Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Can a school insist that a child is moved to a special needs school?

65 replies

Faciadipasta · 27/09/2022 15:46

A child in my DC'S school, aged 7. Parent us being told the school dont have the support available and the child will have to.move to a special school. Parent doesn't want the child moved away from all their friends. Can the school insist? Obviously this isn't really my business but just wanted to offer this mother support and advice. Seems very unfair that the school can just wash their hands of a child like this.
For reference the child is not disruptive, and has no extra physical needs. Just requires extra learning support due to ASD as well as difficulties with handwriting and spelling for example. Don't the school have a responsibility to get the support in for a child with an EHCP?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Underhisi · 02/10/2022 06:32

"Off rolling still definitely happens.
What happens is the child will be seen as disruptive etc , exclusions due to behaviour and after so many exclusions parents are encouraged to remove them or a managed move elsewhere is suggested so 'the child' does not have permanent exclusion on their record."

This happened to my friends child a few years ago. Child was young primary age and was awaiting Ehcp.Parent was told by the school to choose between home schooling or permanent exclusion. Parent refused to home school and was permanently excluded and out of school a year until special school place was found.

NeverDropYourMooncup · 02/10/2022 01:17

At my previous workplace, there were several children who had been sent there by the LA. It was fucking inhumane what they went through, despite having 1:1 TAs and the school was absolutely right to insist that they couldn't meet the needs of all but two of the year 7s. It still took 7 months to find one a place in specialist provision (and they probably spent years trying to get over the trauma) and even longer for others to get that or have managed moves to far, far, better schools.

The LA had insisted upon naming them in the EHCPs despite the school stating from the outset they couldn't meet them, and then we found out that their needs were even higher than had been presented.

Sometimes it's obvious in a school environment that it just isn't right for them. It's not offrolling in the general use of the word when you know you're being expected to be complicit in damaging a child no matter job hard you try.

Georgeandzippyzoo · 02/10/2022 00:32

Iamnotthe1 · 27/09/2022 16:26

Whilst this was something that happened in the past in a small number of schools, the practice has been identified and action taken against it. As such, any child who needs a move from mainstream to special must have a huge amount of evidence that supports it. The school must be able to prove, when questioned, that off-rolling isn't happening and must keep hold of all of the evidence to support this for several years as it will be something Ofsted look at if there is any suspicion or parental report that it might have happened.

Off rolling still definitely happens.

What happens is the child will be seen as disruptive etc , exclusions due to behaviour and after so many exclusions parents are encouraged to remove them or a managed move elsewhere is suggested so 'the child' does not have permanent exclusion on their record...this also allows the school NOT to have a permanently excluded child on their records.
Certain children ARE more at risk of this and that includes looked after, trauma backgrounds, disabilities /SEND.
If a child moves in y10/11 (I believe) then the school have to have it recorded, reasons etc because of off rolling and OFSTED will look into it, but many secondaries do this in y7-9 to weed out those kids that could become that statistic in y10 +.

DooLallyy · 02/10/2022 00:02

Also just to add - although in Mum's eyes the child may be coping ok with mainstream school, they probably aren't coping inside. Imagine going to work every day and struggling to complete your work as fast or as accurately as all your colleagues, you're not as good as the others and you're reminded of it every day. That's got to be tough.
My son had undiagnosed autism through most of his time at primary school, he was bright and clever and hid it so well. I knew there was something different about him but nobody would listen to me, every teacher said "no he's fine in school". Until he hit a wall, he crumbled and couldn't carry on and we've just been through 3 years of sheer hell.
My point is - he might be 'coping' now but if school think that mainstream isn't the right place for him then I think it's wise to listen, they're saying that for a good reason. Forcing a child to attend a setting which isn't meeting their needs can cause lasting damage, it's so important that their needs are identified, understood and fully supported. Being on suicide watch because your autistic child is burnt out isn't much fun 🥲

Ximenean · 01/10/2022 23:50

School can't dictate where he goes, but can argue they are unable to meet his needs as specified in his EHCP.

He also has quite a strong right to a mainstream education if this is his parents' preference, but not the right to dictate which school that is. If his school says they are unable to meet his needs, and that stands up to scrutiny, AND if the LA can find another mainstream that says they can, then they will send him there. Or if no mainstream says they can meet need, then they will look for special schools. In practice this takes months or years in most cases, and until it goes through, his current school have an obligation to try to meet his needs as best they can.

I would suggest parents and SENCo work together to tighten up his EHCP and secure more funding for him. I would also encourage the parents to look round special schools. They just might be blown away.

DooLallyy · 01/10/2022 23:47

It's a very complicated issue, but no, it's not the school that makes the decision, it's the LA who have the final say.
I told the LA that my son needed an SEN school, his mainstream school said they'd done everything possible to support him but they couldn't meet his needs, he had reports from Ed Psych saying he can't cope with a mainstream school but the LA still named the same mainstream on his EHCP, 13 months of fighting later and we've finally been offered an SEN school.
Most LA's will try to keep a child in mainstream where ever possible because most believe that a child has the best chance of academic success in a mainstream with the correct support, so I think if the child is not disruptive and is making progress in a mainstream it's likely the LA would name the mainstream in section I but maybe they can get more funding, eg 1:1 TA/sessions at an alternative provision for more nurture etc.

Devilishpyjamas · 01/10/2022 23:38

Incidentally imo (parent and professional) the right special school is usually streets ahead of the education available in a mainstream school - for the children who need special.

Devilishpyjamas · 01/10/2022 23:36

Most special schools are full and are dealing with a large number of tribunals (ie there are not enough spaces to go round).

Her child is entitled to a suitable education - not the best, but suitable. If the school are saying they cannot provide a suitable education then they need to look for a school that can. It would be worth looking at alternatives so parents know what is out there. Given the difficulties with places I can’t see anyone being forced into a special school against their will.

Hankunamatata · 01/10/2022 23:29

Its usually not just up to the school. If LEA educational psychologist have reviewed and agreed a SN school is appropriate then as a parent I would seriously listen. Its incredibly hard to secure a SN school place.

Its becoming more common in one of the local schools I know well where its take the school staff years to persuade some parents that they cant meet the child's needs while the child(ren) are learning absolutely nothing, not developing any skills, causing chaos in classroom quite often so other children get upset all because the parents want the child to stay in mainstream with their friends and feel the school is failing them even though there have been 1:1 put in place, sensory time, extra literacy and maths etc. Mainstream just cannot meet their needs and parents wont accept that.

Underhisi · 01/10/2022 23:10

"Different LA maintained special schools are there for different needs. Your assertion is incorrect."

Depends where you live. Where I live all the maintained special schools are for children with a learning disability.

Mumofsend · 01/10/2022 15:59

Lougle · 01/10/2022 07:27

"For reference the child is not disruptive, and has no extra physical needs. Just requires extra learning support due to ASD as well as difficulties with handwriting and spelling for example."

This can not be true. There is no way that a child who just needs 'extra learning support' would be offered a special school place. They are highly sought after and very limited. DD1 has been in special school since she was 4. She is now almost 17.

For a mainstream special school place to be offered, the child will need to have a learning disability. That doesn't mean their Autism - many children have Autism without learning disability. DD2 goes to an independent specialist school now because she couldn't cope with the mainstream environment. She couldn't go to a state special school because she doesn't have a learning disability.

Because of the special school environment, many children who were given 1:1 support in mainstream can be given independence in special school. DD1's schools have all been secure, so it didn't matter if a child took a detour on their way to their class because they were safe.

Different LA maintained special schools are there for different needs. Your assertion is incorrect.

itsgettingweird · 01/10/2022 11:49

In theory no.

But schools rarely say they can't meet need and push for special education unless a) it's needed and b) they actually have a cast iron case.

Special school places are like gold dust.

We have pupils transfer mid juniors sometimes and it's the best thing for them. They are in a learning environment with leers learning at their rate and speed. They are part of the community both academically and socially and it can do self esteem the world of good not to feel like you can't keep up and everyone can do things you can't.

Special school doesn't mean no hope or no future or no education. It doesn't mean children have behaviour problems.

Our school has classes that are far more well behaved than some mainstream schools! Our pupils just learn at a slower rate and need extras such as salt and OT.

Underhisi · 01/10/2022 11:45

"They do have a responsibility to educate your friends son, but if he really needs a1-1 and lots of interventions and the school simply don’t have the money or resources to provide it, what do you expect them to do?"

Tell the LA they cannot meet need without x, y, z in place or tell the LA it is impossible to meet need with the exact reasons why. Many schools will not do this. It is easier to push the child out by ' working' on the parents.

ClocksGoingBackwards · 01/10/2022 10:38

The problem is that there’s no guarantee a special school could meet this child’s needs considering that socially he is keeping up with his peers and especially if you’re right that all he needs is extra learning support with handwriting interventions. Special schools aren’t the automatic answer for every child whose needs aren’t being met at mainstream unfortunately.

PinkStickleBrick · 01/10/2022 10:05

The legal answer is no. A parent has the right to choose mainstream education.

Whether that the right thing to do or not is another matte

x2boys · 01/10/2022 10:02

I think special needs provision is very much area dependent, in my LEA we have two SEN primary schools, one that caters for children with moderate to severe learning disabilities, and one that caters for children with severe to profound learning disabilities,they also specialise with children who have autism along with learning disabilities
And again two SEN high school, s for the same reasons ,we also have two primary schools with autism hubs and two high schools with autism hubs .

Novum · 01/10/2022 10:00

Lancrelady80 · 01/10/2022 00:46

Places in special schools are like hens teeth - some parents fight for years to get one for their child.

This. We have a lovely boy in Y5 with autism. But last assessed at developmentally 18 months. Toilet trained in June, in nappies up until then. Needs a totally different curriculum - think occ therapy, speech & lang, sensory. Forget even the EYFS curriculum. It's nothing any of us were trained in and we have no specialists. EHCP in place but v woolly in terms of what to actually do with him - at present, he has a selection of toys various staff members' ch have grown out of. We do activities recommended by occ therapist but as they are couched in jargon eg develop vestibular skills rather than "use swing , soft play, wobble board" then we're in the dark.

He has a 1:1 (actually not HIS 1:1 - she is technically shared with another 3 children but his needs mean she has those others for v little. Lovely lady but again, no specialist.)

His needs are not being met as we have no practical advice. The head won't admit it because he brings extra funding. And although he has been discussed at special school panels year on year, there is never a place for him. His needs aren't considered severe enough in comparison to others.

What is the school doing to tighten up the EHCP? Can you contact the occupational therapist to ask for advice on what exactly you should be doing? Have you recommended at annual reviews that the child has full time dedicated 1:1 support? Have you recommended a full reassessment? Have you suggested to the parents that they appeal for a special school placement and offered to support them with the appeal, including referring them to someone like SOS SEN or IPSEA for support?

Novum · 01/10/2022 09:56

2bazookas · 27/09/2022 16:37

Seems very unfair that the school can just wash their hands of a child like this.
For reference the child is not disruptive, and has no extra physical needs. Just requires extra learning support due to ASD as well as difficulties with handwriting and spelling for example.

With respect, you don't observe or assess that child in class with her peers ; the school does. Far from "washing their hands of her" they are saying that in their experienced professional view she needs more help. Its possible her adoring parent is somewhat blinkered by love and wishful thinking.

It's also possible that the school is wrong - unfortunately some schools are astonishingly bad at dealing with SEN and knowing what children's entitlement is, and/or simply don't want to bother. They have an ongoing duty to use their best endeavours to meet SEN. If they can't do it for resource reasons, they should be calling early annual reviews and strongly recommending amendments to the EHCP that will ensure the right provision is in place. They should also be calling in professionals such as educational psychologists for further advice. It is really only if a child needs support of a type that is unavailable in mainstream schools that a special school should be considered.

Novum · 01/10/2022 09:50

OhmygodDont · 27/09/2022 15:54

In theory no but what happens if the school truly cannot support the child to be in school and learning? Do you keep them there but fail them? If the la won’t hand over more money for more support. Tricky for both I guess.

But they aren't in that situation if they haven't even applied for an EHCP

catscutewhiskers · 01/10/2022 09:44

School do have the responsibility but honestly it's unlikely the child is in the right setting if school are suggesting they need a specialist setting. Most parents have to fight to get specialist.
The child has a right to a mainstream setting if the parents want it. It's almost unheard of for an LA to move a child against the parents wishes to specialist so I wouldn't be worried at all. Specialist usually costs more and the LA are money driven. However what's in the child's best interests- sounds like they won't be meeting their potential if school are saying they can't meet needs.

ClocksGoingBackwards · 01/10/2022 09:37

No, they can’t insist that the child goes to a special school, but they can be truthful and say that they can’t support him.

They do have a responsibility to educate your friends son, but if he really needs a1-1 and lots of interventions and the school simply don’t have the money or resources to provide it, what do you expect them to do?

Is the parent already doing everything they can to get an ehcp in place? It’s not just up to the school.

x2boys · 01/10/2022 09:28

Lancrelady80 · 01/10/2022 00:46

Places in special schools are like hens teeth - some parents fight for years to get one for their child.

This. We have a lovely boy in Y5 with autism. But last assessed at developmentally 18 months. Toilet trained in June, in nappies up until then. Needs a totally different curriculum - think occ therapy, speech & lang, sensory. Forget even the EYFS curriculum. It's nothing any of us were trained in and we have no specialists. EHCP in place but v woolly in terms of what to actually do with him - at present, he has a selection of toys various staff members' ch have grown out of. We do activities recommended by occ therapist but as they are couched in jargon eg develop vestibular skills rather than "use swing , soft play, wobble board" then we're in the dark.

He has a 1:1 (actually not HIS 1:1 - she is technically shared with another 3 children but his needs mean she has those others for v little. Lovely lady but again, no specialist.)

His needs are not being met as we have no practical advice. The head won't admit it because he brings extra funding. And although he has been discussed at special school panels year on year, there is never a place for him. His needs aren't considered severe enough in comparison to others.

That poor child ,I'm. Not blaming you but my son has similar disabilities hes 12 and has always been in a special school ,everything is tailored to his needs they do flour writing ,take him on walks ,do activities teaching him life skills ,they have a flat at the school equipped with a washing machine, cooker etc to teach pupils some independence, they also have a hydro pool ,huge sensory room ,trampolines ,etc this is what he needs

AntlerRose · 01/10/2022 07:47

Lancrelady80 · 01/10/2022 00:46

Places in special schools are like hens teeth - some parents fight for years to get one for their child.

This. We have a lovely boy in Y5 with autism. But last assessed at developmentally 18 months. Toilet trained in June, in nappies up until then. Needs a totally different curriculum - think occ therapy, speech & lang, sensory. Forget even the EYFS curriculum. It's nothing any of us were trained in and we have no specialists. EHCP in place but v woolly in terms of what to actually do with him - at present, he has a selection of toys various staff members' ch have grown out of. We do activities recommended by occ therapist but as they are couched in jargon eg develop vestibular skills rather than "use swing , soft play, wobble board" then we're in the dark.

He has a 1:1 (actually not HIS 1:1 - she is technically shared with another 3 children but his needs mean she has those others for v little. Lovely lady but again, no specialist.)

His needs are not being met as we have no practical advice. The head won't admit it because he brings extra funding. And although he has been discussed at special school panels year on year, there is never a place for him. His needs aren't considered severe enough in comparison to others.

This is heart breaking. Do his parents have capacity to ask for an emergency annual review, get all his assessments re-done and go to tribunal for a properly specified and quantified ehcp if the LA hands back a wooly one? His review this year is a transition review so its where secondary school is considered.

Blahdeebla · 01/10/2022 07:45

In our Borough, they will 'offer' a child borough - wide. If all schools say they can't meet the needs of them then the Borough will give them a place somewhere with extra provision or a special needs school, depending on the case. We had this recently with a child the nursery insisted couldn't cope with mainstream, but parents insisted they could.

Wheresmymoneytree · 01/10/2022 07:40

We have a student that we can’t get into the school building. We can’t meet their needs, their parents agree, they have an ehcp already and we have tried to get them into a special school. They have never been inside the school building as a direct result of their needs. I have worked at my school for 10 years and have never known us say a child’s needs cannot be met before. They’ve been turned down a place. I obviously can’t give more details as it’s a current student.

If your friends child has been offered a place over the student I am supposed to teach then I would take it because they must need it! If it was a case of school just sending students they don’t want then they would be 10x bigger.