Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to think we are entering a new age of feudalism

85 replies

shjjhs12 · 27/09/2022 16:13

Only a few generations ago home ownership was an absolute rite of passage, even the most average job could support an entire family, living standards were good, the retirement age was 65, a 9-5 really was just a 9-5, ect. Today things look completely different. Young people are forced to live at home until their mid 20s as it’s too expensive to move out, home ownership is becoming more and more unrealistic, both parents working far more hours still struggles to maintain a good standard of living, driving is becoming very expensive, holidays are becoming unattainable, fewer people are getting married and having children because of how expensive it is. Today the lives of many people have become far more meaningless with very little to show for, many of us are now just cogs in the machine making money for someone we will never meet. Living standards are materially getting far worse for the majority of people yet the wealth of the super rich keeps growing to the point where now 0.1% of people control massive corporations more powerful than some countries. Anyone else feel like we are entering a new age of feudalism where effectively everyone apart from the super rich is being reduced to a peasant class.

OP posts:
Bideshi · 28/09/2022 20:55

It was also difficult for a woman to get a mortgage. If a woman wanted finance of any kind: mortgage, car loan, HP, she had to be vouched for by a man, usually a father or husband. Mortgages were particularly hard to come by. This right up until the 1970s.

Council houses were the most prevalent forms of housing but there was other public housing too. My DF was a headmaster in a state school and we lived in a school house. There were police houses and sometimes housing for district nurses or GPs, especially in rural areas. New towns offered council housing as an incentive for certain jobs like teaching or public sector employment. My GPs rented (and later bought) a house from the Church Commissioners. The C of E were big landlords, but they've sold off much of their housing stock. We thought of ourselves as MC, but my parents never owned a house until they retired, and only a few the people we mixed with were homeowners. So not a rite of passage.

sweeneytoddsrazor · 28/09/2022 20:32

My parents had their own home in the 70s but like a PP has said we didn't have/do anywhere near as much as people today do. We did Brownies, we had chocolate once a week, we had more or less the same meals every week, roast, egg and chips, faggots, stew , chops , corned beef mash and beans. Sausage and chips.

Fruit that was in season. If we wanted a snack it was bread and jam. Cinema was a very rare treat. We always had to wait until Xmas day to watch the years big blockbuster movie. Didn't need to worry about screen time because kids programs ended at 5 for crossroads.

RosaGallica · 28/09/2022 19:59

MintJulia · 27/09/2022 16:54

I think you have a misaligned view of the 50s, 60s and 70s.

My parents owned their own home, had 5 children, but:

We didn't have out of school activities
Or our own rooms
Clothes came from jumble sales
Uniform was mostly hand me downs
We had one car not two
We didn't eat out at all
We grew our own veg
We had no central heating, ice on the inside of the windows in winter
One bathroom between 7
We didn't ever go to the cinema
We holidayed for one week in the U.K. in a caravan.

It's a trade off. Living like that was miserable. The sacrifices made allowed parents to buy their home but it was no fun at all.

Living like that was miserable was it? Only with the exception of central heating, it sounds pretty normal now. Except that you don’t get the family asset of an owned house at the end. People work all hours now to get this standard with private rentals, and we don’t know what happens at the end when this generation rent gets to retirement age.

NeelyOHara1 · 28/09/2022 19:51

A secure home still being something that is precarious and out of reach for many, in a supposedly highly developed country seems to sum up everything that is wrong with how society has and is being run. It really is as simple as that, I think.

Birdy1066 · 28/09/2022 19:43

Absolutely right. Feudalism yes. In feudal times the lords of the manor and the barons forced their serfs to fight for their causes.No one in their right mind would lay down their lives to protect what this country stands for. The people who fought in the Second World War from the UK believed they were fighting a war for a righteous cause and that afterwards they’d live in a fair and just society. What a joke. Everything that was achieved then - social housing, good health care, free education - all dismantled and destroyed by the Tories.

2bazookas · 28/09/2022 19:36

We're entering a new age of such poor education, people don't even know their own history.

Home ownership was never a rite of passage in UK, and whatever shit we're in now is NOT feudalism, "peasantry" or anything remotely resembling either.

DappledYork · 28/09/2022 18:58

BMW6 · 27/09/2022 17:00

Oh and OP - you don't have a grasp of what "feudalism" means.

Chucking long words about doesn't indicate intelligence.

So basically your entire OP is just wrong.

This happens a lot on Mumsnet.
It also makes me laugh when posters write 'I expressed/communicated to my DP' instead of 'I said' and other such over complicated shite.
Unless a poster is writing up a law, the more complicated the sentence-the dimmer they usually are.

StridTheKiller · 28/09/2022 18:57

Growing up in Scotland (north coast) in the 50s and in the Midlands in the 50s my DPs and friends etc were POOR. DM's lunch was a CUP OF COCOA. For lunch. Occasionally it sould be soup. All consumed standing up in the hall ways. DM's DPs' were tennant farmers, so at least had decent food at home and our fishing industry was still providing seafood straight to this country, not all the mucking zbout you have today, but there were kids even poorer than DM, didn't have SHOES.
DF had a grindingly poor upbringing in the midlands. His DF dies young and He and his brothers had to graft as kids and also go to school.
When i realised what poverty meant back then, for my DP, now in their 70s, it hurt my fucking soul. If still does, to think of them as starvi g, cold children and the many like them.
Yes, life might be tough right now and the shit thing is the wealth divide and constantly having our noses rubbed in ie. The billions spent on the Queen's funeral etc. Money being squandered left right and centre, no body accountable, corruption, greed, it is endless and with no end in sight (though Kier is starting to show vague signs of life, though will be largely unelectable until he stops his gender ID bullshit, so we'll end up with more of the criminally corrupt Tories come GE time). But bloody hell, it's not anywhere NEAR as bad as it was in my DPs' generation's lifetime. Not even close.

Helenloveslee4eva · 28/09/2022 18:51

JeanBodel · 27/09/2022 16:26

Hmm, not sure how well this thread sits with the other thread at the moment about how poor we all were in the 1970's. I don't think home ownership was normal a few generations ago, to be honest.

I do agree living standards are plummeting. The question is, what is our base line - the standards of 1950's-1980's, or the standards of 1990's-2010's?

Absolutely.
child I’d the 1970s here and my parents were the first generation of home owners. In their families. My Nan “ owned “ her last house thry moved into when he retired but only , as I discovered after mum died , because mum and her sister really bought it between them .

so assuming my kids don’t buy ( eldest part owns a flat with me - a bit of pay it forward with my mums inheritance money ) then it’s only my parents and my generation that have owned

JazbayGrapes · 28/09/2022 18:44

It's a tough one! I think we want more. We all want a house with two toilets, foreign holidays. Take outs, phone contracts etc. These were all unheard of.

Yeah, mobile phones and internet have not been invented. Now let's say you're unemployed today. How are you supposed to even look for work without a phone?

verdantverdure · 28/09/2022 18:11

I think the difference is that unaffordable private rent is the norm now.

When I was a small child in primary school most families either had a mortgage or a council house.

We all had gardens, and pets.

So many children nowadays live in exorbitantly priced privately rented flats with no outdoor space and no hope of anything better.

latetothefisting · 28/09/2022 17:15

If anyone is interested in actual statistics and facts rather than made up definitions and utter bullshit based on their own very limited perspective this is interesting

propertyindustryeye.com/what-175-years-of-data-tell-us-about-house-price-affordability-in-the-uk/

Basically

  • the majority (and literally i mean just edging over 50% of the population rather than a huge proportion) owning rather than renting their homes only started from the mid 1970s
  • even at the absolute peak of home ownership in the mid 2000s this was only about 70% of the population
  • in our now apparently completely unaffordable and feudalistic end times this has only decreased by about 6% from said absolute historic peak.
ivykaty44 · 27/09/2022 22:08

I don't think baths are the issue.

they are fundamental to the issue, they are part of the cultural differences between 1970s and 2022

we didn’t expect to bath more than once a week, central heating wasn’t widespread, a quick wash your face I. A cold bathroom was what you got. Things were different, not bad jyst a different way of living.

Kendodd · 27/09/2022 21:48

Don't put up with it OP. Somebody on here pointed me in this direction.

wesayenough.co.uk/

Discovereads · 27/09/2022 21:31

Some people own the home they live in. Fewer in number than forty years ago,

Fewer than twenty years ago, because actually more own homes now than did in 1982.

Discovereads · 27/09/2022 21:28

Rosewaterblossom · 27/09/2022 20:52

I agree totally! The public sector is soooo good in comparison. Both can be shit but the public sector is slightly less shit.

I was public sector and worked those hours for only 37.5hrs pay…it was expected. True we were not generating profit, but we were trying to keep services afloat despite budget cuts. Austerity was bad for all concerned.

QueenOfHiraeth · 27/09/2022 21:26

The OP has the attitude that a lot of people have now in assuming the past was rosy and the hardships of now are the first hardships ever faced
My parents bought their house in the early 60s and were the first people from either side of the family ever to do that. Living standards were far lower whether you owned or rented
I don't for one minute want my DCs or other young folk to have to back to that but we should not assume that the affluence and stability of the last 30ish years is the norm as it really isn't

Rayn22 · 27/09/2022 21:25

It's a tough one! I think we want more. We all want a house with two toilets, foreign holidays. Take outs, phone contracts etc. These were all unheard of.
Living standards will drop and I think we have had it good for a long time. However, with the knowledge and skills we have now we should be able to make sure that we don't go backwards abs at least keep the standard of living we have worked hard for!

AchatAVendre · 27/09/2022 21:25

I've never seen so many hysterical, drama laden posts in one night. Is this what Britain has become? Full of overwrought doom-mongers, competing to see who can become the most popular prophet of doom?

I don't see any of you trying to run the country. Maybe give it 6 months before we have yet another Prime Minister, because all of this chopping and changing is what is really damaging the economy.

BruceHellerAlmighty · 27/09/2022 21:23

it’s unlike those times will re-emerge.

Well they won't ofc if we just lie back and take it.

But, y'know, we don't have to. We don't have to keep a cabinet of millionaires in power when they actively destroy the value of our work which is the cash we get for it, when it's all we've got.

Isleoftights · 27/09/2022 21:22

ps. A friend at Exeter University was sharing a house with an American student, who she said was 'really weird'. In what way is he 'weird' - I asked. 'Well, he has a shower EVERY DAY'. (True story !)

Arenanewbie · 27/09/2022 21:20

I wouldn’t call it feudalism but the situation is crap and getting worse for a lot of people, apart from those who are very rich.
I was listening Keir Stamer’s speech today and he said rightly that lots of people lost hope. And another thing that we should live not survive.

OMG12 · 27/09/2022 21:19

Nah, the last 50-70 years have been a blip historically. Lucky for those who could benefit in those times with large scale home ownership (due to widespread cheap credit and selling off social housing), foreign holidays, lots of disposable income, buying not repairing). It’s out of whack with the ways of the world. Why do people think these things are some kind of right? All these things only really existed in but a blink of an eye, if that.

it’s unlike those times will re-emerge. Probably likely to see the Uber so Italian/materialism on the wane

BruceHellerAlmighty · 27/09/2022 21:18

I don't think baths are the issue.

Isleoftights · 27/09/2022 21:17

Yes, what strikes me is not that we were only allowed to bath once a week (in the late 1960s), but that nobody ever commented on this fact - including my newly acquired best friend, who had been at Eton !