Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to ask daughters boyfriend why he's been kicked out.

115 replies

cheesecadet · 27/09/2022 13:58

My mid teen has been with her boyfriend for 5 months and I've really taken to him, could tell from the start he'd come from a good home. Always very polite and mature & very supportive of her.
My daughter said early on that his parents were too strict. She says he won't tell her why (big red flag). She's either lying to us (so I don't think less of him) or he can't bring himself to tell her (unlikely in my eyes). He's obviously done something. And I want to know if he's not what he seems.
He's coming over later. (he's currently staying with a friend).
Aibu to ask him why?

OP posts:
Wickerbaskethandle · 27/09/2022 17:21

Dannexe · 27/09/2022 17:10

Its also possible of course that he has just left and stomped off to his friends house and not been "kicked out" at all. He's 16, they can't pick him up and bundle him in a car.

As the parent of two large teenage boys I can quite see how a "if you want to live under our roof you need to do xy and z/ stop doing a,b and c" conversation could be repeated by a teenager as being kicked out.

Live under our roof?

Wow.

Dannexe · 27/09/2022 17:10

Its also possible of course that he has just left and stomped off to his friends house and not been "kicked out" at all. He's 16, they can't pick him up and bundle him in a car.

As the parent of two large teenage boys I can quite see how a "if you want to live under our roof you need to do xy and z/ stop doing a,b and c" conversation could be repeated by a teenager as being kicked out.

candycaneframe · 27/09/2022 17:02

@ldontWanna no one has said the op is wrong for being concerned

Being concerned doesn't give you a 'right' to ask someone for personal information.

Is that really hard to grasp?

HardLanding · 27/09/2022 17:02

I too was from a “good home” - big house, private school, etc etc.

As an adult it terrifies me how many people she fooled.

CamilasGabagool · 27/09/2022 16:59

Sunnyqueen · 27/09/2022 16:56

You know there are lots of polite, well presenting kids with absolutely abusive c*nts for parents. The 'he must come from a good home' assumption is ignorant as hell. Perhaps he is like that of his own merit.

This is what was said about me

"You turned out very well considering your mum is batshit" etc etc

steppemum · 27/09/2022 16:59

When ds was in the school sixth form, one of his friends was effectively kicked out of home.
Charming, nice, well spoken and clever.
He came to stay at ours one night per week, and at other people's on other nights and spent the weekends with a relative who live some distance away.

The initial story was that he was kicked out as he and his step dad don't get on.
Then it was that they were veyr strict.
But actually the reason was that he smokes a lot of weed and consistently did it in their house/garden despite being told not to. He and his parents fell out over it big time.

So I am a little sceptical of 16 year olds being kicked out, I think there is usually more to it than meets the eye. Whether that is more on the child's side or more on the parent's obviously depends

Sunnyqueen · 27/09/2022 16:56

You know there are lots of polite, well presenting kids with absolutely abusive c*nts for parents. The 'he must come from a good home' assumption is ignorant as hell. Perhaps he is like that of his own merit.

HardLanding · 27/09/2022 16:55

My Mum told people she kicked me out at 16, with a whole list of reasons (lies) why.

In reality, I ran away to my Grandparents, a few days after I turned 16, because I knew I couldn’t be forced to go back “home” (I’d done this a few times). Home being where my mother was an alcoholic who subjected me to violent attacks at least once a week, alongside emotional and mental abuse.

cheesecadet · 27/09/2022 16:55

So he's coming soon. So far my daughter has said that his parents have told him he can go back on Friday and at first she said he won't go back, but then he might try it but if it doesn't work out he can stay at another friend's house.
I am still going to ask if he's okay, that he doesn't have to tell me the ins and outs but tell him I'll support him if he needs it.

OP posts:
CamilasGabagool · 27/09/2022 16:53

Anyway, can't remember why I shared my post. But I guess my point is - it could be abusive parents.

Still a worry either way!

georgarina · 27/09/2022 16:52

ldontWanna · 27/09/2022 16:46

It's not like he's a random kid from the street. This kid comes into her house and is dating her 15 yo daughter. He might not tell her anything, but don't make her sound like some kind of nutter for being concerned(or the posters agreeing with her).

Same kind of person who says not to call SS because 'it's none of your business'

CamilasGabagool · 27/09/2022 16:51

When i was 17, My mum kicked me out after i tried to disagree with her about something silly (politics maybe). She said "enough of your cheek or you're out" and pointed to the front door.

I thought, OK weird. I'll just message my bf and ask if I can stay with him. His parents said yes and then my mum begged me to stay. So I did.

A week later, my mum came bursting in my bedroom calling me a whore. Because I had a £20 note in my coat pocket. (My grandad gave it to me), but my mums first thought was that I was a prostitute!! Craziness. I was quiet, introverted and had one long term quiet and introverted boyfriend.

I was so shy I wouldn't even wear skirts or shorts. I hated getting my legs out. I never wore makeup or anything.

Anyway she kicked me out again. His dad arrived and I already had everything packed from the first time so I took all my stuff and left. Didn't speak to her for 2 years.

It was bliss

Very abusive and scary at times! All the shouting has left me very anxious and I have incredibly low self esteem.

Always grateful to my boyfriends family. They taught me what a real family is like and I'm the mum I am today because of this.

ldontWanna · 27/09/2022 16:46

candycaneframe · 27/09/2022 16:38

I'm baffled that grown adults on here genuinely think the OP has any right to ask an unrelated child for personal information.

This is basic shit

It's not like he's a random kid from the street. This kid comes into her house and is dating her 15 yo daughter. He might not tell her anything, but don't make her sound like some kind of nutter for being concerned(or the posters agreeing with her).

georgarina · 27/09/2022 16:39

I would talk to him from a place of sympathy and concern, ask what's been going on and if he needs help.

Kicking a 15/16 year old out with nowhere to go is not acceptable.

candycaneframe · 27/09/2022 16:38

I'm baffled that grown adults on here genuinely think the OP has any right to ask an unrelated child for personal information.

This is basic shit

MumCanIDoThat · 27/09/2022 16:36

They are still children and off course you need to know what has happened. You need to know the situation your daughter is involved in.

pointythings · 27/09/2022 16:34

I'd be worried about his home situation more than about anything he's done. Not everyone has great parents. DD2's former GF was very nearly kicked out of her home by her mother - for being gay.

MelodyPondsMum · 27/09/2022 16:33

Maybe he hasn't been kicked out.
My ex left home at 16. As a teen, he could have charmed you with a story about why he left but it wouldn't have been true and he would be the first person to say that he wouldn't want his mid-teen having a relationship with someone like him. He had lots of counselling and was a completely different person as an adult.
So I understand all the posters jumping to paint pictures of abusive homes and caring about whether he has somewhere to stay but they aren't the only reasons someone leaves. You can't stop your DD dating him but I'd be aware that just because you ask him, it doesn't mean he'll tell you the truth.

Goingforarun · 27/09/2022 16:33

Exactly as DNAwrangler said. More likely he’s had a row and wants to shock his parents. Reverse the situation. You should contact his parents if you’re letting him stay at yours.

sóh₂wl̥ · 27/09/2022 16:26

Octomore · 27/09/2022 16:05

It could be the case that there's a severe clash of personalities/expectations and a lack of communication.

You say this as if it would justify it.

Do you think good, non-abusive parents would kick a child out in this scenario? He's a child and they are the adults - managing personality clashes and communicating with your child is part of the job of being a parent.

It what happened with older sibling - 17 not 16 - parents very controlling but not abusive and sibling incredibly selfish and unthinking including lying and stealing- series of massive rows parents laid down law while under their roof and sibling stormed off with stuff and went to live in succession of shared house/squats/sofa surfing.

My DP were devastated - but also with younger kids not in a position to accept the status quo. They actually didn't stop talking and stepped in many times to keep sibling off the streets and get them out of debt but took till 30s till they held a full time job and got a council flat.

They did go back and live for short periods often with limit limits- one of which sibling physically assaulted me -both adults- without warning and my DP upset me by taking their side - and frankly I've had little to do with sibling since.

DNAwrangler · 27/09/2022 16:25

How do you know he’s been kicked out?

Paigeycakey · 27/09/2022 16:18

@ldontWanna agree I moved out too when I was 16 nothing sinister and it wasn't too long. Just like you say parents and teens clash.... some of us on the thread may have it all to come!

Liila · 27/09/2022 16:18

Yes of course you ask him, it is so relevant as he's spending time with your dd.

Also is he staying at a friends long term, is he at college or what? It's all a safeguarding issue, you need to know what has gone on and offer help or contact the services who can help him if you can't.

Pixiedust1234 · 27/09/2022 16:18

Don't let him move in. Show any support for him by offering to accompany him to the council house, benefits office etc. If he's young enough then social services might be worth a try.

Even drug runners can appear nice btw. How do you know he isn't part of that crowd? How do you know he isn't a manipulative abuser himself? Maybe he's been in and out of a young offenders ?

ldontWanna · 27/09/2022 16:14

Octomore · 27/09/2022 16:05

It could be the case that there's a severe clash of personalities/expectations and a lack of communication.

You say this as if it would justify it.

Do you think good, non-abusive parents would kick a child out in this scenario? He's a child and they are the adults - managing personality clashes and communicating with your child is part of the job of being a parent.

"My house my rules!"
"Fine I'm moving out then!"

Or the ultimatum that is such a favourite on MN

"If you don't stop x/start doing y/whatever rules and expectations then you have to find some place else to live."

Kid moves out /says he was kicked out.

Bar preventing him leaving the house, watching him every second they can't stop him.

I'm not saying it's right but it happens a lot.

Swipe left for the next trending thread