Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Are they allowed to post a job advert like this?

68 replies

Echobeachfarawayintime · 27/09/2022 16:06

I'm with an agency who are looking for a support worker for tomorrow.
It's a mental health setting and they've posted that the support worker 'must be white' in order to not upset the client's mental health.
Are they really allowed to post stuff like this?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
EilonwyWithRedGoldHair · 27/09/2022 22:13

Banana2079 · 27/09/2022 21:03

It’s Allowed to request a worker from an ethnic minority so I don’t see why the request for a white worker should be any different
I don’t like either though

Why don't you like it? Plenty of people have posted giving perfectly reasonable explanations for why it may be necessary.

(And of course the person needing the care may just be a racist bigot, but they still need care.)

Banana2079 · 27/09/2022 21:03

It’s Allowed to request a worker from an ethnic minority so I don’t see why the request for a white worker should be any different
I don’t like either though

NerrSnerr · 27/09/2022 21:02

Some people need to do some research on the frontal lobe and what can happen if it's damaged due to brain injury or a neurodegenerative illness. It's shit but it can change your behaviour.

Swashbuckled · 27/09/2022 19:11

Someone I know of was in a Japanese POW camp. When he got dementia, the Chinese psychiatrist (in training) was asked not to deal with him. The poor bugger didn’t know the war was over and he was terrified.

ColonelCarter · 27/09/2022 19:11

roarfeckingroarr · 27/09/2022 17:12

I had an elderly aunt who was a wonderful person. We lost her to dementia long before she died.

Once she had truly lost herself she acted like an awful abusive racist. Maybe she held those views all along but hid them well, or maybe it was the illness. But to say she didn't deserve care is wrong.

Exactly. Dementia and other mental illnesses can turn people in to someone unrecognisable - the mildest, meekest of people become physically aggressive with power and strength that belies their tiny frames. Aggression, racial abuse, sexual behaviour, disinhibition. All normal and absolutely not the fault of the person, who is a shell of their former self.

Best all round that it's clear up front. I've known it the other way, where a black lady would only accept care off black people, due to previous abuse. White carers we're at risk and the service user was at risk of harming themselves and self neglect.

mamabear715 · 27/09/2022 19:09

@Bpdqueen A sensible reply.

Bpdqueen · 27/09/2022 19:07

Yes they are allowed to post it and no its not a big deal. Its the reality of working with service users who lack capacity and are extremely unwell. The staff and service users safety has to be top priority

Redqueenheart · 27/09/2022 18:44

This should read ''ads that ask for people from specific ethnic backgrounds.''...

Redqueenheart · 27/09/2022 18:43

They absolutely can if it is a genuine occupational requirement.

This is why you see ads that:

  • ask for female staff only (for example for services that supports female victims of domestic violence and sexual assault)
  • ask for people for specific ethnic backgrounds. (I have seen this for some services and hostels that help people from Afro-Caribbean or Asian backgrounds)
  • ask for people of a particular faith (some Christian charities for example will ask for employees who are practicing Christians)

In this case it is likely that the person either has reduced mental capacity and/or somehow has a history of trauma associated with someone who happened to be from a particular background.

With mental health issues and issues associated with old age things are not always neat and rational and services have to do their best protect both staff and patients.

Not everything is about discrimination...

When I was running mental health projects we had a few clients who did not want as their support worker people from the same faith or background as them. Because they were worried about the fact that their community had a lot of stigma around mental health and just felt uncomfortable because it was too close to home for them to open up to someone from the same background. They preferred someone who they perceived as more neutral. Of course any support worker would have been professional with them and offer the same level of care but sometimes you do have to work with the patient's concerns, whether they are legitimate or not.

2Hooves · 27/09/2022 18:38

While it sounds awful surely it's better than either putting staff on a potentially dangerous situation or trying to cover it up and making an excuse why they can't have the job?

BeanieTeen · 27/09/2022 18:36

I think it’s just worded badly. It’s not so much about upsetting a clients mental health surely, if it’s someone with serious mental health issues and difference in race is going to cause difficulties then that’s not great for the client of course but I think even worse for the carer. I don’t think the rights and wrongs of it can come into it if the client is genuinely not capable of knowing better and it seems an unfair position to put any carer in.

Sometimeswinning · 27/09/2022 18:29

swimlyn · 27/09/2022 16:55

Being racist AND needing your arse wiped (or equivalent) in old age.

A hell of a dilemma...

Where did you read old age? I've just seen mental health.

TrashyPanda · 27/09/2022 18:27

My late DF had altzheimers and paranoid delusions.

he said things he would never had said before he was ill

the effects of dementia are just awful. Please try to have a little understanding.

Mrsjayy · 27/09/2022 18:24

I think that's probably it the advert is jarring,it is to the point though.

Georgyporky · 27/09/2022 18:22

Perhaps the real mistake was being so open.
Surely the agency know which of their staff would fit the bill ?

titchy · 27/09/2022 18:21

Funny isn't it how posters who are otherwise repulsed by racism, sexism, homophobia, disablism etc still manage to display not one jot of compassion or understanding for those with dementia or MH disorders.

Mischance · 27/09/2022 18:20

It is so hard - my poor OH had Parkinsons and his brain went completely haywire. He believed people (including me) were trying to kill him. We had a Bulgarian carer at one point and he thought she was a spy; and in all the carers' profiles we looked at he rejected anyone black. In the end I had to say to the agency that there was no point suggesting anyone black as OH would believe they were going to attack him. You have no idea how very awkward this all was - I felt dreadful saying this to the agency - but what else could I do? It was deeply embarrassing and put everyone in an awkward situation.

However the last carer we had before he died, when he was not really in a position to object to anyone and no other carers were available, was a Nigerian woman and she was the best we had.

I am sorry if any of my post gives offence, but I am just telling it as it was. I can fully understand that there might be a need to make these stipulations in a job advert. People with serious mental health problems cannot choose what they feel.

I suspect that there are exceptions to the rules to cover this.

OneTC · 27/09/2022 18:16

I would very much credit my upbringing with why I am a liberal open minded non racist good mannered and polite and friendly person. And the person who raised me like that is, thanks to dementia, an increasingly outspoken racist, illiberal, closed minded arsehole but it's absolutely not her fault, or even slightly representative of the previous 86 years of her life. People with dementia and other mental illnesses world becomes much smaller and a much more frightening place and not along rational or predictable lines. Reasonable adjustments can be made without offending anyone

The idea you'd withhold care from people in this position is fucking horrific and anyone who suggested it should be ashamed of themselves

XenoBitch · 27/09/2022 18:16

The ad said the role is in a MH setting, so there might be an element of previous trauma there, or the client simply lacks capacity.

I was kicked and spat at for being female by a patient I was caring for. Patient was sweet as pie to male staff. Patient had dementia. The same could apply with race, hair colour, clothing colour... anything really.

strugglingmum82 · 27/09/2022 18:15

From previous experience. We would go into a service user if we were white women, under 50, and no blondes.

Service user had been severely abused throughout his life. He was non verbal and would scream and hurt himself.

Blueblell · 27/09/2022 18:11

It’s working with someone has possibly a severe mental illness. I would assume they have specified the race for a compelling reason.

melj1213 · 27/09/2022 18:06

There are many number of reasons that they may specify a white person - it could be because the client is a raging racist and so a support worker of colour would be in danger of physical/verbal abuse; it could be because the client has severe mental health issues whereby they have a fear of POC in that they believe they are trying to harm them, and so having a support worker of colour would be actively harmful of their mental health and the worker's safety; the client could have had bad experiences in the past with a POC - abuse/harassment etc - and so now their behaviour can be triggered by POC in their personal space.

Many people with mental health problems, dementia, brain injuries etc can display abhorrent behaviour but the person is not an inherently awful person, it is caused by their condition. When my grandmother got dementia she became the most verbally and physically abusive old woman. This is a woman who never so much as raised her voice to us never mind swore or smacked, but as the dementia worsened the venom that would spew from her would have made a sailor blush and she would think nothing of smacking/hitting/shoving someone if she didn't like what they were doing. Fortunately her carers all knew her as she ironically used to volunteer at the home she went into (we live in a small town) so they knew that her behaviour was a symptom of her dementia because it was heartbreaking to see my lovely grandma calling people "fucking prostitutes" for wearing bright lipstick when she would threaten to wash our mouth out with soap if we so much as said "damn" in her hearing.

People like my grandmother still require care and dignity in their support and if that means specifying that any support has to come from a white woman, in order to keep both the client and worker safe, then I think that's better than putting people at risk because nobody wants to be seen as discriminating.

AchatAVendre · 27/09/2022 18:04

Surely they must have worded it somewhat sympathetically and in a reasonably explanatory way? They must be able to justify this requirement under the Equality Act.

I find it disgusting. I hope they have some watertight justification in place.

TooMuchToDoTooLittleInclination · 27/09/2022 18:01

VanillaSpiceCandle · 27/09/2022 16:34

I’d say someone like that doesn’t deserve any help. Leave them to it and see how they get on.

I think that job spec is on such dodgy ground it’s probably been triple checked by legal. Most likely to reduce the chance of the new employee being abused.

I hope you don't work in any care setting.

@Echobeachfarawayintime I'm sorry if this has upset you. However, working with clients who have MH problems, you should know that some people can't help their reactions. Maybe they were attacked by a Green person & now only trust white people to help them. If a Client only wanted a black/Chinese/polish/purple person if that can be accommodated I think it should be. They are the client & they should have the choice when at all possible.

AMindNeedsBooks · 27/09/2022 18:01

MarmiteCoriander · 27/09/2022 16:10

They can advertise for a male or female careworker only, but there is always a small print saying 'under the discrimination act ..... this job is exempt.....' So maybe its the same?

It is yes. Same for any protected characteristic as long as the company can prove the reason is to achieve a legitimate aim. In this case, not upsetting client OR staff member.