Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to think we are entering a new age of feudalism

85 replies

shjjhs12 · 27/09/2022 16:13

Only a few generations ago home ownership was an absolute rite of passage, even the most average job could support an entire family, living standards were good, the retirement age was 65, a 9-5 really was just a 9-5, ect. Today things look completely different. Young people are forced to live at home until their mid 20s as it’s too expensive to move out, home ownership is becoming more and more unrealistic, both parents working far more hours still struggles to maintain a good standard of living, driving is becoming very expensive, holidays are becoming unattainable, fewer people are getting married and having children because of how expensive it is. Today the lives of many people have become far more meaningless with very little to show for, many of us are now just cogs in the machine making money for someone we will never meet. Living standards are materially getting far worse for the majority of people yet the wealth of the super rich keeps growing to the point where now 0.1% of people control massive corporations more powerful than some countries. Anyone else feel like we are entering a new age of feudalism where effectively everyone apart from the super rich is being reduced to a peasant class.

OP posts:
ivykaty44 · 27/09/2022 21:15

Isleoftights The British were renowned for bathing once a week and not showering, it was how things were

BruceHellerAlmighty · 27/09/2022 21:14

The spread of asset ownership has narrowed conspicuously since the 1970s though, and in the last 15 years cash has been devalued. If you don't own "stuff" now, you're more unlikely to do so with every passing day and what you do own (cash) is worth less with every passing day.

Just look at that budget-NOT-BUDGET on Friday. Once they'd got through with that, every citizen in the UK had had their personal cash wealth devalued, whether their personal cash wealth was a fiver or whether it was £5k. Every single person's money that they had gone out to work to earn was worth less by the end of Friday. And worth even less again by midday on Monday.

And that's just one day.

It's been happening for fifteen years!

ivykaty44 · 27/09/2022 21:12

Hmm, not sure how well this thread sits with the other thread at the moment about how poor we all were in the 1970's. I don't think home ownership was normal a few generations ago, to be honest.

33% council rentals
33% private rentals
33% owner occupied

that’s the 1970s stats for homes

Isleoftights · 27/09/2022 21:06

'Only a few generations ago.....living standards were good.' No they weren't......most British adults in the 1950/60s didn't have their own teeth. Clare Rayner (remember her) recalled working on a maternity ward in the 1960s, and placing a glass of water beside every bed.....for the nursing mothers to place their false teeth in. I grew up in Manchester in the 1960s: my father worked for British Rail, my mother a waitress. We didn't have a telephone, fridge, shower, washing machine, or car. My mother wheeled the washing in a pram, once a week, to a communal 'wash house'. I went to a 'posh' university (Exeter), where the bathroom was kept locked, and you were allowed access to it once a week. We considered this perfectly normal.

BruceHellerAlmighty · 27/09/2022 21:04

They are the precariat

BruceHellerAlmighty · 27/09/2022 21:01

YANBU and I've been saying this for ages.

There is an international asset owning class - our cabinet, Trump, Zelenskiy et al are all members of it - and below it varying degrees of precarity.

Some people own the home they live in. Fewer in number than forty years ago, and actively stripped of whatever they've managed to accumulate by various mechanisms. We used to call them the middle class.

Others don't even own that one asset and never will. Their only wealth is in cash, value now eroded.

Others don't even have cash, just cashflow, diminishing, increasingly accompanied by debt as what they earn is worth less and less . They are the precarity, still holding onto the lie of working and doing the right thing.

Rosewaterblossom · 27/09/2022 20:52

RoseyLentil · 27/09/2022 16:28

This is why I will never work for the private sector again. I'm done with working 50 / 60 / 70 hours for 40hrs pay so my boss can live in a big house, send his kids to private schools, his wife doesn't work and they go on fancy foreign holidays 3 times a year. Twat Angry

I agree totally! The public sector is soooo good in comparison. Both can be shit but the public sector is slightly less shit.

entropynow · 27/09/2022 20:47

Octomore · 27/09/2022 16:26

Only a few generations ago home ownership was an absolute rite of passage

This isn't true, unless you're referring to the established middle classes (who are still able to buy properties now due to inheritance).

There was a brief historical blip where normal WC people could buy homes, but it wasn't "a few generations ago", it was more recent than that. Most people rented before the 70s, with large numbers living in secure, good quality council housing.

Not even true for the MC. Most of them rented too.

entropynow · 27/09/2022 20:45

latetothefisting · 27/09/2022 16:56

tell me you don't understand what feudalism was without telling me tell me you don't understand what feudalism was.... as far as I know having less disposable income at the moment isn't the same as not being able to move areas, marry, or work without my employer's consent?

@Discovereads is completely right, you are looking with rose tinted glasses at the past as a generic and homogenous 'better time' when for 99% of people it wasn't.

You can point out things are a bit shit at the moment without completely exaggerating and ignoring the parts of history that don't fit in with the point you're making.

Personally as a woman I'd still rather be living in the UK now than at nearly any other point in history. I'd imagine people from most minority groups would say the same. =

👏👏👏
Honestly people need to read some actual history books instead of parroting words and phrases they don't understand.

Pepsipepsi · 27/09/2022 19:48

Userg1234 · 27/09/2022 19:38

Absolute and utter bollocks my parents grandparents lived in absolute poverty living in squalid slum conditions having little or no education. Dad's family were Dockers only working if there was a ship to deal with and they were in favour with the charge hands. Mum's were miners in the West Country working"hot" pits naked cos you just couldn't wear clothes due to the heat.
My mum left school at 14 as she had to earn to help her 10 siblings. Dad never was sent to school. He always worked in the family business.
the welfare state kept/keeps my relations in food, housing, etc. Most have good jobs, own nice houses etc etc

That's the point. If things improved so much that you and your family aren't now living in a slum or working down a mine, then why should we accept such a massive decline in living standards now?
It's not like there's a shortage of wealth, billionaires are getting richer, poor people still counting their pennies as always.

Userg1234 · 27/09/2022 19:38

Absolute and utter bollocks my parents grandparents lived in absolute poverty living in squalid slum conditions having little or no education. Dad's family were Dockers only working if there was a ship to deal with and they were in favour with the charge hands. Mum's were miners in the West Country working"hot" pits naked cos you just couldn't wear clothes due to the heat.
My mum left school at 14 as she had to earn to help her 10 siblings. Dad never was sent to school. He always worked in the family business.
the welfare state kept/keeps my relations in food, housing, etc. Most have good jobs, own nice houses etc etc

verdantverdure · 27/09/2022 19:23

verdantverdure · 27/09/2022 16:41

I do feel shat on by this government.

What's the point of working and striving and doing all the right things if their tinkering with our economy to give tax breaks to the rich is going to put up the cost of everything and turn everything to shit?

I remember the shithole rented room with shared facilities my mums friend and her kids were shoved into when their home was repossessed.

That's going to happen to some of us isn't it?

Absolutely dreading two more years of this

I'm really angry about this tonight.

Conservative MPs must know what they are doing to us rdivaru people in their constituencies.

"Oh you can't afford to pay the ridiculously extortionate energy bills? LOL wait until you see what we're going to do to with your mortgages!"

Cheeselog · 27/09/2022 17:11

I voted YABU because you both don’t know what feudalism is and have a very rose tinted view of what life was like for working class people more than 1-2 generations ago. But obviously you’re not wrong that subsequent generations will not be as rich as boomers.

mackthepony · 27/09/2022 17:11

Completely agree.

Very glad I moved abroad 15 years ago.

YennefersDress · 27/09/2022 17:08

I know he was right about the lower chances of owning these things, but I found the idea that young people must accept this state of affairs - and do - utterly depressing. Yes, historically owning your own home has been for a minority, but the control it gives you over your own life and finances as you get older is so immense I can’t accept turning back the clock to a small percentage owning everything and exploiting everyone else.

Couldn't agree more with all of this.

There was a brief historical blip where normal WC people could buy homes, but it wasn't "a few generations ago", it was more recent than that. Most people rented before the 70s, with large numbers living in secure, good quality council housing.*

But it shouldn't be a 'brief historical blip'! It's a bloody good thing that living standards improved and the ability to have the security of a home they owned became possible for working class people. It's not acceptable that we are going backwards.

Discovereads · 27/09/2022 17:03

@latetothefisting
tell me you don't understand what feudalism was without telling me tell me you don't understand what feudalism was.... as far as I know having less disposable income at the moment isn't the same as not being able to move areas, marry, or work without my employer's consent?

Im glad you pointed this out because I felt too pedantic to highlight that the word “feudalism” was being flagrantly misused.

MimosaSunrise · 27/09/2022 17:02

I was talking to someone recently who was saying younger generations (I would guess he meant youngest millennials and younger) no longer expect to own houses or cars. They accept this and actively spend and prioritise differently. For example, they would be looking to subscribe to things rather than buy them.

I know he was right about the lower chances of owning these things, but I found the idea that young people must accept this state of affairs - and do - utterly depressing. Yes, historically owning your own home has been for a minority, but the control it gives you over your own life and finances as you get older is so immense I can’t accept turning back the clock to a small percentage owning everything and exploiting everyone else.

BMW6 · 27/09/2022 17:00

Oh and OP - you don't have a grasp of what "feudalism" means.

Chucking long words about doesn't indicate intelligence.

So basically your entire OP is just wrong.

YennefersDress · 27/09/2022 16:57

The way I see it is broadly, those born in the boomer generation have broadly (I say broadly as I know not everyone) saw living standards increase in many ways throughout their lives, and now millennials/gen Z are seeing things decline massively. And I think that is the true measure of a failed state and a disgraceful government.

I'm not saying that to have a go at boomers btw. It's good that they saw many things improve, and that's how things should have stayed. I'm also aware that things were also particularly difficult for women in the very recent past with equal pay, being able to buy a home. Which disgusts me. Personally I think society should become more united over this and stand up for each others rights. I'm in my 30s and fully supported the WASPY women over pensions. I'm sure there are lots of people of that generation who are equally disgusted at this current government and the impact it is having particularly on younger people.

latetothefisting · 27/09/2022 16:56

tell me you don't understand what feudalism was without telling me tell me you don't understand what feudalism was.... as far as I know having less disposable income at the moment isn't the same as not being able to move areas, marry, or work without my employer's consent?

@Discovereads is completely right, you are looking with rose tinted glasses at the past as a generic and homogenous 'better time' when for 99% of people it wasn't.

You can point out things are a bit shit at the moment without completely exaggerating and ignoring the parts of history that don't fit in with the point you're making.

Personally as a woman I'd still rather be living in the UK now than at nearly any other point in history. I'd imagine people from most minority groups would say the same. =

MintJulia · 27/09/2022 16:54

I think you have a misaligned view of the 50s, 60s and 70s.

My parents owned their own home, had 5 children, but:

We didn't have out of school activities
Or our own rooms
Clothes came from jumble sales
Uniform was mostly hand me downs
We had one car not two
We didn't eat out at all
We grew our own veg
We had no central heating, ice on the inside of the windows in winter
One bathroom between 7
We didn't ever go to the cinema
We holidayed for one week in the U.K. in a caravan.

It's a trade off. Living like that was miserable. The sacrifices made allowed parents to buy their home but it was no fun at all.

BMW6 · 27/09/2022 16:54

Home ownership is a recent change. My parents never expected to buy property when they were growing up - renting rooms (or half a house if you were quite flush) was the norm.

Council home renting then took off but still home ownership spoke of wealth.

It was Thatcher in the 1980's that normalised house purchasing.

LaurieFairyCake · 27/09/2022 16:52

Well there's only one generation born who have been able to afford to do that

So actually before then and now is the norm

It's very hard to follow the baby boomer generation and those who are inheriting from them (the age of people governing us Hmm) as they've been so much richer

Charley50 · 27/09/2022 16:50

I agree. It now feels like the majority of us, especially under 40s, are just working to feed debt and rent and make billionaires richer.

Thinkbiglittleone · 27/09/2022 16:49

RoseyLentil · 27/09/2022 16:28

This is why I will never work for the private sector again. I'm done with working 50 / 60 / 70 hours for 40hrs pay so my boss can live in a big house, send his kids to private schools, his wife doesn't work and they go on fancy foreign holidays 3 times a year. Twat Angry

This actually made me laugh out loud as it's so bloody true.

Swipe left for the next trending thread