Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to ask daughters boyfriend why he's been kicked out.

115 replies

cheesecadet · 27/09/2022 13:58

My mid teen has been with her boyfriend for 5 months and I've really taken to him, could tell from the start he'd come from a good home. Always very polite and mature & very supportive of her.
My daughter said early on that his parents were too strict. She says he won't tell her why (big red flag). She's either lying to us (so I don't think less of him) or he can't bring himself to tell her (unlikely in my eyes). He's obviously done something. And I want to know if he's not what he seems.
He's coming over later. (he's currently staying with a friend).
Aibu to ask him why?

OP posts:
AuntSalli · 27/09/2022 16:11

billy1966 · 27/09/2022 14:11

Your daughter is still very young.

Good familys don't throw out children from the home, so I would want to know.

In retrospect it is as clear as day that my father has asperges, so I would quite regularly get thrown out of the house between the age of 14 and 16 for simply questioning whether or not having spaghetti Bolognese from a jarfor the fifth day in a row was palatable, or wondering whether I could get some new school uniform as mine had holes in it would get me a severe smack round the face.

on the surface of course he was a perfectly respectable businessman that turned up for every parents evening, smiled and nodded in the right places and appeared to be a model parent.

Ponoka7 · 27/09/2022 16:11

I think that you should get to the bottom of where he is staying and what he is doing for money. Treating your DD well is a bit of a red herring. Trouble can come from issues caused by lifestyle etc.

candycaneframe · 27/09/2022 16:08

Imtoowettowoo · 27/09/2022 15:46

OP, If your daughter has been seeing this chap for 5 months and they are both minors then surely you have the 'phone number for his parents?

I would certainly ask him what is going on and, if necessary, follow it up with a 'phone call to his parents.

It could be a ruse on behalf of DD to have him living at your house.

You certainly need to get to the bottom of this.

Why would the op have his parents phone number?

Do you think it's normal to have your teenagers boyfriends parents numbers at 16?

Christ almighty

cheesecadet · 27/09/2022 16:08

Thank you so much everyone.
Indeed he could lie, I'm aware of that.
I'm going to gently make him aware that I'm here if he needs any support. I won't make it the first thing I say, I'll be friendly and weigh up the situation first. I just want to know that my daughter is safe. Also that he is too.

OP posts:
goldfinchonthelawn · 27/09/2022 16:08

Minimalme · 27/09/2022 14:15

I came from a 'good home'. I am no contact with my 'good parents'.

I have never done anything wrong.

This. I knew a few people in my teens, including DSis's first boyfriend, who were good people but kicked out from home on the stupidest of reasons. Parents could seem like good people but be cruel and controlling or neglectful and indifferent.

Algor1thm · 27/09/2022 16:07

I think you should ask, but from the point of view of helping to safeguard him and find out if he's being abused in any way. Please don't go in with the assumption that he's done something wrong and his parents are in the right. You seem to be basing the fact that he comes from a 'good home' on his manners? That's not a lot to go by.

Now he may well be completely unwilling to talk to you about it, especially if he's closed off to your daughter about it too. This is even more of a red flag that he may be a victim of abuse. I wonder if there's anything that you can do to support him? Although if he's a minor who's been made homeless I assume social services are involved? If not then please contact them ASAP.

Octomore · 27/09/2022 16:05

It could be the case that there's a severe clash of personalities/expectations and a lack of communication.

You say this as if it would justify it.

Do you think good, non-abusive parents would kick a child out in this scenario? He's a child and they are the adults - managing personality clashes and communicating with your child is part of the job of being a parent.

ldontWanna · 27/09/2022 16:03

I don't see anything wrong with asking. In fact, you'd be failing to safeguard your daughter if you didn't .
It could be the case that his parents are abusive.
It could be the case that there's a severe clash of personalities/expectations and a lack of communication.

It could also be the case(and no one seems to want to consider it) that he has done something that is "that bad".(drugs,gangs,abusive towards his parents or a sibling etc.)

Just keep it simple,friendly and definitely go in with an open mind. If you get more info you can form an opinion then and deciding what,if anything, you should do next.

Strangeways19 · 27/09/2022 16:02

I would not ask him or probe. It is private. I would though offer him support. If say "hey Jo, I'm sorry to hear that you're having a tough time please know that we are here should you need us to talk/ watch a film/just spend some time should you need it ' (or whatever you want/can offer). This way he's much more likely to be open to building some trust & confiding.

I too was that teen, came from a 'good family ' went to school with black eyes that no-one questioned because I was so mad most of the time no-one wanted to approach me.
I had an abusive older sibling that was out of parental control & I took the brunt. It was an awful situation. My sibling kicked me out at 16 - parents did nothing.

Obvious no contact with any of them now, I think I'm very well out of it.

moonypadfootprongs · 27/09/2022 15:56

Surely the only thing you need to know is that he has a safe place to stay tonight!!!
It's not your business to know the ins and outs of it unless he chooses to share that with you.

wildseas · 27/09/2022 15:56

I agree with pp.

I think your best bet is to open a sympathetic conversation with him, ask him if he needs support with anything, check that he has somewhere to sleep.

As part of that I think its appropriate to ask what happened, but not to comment or judge.

I think if you do that its likely he'll open up either during the conversation or in future once he knows he can trust you.

ShirtingForkBalls · 27/09/2022 15:56

I'd ask. But in a caring way. Not in an accusatory way op.

Tropicaliyes · 27/09/2022 15:54

I was kicked out at 16, I didn’t do anything wrong but it was all because I became sick at 11 and my mother didn’t want to deal with me anymore! I have two other siblings, one older and one younger and my older sibling left of her own accord roughly at the same age and my younger sibling is still there to this day and has been treated VERY different to my sister and I!

I couldn’t help getting sick, but the fact that I was out the home now didn’t reflect badly on anyone else except me! I had plenty of friends around me, some which were very close and ultimately I was the one that screwed around way less than them as I have so much more to lose than they did.

over 15 years later from that day I seem to be the only one progressing in life whereas they all are stuck in a time warp doing the same things they were back then, hoping life will change but doing nothing positive to make that change!

the fact this boy has such a supportive family on his girlfriends side is more valuable than anything, I really appreciated my friends family that treated me better than my own blood! They provided a sense of normalcy and belonging I never felt.

he will come to you when he is ready to let you know what has happened. I wouldn’t ask him directly but I would speak to your daughter to try and get a clearer picture of him, she for sure will feed the info back to him so he will know you would like to know but would be willing to wait until his ready.

girlmom21 · 27/09/2022 15:50

IncompleteSenten · 27/09/2022 15:48

What makes you think he'd tell you the truth?

Because if he needs help or he's upset having an adult he feels he can trust could be exactly what he needs.

Calphurnia88 · 27/09/2022 15:50

For your daughters sake you should find out, but tread carefully.

Parental abuse is one scenario, but when I was a similar age I had a boyfriend (my first) who from the outset seemed mature and polite but was actually very troubled, and exhibited a lot of controlling and threatening behaviour towards me that I was too naive to understand at the time. It wasn't until his parents met my parents about a year into the relationship that I found out he had a violent past. It was almost a relief, as from there I felt I could have a open dialogue with my parents about how he had been treating me, which gave me the confidence to end the relationship. It took a year though and I wish we could have had the conversation sooner.

Not saying this is what is happening with your daughter, but she needs to be your number one concern.

IncompleteSenten · 27/09/2022 15:48

What makes you think he'd tell you the truth?

Octomore · 27/09/2022 15:46

Also, bear in mind that children do not realise that what their parents do isn't normal, so your chances of getting a genuine picture from this kid may well be low.

The home you grow up in is the only "normal" you know until you hit adulthood. Children who grow up in abusive homes end up with very skewed ideas about what "normal" parent behaviour looks like, so they justify and defend it.

They also grow up fully believing what their parents say about them. If their parent says their behaviour is awful, they'll believe it.

Most people I've spoken to who were abused as children only realised as adults that what went on in their childhood homes was a million miles from normal.

For me, it's been having nieces and nephews, thinking about how I was treated at their age, and realising how small and vulnerable I was. Prior to that, I just dismissed my experiences as being within the normal range of parent behaviour.

summergone · 27/09/2022 15:46

I wouldn't mention you hope your dd is being treated ok , I would hope that she has the mindset that if she isn't being treated ok then she should end the relationship. I would say something along the lines of ' dd said you're not living at home at the moment is everything ok ? Do you need help with anything ?'

Imtoowettowoo · 27/09/2022 15:46

OP, If your daughter has been seeing this chap for 5 months and they are both minors then surely you have the 'phone number for his parents?

I would certainly ask him what is going on and, if necessary, follow it up with a 'phone call to his parents.

It could be a ruse on behalf of DD to have him living at your house.

You certainly need to get to the bottom of this.

been and done it. · 27/09/2022 15:45

He could also be doing/dealing drugs/stealing being abusive to younger siblings/ taking their car/staying out all night. All of those things or none of them but as a parent you need to know..end of...it's no-one else's business on here how or why his parents have chucked him out..how they deal with him is their concern not ours. Just ask him.

Ilovenutellaaaaa · 27/09/2022 15:44

Can't you call his parents and just ask, say something like you are aware that he's been kicked out, and you are just wondering why because you have your daughter to think about, ....for example if he got kicked out over something like coming home late, not helping round the house, etc then that's one thing, but if he got kicked out because of something like drugs or being violent to his parents or being in trouble with the police then you need to know for your daughter's sake

The fact that he won't say is a huge red flag, if he won't say then ask his parents yourself...

Lndnmummy · 27/09/2022 15:39

Octomore · 27/09/2022 15:35

It took me years and I mean years not to justify what my parents did I always blamed me but actually I was a good kid really

Same. It's only as an adult that I've come to realise exactly how badly my parents failed me.

Me too

Floomobal · 27/09/2022 15:38

could tell from the start he'd come from a good home

A “good home” wouldn’t kick a child out, so I wouldn’t describe it as that. I think depending on how well you know him, asking if he’s ok is appropriate. Asking what he’s done and why he’s been abandoned by his parents isn’t really appropriate

Lndnmummy · 27/09/2022 15:38

If it was me, I would be worried for his wellbeing and want to see if I could help in anyway. He could be vulnerable and need help and support from adults around him. So I would approach him with that in mind. I hope he is ok.

Octomore · 27/09/2022 15:35

It took me years and I mean years not to justify what my parents did I always blamed me but actually I was a good kid really

Same. It's only as an adult that I've come to realise exactly how badly my parents failed me.

Swipe left for the next trending thread