon become run down if people didn't spend out to decorate and improve them. It makes sense for long term tenancies to be provided.

I'm in a council property and have been for 17 years. Two of my children were born in this house and have gone to the local schools. It's a rural area so the community is quite tight knit. In principle I'd be willing to downsize when my children are grown and leave home, so long as the rent was cheaper, I kept a spare bedroom for my children to stay when needed and I still had a garden, even if smaller. I'm happy to compromise but wouldn't want a one bed flat in a tower block in exchange for the tenancy that means I could stay here for life.

I very much agree that the housing situation is very difficult but moving people from place to place isnt the answer.

Openrelationship · 27/09/2022 17:57

It’s not true to say there aren’t smaller properties for them to move into. The majority of people seeking a 3 bed are families who have lived in 2 bedroom council houses for years, and their children have now reached an age where they qualify for 3 beds (usually when oldest is around age 10) but they are waiting for years. I don’t understand why the HA’s (as they’re not usually council owned anymore) don’t just force a swap from the underoccupied with the overoccupied.
The bedroom tax was a farce as it didn’t apply to pensioners.
Social housing needs a huge overhaul.

Cornettoninja · 27/09/2022 17:57

They are relying on someone else to support a basic need

given all the interventions with mortgages, stamp duties and ftb deals I’m going to say that people who haven’t received, directly or indirectly, some sort of ‘support’ to acquire a ‘basic need’ has been received by a large proportion of the population.

That’s before even thinking about those who’ve had substantial family help. It’d be interesting to trace back the proportion who have indirectly benefitted because of a previous generation originally needing that basic support and gaining right to buy…

Fuwari · 27/09/2022 17:57

This again, yawn!

Everyone has to take their turn. I was also at one time stuck in a 2 bed flat with 2 dc (opposite sexes) looking at all the old people "hogging" 3 bed houses. I had to wait until mine were teens to get a 3 bed. That's how it works.

I then managed a canny swap and got myself into a lovely 4bed. (At the time, 2005, my HA would allow you to swap into somewhere with 1 more bedroom than needed) Beautiful house (Victorian on a private street) brilliant location. Like hell am I ever giving it up and I have a secure tenancy so it is mine till I die! You don't like that, tough.

My HA offer 1k per bedroom to downsize. I'd need at least a 2 bed as autistic DS will probably always live with me. That's 2k I'd get and I have spent several times that on doing up this house. It just isn't worth it. I have paid my own rent since I moved in so the bedroom tax doesn't matter.

I am going to enjoy my house to the fullest. Random strangers stuck in whatever they're stuck in is of no concern to me. That's life.

autyspauty · 27/09/2022 17:57

Brefugee · 27/09/2022 16:26

there is a MASSIVE lack of smaller properties. Best thing to do is vote for parties who support a massive programme of building social housing

fuck building more to sell them off again. they should start serious buy back schemes.

And also incentives moving to a smaller property with a cash incentive. Imagine your children move out, you stop receiving child benefit but you know that you can move into a 2 or 1 bed property and get £6000 cash. So many people would do it. So many fucking people would do it.

ofwarren · 27/09/2022 17:56

TimBoothseyes · 27/09/2022 17:54

So it's never been painted, never had flooring, no curtain rails, no lightshades? Really?

Exactly!
You get given a shell of a building. We ended up having to get a loan to buy all the things we need to even make it livable. Still paying it back years later.

SwordToFlamethrower · 27/09/2022 17:54

No. It is cruel. That is someone's beloved home. They just expect parents to fork out thousands for removals, deposits, new furniture, carpets and curtains???
Just build more houses and stop penalising regular people.

TimBoothseyes · 27/09/2022 17:54

Ahbisto · 27/09/2022 17:50

Yeah pretty much it does.

So it's never been painted, never had flooring, no curtain rails, no lightshades? Really?

OhmygodDont · 27/09/2022 17:53

Swapping should be easier as well I think.

if two people are happy to swap houses providing one isn’t trying to upsize when it isn’t need they should be allowed to get on with it.

someone moving from a three to a two is better than them not moving at all.

ancientgran · 27/09/2022 17:53

I remember in the 1960s in the city where I lived they built one bedroom bungalows for the over 60s which were low rent and very easy to heat. They were an attractive option for people, sometimes the carrot works better than the stick.

It was probably in the 1980s that locally they emptied a 12 storey block of flats and put in facilities for the elderly like one of the flats on the ground floor became a community area where the tenants could organise activities. It went from being a bit of a rough place to being a popular choice and I think they did the same with a neighbouring block. That first block will have freed up nearly 50 houses for families and provided something positive for the people who moved into it.

I think a bit of creative thinking could achieve a good outcome for both groups.

Pollydon · 27/09/2022 17:53

Ahbisto · 27/09/2022 17:05

So like any other private rent they shouldn’t decorate or floor it.

Why not go the whole hog and just give them cardboard boxes to live in ?
My god, some people have no idea of their privileges and sneer on those beneath them. Nasty.

User4738737383647474 · 27/09/2022 17:52

Your point is valid and it would make sense but where do you suggest the people under occupying 3 bed properties to move to? There is a shortage of 1 bed places too. Cannot kick them out on the streets, most would not afford private rent.

so YABU unless you have a solution to where they can live??

where I live there were barely any one bed places. Council flats aren't really a thing in my area, just houses and some bungalows for older people.

also, quite frankly it's their home. For many it's all they've ever known, raised their kids there etc!

I grew up in a street with 1970s built council houses. Ours was council but the issue was that I would say over 50 percent of the houses were bought by the tenants under Thatcher and now privately owned, in more recent times many are private let out for extortionate prices! That is a massive contributing factor in the lack of social housing in many areas - Maggie Bloody Thatcher.

Lifewillbethedeathofme · 27/09/2022 17:51

Council houses have different tenancies so that the residents feel secure. The homes can be in poor condition and need to be looked after , decorated and have flooring installed etc so the responsibility for them is different to the private sector. Residents invest a lot of money into the properties.

Not that long ago over a third of the population lives in social housing with a mix of families , older people who had a variety of jobs etc. People should be cross that there is a lack of suitable housing , however, the blame is not with people where children have grown.

ofwarren · 27/09/2022 17:51

Ahbisto · 27/09/2022 17:44

Have you never seen a council house?

ffs for the third time I grew up in one, all my neighbours were also in them and my parents still in them and they don’t all look like that, give it a rest/

What do you mean by "don't floor it" then? If I hadn't floored mine, my 2 babies at the time would have been living in a dusty cold house. I couldn't let them crawl on the floors or they would get covered in dust or cut themselves.

lannistunut · 27/09/2022 17:51

Ahbisto · 27/09/2022 17:43

they are social housing tenants.

so by using the word tenant you do understand it’s rented accommodation? As this seemed to be something you were arguing against.

we do not live in a communist state. Social housing should be available based on need. It should never have been a life long right because it’s led to abuse.

It has nothing to do with communism, you seem a little confused. Britain has never been communist.

Ahbisto · 27/09/2022 17:50

TimBoothseyes · 27/09/2022 17:46

Of course they don't because the tenants have made it how they wanted it. Does your parents house look the same as it did when they moved in? If not, why not?

Yeah pretty much it does.

Cornettoninja · 27/09/2022 17:50

Ahbisto · 27/09/2022 17:43

they are social housing tenants.

so by using the word tenant you do understand it’s rented accommodation? As this seemed to be something you were arguing against.

we do not live in a communist state. Social housing should be available based on need. It should never have been a life long right because it’s led to abuse.

It’s led to abuse? How exactly? By people living in it?

NalaNana · 27/09/2022 17:49

Separate issue but I can't believe that they are homes for life with no thresholds! My friend's partner has just got a new job and their annual combined income will now be over £50,000 (up north). I asked them if the new job would mean they would have to leave and couldn't believe it when they said no, when you're in the system, you're in! Surely council housing should be available for those who need it?!

stripeyzeb · 27/09/2022 17:49

I grew up in a HA home, along with my siblings and parents. One by one we've all left and now it's just my dad on his own, but it's been the family home for 42 years. The thought of being forced to move would be agony for dad. I realise there's a housing shortage but evicting people from their homes to make room for bigger families would be very cruel.

Sapphire387 · 27/09/2022 17:48

Or we could invest in building a lot more social housing and then there wouldn't be such an urgent need to ask these people to downsize.

oddoneoutalways · 27/09/2022 17:48

Ahbisto · 27/09/2022 16:55

I think there is a lot of emotion tied to this and that’s why tenancies for life are being scaled out. I personally believe social housing should be reviewed annually as to the need and if the need no longer exists then end the tenancy And move to either a smaller property or to a private rental if income has increased past the level you’d currently be eligible/

my opinion is they should be there to fill a need for as long as it is an actual need/

I agree with this.

It's no harsher to say that someone in social housing should downsize if their needs change than it is to say that I need to downsize if I can't pay my mortgage anymore because of circumstances outside of my control. It would upset me greatly to do so but if I ever can't pay then that's exactly what would happen! I couldn't say 'please don't repossess me, I really like my home and where I live and I've spent loads of money and time on my garden!', could I?!

Private renters have to move out of their homes all the time, on the whims of landlords who decide to sell etc.

It is difficult, but that's life I'm afraid. No way should a couple whose children have grown up and moved out be allowed to stay in a 3 bed because they like their garden and their home when another family is overcrowded across the town. It's ludicrous.

Requirements should be assessed annually, and people placed in suitable homes for their current requirements not what they'd like in an ideal world. I also agree that we need more social housing - that goes without saying!

Beachbreak2411 · 27/09/2022 17:48

This is a tough one; I completely get the fact bigger properties are needed and overcrowding etc (I waited 3 years for our house.. in a crappy b&b and then a awful tiny flat). But those houses become homes! My dd is a way off leaving home yet but I’d be gutted to be booted out of our home once she leaves for uni (10’ish years away) as I’ve done work on it, made it our home!!

candycaneframe · 27/09/2022 17:47

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.