Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Do you agree with these benefits?

328 replies

Sophieleigh26 · 27/09/2022 16:18

Do you think the amount people get in benefits (before deductions like earnings) is the right amount, or it should be more / less?

MONTHLY AMOUNT
Single & under 25 £265.31
Single & over 25 £334.91
Couple both under 25 £416.45
Couple over 25 £525.72

£244.58 extra allowance for children (up to 2 children)

A single parent not working (24) with one child (1) would receive £509.89 a month, before deductions (loans, debt etc)

obviously these are just summaries and there are different rules if you have children born before 2017, for example, or disabilities, childcare costs.

YABU - It seems ok / right
YANBU - It should be more / less

OP posts:
TigerRag · 01/10/2022 13:26

ItsJustLittleOlMe · 01/10/2022 10:03

Considering that I am, as I stated, the appointee for my mums finances and deal with all things financial, yes, I do know what things cost her.

And you also state that disability benefits aren't what I think they are. Did you miss where I said I was the appointee for my mother? Do you know what that is? It is where I have responsibility for all her DWP benefits, they get paid into my account (I have a separate account for this, but in my name) and this account both receives all of her monthly benefits and pays out all of her monthly expenses, bills, rent etc. I could tell you down to the last penny what my mother receives in benefits monthly. So I not sure where you're getting that I don't know how much disability benefits are.

You do know that all disabilities are different though, surely? You say that it is expensive being disabled...it entirely depends on what your disability is and what care needs that disability requires. My mum doesn't require any of the adaptations that you have listed, she has a manual wheelchair and zimmer provided by the NHS occupational therapy service. Other than that, there isn't anything else she needs to pay for in regards to her disability. Every disability is different, which I'm surprised that you don't seem aware of and are just lumping everyone in together, being that you say you are disabled.

Ergo, you're saying hat disability benefits are generous based on one experience.. I know people who are in debt because of their disability. I've got a friend who had to crowfund for equipment for her child's disability equipment. So much stuff isn't available on the NHS.

Your moter's disability is her. Just because she supposedly gets a load of money that she doesn't need, doesn't mean it's the same for the rest of us.

ItsJustLittleOlMe · 01/10/2022 10:03

TigerRag · 28/09/2022 08:03

Do you know how expensive being disabled really is? Scope did research and it's around £583 per month. I've had to take out a loan (provided by the company with no interest charged) to buy a piece of equipment just so I can read. And a lot of the basic things (landline phone, mobile phone, laptop, etc) you buy are more expensive because as a disabled person, they need to be adapted. I bought my first landline phone when I moved out in 2015 for £10. I started losing my hearing about 9 months later. My adapted phone cost me £50.

I have to pay for care.

Disability benefits really aren't as much as you think they are.

A lot of the things disabled people need aren't provided by the NHS. I could get a magnifying glass from them; but they're actually not that helpful. My current electronic one (where I can change the background colour and magnification level) cost me around £700. My talking one cost me around £2500.

Considering that I am, as I stated, the appointee for my mums finances and deal with all things financial, yes, I do know what things cost her.

And you also state that disability benefits aren't what I think they are. Did you miss where I said I was the appointee for my mother? Do you know what that is? It is where I have responsibility for all her DWP benefits, they get paid into my account (I have a separate account for this, but in my name) and this account both receives all of her monthly benefits and pays out all of her monthly expenses, bills, rent etc. I could tell you down to the last penny what my mother receives in benefits monthly. So I not sure where you're getting that I don't know how much disability benefits are.

You do know that all disabilities are different though, surely? You say that it is expensive being disabled...it entirely depends on what your disability is and what care needs that disability requires. My mum doesn't require any of the adaptations that you have listed, she has a manual wheelchair and zimmer provided by the NHS occupational therapy service. Other than that, there isn't anything else she needs to pay for in regards to her disability. Every disability is different, which I'm surprised that you don't seem aware of and are just lumping everyone in together, being that you say you are disabled.

Crumpleton · 29/09/2022 20:34

MoCaine · 28/09/2022 14:24

i have an imagine of Crumpleton saying to a small boy...''would do you mean you won't fit up the chimney ? Have you even tried ?''

@MoCaine
Chimney??
Jumping on someone's post...
Really shouldn't judge others by your own thoughts...
At least have the balls to put it under your own name.

Inghean · 29/09/2022 17:42

@FrankTheThunderbird Me too. UC acknowledge I'm too ill to work, but I've been on the basic rate £334 for a year. I am choosing between using fuel and eating, and every fortnight I have to sit for days without electricity because it runs out and I cannot top up my meter until UC comes in. So I cannot use my freezer and I've lost weight. Foodbank food is making my health even worse.

People have no idea. There are very very long waits and lots of wrongful declines (70% I think).

Also people forget about the 5 week wait for payment, you then need to take out a loan to pay rent and live, which then reduces your payments to even below the basic level for a whole year whilst it's clawed back.

pointythings · 29/09/2022 17:38

The whole 'don't have kids you can't afford' thing shows a serious lack of thinking. People have kids and then fall on hard times - an accident or serious illness can put someone on the breadline almost overnight. People like to think it couldn't happen to them, but it can. If you're on a low income and just getting by, saving is also not a realistic option - certainly not the amounts needed to be able to live without benefits when disaster strikes.

The 'I'm alright' brigade really need to take a look at what real life is like.

FrankTheThunderbird · 29/09/2022 17:14

I'm "too ill" to work but apparently not ill enough for LCWRA/PIP.

XenoBitch · 29/09/2022 17:07

MsPincher · 29/09/2022 17:00

uc isn’t supposed to be for people who are Ill or disabled though. They are supposed to be able to claim pip or other benefits. Whether or not they get them in practice (or indeed if they are in fact disabled or ill) is another matter.

UC is for people that are ill/disabled. There is an element for it (LCWRA). Not everyone that claims it is on PIP/DLA. PIP/DLA exists to cover the extra costs that someone with a disability may incur, not to pay for the usual day to day things like bills, food ect. That is exactly what UC is for.

MsPincher · 29/09/2022 17:00

LakieLady · 28/09/2022 15:41

No, it's for people who are ill/disabled as well. There are extra amounts that get added, but it takes ages to get those in place.

I was at a PIP appeal last week. The original application was made in April last year. The wait for assessments, decisions, etc is ridiculous.

uc isn’t supposed to be for people who are Ill or disabled though. They are supposed to be able to claim pip or other benefits. Whether or not they get them in practice (or indeed if they are in fact disabled or ill) is another matter.

DashboardConfessional · 29/09/2022 16:52

Dotjones · 29/09/2022 11:21

Single & under 25 £265.31 - too high, should be living with parents
Single & over 25 £334.91 - too low, should be about 4x this value
Couple both under 25 £416.45 - too high, two sets of parents to live with so no excuse
Couple over 25 £525.72 - should be the same combined as the single person gets individually, they can live in a one bed flat the same as a single person

£244.58 extra allowance for children (up to 2 children) - should be zero, don't have kids you can't afford

A single parent not working (24) with one child (1) would receive £509.89 a month, before deductions (loans, debt etc) - too high, should be living with parents at 24 so no payments needed, the parents can support them and the child

Ooh, fab, does living in a 1 bed flat together halve your food bill and transport costs? Where do I get my refund for the last 13 years of cohabitation?

RagingWoke · 29/09/2022 11:53

Dotjones · 29/09/2022 11:21

Single & under 25 £265.31 - too high, should be living with parents
Single & over 25 £334.91 - too low, should be about 4x this value
Couple both under 25 £416.45 - too high, two sets of parents to live with so no excuse
Couple over 25 £525.72 - should be the same combined as the single person gets individually, they can live in a one bed flat the same as a single person

£244.58 extra allowance for children (up to 2 children) - should be zero, don't have kids you can't afford

A single parent not working (24) with one child (1) would receive £509.89 a month, before deductions (loans, debt etc) - too high, should be living with parents at 24 so no payments needed, the parents can support them and the child

It's not as simple as 'should live with parents'

Generally speaking, a person is more likely to need support from benefits if they come from a similar background. It's hard to get out of that cycle, so where parents are also on low incomes it's not necessarily an option that they can just support adult children and their children. Most houses don't have space for that many adults plus dc.

Of course, there's the whataboutery to follow. There's the abusive and NC families, parents move and no space/too far, disability and infinite other reasons.

'Can't afford them don't have them' is easy enough to say in practise though it's not that simple. An unplanned pregnancy is just that and it's not the childrens fault, they should not be made to suffer.

I'm not defending the benefits system at all, it's unfit for purpose but that isn't the fault of those relying on it to survive. I don't agree with the under/over 25- nothing is cheaper because you are under 25.

XenoBitch · 29/09/2022 11:47

Dotjones · 29/09/2022 11:21

Single & under 25 £265.31 - too high, should be living with parents
Single & over 25 £334.91 - too low, should be about 4x this value
Couple both under 25 £416.45 - too high, two sets of parents to live with so no excuse
Couple over 25 £525.72 - should be the same combined as the single person gets individually, they can live in a one bed flat the same as a single person

£244.58 extra allowance for children (up to 2 children) - should be zero, don't have kids you can't afford

A single parent not working (24) with one child (1) would receive £509.89 a month, before deductions (loans, debt etc) - too high, should be living with parents at 24 so no payments needed, the parents can support them and the child

This has to be a joke. Can you not think of any reason why a 25 year old would not want to living with their parents?

Why should the parents of an adult child be supporting them (and any children)? They may be low income or on benefits themselves.

Sophieleigh26 · 29/09/2022 11:31

@TigerRag
I’m under 25
I moved out at 16 into a hostel
was under social care as I have NC with my parents
Lived in hostels till I was 18, got a 1 bed flat in the worst possible condition, did it up
did several house exchanges and now have a lovely 2 bed new build
it’s been extremely difficult just getting by though. I tried going to uni but they count maintenance loan as income so I got no benefits and I couldn’t afford to live (have a 4 year old too)

OP posts:
TigerRag · 29/09/2022 11:26

What happens if you have no living parents? Do the under 25s live on the streets?

Dotjones · 29/09/2022 11:21

Single & under 25 £265.31 - too high, should be living with parents
Single & over 25 £334.91 - too low, should be about 4x this value
Couple both under 25 £416.45 - too high, two sets of parents to live with so no excuse
Couple over 25 £525.72 - should be the same combined as the single person gets individually, they can live in a one bed flat the same as a single person

£244.58 extra allowance for children (up to 2 children) - should be zero, don't have kids you can't afford

A single parent not working (24) with one child (1) would receive £509.89 a month, before deductions (loans, debt etc) - too high, should be living with parents at 24 so no payments needed, the parents can support them and the child

serenghetti2011 · 29/09/2022 11:17

I’m a nurse, I work 2 long shifts which is all I can get childcare for as I have a child with additional needs, timings of shifts etc. I could leave and work full time at nmw and earn what I do now but I’d still get top ups as I do now. These, of course will stop when my children are no longer dependent solely on me - rightly so. I can then increase my hours and work more extra shifts. There is not a lot I can do re extra work I work the days my children are with their dad and occasionally my eldest son will help out.

wgen they were small I was with their dad but after we split life became very difficult trying to juggle shifts and kids and find childcare - nursing isn’t conducive to normal childcare so I had to stay on part time. I don’t get hb but some wtc and ctc and cb. I have nothing left at end of the month not a bean I’m really worried for winter ❄️

LakieLady · 28/09/2022 16:43

sweetkitty · 27/09/2022 23:42

I don’t understand how a friend can work 16 hours a week and still keep her UC, yet if she works full time she’s much worse off? Surely the system is flawed somewhere, full time work should always pay more.

Even people on quite good incomes can still need help in high rent areas.

A couple of years ago, I had a client who was a nursing sister with 3 children. She (quite rightly) had a far higher salary than mine, but was still entitled to UC because rents and childcare costs here are so high.

Mfsf · 28/09/2022 16:38

Having lived on benefits a few years ago when my son was young ( he is 20 now ) I have to say they are extremely low .even if full rent is paid those amounts are not enough for food , transport and household bills . No wonder so many get stuck on the benefit cycle . I was only in full benefits around 3 months and it was awful just plain awful 😞, no money for anything nice , no way to go out , I can see why people get depressed and I’ll and why children often end up doing worse in school , think about it getting home and not even being able to have a bit of heating on for comfort or enough food or anything nice to look forward . It’s vicious cycle that is hard to break .

oviraptor21 · 28/09/2022 16:37

pointythings · 27/09/2022 16:47

Benefits are insanely low in the UK. As are pensions. I continue to be surprised that people don't wonder where the hell all our taxes are going.

They are substantially higher than in many other countries.

LakieLady · 28/09/2022 16:33

ComtesseDeSpair · 27/09/2022 22:04

Are you young and able bodied / mentally healthy and capable of working? If so then why aren’t you in work and why would you think others are obliged to pay to give your friends and family birthday presents and feed your pet? If you’re not, then the person you quoted didn’t seem to be referring to you at all.

I have a young client who lives in a village 8 miles from the nearest town and the first bus isn't till 10.14.

I got a grant from a charity so he could get a bike and cycle to interviews and, hopefully, to work. Before he'd got a job, his bike was stolen - from outside the job centre - and he had to decline the job offer he'd got because he had no way of getting there.

This isn't in an especially rural area, either - it's barely 50 miles from London.
Transport in rural areas is a huge obstacle to getting a job, especially for young people. I live in a town of nearly 20k population, and my first bus isn't till gone 9.00.

LakieLady · 28/09/2022 16:17

NewBootsAndRanty · 27/09/2022 21:33

Is housing benefit for under 35s still capped at shared accommodation only levels?
(I think that was the case a while back)

Yes, it is.

I've worked with a few young homeless clients who've been placed in social housing following discharge from psych hospitals. Until they get PIP in payment, they get the shared accommodation rate, which is less than their rent.

I've had to do a lot of special pleading with councils to get discretionary housing payments and beg them not to start eviction proceedings. The uncertainty has damn near sent a couple of them into crisis.

BuzzingFridge · 28/09/2022 16:05

I think it should be more

LakieLady · 28/09/2022 16:01

Actupfishy · 27/09/2022 17:21

Pip doesn’t take a year OP.

Birthdays, days out are luxuries many working single parents can’t afford.

You're right about PIP not taking a year. If you have to appeal, it takes 18 months.

I do a PIP application most weeks, sometimes 2, so probably 40+ a year. I've currently got cases that I did 5 months ago, and they haven't even got a date for their assessment yet. It can take another 2-3 months to get a decision after the assessment, so even if you get an award without appealing, it's still taking over 6 months before you get the actual money.

LakieLady · 28/09/2022 15:53

This reply has been deleted

Post withdrawn at author's request

Not necessarily. Councils run their own schemes for council tax and in my area the minimum people pay is 18% of the total and that's only one council out of 2 counties and a city. The others all have a minimum payment of 20% of the total.

Council tax here is over £2k for a band C property.

The maximum allowed for housing costs is often significantly less than the actual rent and if you're not on an illness/disability benefit and subject to the benefit cap, you won't even get the full amount up to the maximum entitlement.

Rents are so high in this part of the SE that I had a single client in social housing who was benefit capped a little while ago.

weekendninja · 28/09/2022 15:47

No idea why I've given you a cake rather than a raised eyebrow.

weekendninja · 28/09/2022 15:46

Paigeycakey · 28/09/2022 15:16

@weekendninja wake up the system is floored. Do you think the Gov don't realise this? They are fully aware of this but all too happy for it to remain this way.

@Paigeycakey No need to wake up. Hmm
Of course they realise this...just too scared to make changes and then losing votes.