Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Can a school insist that a child is moved to a special needs school?

65 replies

Faciadipasta · 27/09/2022 15:46

A child in my DC'S school, aged 7. Parent us being told the school dont have the support available and the child will have to.move to a special school. Parent doesn't want the child moved away from all their friends. Can the school insist? Obviously this isn't really my business but just wanted to offer this mother support and advice. Seems very unfair that the school can just wash their hands of a child like this.
For reference the child is not disruptive, and has no extra physical needs. Just requires extra learning support due to ASD as well as difficulties with handwriting and spelling for example. Don't the school have a responsibility to get the support in for a child with an EHCP?

OP posts:
WhatALoadOfWankyness · 01/10/2022 07:34

From what you've said I don't think they'd reach the criteria for a special school
@Goatinthegarden , that's fucking heartbreaking, poor little girl

Underhisi · 01/10/2022 07:34

There are state special schools for children who have ASD but no learning disability but they are only in some areas and they tend to be filled with children who have exhibited problem behaviours in mainstream ( becoming distressed in school) or children who have parents who went to tribunal.

Lougle · 01/10/2022 07:27

"For reference the child is not disruptive, and has no extra physical needs. Just requires extra learning support due to ASD as well as difficulties with handwriting and spelling for example."

This can not be true. There is no way that a child who just needs 'extra learning support' would be offered a special school place. They are highly sought after and very limited. DD1 has been in special school since she was 4. She is now almost 17.

For a mainstream special school place to be offered, the child will need to have a learning disability. That doesn't mean their Autism - many children have Autism without learning disability. DD2 goes to an independent specialist school now because she couldn't cope with the mainstream environment. She couldn't go to a state special school because she doesn't have a learning disability.

Because of the special school environment, many children who were given 1:1 support in mainstream can be given independence in special school. DD1's schools have all been secure, so it didn't matter if a child took a detour on their way to their class because they were safe.

Goatinthegarden · 01/10/2022 07:26

2bazookas · 27/09/2022 16:37

Seems very unfair that the school can just wash their hands of a child like this.
For reference the child is not disruptive, and has no extra physical needs. Just requires extra learning support due to ASD as well as difficulties with handwriting and spelling for example.

With respect, you don't observe or assess that child in class with her peers ; the school does. Far from "washing their hands of her" they are saying that in their experienced professional view she needs more help. Its possible her adoring parent is somewhat blinkered by love and wishful thinking.

This. Where I teach, it is almost impossible to get a child into any sort of alternative provision, even if their needs are very high. Schools cannot just put children into specialist settings on a whim.

Inclusion is a lovely idea, but mainstream not always the best setting. Especially now we have such a lack of support staff. I teach upper primary and currently have a girl in her final year. Her behaviour is perfect; she is a lovely child who always works hard, tries her very best and really cares about others.

She cannot read, write, or communicate clearly. She has difficulty coordinating her movements and so physical activities are also a challenge for her. Her interests and understanding is very different to that of her peers. They have an obvious affection for her and are kind to her, but they do not play with her or engage with her unless paired up together.

She really needs 1:1 support all day, but we can’t offer that. She gets 4 hours a week. Her options for much of the school day are to sit at a table of peers, but work on her own tasks (so she is present, but not really ‘included’), or ‘join in’ with learning far beyond her capabilities. She has to have very different learning activities to the rest of the class. She is aware of this and her confidence and mental health is being damaged.

We have fought hard to get any kind of alternative education for her. All we have been offered is one morning a week in a special education setting. She LOVES it. She has made a genuine friend who has similar interests. They learn practical life skills and she gets to engage with peers working on the same academic tasks as her.

TatumHigh · 01/10/2022 07:00

Lancrelady80 · 01/10/2022 00:46

Places in special schools are like hens teeth - some parents fight for years to get one for their child.

This. We have a lovely boy in Y5 with autism. But last assessed at developmentally 18 months. Toilet trained in June, in nappies up until then. Needs a totally different curriculum - think occ therapy, speech & lang, sensory. Forget even the EYFS curriculum. It's nothing any of us were trained in and we have no specialists. EHCP in place but v woolly in terms of what to actually do with him - at present, he has a selection of toys various staff members' ch have grown out of. We do activities recommended by occ therapist but as they are couched in jargon eg develop vestibular skills rather than "use swing , soft play, wobble board" then we're in the dark.

He has a 1:1 (actually not HIS 1:1 - she is technically shared with another 3 children but his needs mean she has those others for v little. Lovely lady but again, no specialist.)

His needs are not being met as we have no practical advice. The head won't admit it because he brings extra funding. And although he has been discussed at special school panels year on year, there is never a place for him. His needs aren't considered severe enough in comparison to others.

Take the LA to tribunal to get him into SEN school. It'll be a pain/expense in the short term, but it'll get your son a placement.

Over 95% of tribunal cases go in favour of the parent.

Underhisi · 01/10/2022 06:58

And yes there are frequently no places in special schools. Some children are waiting for places for years and others who have been excluded are out of school for years.

Underhisi · 01/10/2022 06:56

School can tell the LA they cannot meet need but need to give one of 3 legal reasons. Not being suitable for mainstream isn't one of them.
LA then decides whether to name a different school. Child has a right to mainstream education but not in a particular mainstream school. It is very difficult to force special school and LA know that so rarely go there.
If a child has behavioural issues a school may force the issue by excluding. They may also put constant pressure on the parents.

Lancrelady80 · 01/10/2022 00:46

Places in special schools are like hens teeth - some parents fight for years to get one for their child.

This. We have a lovely boy in Y5 with autism. But last assessed at developmentally 18 months. Toilet trained in June, in nappies up until then. Needs a totally different curriculum - think occ therapy, speech & lang, sensory. Forget even the EYFS curriculum. It's nothing any of us were trained in and we have no specialists. EHCP in place but v woolly in terms of what to actually do with him - at present, he has a selection of toys various staff members' ch have grown out of. We do activities recommended by occ therapist but as they are couched in jargon eg develop vestibular skills rather than "use swing , soft play, wobble board" then we're in the dark.

He has a 1:1 (actually not HIS 1:1 - she is technically shared with another 3 children but his needs mean she has those others for v little. Lovely lady but again, no specialist.)

His needs are not being met as we have no practical advice. The head won't admit it because he brings extra funding. And although he has been discussed at special school panels year on year, there is never a place for him. His needs aren't considered severe enough in comparison to others.

KingCharlespen · 30/09/2022 21:19

FarmerRefuted · 27/09/2022 16:18

Some schools are notorious for off-rolling children by stealth and children with SEN are more likely to fall foul of this practice. DC old school would suggest special school to a lot of parents of children with SEN and/or disabilities, make a lot of noise about being unable to meet their needs, and would be deliberately difficult (e.g., disciplining children for behaviour related to their SEN, providing the bare minimum in support, not differentiating, refusing or withdrawing reasonable adjustments, etc). They could meet needs, they just didn't want to because they didn't want the extra work involved so employed all of these tactics to force these children out.

Very worrying. I work with an outside youth organisation and remember a VP explaining to us that two of our students had been suspended with a hope that they'd be permanently excluded. The other had a mother who "argued her case" and they'd have to bring him back.
The other boys were totally expendable.

StripeyDeckchair · 30/09/2022 20:37

Places in special schools are like hens teeth - some parents fight for years to get one for their child.
If a child is offered a space then they must meet the criteria for attending rhe school. I would suggest the parent visit the school with their child and see what is on offer.

You haven't seen the EHCP (which are hard enough to get BTW) and don't know what the child's issues are. They might seem OK now however the gap may well get more noticeable as the cohort age making school life harder for the child.

I see children who have been offered a place in a specialist school in a standard secondary and totally unable to cope. This is because the parents want mainstream education for the child - I think its a form of child abuse.

Tillytina123 · 30/09/2022 20:18

Can any one recommend a special school in richmomd or twickenham private small surroundings for mild autism 12 year old boy

Goingforarun · 27/09/2022 17:01

Sometimes the reality of the child’s experience in mainstream doesn’t match with the parents perception. Just they find out exactly what he’s having difficulty with and what the school has done so far to support that and if they could talk to their child about what it’s like at the school and whether he’d be happy at school where more children were working at his level where he’d get more support.

Mumofsend · 27/09/2022 16:44

Iamnotthe1 · 27/09/2022 16:33

tackled the LA to get her plan properly provisioned and subsequently funded.

This is a really important point. Most EHCPs have over-promised provisions but an underfunded level of support. Most parents don't realise that they can challenge the LA when these don't match and the LA banks on schools either "making it work" or quietly not coping.

Yes, it absolutely was the crucial bit in why it worked for my DD. Even down to things like having TA hours extra to do all the prep bits needed.

BeautifulDragon · 27/09/2022 16:39

They can't insist, but if the school are telling them they can't meet the child's needs I would believe them and consider options.

2bazookas · 27/09/2022 16:37

Seems very unfair that the school can just wash their hands of a child like this.
For reference the child is not disruptive, and has no extra physical needs. Just requires extra learning support due to ASD as well as difficulties with handwriting and spelling for example.

With respect, you don't observe or assess that child in class with her peers ; the school does. Far from "washing their hands of her" they are saying that in their experienced professional view she needs more help. Its possible her adoring parent is somewhat blinkered by love and wishful thinking.

ghostsandpumpkinsalready · 27/09/2022 16:37

The school will have to prove with evidence that they can't meet the child's needs and if mum is adamant she wants her child to stay they will struggle to go against parental choice.
However believe me they will make it unpleasant for the mother if they really don't want the child there!

Iamnotthe1 · 27/09/2022 16:35

Mumofsend · 27/09/2022 16:28

My DD's school gave me an ultimatum of specialist or remove her. This was 18 months ago. It very much still happens.

Whilst they may say that, and it's very worrying for parents, there's no bite to this bark. They don't have the power to remove her, despite what they may claim, and there is not a single LA that would allow a threat like that to stand up in tribunal.

Iamnotthe1 · 27/09/2022 16:33

tackled the LA to get her plan properly provisioned and subsequently funded.

This is a really important point. Most EHCPs have over-promised provisions but an underfunded level of support. Most parents don't realise that they can challenge the LA when these don't match and the LA banks on schools either "making it work" or quietly not coping.

gogohmm · 27/09/2022 16:32

School can try but parents can fight it - I did and won. School really didn't want the hassle, I was dealt with like a pushy parent, head had the audacity to say girls couldn't be autistic and drs were diagnosing on demand! Upshot was she was sacked within 2 weeks, sorry moved on to a non school based role (conversation wasn't recorded so my word against hers, they believed me but compromised to avoid a tribunal situation)

buttons123456 · 27/09/2022 16:29

They can say they can't meet his needs but they will have to show evidence ..

Usually it's a conversation with parents and teachers though and it's done amicably ..

My son did 3 years in MS then I moved him to Sen school in year 2 because it was becoming overwhelming...

I would suggest to your friend she starts looking for schools and doesn't wait for the LA to do it ..

There is obviously reasons why they can't meet his needs so she needs to talk to them about that . I was very upset at first but knew it was the right thing for my son ultimately.

Mumofsend · 27/09/2022 16:28

Iamnotthe1 · 27/09/2022 16:26

Whilst this was something that happened in the past in a small number of schools, the practice has been identified and action taken against it. As such, any child who needs a move from mainstream to special must have a huge amount of evidence that supports it. The school must be able to prove, when questioned, that off-rolling isn't happening and must keep hold of all of the evidence to support this for several years as it will be something Ofsted look at if there is any suspicion or parental report that it might have happened.

My DD's school gave me an ultimatum of specialist or remove her. This was 18 months ago. It very much still happens.

Iamnotthe1 · 27/09/2022 16:26

FarmerRefuted · 27/09/2022 16:18

Some schools are notorious for off-rolling children by stealth and children with SEN are more likely to fall foul of this practice. DC old school would suggest special school to a lot of parents of children with SEN and/or disabilities, make a lot of noise about being unable to meet their needs, and would be deliberately difficult (e.g., disciplining children for behaviour related to their SEN, providing the bare minimum in support, not differentiating, refusing or withdrawing reasonable adjustments, etc). They could meet needs, they just didn't want to because they didn't want the extra work involved so employed all of these tactics to force these children out.

Whilst this was something that happened in the past in a small number of schools, the practice has been identified and action taken against it. As such, any child who needs a move from mainstream to special must have a huge amount of evidence that supports it. The school must be able to prove, when questioned, that off-rolling isn't happening and must keep hold of all of the evidence to support this for several years as it will be something Ofsted look at if there is any suspicion or parental report that it might have happened.

Mumofsend · 27/09/2022 16:24

My DD's school were adamant she had to go in to specialist. I refused and tackled the LA to get her plan properly provisioned and subsequently funded. It worked and she is doing phenomenally.

I'm happy to chat via message for specifics.

A child has a legal right to a mainstream education and I do think there is a divide between those who simply can't cope in mainstream due to things no one can control and those who just need lots of support to do so.

Needmorelego · 27/09/2022 16:21

@FarmerRefuted yes rather depressingly that's is true. Although I have heard it more for secondary schools rather than primary.

Iamnotthe1 · 27/09/2022 16:20

Schools must provide the provision set out in the EHCP. However, they can state that they are unable to provide that level of provision. That could be for a wide range of reasons (funding, resources, specialist support, staffing, impact, etc). The local authority is the one who then makes the decision as to whether or not they think the school can offer that level of provision.

Unfortunately, it is in the local authority's interest to act as if the school can meet the needs as it's cheaper for them. As such, they tend to claim a school can do it even if they can't. If they agree that the school can't meet the child's need for provision as set out in the EHCP then they must provide an alternative (potentially another mainstream but it could be a resourced provision setting or even a special school). It's also why they encourage "trying" the child in mainstream first as they know the child is less likely to move to special provision even if they need it.

Parental choice goes a long way here too. If the parent is pushing for resourced or special provision, the local authority is more likely to agree (though certainly not definite). If the parent isn't pushing or is, instead, saying they want mainstream then the local authority almost never recommends special.

Swipe left for the next trending thread