Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to believe rich people should contribute much more?

696 replies

marcusian · 27/09/2022 13:16

A bit tongue in cheek, but given that its almost impossible for poorly paid workers including care workers and nurses to strike, and that the government have given people earning over £100K a massive pay rise, what other ways could the most wealthy be made to pay?

My idea: - a new LUXURIES tax (think 50% VAT) on things ordinary people cant buy, like superyachts, airplanes, £10K+ dining tables, a box at wimbledon, £500+ handbags, £100+ football boots!

AIBU - No - they should pay more and heres my ideas how they should do it!
AIBU - Yes - leave wealthy people alone, its not their fault

AIBU to believe rich people should contribute much more?
OP posts:
MsPincher · 29/09/2022 09:41

I don’t agree with the recent tax cuts but taxing “luxury goods” won’t raise significant revenue. They are of course already taxed if purchased in the uK. There’s not enough of them to make any difference. Also people can and do buy them overseas. So there’s no point really.

XingMing · 29/09/2022 09:33

Thank you @Blossomtoes . It's now 26 hours wait for an ambulance. It's not that they are not being dispatched; they are being diverted enroute to emergencies. The care home is only 15 minutes from the hospital.

Right now we are regretting moving her to the Southwest. SIL in the SE (who works in care) says her local ambulance A&E is averaging 3+3 hour waits.

That said, I have had exceptional care for breast cancer from the same hospital.

Blossomtoes · 29/09/2022 09:22

XingMing · 29/09/2022 08:24

Thanks @Topgub . She is still waiting for an ambulance, and the waitinng time at A&E is over 12 hours to see the doctor.

This is horrendous @XingMing. I am sorry.

Just to illustrate how fast this deterioration has happened, my dad fell in his care home and broke his hip on the Sunday of a bank holiday weekend. The ambulance was there in 20 minutes and his hip was replaced that afternoon. That was in 2015. How can things have got so bad in just seven years?

midgetastic · 29/09/2022 08:29

There are not enough high paying jobs for everyone

That's the bloody problem - if all jobs paid enough for a basic standard of living you would have no one in work and on benefits , no one in work not wanting to turn the heating on . But they don't. Many jobs don't and that includes most of those where recruitment is difficult

Hope that helps you understand why people are not just negotiating or walking to a new job for more pay

XingMing · 29/09/2022 08:24

Thanks @Topgub . She is still waiting for an ambulance, and the waitinng time at A&E is over 12 hours to see the doctor.

ExpectMore · 29/09/2022 06:49

@Topgub

I even literally said more than once that increasing wages is far better than taxation.

There's nothing stopping an individual negotiating a wage increase with their employer? We don't need the government to do it for them nor to set rules to make it happen. Doing so just creates an inefficient system, which just be funded, and this requires more tax (relatively) to operate.

And if they're unable to negotiate a higher rate with their current employer, there's nothing stopping the vast majority of people of finding an alternative employer.

Clearly there are a few exceptions to this rule (for example, criminal barristers {whose strike I support, unlike the other strikes happening at present}, although even then it could be argued that they could find alternative employment and the demand-supply curve economics would eventually rebalance the system).

Itsacafe · 29/09/2022 06:43

Topgub - you talk about there being a "fixed number of top jobs." Do you understand that the super-rich are not salaried people doing any one of "a fixed number of jobs?" You ding buy a super-yacht on a 'salary' fgs..The super-rich have usually created something that didn't exist before. They have maybe created or sold a company or similar. Wealth comes from the way they invest. The super-rich will have taken a lot of risks along the way. No "job" pays a £100 million salary.

Topgub · 29/09/2022 06:24

@XingMing

Jeeze. How very mean girls. I hope your mil is OK.

@Linning

Yes. As I said. We all need to do more globally. I'm definitely not thinking of my own situation. I dont need more money. I dont think the uk needs more money either. We could definitely afford to pay a global levelling tax

Its a common tactic though. Those who can most afford it saying pfffft. Why should I give up any of my money? Those with much much less than me don't.

Bit hollow

And as usual no one is actually reading what I've said. Too quick to jump to personal offence and join the mean girls clique

I even literally said more than once that increasing wages is far better than taxation.

Much easier to ignore the salient points that can't be argued with though.

Hearthnhome · 29/09/2022 05:08

Reading the last few pages the problem seems to be people not paying the tax they should or taking from the system when they could be putting in.

So not about taxing the ‘rich’ more. But about closing loopholes that allow people to get away without paying tax, or less tax than they should.

Trying to find away to get the ones abusing benefits at the other end is far more difficult, because it usually ends in people who are in genuine need being worse off.

If this is the problem, I can’t imagine many people disagreeing that tax evasion is wrong.

But that’s not quite as inflammatory for some.

Anon778833 · 29/09/2022 02:40

Before ever deciding what other people can and can't buy with their money I'd focus on myself and really examine whether I'm actually putting enough energy into my own success.

Too bad that people with disabilities can’t do that Hmm

The way that this country is currently run, disabled people are shat on from a great height. Most PIP claimants get 0 points. The assessors tell lies. Usually this is overturned if you are tenacious enough to appeal. But the government saves a lot of money turning away genuine claimants because many of them have enough problems without the added stress of an appeal.

Anon778833 · 29/09/2022 02:31

YANBU. Since this government got in, the rich have become richer and richer and richer at the expense of the vulnerable. There were stats on how the richest quadrupled their wealth even after the first four years of the Tory / Libdem coalition.

Starseeking · 29/09/2022 02:27

Quincythequince · 27/09/2022 13:41

If you make 160k a year, the removal of the higher tax rate means you will be £500 better off!

£500.

You obviously get the same benefit on the portion of your earnings that are taxed at the basic rate, which every tax payer gets.

Once you are earning over £125k, you no longer receive the personal allowance of £12k, so actually pay more at 20% than most.

XingMing · 29/09/2022 00:21

Topgub sleeps... I could be wrong.

<please excuse the black humour. I am keeping myself awake while waiting for news on the arrival of an ambulance to take DMIL to hospital after a fall at 7am today. She has been lying on the floor in her care home for 17 hours so far with possible fractures of pelvis and shoulder and faces a six hour wait to be assessed by a doctor. She is 93 and has dementia. But she is safe and is being looked after, so in today's NHS, not a priority>

Linning · 28/09/2022 23:50

@Topgub

But low earners in the UK are much richer than low earners in say Sri Lanka. So, in agreement with you, and because the unfairness of wealth vs poverty can’t really be limited by country or border. How much redistribution of wealth tax should each of us pay including low UK earners who are “rich” to most people living in poverty worldwide?

How much do you earn? How much are you taxed? and how much more do you feel you should personally be taxed on your “wealth” and assets to make up for the wealth gap between you the next (+ following) lower earners? what would be a fair figure to you? Both for the rich and for people like you? And how much of your income currently goes to charity and fundings for people with less means?

Because most of the time people who don’t earn a lot complain about rich people hoarding money and it needing redistributing but what they mean is give it to the poor people in this country so they can increase their own personal wealth with no forward plan to pass that money forward to the poorer people in this world (most of which are out of the UK). So pretty much take money from the very top, bring it to the bottom of the very top of the worldwide wealth pyramid and pretend you are making the world a better place for everybody when in reality you have only made it better for the citizens of some of the wealthiest countries and just increased the gap with rest of the world.

So, most of the time, people who ask for wealth to be redistributed are thinking of their own situation and how it will be bettered by the redistribution of this wealth and never really question that they actually are also at the very top of a much bigger unfair pyramid and that to be fair, their wealth and assets should also be redistributed to people on the bottom, but the thing is similarly, they don’t want to part with the little they have even if that little is 100x than most. The difference is that the low earner in the UK will look at the rich who is already paying loads of taxes and probably also indulging in ample charity donations but has a 100x more than him and say “that’s not enough, you should give most of what you have nobody should have 100x than the average person!” And forget to look at the fact that they have 100x more than somebody else and yet passing none of their wealth back to them.

It’s a continuous cycle sadly. As, if you took things globally (which one should), the UK should have to pay a huge tax to each lower earning country to equalize the field for all as a financially better country, but I doubt people would be happy. (Especially as a big incentive of Brexit was to keep UK money into the UK.)

So I don’t believe success is in endlessly taxing to the point you make not working or working less/earning less more compelling, but in stopping inherited wealth so as to stop increasing the gap between rich and poor.

XingMing · 28/09/2022 23:38

Topgub · Today 23:17
Good job I've not done that then eh.
But let's face it, it's a great start
Not like we can tax the poor.

@Topgub
All KK had to do was shift the tax bands to reflect inflation at the lower income earning levels to protect the poorest paid from paying more.

Lassie76 · 28/09/2022 23:37

"Not like we can tax the poor.
Also no one squealing about how we should leave the poor rich people alone as suggested an alternative."

How about tackling the almost 9 Billion pounds lost in benefit fraud in one year alone?
Oh no, I forgot, it's only wealthy people who suck the system dry.

XingMing · 28/09/2022 23:34

Can I suggest that anyone posting here avoids using the @ tag to Topgrub because, as a trial exercise, my next post will use it. And I am sure there will be a response within minutes. It is 11.30pm, and I am waiting for a call about an ambulance IRL, so watch this space. It may take a few minutes to write my post; please bear with me.

Winceybincey · 28/09/2022 23:22

tenbob · 27/09/2022 13:25

I know it’s tongue in cheek but it shows a total lack of understanding of how these things work

A superyacht or plane is about as mobile an asset as you can get
The UK whacks a massive tax on, but Europe doesn’t
Clearly no one is going to buy from a UK company and pay the tax when they can buy from an Italian company and not pay it
So all it does is mean the UK companies go bust and the craftsmen working there lose their jobs

A £10k dinner - is this £10k per head? Because those dinners don’t exist, and for most £10k bills for a group, a large part will be the wine which is already very heavily taxed.
Or £10k for the total bill regardless of how many people are there? Because that’s going to screw over an awful lot of people getting married!
And the majority of those dinners will be corporate entertainment to a lesser or greater degree

Wimbledon- Roland Garos and the Swiss open doesn’t charge the tax, and it’s 2hrs to get your guests there. So who do you think now gets the corporate hospitality budget?

Op said a 10k dining table, not dinner

XingMing · 28/09/2022 23:20

I'm sure Topgrub is being compensated for the sterling hours they are putting in on MN (almost 36 non stop by my rough calculations) across this and another thread or two, but by whom? And I am beginning to suspect that they are a relay team.

Topgub · 28/09/2022 23:17

Good job I've not done that then eh.

But let's face it, it's a great start

Not like we can tax the poor.

Also no one squealing about how we should leave the poor rich people alone as suggested an alternative.

Except chanting let them make their own money.

Talk about ignoring the complex and multi faceted

Itsacafe · 28/09/2022 23:12

Exactly. It's all relative..Thankyou.

That's not to diminish the issue if global inequality, but just to recognise that it is complex and multi- faceted (well, far more so than just people chanting "tax the rich").

Topgub · 28/09/2022 22:59

@Itsacafe

Oh I'm part of the problem, globally. 100%

Even inthe uk I could probably do more than I do.

All relative, eh?

Itsacafe · 28/09/2022 22:55

"It would need a global agreement."

Oh well, why didn't you say...,

How much for you earn Topgub? I can find the actual evidence for you if you like (Google the 'elephant curve'), but it's something like a person on a low wage in the U.K. is still wealthier than 75% if the world. So are YOU taxed enough? Presumably you'd be fine to have your income redistributed to perhaps the average person in Albania, or Afghanistan? Where do you draw the line with your "global agreements?" Where does it end?

Topgub · 28/09/2022 22:53

@Itsacafe

Lol.

Why can none of you debate points without getting personal.

talk about bland and boring. They're not even good insults.

If you have a point to make other than I dont like your opinion but can't actually argue against it, I'm all ears

Itsacafe · 28/09/2022 22:46

Topgub - Some people do evade tax .Did you just realise this?

If you want to make an actual meaningful point, you need actual evidence. A opinion piece in a newspaper article tells people nothing quantifiable.

Define what you mean by 'the rich' - 1 million? 100 million? Define how many there are. Provide evidence of who is evading tax. Name names. How are they hoarding it - what is the trend? Where? To what extent? Who and what precisely are you talking about?

I'm sure some uber wealthy du evade tax - we all know this. But just chanting "the rich evade tax - fact" is beyond mind- numbing. Nobody is an economist on here, but nor are people 6 years-old so please stop arguing in such bland, boring, simplistic terms. Try to think about it in a slightly more relevant and nuanced way.