Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think Starmer is starting to show some original ideas?

193 replies

CurseOfBigness · 27/09/2022 15:40

“He pledges to set up a publicly-owned green energy company within a year if he is elected, with 100% clean power by 2030”

Sounds enterprising and different to the bog standard ‘we’re going to nationalise everything’. There’s agency with it being green energy and good for the environment. Sounds more like responsible nationalisation…

“He says the war in Ukraine was the spark that caused rising energy costs, but that the country was not in a position to deal with it.”

And that’s insightful. Sounds like he’s thought something through.

Being reported Live from Labour conference: www.bbc.co.uk/news/live/uk-politics-63042145

P.S. I’m a centric voter who swings and sways depending on what’s going on at the time and what’s on offer etc.
Right now, I do not like Truss’ government because she seems irresponsible (dodging the OBR report for the mini budget with semantics) and she just doesn’t care…
Labour as the obvious opposition but there are other options. This is the first time in a while I’ve seen Starmer present a fresh new idea…

OP posts:
RufustheFloralmissingreindeer · 28/09/2022 08:46

Actually while im here

yes I would agree that many people don’t seem to care about the womens rights issue compared to climate etc

but I would also say that some of these issues and there potential outcomes aren’t being reported by the media…as i said above

RufustheFloralmissingreindeer · 28/09/2022 08:43

I want the truth, the whole truth and nothing but the truth. Surely you do too?

both in real life and politics you are never going to get that

i was disappointed in Kier when he started, mainly because even in interviews he didn’t really seem to be saying anything but hopefully he will come into his own. At the very least we need a strong opposition

and I completely agree re labour points and plans not being reported, obviously the same thing happens with lib dems etc and ive had to explain this to friends and family on many occasions

Tiani4 · 28/09/2022 08:40

I am weirdly grateful for Liz Truss. As am now anticipating a big swing to Labour for the next election, enough to get Labour in government - we just needed an electable leader of the Labour Party. It's great that Kier is getting the recognition he deserves as a potentially great PM

CurseOfBigness · 28/09/2022 08:30

Dragonskin · 28/09/2022 07:49

*“He says the war in Ukraine was the spark that caused rising energy costs, but that the country was not in a position to deal with it.”

And that’s insightful. Sounds like he’s thought something through.*

Good god, if people consider something that is so basic and blatantly obvious as 'insightful' from a political leader, the bar is set very low!

Rising energy bills ‘price worth paying’ for Ukraine support, says Liz Truss

He’s offering a solution. That’s a whole lot better than Truss’ solution that we simply accept the sacrifice.

Starmer is saying we can do both. Support Ukraine and also have a solution ourselves that doesn’t mean the UK people are being sacrificed in the process.

OP posts:
Dragonskin · 28/09/2022 07:49

*“He says the war in Ukraine was the spark that caused rising energy costs, but that the country was not in a position to deal with it.”

And that’s insightful. Sounds like he’s thought something through.*

Good god, if people consider something that is so basic and blatantly obvious as 'insightful' from a political leader, the bar is set very low!

WandaWomblesaurus · 28/09/2022 07:40

Fishandchipsupper · 27/09/2022 16:44

Yeah but no but what about women? Still no recognition of 51% of the population.

Exactly. HE can say what he wants but he can't speak the truth.

MayThe4th · 28/09/2022 03:28

MayThe4th · 28/09/2022 03:26

The way people starting threads or talking eloquently about one or other side of the debate are accused of being plants or press is truly pathetic.

Presumably those who are incapable of formulating a decent argument or opinion can’t believe that there are other people who can, so they must be press or bots. Okayyyy.

As for the trans debate, there is a discussion to be had, but the reality is that there is no straightforward answer here. Gender issues are here to stay. But if something isn’t done how you identify is going to be irrelevant because you’re going to be financially fucked, but hey, as long as you can push the women’s rights issue which seemingly most people don’t care about in comparison then crack on.

Most governments across the world are coming up against this now. The NZ government are pushing towards puberty blockers being widely accepted, and yet people talk up Jasinda Arden as the next great pm, and what with her being a woman and all.

I’ve never voted labour or conservative, but at this point it’s a question of priority. And if you’re prepared to throw the economy to the tourists and plunge a significant proportion of society into further poverty over a discussion on the definition of a woman then that says more about you than anything else.

*economy under the bus

MayThe4th · 28/09/2022 03:26

The way people starting threads or talking eloquently about one or other side of the debate are accused of being plants or press is truly pathetic.

Presumably those who are incapable of formulating a decent argument or opinion can’t believe that there are other people who can, so they must be press or bots. Okayyyy.

As for the trans debate, there is a discussion to be had, but the reality is that there is no straightforward answer here. Gender issues are here to stay. But if something isn’t done how you identify is going to be irrelevant because you’re going to be financially fucked, but hey, as long as you can push the women’s rights issue which seemingly most people don’t care about in comparison then crack on.

Most governments across the world are coming up against this now. The NZ government are pushing towards puberty blockers being widely accepted, and yet people talk up Jasinda Arden as the next great pm, and what with her being a woman and all.

I’ve never voted labour or conservative, but at this point it’s a question of priority. And if you’re prepared to throw the economy to the tourists and plunge a significant proportion of society into further poverty over a discussion on the definition of a woman then that says more about you than anything else.

HellonHeels · 28/09/2022 03:01

StrictlyAFemaleFemale · 27/09/2022 16:56

Labour cannot identify what a woman is and without the very basic terminology our sex based rights are meaningless. Go onto twitter and search #labourlosingwomen

This!

ilovesooty · 28/09/2022 02:18

basilmint · 28/09/2022 01:21

Yet again this blatant Labour PR thread is failing to listen to women

Speak for yourself. Many women on this thread and others have said that the TWAW issue is way down the list of issues compared to the way current government policy is affecting women.

I would be interested to see polling which shows this would be an issue in deciding votes in an election. Voters will be prioritising the economy, cost of living, health care. I would expect environmental issues to be considered more important than trans issues among the wider electorate.

Agreed.

Nat6999 · 28/09/2022 02:15

This was the best speech I have heard from Keir Starmer, I'm a Labour Party member & this is the most I have heard them sound like a party getting ready to govern. The Great British Energy idea is nothing short of Genius & if it takes off will be brilliant for this country, it will create jobs & stop us from importing energy from places like France, green energy could be a new industrial revolution for the country, it could be something that school & University leavers could aspire to work in & be a growth industry.

CurseOfBigness · 28/09/2022 02:12

Oiseaux · 28/09/2022 01:37

He's controlled opposition. Tory plant. Can't stand him.

That’s like saying Truss is a Labour plant. Seems to be the only explanation for why she’d be prepared to be “unpopular” as leader of the conservatives. And follow through to unpopularity…. By crashing the pound within a week!

We know it’s far fetched and probably not true. But who knows?

OP posts:
JockTamsonsBairns · 28/09/2022 02:09

Fishandchipsupper · 28/09/2022 00:32

So impressive, he can’t decide whether women or men are the cervix havers.

I know, right?
Starmer is the hateful enemy here.
If only we could have a Tory government forever, cos they're massive on women's issues.

JockTamsonsBairns · 28/09/2022 02:05

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

But her vote is equal to yours.

JockTamsonsBairns · 28/09/2022 01:58

Fishandchipsupper · 28/09/2022 00:35

Also wasn’t he director of public prosecutions when the Rotherham Grooming Gang were operating with the knowledge of the labour council and police because they were too scared of being called racists. I can see a parallel now where Keir is too scared to be called a transphobe.

Oh shit. So you're race baiting now?
Hope the Tory Party gives you the safe solution you're looking for.

JockTamsonsBairns · 28/09/2022 01:49

Fishandchipsupper · 28/09/2022 00:05

Well if you stopped the PR flattery of Kier Starmer, you’d have noticed that Gender Critical women have been banned from the Labour conference. Lesbians have been banned from the conference.

And Keir and Stella Creasey David Lamey and the rest of the hierarchy think that men can become women because of their feelings. When women object to losing their rights and voices and safety, when peodophiles can state that they are women and get housed in prisons where there’s a mother and baby unit and a teenage girl unit. And Labour think that the women who object to this erosion of women’s safety and rights means they are’Rights hoarding dinosaurs’.
Your media people who have started this thread need to report back to head office that Labour Is Losing Women.

Lesbians have been banned from conference?
Not my experience.

JockTamsonsBairns · 28/09/2022 01:43

KendrickLamaze · 27/09/2022 19:55

@Suprima how is what I've said why we are fucked? I think those in power caused it.

Tory Lite is the right side of labour. An example is sacking Sam Tarry for being on a picket line. He appeared to be trying to get Tory voters on side rather than investing in his own parties narrative.

He didn't sack Sam Tarry for being on a picket line ffs! 🤦‍♀️. Stop peddling this Daily Express shit.
Tarry was sacked because he took it upon himself to declare what he thought Labour policy should be while being interviewed by the media. He had no place to do that, and he undermined the leadership by doing so.

Oiseaux · 28/09/2022 01:37

He's controlled opposition. Tory plant. Can't stand him.

basilmint · 28/09/2022 01:21

Yet again this blatant Labour PR thread is failing to listen to women

Speak for yourself. Many women on this thread and others have said that the TWAW issue is way down the list of issues compared to the way current government policy is affecting women.

I would be interested to see polling which shows this would be an issue in deciding votes in an election. Voters will be prioritising the economy, cost of living, health care. I would expect environmental issues to be considered more important than trans issues among the wider electorate.

JockTamsonsBairns · 28/09/2022 01:20

MeanderingGently · 27/09/2022 17:21

Well, I never EVER thought I'd say this in my lifetime but......

....as a life-long Tory voter, Starmer might just get my vote one day.

If he wants to catch votes from people like me (totally Tory in all my 60-odd years, didn't particularly have a problem with Boris or BREXIT, have grown up with a deep suspicion of Labour), he is going the right way about it.

Starmer gives the impression of thinking things through. Instead of just criticising the government (a total turn-off if ever there was one) he is giving sensible alternatives and costed-out solutions. I have listened to some of the interviews, and he comes across as balanced in his viewpoint, doesn't fudge the question, doesn't get rattled when the interviewer tries a trick question or two.

For the first time I see a Labour leader that I could relate to, that I would not be afraid to vote for.
I can't believe I'm saying this, but Liz Truss and her cronies have made some pretty shit decisions in the last few days. When the country is in crisis and ordinary folks are terrified that they won't be able to eat/heat or pay the mortgage, who the bloody hell would produce a mini budget which rewards high earners, removes bankers' bonus cap, and will send inflation shooting skywards? Fucking madness. I am shocked by the party I supposedly support.

I tell you, I am seriously considering changing my political alliances, and if I think this, there must be many others who also feel the same.....

If it comes as any comfort, you are most definitely not alone!
I'm a LP member, very unusually married to a dyed in the wool Tory voter.
DH has been utterly dismayed at the Tory Party over the past 5 years, and is beginning to look favourably towards Starmer as a very viable option.
Perhaps more interestingly, one of my closest friends is (was) a Tory party staffer. We've had the most illustrious political conversations over the years - and, since Truss took office, she has downed tools and is also listening to Starmer with interest.

Before anyone else says it, I do very much acknowledge that there is a conversation to be had amongst the Labour Party on the back of the sheer number of right-of-centre voters beginning to infiltrate the ranks. It does raise genuine questions about what we really stand for.
Left wing purists would say that there's no place within Labour for either my husband or my friend, and that "Tories = Bad".
I don't subscribe to that. I don't buy into political extremism. I think the Labour Party can be big enough to accommodate a broadchurch of ideas, and that we can stand for creating an equality of opportunity in a way that the Tory Party can't, because it's not within their ideology to do so.

I think there's a bit of excitement around Labour at the moment, and we've seen some pretty progressive policies coming through from the conference.
Lots of the Starmer critics have slated him for being lacking in clear policy, and for failing to offer up a strong opposition. I was one of those critics - but he's been brilliant this conference, and I really hope that he can ride the bounce in the polls and be the unifying leader that this country needs.

CurseOfBigness · 28/09/2022 01:20

^fair hearing

OP posts:
CurseOfBigness · 28/09/2022 01:18

@Fishandchipsupper Why are you surprised I’m treating your claims with scepticism?!

You’ve outright accused me of being Labour media PR (and I’m definitely not!). How can I trust your credibility?

I sense emotions are running high for you.

I have in the past made errors of judgement about things when matters are emotive. Of course women’s rights matter to me (I’m a woman and I’m very well read on suffragette history). That’s why I want to do some reading about your claims and give them a fair balance - this means credibility too.

I imagine you want to be fair as well?

So… Boris Johnson seems to be the source of the line that Starmer “struggled to define what a woman was”.

I want to probe this. Firstly, Is this true? Also, has Boris defined what a woman was? What’s really going on here?

I want the truth, the whole truth and nothing but the truth. Surely you do too?

OP posts:
AuntTwacky · 28/09/2022 01:16

And you don't give a shit about the new Italian pm being a far right lunatic

AuntTwacky · 28/09/2022 01:15

Thank you!

Fishandchipsupper · 28/09/2022 01:12

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.