Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to believe rich people should contribute much more?

696 replies

marcusian · 27/09/2022 13:16

A bit tongue in cheek, but given that its almost impossible for poorly paid workers including care workers and nurses to strike, and that the government have given people earning over £100K a massive pay rise, what other ways could the most wealthy be made to pay?

My idea: - a new LUXURIES tax (think 50% VAT) on things ordinary people cant buy, like superyachts, airplanes, £10K+ dining tables, a box at wimbledon, £500+ handbags, £100+ football boots!

AIBU - No - they should pay more and heres my ideas how they should do it!
AIBU - Yes - leave wealthy people alone, its not their fault

AIBU to believe rich people should contribute much more?
OP posts:
BecauseICan22 · 28/09/2022 13:47

SelfMadeCookie · 28/09/2022 13:41

I happily paid and would have continued to pay 45%. I have charities on debit. But much like other high earners on this thread - stating my income is a matter of 'privilege and luck' drives me up the wall.

I came to London on my own, very young, from a war zone with £300 in my pocket - because that's how much my ENTIRE EXTENDED family could collect to give me a chance.

I worked 2 jobs to put myself through school. My non-EU tuition was 3x the one paid by majority of students. I also wasn't eligible for any loans or scholarships because I wasn't from the 'right' non-EU war torn country. I gave up my entire life for 10+ years - had no friends, relationships, didn't get to visit home, survived rape without anyone to support me... and kept paying my dues to this country. Today I pay more in taxes per month then I could afford to spend on food YEARLY when I first came to London.

And I'll be damned if I ever feel that I have to apologise for being a high earner to healthy individuals in this country - unless they too spent years eating mouldy bread, sharing single blanket with 5 family members in December in a bomb destroyed shelter, fearing neither of them would live to see the next day.

I agree.

Don't ever apologise for where you've come from, how you got where you are now and where you're going to go in the future - you have broken yourself to create the person and reality that your are living today. A healthy person has the same 24 hours in the day that you do, it's what you choose to do with those 24 hours.

Work ethic and resilience are not highlighted enough, success just falls into your lap doesn't it. Of course it doesn't! A majority of successful people work their arse off for it and they sacrifice a lot along the way.

Congratulations on your achievements, may you continue to prosper and I'm sorry about the rape. No one should have to suffer through that. I hope you're well and happy.

carmenitapink · 28/09/2022 13:45

MrAutumnal · 27/09/2022 23:02

When posters repeatedly come out with these types of threads it makes some high earners want to vote Tory. Luckily they all don’t but vilifying ‘the rich’ when a £100k salary would buy 2 things off your list (and a clue one is not a super yacht) is pretty stupid, irrespective of the validity of supporting people in poverty/on lower incomes.

It’s way more complex than that and I’d get your head around it as threads like this will lose Labour the next election otherwise. ‘Tax the rich’ more and more and more when they already pay huge amounts in income tax, stamp duty, capital gains, plus send kids private, private NHS etc. is not a solution that’s going to work.

This summarises so well why the Tories will probably still win the next election, because some of Labour's policies sound like some of the loons on this thread suggesting super tax of super yachts, while having no understanding of economics 😩

VoiceaFromUranus · 28/09/2022 13:44

Take it by the logic applied on here we shouldn't be voting for Starmer as he benefitted from the 11 plus and attendance at a selective school?

SelfMadeCookie · 28/09/2022 13:41

I happily paid and would have continued to pay 45%. I have charities on debit. But much like other high earners on this thread - stating my income is a matter of 'privilege and luck' drives me up the wall.

I came to London on my own, very young, from a war zone with £300 in my pocket - because that's how much my ENTIRE EXTENDED family could collect to give me a chance.

I worked 2 jobs to put myself through school. My non-EU tuition was 3x the one paid by majority of students. I also wasn't eligible for any loans or scholarships because I wasn't from the 'right' non-EU war torn country. I gave up my entire life for 10+ years - had no friends, relationships, didn't get to visit home, survived rape without anyone to support me... and kept paying my dues to this country. Today I pay more in taxes per month then I could afford to spend on food YEARLY when I first came to London.

And I'll be damned if I ever feel that I have to apologise for being a high earner to healthy individuals in this country - unless they too spent years eating mouldy bread, sharing single blanket with 5 family members in December in a bomb destroyed shelter, fearing neither of them would live to see the next day.

Lassie76 · 28/09/2022 13:35

Topgub · 28/09/2022 13:19

@Lassie76

Nope

want what I've not earned! I'm ENTITLED to it even though I don't earn it or am not qualified for it! It's not fair! Give me free money! Take more from the wealthy!

I havent once said anyone should be given anything they haven't earned.

But again you're highlighting a point.

Do the mega wealthy really earn their money? Are they really more qualified?

Do you honestly think that someone deserves a wage of millions and another of 12k?

I dont

I know the rich have to pretend that they deserve their wealth but it is a bit laughable when you really think about it

And the high earners whom you were poorly lampooning in your post have ALSO never ONCE said the things that YOU said they did.

"Cause it's not fair...I want MY money!!" etc. This is what YOU said.

I was being sarcastic, clearly you don't understand that.

ExpectMore · 28/09/2022 13:34

Topgub · 28/09/2022 13:14

@Hearthnhome

No you're right. There wasn't

In this imaginary universe of apples and gold (5 apples and 2 bits of gold) wealth was created by turning the apples into cider and the gold into jewellery.

@Turkey98 failed to mention who was buying the cider or jewellery though.

Given that the only wealth that exists were the apples and gold.

It's laughable, and incredibly frustrating, how you're still missing the point. I guess it evidences that some people just don't get it.

To help:
Apples and gold are resources. They are "processed" (into cider, into jewellery) through the application of effort and innovation, the process of doing so has created wealth.

Reference your point re. the situation being "imaginary", it's common practice to use hypothetical situations to illustrate a point. If you have an issue with this practice then stay well clear of any services or products that have benefited from science....

XingMing · 28/09/2022 13:32

I spend too much time on these socio-economic-politics threads, because I have plenty of time to read about the subjects -- which was the substance of my degree. I work part time, as a pension fund admin, while DH works out how to retire from the business he started while ensuring its continuation.

There are always a complete spectrum of posters, from the barking mad and mind-blowingly entitled (at either end of the L-R political arc) to the clever, thoughtful and sympathetic who bring valuable ideas and insights into areas where I'm uninformed. I like to think my posts are considered and balanced, because I'm no idealogue. When the facts change, I change my mind. I recognise lots of usernames from the sections I follow, and generally know who to read closely -- even where they hold different opinions.

BecauseICan22 · 28/09/2022 13:24

Topgub · 28/09/2022 13:19

@Lassie76

Nope

want what I've not earned! I'm ENTITLED to it even though I don't earn it or am not qualified for it! It's not fair! Give me free money! Take more from the wealthy!

I havent once said anyone should be given anything they haven't earned.

But again you're highlighting a point.

Do the mega wealthy really earn their money? Are they really more qualified?

Do you honestly think that someone deserves a wage of millions and another of 12k?

I dont

I know the rich have to pretend that they deserve their wealth but it is a bit laughable when you really think about it

Hello,

You make a lot of sweeping statements.

Do I think an able adult who has had a free education and free health care and then free money because you know, they weren't given the same opportunities to progress, deserves free money in the form of tax that myself and millions of others (including Nurses and Binmen) pay in order to house them and carry them through this life? Absolutely not. But I and others still pay.

I can tell you I'm definitely qualified in the form of business acumen and a LLB 1st (which I did alongside my full-time job and raising my children), and yes, I EARN my money - always have.

Incidentally, how much do you pay in taxes?

BecauseICan22 · 28/09/2022 13:19

Lassie76 · 28/09/2022 13:15

Have a great time, good luck to you.
Hard work pays off it would seem, who would have thought?

Prepare yourself for the incoming "stealth boast" accusers.

Fuck it. Life really is what you make it, health permitting - I'm done feeling guilty for my achievements.

Lassie, whatever you're doing with your life, keep smashing it! I wish you nothing but the best 😊

Better now discuss the 8 bedroom house we've just bought for our family and my elderly in-laws. Oh shit, too late.

Topgub · 28/09/2022 13:19

@Lassie76

Nope

want what I've not earned! I'm ENTITLED to it even though I don't earn it or am not qualified for it! It's not fair! Give me free money! Take more from the wealthy!

I havent once said anyone should be given anything they haven't earned.

But again you're highlighting a point.

Do the mega wealthy really earn their money? Are they really more qualified?

Do you honestly think that someone deserves a wage of millions and another of 12k?

I dont

I know the rich have to pretend that they deserve their wealth but it is a bit laughable when you really think about it

BecauseICan22 · 28/09/2022 13:17

BecauseICan22 · 28/09/2022 10:26

42, yes it's a different world. However, its's always going to be 'a different world', that's the nature of life and evolution.

I absolutely know life is bone crunchingy hard and it's soul destroying to have to fight to survive. I support and care for those that simply can't do it for themselves. It might be because of their mental/physical, age related health. I advocate for our most vulnerable and my income is hugely used to help and support others. They need my help.

I cannot stand the lazy individuals who complain about everything but cannot put in the hard work. There are so, so many people like this out there, tearing down the 'rich' but doing nothing to better their own circumstances.
I've survived on 2 hours sleep at times, working and studying.
I've been through horrific child abuse (sexual and violence) from being as little as I can remember right upto when I ran away from home.
I've given birth 3 times.
I've had a traumatic divorce which led to me being a lone parent for 7 years and this year alone, I've suffered 4 consecutive pregnancy losses.

I KNOW how hard it is.

My 15 year old is desperately trying to get a part time job and learn about money management. You know why? Because she says that when she goes to Uni, she's going to work and study at the same time to support herself so she'd like to learn that now.
Does she have to? Hell no, she'll never go without but the fact that she has zero privilege or entitlement in her, considering the life she has been blessed with, yeah I can respect her work ethic. It's the same as mine.

I note certain posters are fixating on what furthers their agenda. So let me highlight a tiny snapshot of my life.

I'd love to hear from anyone that wishes to tell me it's just 'luck'.

Utter crap.

Lassie76 · 28/09/2022 13:15

BecauseICan22 · 28/09/2022 13:11

Thank you both. We've just booked a trip to New York for a week and we're planning Lapland in December with our children. Hard work has been the absolute ethos for over 20 years of my life, I'm ready to kick back.

I would never begrudge or judge someone for how much or how little they have.
Those that have more, I aspire to.
Those that have less, I offer a hand to and ask them to come along for the ride. I have taught my children the same values. Life is good.

Have a great time, good luck to you.
Hard work pays off it would seem, who would have thought?

Prepare yourself for the incoming "stealth boast" accusers.

BecauseICan22 · 28/09/2022 13:14

AchatAVendre · 28/09/2022 13:11

You're wasting your time on here. I wouldn't even be commenting if I hadn't reached the stage of my life where I no longer have to work full time and am winding down from a stressful career.

The sheer ignorance shown by some posters castigating some posters for working hard and making money when they themselves clearly have the free time to post endlessly in the middle of the day.

Hey, I understand your view but think it's so narrow minded and bitter when some people really do belive the bullshit of the wealthy should pay more and more.

Also, I still work full time, I'm a bit of a workaholic but that's part of what you sacrifice you make money. I know what I've missed out on but I also know what I've created. I'm blessed but not through luck.

Topgub · 28/09/2022 13:14

@Hearthnhome

No you're right. There wasn't

In this imaginary universe of apples and gold (5 apples and 2 bits of gold) wealth was created by turning the apples into cider and the gold into jewellery.

@Turkey98 failed to mention who was buying the cider or jewellery though.

Given that the only wealth that exists were the apples and gold.

BecauseICan22 · 28/09/2022 13:11

ExpectMore · 28/09/2022 12:24

@Lassie76 @BecauseICan22

Well done to you. Enjoy your money

Seconded! We'll done!

Thank you both. We've just booked a trip to New York for a week and we're planning Lapland in December with our children. Hard work has been the absolute ethos for over 20 years of my life, I'm ready to kick back.

I would never begrudge or judge someone for how much or how little they have.
Those that have more, I aspire to.
Those that have less, I offer a hand to and ask them to come along for the ride. I have taught my children the same values. Life is good.

AchatAVendre · 28/09/2022 13:11

BecauseICan22 · 28/09/2022 13:07

Hello =)
I'd like to state that the shares were part a of company that I started, sold on and retained my shares in which have been sold as part of a merger.

I missed time with my children, didn't have a relationship, didn't go on holidays, had no life outside of the business and broke my back day and night. I ABSOLUTELY worked for every penny and sacrificed a lot to get to where I am.

Either way, I've still pumped £400,000 BACK into the economy as well as all the other tax I pay and the public services I pay for which I don't take advantage of.

No one can convince me that my life has been easy and I got what I have through luck, entitlement, who I know or clever accounting.

You're wasting your time on here. I wouldn't even be commenting if I hadn't reached the stage of my life where I no longer have to work full time and am winding down from a stressful career.

The sheer ignorance shown by some posters castigating some posters for working hard and making money when they themselves clearly have the free time to post endlessly in the middle of the day.

Lassie76 · 28/09/2022 13:10

"Defensive drivel"?

It's a FACT that high earners pay vast amounts of tax, almost half their salary.

How is stating that defensive?

People are entitled to be proud of what they have achieved if they have sacrificed everything to get there.
Some people expect the same rewards and riches without having to put the effort in to get there.

Cue "defensive drivel" about nurses, bin men, carers, retail workers etc.

BecauseICan22 · 28/09/2022 13:09

Lassie76 · 28/09/2022 11:11

"Absolutely this. They may work hard too but they certainly got all the advantages of a privileged upbringing and all the contacts, right accent etc to get their jobs"

Drivel.
EVERY high earner I know came from a council background to working class parents.
It's such a lazy belief that "rich" people do nothing, have not earned their lifestyle, contribute nothing, had a privileged upbringing, have posh accents, "know" the right people etc.
It must be galling to accept that most of the time they simply worked their arses off, rose through the ranks in their profession through sheer determination, sacrifice and drive to the point of physical or mental exhaustion, and deserve every damn penny they earn.

So much hatred for high earners.
It seems ingrained in a lot of people that they are "owed" a certain lifestyle or bank balance.
How about tackling the other end of the scale where able people feel entitled to things they have never worked a day in their lives for? Where they contribute nothing to society?

How much more do you possibly WANT from high earners?
Most people on this thread are talking about high earners in terms of the >100K salary, NOT the yaught owning super rich hedge fund managers. And these people already pay VAST amounts in taxes.

But all wealth comes from clicking your fingers at the money tree don't you know! I've spent my youth clubbing, holidaying, shopping and investing next to nothing in my own growth and progression. THAT'S how I got to where I am. =)

BecauseICan22 · 28/09/2022 13:07

Itsmybirthday19 · 28/09/2022 12:16

So, assuming the poster who paid £400k tax on their share disposal paid higher rate CGT, the overall profit was £2m.

Shares are a bit of a gamble and it's reasonable to assume the PP invested a fair whack with no guarantee of a return.

Arguably comparable to betting on a horse or playing the lottery. Profits you don't pay tax on...

Would folk be this angry if that poster had won the lottery or got lucky on the gee-gees, I wonder?

Hello =)
I'd like to state that the shares were part a of company that I started, sold on and retained my shares in which have been sold as part of a merger.

I missed time with my children, didn't have a relationship, didn't go on holidays, had no life outside of the business and broke my back day and night. I ABSOLUTELY worked for every penny and sacrificed a lot to get to where I am.

Either way, I've still pumped £400,000 BACK into the economy as well as all the other tax I pay and the public services I pay for which I don't take advantage of.

No one can convince me that my life has been easy and I got what I have through luck, entitlement, who I know or clever accounting.

ExpectMore · 28/09/2022 13:05

Or do you think no one should do those jobs?

@Thesinisterdiagram no, of course they should.

Not sure the relevancy of your question, particularly given there was an obvious answer to it?

For clarity, my position is: if people want more money, they should work for it, and have the opportunity to do so. If they don't want more money, then that's grand, no-one is forcing them to want more. My issue is with people that want more and seek to gain more through 0 work (be that development, additional hours, second job, study etc) but instead want to take what others have worked hard for and earned.

hattie43 · 28/09/2022 13:00

Why is it the British seem to hate anyone who does well for themselves . Unless you inherit wealth is not 'luck' it is earnt through hard work , grit and stamina , putting yourself out , taking risks and responsibilities. Some of the wealthiest people I know have come from the toughest of backgrounds literally clawing their way up to be high achievers .
Why are we made to feel guilty when no-one dares challenges why poor people are poor . Some are poor through I'll health and there's nothing can be done and these are who we need to support . Others are poor through nothing but bad choices eg the countless women who bare kids to feckless useless men who cannot and will not support them or their kids , or the drug addicts , since when has taking drugs or excess alcohol ever been a good choice . All these so called ' vulnerables' who are only vulnerable through their own bad choices . Be grateful for the amount of tax the well off pay because you'd notice if all your services suddenly started to be charged for .
A persons start in life often sucks but it's what you do as an individual that shapes your future . I'd like to be a brain surgeon but I'm not intelligent enough . There are always compromises to be made and we have to accept that life isn't fair and make of it the best you can .

marcusian · 28/09/2022 12:59

Lassie76 · 28/09/2022 11:15

Also, who is "evading" tax?

They already pay MASSIVE amount of tax, stop acting as if the high earners are now somehow "evading" paying what they owe when they contribute more than anyone else in society already.
You are acting as if tax has been abolished for the high earners!

Hmmm...some interesting comments and some defensive drivel and vitriol just focussing on tax.

Perhaps time to bring us back to some basic ethical points:

  • By rich i don't meaning earning £100K a year, i thought that was obvious unless you feel defensive about that. It is obviously contextual, personally I mean anyone in the UK earning over c.£250K or with assets of more than £2m.
  • Yes we live in a global system that makes it harder to achieve fairness and kindness. However trickle down economics has been shown to be bollocks, as the massively increasing world and UK wealth gap clearly shows. So should you give up? Surely not if you have a brain and a heart. It has always been the case that democratic capitalism has to be fettered, the only question is when and where, and that is where we have gone badly wrong.
  • I agree with some OPs that, life isn't inherently fair, which is why, whatever your faith or no-faith, as a society it is ethically incumbent on us to share with our poorest.
  • There is an incredibly flawed presumption that we live in a meritocracy where people deserve what they get, that rich people got there entirely through endeavour, and poor people dont work hard enough or are too stupid.
  • Significant research indicates that successful entrepreneurs are not primarily motivated by £ or financial reward or power, its rather about seeing an idea and enjoying making it happen/be used. It often makes no difference to them whether they earn £250K or £250m.
  • If people want to leave the UK to earn more than £250K then frankly let them, absolutely no one is indispensible, and there are at least hundreds if not thousands of intelligent people in the UK who could do any of those jobs well.
  • The majority of super-rich also readily acknowledge that "Success" in business is primarily based on luck, i.e. being in the right place at the right time. There is a frankly terribly arrogant assumption that success is not heavily influenced by background and capital. Whilst there may be the odd exception, they are a tiny number, there are millions of talented people brought up council estates in the UK, and there are hundreds of millions of talented people throughout the world, e.g. who dont have access to either capital, opportunity or good fortune. Is their poverty deserved? Are they all lazy or unambitious?
  • Financial success is also more often than not based on ruthlessness and exploitation. Even the often cited-as-saintly Bill Gates is a ruthless business man. Not for no reason, it really is harder for a rich man to be good [enter the kingdom of heaven], than to find a needle in a haystack. Its good that some rich people aim to give all their money away, but its so very obviously immoral that they were able to earn such wealth in the first place! I for one will therefore continue to work towards wealth-redistribution.
OP posts:
Thesinisterdiagram · 28/09/2022 12:58

ExpectMore · 28/09/2022 12:27

@Thesinisterdiagram

The wealthiest in society are those who have benefited the most from ‘the system’ we have created.

Whilst I disagree with your point, even if it were to be true, they've benefited as a result of of hard work and graft... an option which is open to everyone (medical exceptions aside).

Plenty of people ‘work hard and graft’ though. We don’t need everyone to be CEO’s and millionaire investors. We need care workers, nurses, retail and warehouse workers, teachers etc. Or do you think no one should do those jobs?

Hermione101 · 28/09/2022 12:45

What is it with the UK's obsession with taxing rich people?? This is the depressing tall poppy syndrome mentality behind this country's inability to compete on an international level in entrepreneurship and business.

There's going to be a brain drain in this country of high earners and entrepreneurs. Why would anyone set up a business here if they are just going to be taxed to death? Why would a doctor stay here when they can make 3x in the US and not have to deal with some ludicrous pension cap and extortionate high taxes?

Almost every single person I know who has created real wealth either through business, saving, work, were immigrants (including my parents), or started with very little.

Why on earth would you want to disincentivize that through taxes?

ExpectMore · 28/09/2022 12:31

Lassie76 · 28/09/2022 12:24

"Cause its not faiiiiiiirrrrrrrr!!! Stamps feet. Itssss mmmmmyyyy mmmooonneeyyy
Petted lip"

on the flip side

"I want what I've not earned! I'm ENTITLED to it even though I don't earn it or am not qualified for it! It's not fair! Give me free money! Take more from the wealthy! Stamps feet, etc etc"

As ridiculous as your post.

🤣 I'm pretty sure you've just copied and pasted some pp there 🤣

Swipe left for the next trending thread