Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think councils should move people to smaller properties when kids move out?

417 replies

Faithin · 27/09/2022 16:20

There's a huge lack of 3 bedroom social housing where I live (and everywhere I think?)
a lot of the people living in the 3 bed places are usually just 1 or 2 adults as the kids have grown up and moved out. Meanwhile there's lots of young families overcrowded in 1 and 2 bed flats with no garden etc
aibu to think those that actually need the space should be in the houses and those who don't should be made to downsize?
as the waiting list is so long, what tends to happen is peoples children are in their teens by the time they are moved into a 3 bed property, the grow up and leave within a couple of years and the parents stay, so the vast majority are under-occupied.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
BigFatLiar · 29/02/2024 16:38

I doubt that there are that many smaller houses available to move to. OH grew up in council housing, a good size three bedroom with a decent sized garden. It wasn't just a house it was their home. It was a nice neighbourhood with good neighbours. I doubt the idea of his parents moving to a strange smaller place where they knew no one would have gone down well. Lots of room for when we visited and the girls loved the big garden.

Grapewrath · 29/02/2024 15:45

I’m in a 3 bed house with two young adults. When they move out I’d be happy to downsize but all of the recent home are affordable rent, not social so I’d be paying far more for a smaller property as I’m in social rent. I can’t afford to absorb that cost on my current income.
if the rent was like for like I’d be more than tbh

Teajenny7 · 28/02/2024 20:24

Typo
NOT introduced the 'right to buy'

Teajenny7 · 28/02/2024 20:19

It would be better if they had 'right to buy' at massive discounts. Often it was the tenants relatives who supplied the loan. Then began acquiring more properties for renting out often back to the council.

Waiting for a council house is nothing new. My parents joined the waiting list in 1959 when they got married ( before starting a family). They never actually got a house or flat before they died in the 1990s. They didn't resent that others who had a council house.

Good council tenants make the house or flat their own home. They look after it and invest in it. Those lucky enough to have garden spend a lot making them look nice.
Good tenants make communities.

Flensburg · 28/02/2024 19:35

Do children deserve gardens more than adults?

Seymour5 · 28/02/2024 19:31

We are an ageing population, if the right kind of retirement housing was available and affordable, I’m sure more of us would move. One of my better off friends has just bought a lovely, two bedroomed flat, enough room for a visitor, or a grandchild to stay. However, it cost more than the large, two bathroomed house she sold. Most of us can’t afford that.

Also, more families live at a distance these days, we don’t all have children or grandchildren nearby. It’s a big load off their minds if their parents can access suitable, secure housing in the later stages of life. That has the added bonus of freeing up more family sized homes for younger families.

LadyBird1973 · 28/02/2024 13:18

This is the thing - people are blaming each other instead of looking at what needs to be done to encourage change.
No one is going to swap a home they've worked on and improved, for a grotty flat miles from their community, that's not even cheaper. Their argument will be why should they sacrifice their standard of living because other people have kids - not their circus etc.

OTOH, if you build bungalows with easily manageable gardens, in the same communities (with reduced rents) and renovate the flats so they have decent kitchens and bathrooms and aren't in a state because they've been knocked to shit by the previous tenants, you will incentivise people to move. My own parents did a house swap with a neighbour because she had a smaller house but with a better garden and needed more bedrooms, whereas my parents needed fewer rooms but valued the garden more. Carrot, not stick!

Tumbleweed101 · 27/02/2024 21:06

My dad has a 3 bed council property in London. He lives there alone now. He looked seriously at downsizing and moving to my area (2hrs out of London). The property he was considered for was a tiny one bed bungalow without a proper garden (He has a dog) and double the rent of his three bed house with a garden and good public transport (he had cancer and couldn't drive for a while). Until there is real incentive to move then people won't be leaving a long term home where they raised families and have friends and memories.

I also rent a council property- 3 bed - and I have four children. I'd consider downsizing as in my older age i may find the garden difficult to maintain and I'd be happy for a young family to take the additional space. But only if the home I got offered was a good swap. I'd want a 2 bed bungalow with a small garden, for example. Rent no higher than my current rent. Otherwise why would I swap to be worse off than staying put?

Sugarplumfairy65 · 27/02/2024 20:36

Treehuggingmutherfunkin · 26/02/2024 23:21

Yes they should. Council homes were not meant to be life long homes it was starters now everyone just lives in them till they die which is why there is none

A council house has always been for life.

Seymour5 · 27/02/2024 18:12

Ali1262 · 27/02/2024 14:15

Thank you for this. I have had the same argument with my local council. My son is in the military and comes home every leave. His home is my address his camp is his work address but they still say I have to pay the bedroom tax it's maddening

Anyone paying their rent themselves (without means tested benefits) pays the designated amount for the social housing property they occupy. The ‘bedroom tax’ is such a misnomer, it essentially means that anyone under state retirement age will only get housing benefit/an amount in Universal Credit that equates to the size of property they are entitled to. So a single person in a three bedroomed house will have to make up the difference, or downsize to a one bedroomed home.

Those unfortunate enough not to get social housing, ie private renters, have always had their housing benefits based on appropriately sized property, and even then it can be capped with the tenant making up the shortfall.

Perhaps your son could make up the difference?

BobbyBiscuits · 27/02/2024 14:35

@Treehuggingmutherfunkin As others have said this is wide off the mark. It sounds almost like you have never lived in the UK, or known anyone who has?

NotQuiteNorma · 27/02/2024 14:32

Faithin · 27/09/2022 16:36

they are hardly going to be moved across the country, they'd be moved within the same borough because it would be with the same council.

You are aware many boroughs are sending tenants hundreds of miles away already?

cardibach · 27/02/2024 14:31

Faithin · 27/09/2022 16:36

they are hardly going to be moved across the country, they'd be moved within the same borough because it would be with the same council.

That may mean close in a city. Have you seen how big some more rural council areas are? As people get older, they need to maintain social networks.

JenniferBooth · 27/02/2024 14:26

Maybe if people in relationships got to know each other properly instead of having babies together almost straight away they wouldnt end up splitting up and end up needing two homes instead of one.

Ali1262 · 27/02/2024 14:15

Brokendaughter · 27/09/2022 16:45

YABU.

It's all very well saying that, but life isn't always that simple.

At what point do you throw them out of the home they have decorated/furnished?
The second their oldest child goes to Uni?
After all, some children never really return home except to visit, so why should that child still have a home?
Then downgrade again if a second child leaves?

Who is paying for all these moves, what happens to all their stuff?
Why would you introduce so much instability into peoples lives when part of the intention of social housing is to provide some stability?

How about instead of them moving their parent in to care for them, the state can pay for that parent to be in a care home as they definitely won't have the space?

Or what if their uni child needs somewhere to live after uni or if it just doesn't work out?
Should they be homeless because after decades of being occupied, a room was empty for a few months?

What about the younger unmarried kids who join the military?
Don't they get homes to return to between postings?

What about the family who choose to become a foster family once their own children are grown?
Shall we just leave those kids without a home because you don't like the idea of someone having a cm more space for a bit?

What about disabled people who need an extra room for their overnight carer or equipment due to their disability?

A home isn't just about how many rooms are in it.

Thank you for this. I have had the same argument with my local council. My son is in the military and comes home every leave. His home is my address his camp is his work address but they still say I have to pay the bedroom tax it's maddening

mummymeister · 27/02/2024 13:45

If you go back and read the very origins of the provision of social housing the reason that council estates consisted of a mix of sizes was so that people could move between them according to need. so a young married couple might start in a one bedroom house then if they have children move to a 2, 3 or 4 and then when the children themselves moved out the couple would then downsize the other way. But, and this is the key point, they would be staying in broadly the same area with each move so no need to uproot in terms of family, friends and support networks. I also like the origins of the peabody trust properties in London. you moved in if your salary was below national average wage - so usually if you were a student, leaving home for the first time, first job that sort of thing. if you then earned over national average way ( i think it was 10%) then you were given a year to move out and go either into private rented or buy your own. that way there was constant churn and the cheaper properties that they were were occupied by those less able to afford them. people might not want to move to downsize but these are likely the same ones who upsized when multiple children came along.

Cornettoninja · 27/02/2024 13:38

Kendodd · 27/02/2024 13:25

Why does your mum deserve that house ? And why is the fact it wasn't built as a council house make a difference?

I’m missing something too. Surely if the council hadn’t stepped in she’d have had to sell it and seek housing from the council or buy a smaller property depending on equity and her ex’s claim anyway? She swopped the benefit of home ownership for not having to move her family whilst she needed the house.

I’m not saying she should be forced but she’s only there because of using council resources. Her position isn’t any different to anyone else in social housing.

Kendodd · 27/02/2024 13:29

WhileMyGuitarGentlyWeeps · 29/09/2022 11:35

This. ^ If the jealous haters had their way, they would be forcing all children to move out by the age of 21

I know how much harder things are for young people these days. They can't even get council house previous generations could. I know I'm very lucky to be able to do this but I plan to sell my big expensive house, that I won't need anymore, when my children are young adults, and buy them a small house each with the money.

Kendodd · 27/02/2024 13:25

AlwaysChangingNames123 · 27/02/2024 09:38

Not every council house was originally a council house though.

My mum had to sell her house to the council after her and my dad split up and he stopped contributing his half to the mortgage.

Its a beautiful 4 bed detached house with massive gardens and a garage. She had to sell it whilst we were all still living in it as teenagers.

We are all adults now and theres only 1 adult child left at home.

Why should my mum downsize to a small shit 2 bed council house or flat when she has poured over 25 years of her money / time / love into her house. What if one of us divorces ect and have to move back home?

She pays the excess bedroom tax ect so I think she should be able to stay there until she dies. It's not her fault her life went down this path and she tried so so hard to stop it being this way

I remember being 14 and going to work with my mum as a cleaner. She was so excited to get her first ever paycheck and her face dropped when she opened it. It was for 400 and odd pound and the mortgage alone was 800.

Fuck, that makes me want to cry remembering how upset she was and how much she tried and tried to keep that house

So maybe for your average council house yes, but not every council house was originally one and not everyone living in a council house that's too big for them is greedy ect

My mum deserves that house and all its spare bedrooms

Why does your mum deserve that house ? And why is the fact it wasn't built as a council house make a difference?

gabsdot · 27/02/2024 10:08

I am inclined to agree with you. My MIL has lived in the same council house for over 40 years. They built some appartments 2 minutes walk from when she lives and she was offered a transfer but she refused, vehimently. Personally I think she should have moved. She would have got a nice new place all on one level. But she's older now and doesn't like change and she has nice neighbours. I understand why she wouldn't move.

MIL also has a friend who lives alone in a 4 bed council house. She has poor mobility so she barely uses the upstairs. Such a waste.

Maybe the expectation with council housing should be different. You get the house for as long as you need it. If people knew that at the start it would make it easier to get people to move.

GasPanic · 27/02/2024 09:53

Yes.

We are in a housing crisis. To help get out of that crisis we need to maximise our use of the space available.

Or alternatively we can build more houses/stop importing people.

Maths meets reality.

AlwaysChangingNames123 · 27/02/2024 09:38

Treehuggingmutherfunkin · 26/02/2024 23:21

Yes they should. Council homes were not meant to be life long homes it was starters now everyone just lives in them till they die which is why there is none

Not every council house was originally a council house though.

My mum had to sell her house to the council after her and my dad split up and he stopped contributing his half to the mortgage.

Its a beautiful 4 bed detached house with massive gardens and a garage. She had to sell it whilst we were all still living in it as teenagers.

We are all adults now and theres only 1 adult child left at home.

Why should my mum downsize to a small shit 2 bed council house or flat when she has poured over 25 years of her money / time / love into her house. What if one of us divorces ect and have to move back home?

She pays the excess bedroom tax ect so I think she should be able to stay there until she dies. It's not her fault her life went down this path and she tried so so hard to stop it being this way

I remember being 14 and going to work with my mum as a cleaner. She was so excited to get her first ever paycheck and her face dropped when she opened it. It was for 400 and odd pound and the mortgage alone was 800.

Fuck, that makes me want to cry remembering how upset she was and how much she tried and tried to keep that house

So maybe for your average council house yes, but not every council house was originally one and not everyone living in a council house that's too big for them is greedy ect

My mum deserves that house and all its spare bedrooms

eatdrinkandbemerry · 27/02/2024 09:33

It's crazy.
I'm overcrowded in a two bedroom but my next door neighbour is single in a three bedroom.
He offered to swap ( he's never worked so never paid a penny in rent).
The council wouldn't allow it because my house is too big for him 😳
So if we wanted to swap he would have to find a one bedroom and swap with someone who wanted a two bedroom and then I would have to swap with them!
Honestly it's crazy.

Beezknees · 27/02/2024 07:09

Magic83 · 26/02/2024 21:55

My daughter has moved out and im still paying full rent. Im worried that the council might make me and my son move into a smaller property if i tell them

This is an old thread, you'll be bettet starting your own if you want advice.

Magic83 · 27/02/2024 07:07

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Swipe left for the next trending thread