Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Can a school insist that a child is moved to a special needs school?

65 replies

Faciadipasta · 27/09/2022 15:46

A child in my DC'S school, aged 7. Parent us being told the school dont have the support available and the child will have to.move to a special school. Parent doesn't want the child moved away from all their friends. Can the school insist? Obviously this isn't really my business but just wanted to offer this mother support and advice. Seems very unfair that the school can just wash their hands of a child like this.
For reference the child is not disruptive, and has no extra physical needs. Just requires extra learning support due to ASD as well as difficulties with handwriting and spelling for example. Don't the school have a responsibility to get the support in for a child with an EHCP?

OP posts:
FarmerRefuted · 27/09/2022 16:18

Needmorelego · 27/09/2022 16:08

SEN schools are difficult to get into. There isn't enough of them. I doubt the school would be suggesting it unless they really thought the child needed it.

Some schools are notorious for off-rolling children by stealth and children with SEN are more likely to fall foul of this practice. DC old school would suggest special school to a lot of parents of children with SEN and/or disabilities, make a lot of noise about being unable to meet their needs, and would be deliberately difficult (e.g., disciplining children for behaviour related to their SEN, providing the bare minimum in support, not differentiating, refusing or withdrawing reasonable adjustments, etc). They could meet needs, they just didn't want to because they didn't want the extra work involved so employed all of these tactics to force these children out.

Bluevelvetsofa · 27/09/2022 16:14

What support is the school currently offering?
What is the impact of that support and how has it been reviewed?
What does the child need that the school aren’t able to offer?

It’s true that mainstream school isn’t always suitable for some children, but the school can’t decide it’s not suitable without evidencing what they’ve done and its impact.

If the school is saying that they don’t have the support available, then an emergency review should indicate that they need more funding to give more support. Specialist teaching might be a part of that.

Itstarts · 27/09/2022 16:09

If a child has been offered a SEN placement at a specialist school, the parents would be fools not to accept. Those places are worth more than gold. So many children being denied an appropriate education because of lack of funding. If the child is deemed to be in need of a specialist setting, it's neglectful to deny them the support they need.

But no, the school can't force it. It is ultimately the parents choice.

Needmorelego · 27/09/2022 16:08

SEN schools are difficult to get into. There isn't enough of them. I doubt the school would be suggesting it unless they really thought the child needed it.

WonderingWanda · 27/09/2022 16:04

The parents needs to find out what specific needs the school feel unable to meet. Students don't go to special schools just because of behaviour. If he is for example unable to read so cannot access the curriculum then he might benefit from specialist teaching that a teaching assistant is unable to provide.

EveryFlightBeginsWithAFall · 27/09/2022 16:04

Ah read the last part wrong, if he already has an ehcp and the school feel they still can't meet the child's needs then they should be providing evidence . Mainstream is not the best environment for every child, even with an ehcp

DoodlePug · 27/09/2022 16:02

I was heavily pressured. I suspect because they were only 1 child over the limit to reduce their staffing levels Tbh since up to this point they just kept saying they needed more funding and kept getting it.

If near enough coping in mainstream then a school with a designated provision sounds more appropriate than a proper special needs school.

It was a good move for us both academically and to get much better pastoral care but down side is that it is miles away so long journeys in the taxi and no friends near by.

We'd move but he is more attatched to the house than anything else.

Sirzy · 27/09/2022 15:59

Mainstream is always (rightly or wrongly) the default but a school can say that they can’t meet the needs as outlined in the EHCP. Obviously the parents can appeal this and the LA would expect the school
to evidence why.

sounds like the parents and the senco need to sit down and discuss things properly and then the parents need to consider if that is the right environment for their child

FarmerRefuted · 27/09/2022 15:58

The Local Authority can only refuse a place if a mainstream education would be incompatible with the efficient education of others and there are no reasonable steps the Local Authority could take to rectify this. They have to prove this too, they can't just say it.

Your friend would have grounds to take the LA to tribunal, I'd suggest she speaks to SENDIAS and IPSEA for advice on this.

EveryFlightBeginsWithAFall · 27/09/2022 15:57

Well you can't just rock up to special school and get a place. Your friend needs to look into an ehcp, the school can apply or you used to be able to start the process yourself

x2boys · 27/09/2022 15:57

Schools can't insist ,but I would encourage the mother to have a look around ,my son has severe autism and learning disabilities, and has always been at a special school, hea 12 now ,his school is the best environment for him ,that's obviously not going to be the case for everyone, but it's good to know whats out there ,she should probably contact the local SEN Independent advisory service for support to if she hasn't already.

Rinoachicken · 27/09/2022 15:56

Does the child have an EHCP already? Is it any good (they are not always!). Does the child already have the maximum amount of hours of 1:1? Is that in the best interest long term of the child?

The school has a right to say they cannot meet the need as laid out in the EHCP.
It may be more about the child’s well-being as a whole.

My son has an EHCP and I trying to get him out of mainstream. His school agree mainstream is not right for him. He has friends there and likes his teacher sure. But he is 3yrs behind his peers and even with full time 1:1 the mainstream environment wi the it’s full and busy classroom and many transitions in the day, it’s not the an environment conducive for him to learn.

A child who is in and out of the classroom for 1:1 or small group work, that can be disruptive to a class. And in the case of my son, who has to have work massive adapted for him and has an adult with him all the time, it’s isolating and marks him out as ‘different’ which he is now noticing and effects his self esteem.

Yes he will miss his friends initially, but he will
make new ones, and in the bigger scheme of things, it’s critically important that he is in the correct learning environment with the right support so he can achieve his potential, wherever that may be.

Eekle · 27/09/2022 15:55

The school cannot insist, though sometimes they try and persuade parents to move children to an alternative setting if they cannot cope, or feel the child would be happier elsewhere. Sometimes it is (and shouldn't be) budget or staffing (or lack thereof - shortage of TAs, as with everything else) related, too

They should be trying to support the child remaining in mainstream in the first instance, though - can they prove to friend that they've exhausted every avenue.

OhmygodDont · 27/09/2022 15:54

In theory no but what happens if the school truly cannot support the child to be in school and learning? Do you keep them there but fail them? If the la won’t hand over more money for more support. Tricky for both I guess.

catsnore · 27/09/2022 15:51

Under the current way of thinking, the school should be doing everything in their power to keep them in mainstream school. This sounds like a money thing. Budgets are very limited, pots of money are ring fenced and with the bills going up, schools are struggling just like everyone else. They should in theory be able to get funding though?

Swipe left for the next trending thread