Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Do you agree with these benefits?

328 replies

Sophieleigh26 · 27/09/2022 16:18

Do you think the amount people get in benefits (before deductions like earnings) is the right amount, or it should be more / less?

MONTHLY AMOUNT
Single & under 25 £265.31
Single & over 25 £334.91
Couple both under 25 £416.45
Couple over 25 £525.72

£244.58 extra allowance for children (up to 2 children)

A single parent not working (24) with one child (1) would receive £509.89 a month, before deductions (loans, debt etc)

obviously these are just summaries and there are different rules if you have children born before 2017, for example, or disabilities, childcare costs.

YABU - It seems ok / right
YANBU - It should be more / less

OP posts:
palygold · 28/09/2022 10:10

weekendninja · 28/09/2022 09:51

Yes, they are low but if you increase them where is the incentive?

I'm all for increasing benefits for the disabled and assistance between gaining employment but for the most part benefits are not a long term option; some people soon to think it is.

The amount of people that I know that won't increase their hours because it's not worth it/want to spend quality time with their DC is astonishing. Increase it and what is really the point of us working? This country is on its knees and those that can have a part to play.

It is temporary help though, so shouldn't that be adequate if you're between jobs and have possibly depleted any savings?
Aren't people sanctioned if they're not able to prove they're looking for, and applying for, work?

I'm trying to understand really. It sounds like some sort of overhaul is needed?

weekendninja · 28/09/2022 09:51

Yes, they are low but if you increase them where is the incentive?

I'm all for increasing benefits for the disabled and assistance between gaining employment but for the most part benefits are not a long term option; some people soon to think it is.

The amount of people that I know that won't increase their hours because it's not worth it/want to spend quality time with their DC is astonishing. Increase it and what is really the point of us working? This country is on its knees and those that can have a part to play.

MerlinsButler · 28/09/2022 09:42

The whole benefits system needs an overhaul. The benefits system absolutely should not be subsidising companies who pay minimum wage (which is too low) whilst making huge profits. It's a disgrace in this country that people can be working a NMW job and still need UC top-ups ( childcare funding is obviously different)

The benefit system absolutely should be subsidising those who cannot work whether due to disability / illness / caring for disabled children etc. And these amounts paid should be higher and set at a rate that is liveable on without any kind of penury or punishment.

Likewise carers allowance should be at a liveable wage level. In effect carers are saving the councils thousands by what they do and the allowance ( stupid name for it) should reflect that. They should be paid and be entitled to pensions etc as if they were employed by the council to provide that care .

For those able to work / job seeking it should be set at a level that you can survive on but it should be time limited - it should be a safety net not a lifestyle choice and yes people do choose to remain on UC rather than work and it is disingenuous to believe they don't.
They then do cash in hand jobs / move Partners in off the radar etc and live quite happily. If you don't live in Mumsnet middle class utopia you can see this everywhere. They are fairly brazen about it.

The benefit system should help those who cannot work much more than it does and those who won't work much less.

MoCaine · 28/09/2022 09:35

CandlesBlanketsandTea · 28/09/2022 06:54

Obviously these benefits are not enough. If you have a car or any debt when you claim benefits you are truly screwed. There are also plenty of people who suffer illness, or have an accident who can't work but don't qualify for PIP. The benefits are just so low and it leaves people desperate.

With more automation we will end up with less people needing to work, and some people frankly aren't up to it. I think we will move to a universal basic income. We really need to focus our anger at the high earners, and large corporations who are hiding billions that should be paid in taxes.

Also fun fact, the majority of us will never pay into the system what we take out, so anyone using that argument should consider earning more to put more in the pot.

''we need to focus our anger on high earners''

i don't know about that, but the sun, daily mail, express are all good at pitting us against each other, like the ''disabled'' guy thats running around in a brand new SUV for free, when in fact a whole chuck of his benefit is taken from him to pay for it, and they also don't see him unable to get out of bed on a bad day.

basically the posh/rich have always been posh and rich, they've never been in our firing line, when people we perceive to be lesser than ourselves seem to be getting on, then we see the toys coming out of the pram and people buying into the shit the centre right media sells us.

MoCaine · 28/09/2022 09:22

they're way too high, i gave my fellow tory chum £2.6 million for 100 boxes of out of date unusable face masks during the pandemic, i need to make cuts somewhere, and as these plebs probably don't vote for my cult,.......

Paigeycakey · 28/09/2022 09:15

XPD · 28/09/2022 09:00

It's a joke saying PIP is Hugh. I get £333 a month.

Not a lot when I have to pay for a Gardner, cleaner, cabs, loan for an adapted bathroom and dishwasher. I even pay someone to wash my hair twice a week because I can't.

PIP is a huge benefit. Sorry but it is. I have a few members who recieve it. You can also work along side PIP and its not affected. Is there different rates to PIP?

XPD · 28/09/2022 09:00

It's a joke saying PIP is Hugh. I get £333 a month.

Not a lot when I have to pay for a Gardner, cleaner, cabs, loan for an adapted bathroom and dishwasher. I even pay someone to wash my hair twice a week because I can't.

Sirzy · 28/09/2022 08:36

£69 is such a significant amount extra for the fact that I have had to give up work to care for my son. The idea of it not being 35 a week is laughable too.

Underhisi · 28/09/2022 08:27

My benefit for working at least 35 hours a week is 69.70.

Some people are under the impression that the NHS or Council provides all specialist equipment for disabled people. It doesn't. My teenagers specialist buggy, specialist sleeping space ( costing thousands), safety products and alterations in the house and most of his continence products were/are funded by us/disability allowance. On top of this is extra day to day costs of a profoundly disabled child.

vivainsomnia · 28/09/2022 08:22

If you don't have caring responsibilities, nor disabilities, there are no reasons why you shouldn't be working. In this instance, it is right that benefits should only cover the minimum for what should be a short time.

If you are disabled or care for a disabled person, benefits go up significantly, often more than the average salary.

If you have children, you should get CMS. Once the children are over 5, you should be working FT and claim help with childcare. It won't pay all but you should still be better off than claiming benefits.

TigerRag · 28/09/2022 08:03

ItsJustLittleOlMe · 27/09/2022 22:14

Yes, this. I've just had a baby and had a relationship breakdown, so am reliant on UC atm. It isn't a lot (it's as is said in the OP actually). However I am grateful for the help I receive. On the other hand, disability benefits are a lot. I know this as I am the appointee for my parent so deal with all of their money.

Do you know how expensive being disabled really is? Scope did research and it's around £583 per month. I've had to take out a loan (provided by the company with no interest charged) to buy a piece of equipment just so I can read. And a lot of the basic things (landline phone, mobile phone, laptop, etc) you buy are more expensive because as a disabled person, they need to be adapted. I bought my first landline phone when I moved out in 2015 for £10. I started losing my hearing about 9 months later. My adapted phone cost me £50.

I have to pay for care.

Disability benefits really aren't as much as you think they are.

A lot of the things disabled people need aren't provided by the NHS. I could get a magnifying glass from them; but they're actually not that helpful. My current electronic one (where I can change the background colour and magnification level) cost me around £700. My talking one cost me around £2500.

120go · 28/09/2022 08:03

urbanbuddha · 27/09/2022 22:55

Poor people live in poor places. That is how it should be, it's not some injustice.

Dear God!

The poor must take responsibility for their poverty. Ignore the injustices created by inherited wealth.

Who cleans the hospitals, who serves the meals in fancy restaurants charging more than a week's benefits for a single meal, who looks after the children in this Utopia of yours. Or do the poor travel hours to their minimum wage jobs because that's what they deserve. The poor must be punished for being poor. What an appalling view to have.

Why would any company choose to pay more than the bare minimum when people like you force the taxpayer to top them up to market rate?

Perversion of market forces is the reason for so many problems in our society.

CandlesBlanketsandTea · 28/09/2022 06:54

Obviously these benefits are not enough. If you have a car or any debt when you claim benefits you are truly screwed. There are also plenty of people who suffer illness, or have an accident who can't work but don't qualify for PIP. The benefits are just so low and it leaves people desperate.

With more automation we will end up with less people needing to work, and some people frankly aren't up to it. I think we will move to a universal basic income. We really need to focus our anger at the high earners, and large corporations who are hiding billions that should be paid in taxes.

Also fun fact, the majority of us will never pay into the system what we take out, so anyone using that argument should consider earning more to put more in the pot.

Shoxfordian · 28/09/2022 05:44

It does seem quite low, I don’t know why it’s less for under 25s either- presumably the costs of living are the same.

WanderingFruitWonderer · 28/09/2022 05:27

Too low; and obscene that under 25s get less. It's pure ageism.
The crazy narrative that benefit claimants have made it a lifestyle choice is nearly always false in my opinion. I'll never understand why people pick on the poor.

WeisheitNurInWahrheit · 28/09/2022 04:19

heresamarshmallow · 27/09/2022 23:30

There seems to be this weird mentality of “why would people WANT to work when they can get nearly minimum wage by being on benefits”

And that thought process doesn’t extend to “oh, maybe minimum wage is too low”… (which it is, as are UC payments)

Also worth noting that if you’re in receipt of disability benefits, and you move in with a partner, you lose them. Even though they’re paid to you, for a reason, and it’s your income. There’s just this assumption that you will become entirely financial dependent on your partner. It’s a very precarious situation to be in.

To clarify the important point made by heresamarshmallow, while you will continue to receive DLA/PIP (they’re not means tested) you stop receiving ESA/UC (or receive a reduced amount) because they will be expected to support you completely.

The government are well aware that disabled people - particularly disabled women - are at much higher risk of domestic abuse of all kinds. For example, Public Health England wrote a report in 2015; & as Women’s Aid point out, the 1995 British Crime Survey showed disabled women are twice as likely to experience domestic violence than non-disabled women.

Despite this; & despite knowing DLA/PIP are frequently not enough (as per the Scope research I mentioned in my earlier post) to cover the extra costs faced by disabled people; the government choose to put disabled people in a situation of being completely financially dependent on their partner if they move in together. There isn’t even a mechanism to pause a claim as some kind of safety-net: as soon as you move in together your ESA/UC is gone; & if you break up you’ll have to make a new claim.

Mumof3girlsandaboy · 28/09/2022 01:56

ForeverFailing · 27/09/2022 19:37

Not having to pay rent, council tax, prescriptions, school meals, dental costs etc I would say it’s about right.
UC is an in work benefit and in most circumstances people are better off in work. Those who honestly can’t work get extra, as do carers and those with disabled children

This!

Mumof3girlsandaboy · 28/09/2022 01:47

XenoBitch · 27/09/2022 17:30

How many of those vacancies are full time? So many are part time with not much option to get a full time job. Someone has to do the low paid jobs

Honestly, this whole "there are more jobs than there are unemployed" trope is so done.
I have a relative who has a cleaning company and is advertising (so one of these jobs) for a cleaner to work once a fortnight for two hours. Yeah, that will get someone off of benefits.

Absolutely!

XPD · 28/09/2022 00:09
  1. Minimum wage needs to be higher
  2. Childcare costs need more funding

You will ALWAYS get a minority of people who want to live on benefits, who see them as a way of life. Its a small % though and others who are disabled, unemployed for a short amount of time or are raising young children need to get more.

I wish benefits were given on a case by case basis.

whatsthestory123 · 27/09/2022 23:53

it is low if your just on the basic the only way you could up it is if you get CMS payments but sadly many dont seem to want to pay for their children

Choopi · 27/09/2022 23:44

It's insanely low. I don't know why people talk about uk benefits being generous. There would be outrage where I am if those were the going rates.

sweetkitty · 27/09/2022 23:42

I don’t understand how a friend can work 16 hours a week and still keep her UC, yet if she works full time she’s much worse off? Surely the system is flawed somewhere, full time work should always pay more.

whatsthestory123 · 27/09/2022 23:39

hamsterchump · 27/09/2022 23:06

Maybe put down the binoculars and logbook, close the curtains, stop watching your neighbours and imagining their situation is a large scale problem?

Seriously, how would you know this level of detail unless you're just referring to one or two not very representative anecdotal examples that have got you all excited?

lol do you not have friends do you not live where neighbours know each other do your adult kids not have friends that you have known for years

you sound like you dont really know what is going on in the country,or you live in a wealthy area where you never see your neighbours and you just interact with people like yourself

i dont have any binoculars and logbook i dont need to im in the thick of it not everybody lives the MN dream

heresamarshmallow · 27/09/2022 23:33

Oh, and apologies if I’ve missed others mention this, but Carer’s Allowance is considered taxable income.

heresamarshmallow · 27/09/2022 23:30

There seems to be this weird mentality of “why would people WANT to work when they can get nearly minimum wage by being on benefits”

And that thought process doesn’t extend to “oh, maybe minimum wage is too low”… (which it is, as are UC payments)

Also worth noting that if you’re in receipt of disability benefits, and you move in with a partner, you lose them. Even though they’re paid to you, for a reason, and it’s your income. There’s just this assumption that you will become entirely financial dependent on your partner. It’s a very precarious situation to be in.

Swipe left for the next trending thread