Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to believe rich people should contribute much more?

696 replies

marcusian · 27/09/2022 13:16

A bit tongue in cheek, but given that its almost impossible for poorly paid workers including care workers and nurses to strike, and that the government have given people earning over £100K a massive pay rise, what other ways could the most wealthy be made to pay?

My idea: - a new LUXURIES tax (think 50% VAT) on things ordinary people cant buy, like superyachts, airplanes, £10K+ dining tables, a box at wimbledon, £500+ handbags, £100+ football boots!

AIBU - No - they should pay more and heres my ideas how they should do it!
AIBU - Yes - leave wealthy people alone, its not their fault

AIBU to believe rich people should contribute much more?
OP posts:
XingMing · 29/09/2022 14:24

Be fair Topgub... I was completely even handed! Complimentary about my care and horrified by the emergency care system in the same paragraph. I could point you to threads where I've talked about the NHS at greater length. However, this is my first encounter with its shortcomings.

NewPapaGuinea · 29/09/2022 14:19

I think rich people have elaborate ways of minimising their tax liability. Tax them more or not, closing the loopholes would help.

Topgub · 29/09/2022 14:17

@linning

Of course they were trying to be 'mean' its what people do when they get annoyed theyre being disagreed with and dont know how to challenge it

I dont think I've been vague at all. There's no point me giving you imaginary figures that you'll just point out are imaginary.

You dont need exact figures to be able to understand that wealth inequality is a real thing that as a society we need to tackle. Its not about me or you personally. I dont want to tackle wealth inequality for myself. I dont live in poverty. Nor do I agree with your assessment that the poor pass the bucket upwards. Its well documented that poorer people give more as a proportion of their income to charity than well off people do. Pay more tax as a proportion of income.

I also don't buy into the narrative that all higher earners pay upwards of 50% tax on their whole wage/income. Estimates (depending on avoidance etc) range from 10 to 50. Pretty big range. And of course some pay 0.

And yes billions are lost in benefit fraud. Billions also go unclaimed. The estimates for tax evasion go from 6 billion to 90 billion.

The stats on wealth inequality are undeniable.

I've seen lots of comments defending wealth inequality on this thread. People should work harder, get a different job. Invent their own business. Just leave poor rich people alone!

None of them particularly realistic or helpful.

If you wish to continue defending a society where a kardashian or a musk exist while children starve to death then that's your perogative.

I dont agree that it's OK and agree with the op that more needs to be done.

Oh and the irony of people bemoaning the state of the health services while celebrating tax cuts is quite something.

Badbadbunny · 29/09/2022 14:13

piesforever · 29/09/2022 12:43

Rich people do not pay 40% tax. It's 40% on over 50ish k and self employed often less. Yes absolutely tax the high earners more!! Our society is unequal enough. It's a no brainer.

Yes they do. There comes a point on the income curve where the tax/nic deductions total more than 40%, in fact closer to 50%. As income rises, the 20% rate on the £37.5k gets less and less relevant, and there are the 62% marginal rates between 50-60 and 100-125, so on incomes over around £170k, the total tax and NIC is just under 50% of the total income.

Hearthnhome · 29/09/2022 13:35

piesforever · 29/09/2022 12:45

No they don't as a percentage of earnings!

What is this in reference to? Can you explain?

piesforever · 29/09/2022 12:45

No they don't as a percentage of earnings!

piesforever · 29/09/2022 12:43

Rich people do not pay 40% tax. It's 40% on over 50ish k and self employed often less. Yes absolutely tax the high earners more!! Our society is unequal enough. It's a no brainer.

Badbadbunny · 29/09/2022 12:20

BigWoollyJumpers · 29/09/2022 12:05

I'm not so sure that they do move tbh. However, I suspect an awful lot just give up working. We have lost tens of thousands of "economic units" aged 50+ in the last couple of years, mostly full-time, qualified, high earning individuals.

Your bog standard higher paid worker doesn't move abroad just for tax reasons. It's the very high earners who move, such as athletes, pop stars, actors, TV presenters, and those running "virtual" businesses that can be run from anywhere, etc., often to tax havens or low tax countries. But even "bog standard" workers earning good money are moving, not only for tax reasons, but for better working conditions, better pay and higher standard of living, i.e. doctors and IT consultants moving to Australia and Canada.

As for older people who've stopped working, that's usually down to them now receiving "gold plated" pensions, i.e. doctors, dentists, and even teachers & emergency workers, who have worked enough years to have accrued pretty high wages (and lump sums) meaning they don't "need" to work from their mid 50's onwards. Perhaps we've been too generous with pension schemes in the past?? (I know that a lot of the generosity has been scaled back for younger workers in those jobs).

There are also the restrictions/penalties on "high" pension funds which the general public wanted, but which have had a negative side effect, i.e. doctors who have to cut back their hours due to the punitive tax they have to pay not just on their wages over £100k but also on the compulsory employers pension contributions made by their employer which push their pension funds above the relatively recent limits!

MarshaBradyo · 29/09/2022 12:19

I think you'lll find that if you you can satisfy local wealth creation / investment/ property criteria, which would include a majority of the 600,000 you refer to, you'd find the welcome mat rolled out.

yes

MarshaBradyo · 29/09/2022 12:16

To give an example software developers be paid more in US and you often see posts along those lines

We need something that we ‘re strong in it probably won’t be that to same extent but it has been and can be FS

XingMing · 29/09/2022 12:15

I think you'lll find that if you you can satisfy local wealth creation / investment/ property criteria, which would include a majority of the 600,000 you refer to, you'd find the welcome mat rolled out.

For example, Italy, Portugal and Spain all want to attract people back to depopulated rural areas, and have programmes to achieve this. Google Portugal's Golden Visa or My Second Home Malaysia as examples aimed at retirees. You can certainly buy residency in the Caribbean: it costs about $200k in Antigua for example, plus a home on top. Same is true in New Zealand, if you buy a business and could create employment... we briefly looked at a (small and very rundown) shipyard there. There are increasing numbers of Digital Nomad schemes from Bali to the most recent Eastern European accession countries.

@MsPincher going back to days when private health insurance was tax deductible would be sensible, as would making a % of childcare costs. It always irked me when I was a freelance copywriter that I could have deducted the cost of a secretary but not the nanny who enabled me to travel and work. A degree of index-linking to the rate at which income starts would make a lot of difference too.

Badbadbunny · 29/09/2022 12:14

SwordToFlamethrower · 29/09/2022 10:55

Absolutely they should pay more tax. Without question.

They already do.

MarshaBradyo · 29/09/2022 12:13

It’s funny on other threads people saying they’re leaving but on this one people with higher resources and abilities won’t make choices.

However it’s also to attract

Use visas to get the skills you want too and build sectors. I’m more used to points based systems as have lived elsewhere.

BigWoollyJumpers · 29/09/2022 12:05

Blossomtoes · 29/09/2022 11:52

I really don’t understand why people keep trotting this out. Where are these 600,000 people going to move to? Taxes are higher in most English speaking countries, they’re certainly higher in Scandinavia and Europe’s closed to us. Where is this low tax utopia all these wealthy people are going to flock to?

I'm not so sure that they do move tbh. However, I suspect an awful lot just give up working. We have lost tens of thousands of "economic units" aged 50+ in the last couple of years, mostly full-time, qualified, high earning individuals.

Blossomtoes · 29/09/2022 11:52

MarshaBradyo · 29/09/2022 10:46

It gets more problematic when tax the rich means people just leave.

Those tax receipts need to be picked up. By whom

We need a strong FS in the U.K. and the services sector contributes massively to GDP

That means being attractive in pay

I really don’t understand why people keep trotting this out. Where are these 600,000 people going to move to? Taxes are higher in most English speaking countries, they’re certainly higher in Scandinavia and Europe’s closed to us. Where is this low tax utopia all these wealthy people are going to flock to?

MorrisZapp · 29/09/2022 11:08

Isn't VAT paid as a percentage though? So the bigger the luxury item I buy, the more VAT I pay?

SwordToFlamethrower · 29/09/2022 10:57

Quincythequince · 27/09/2022 13:52

They do contribute more That is an indisputable fact. You don’t have to like it, but it is.

43% British adults pay no tax at all!

None.

Er what planet are you on? EVERYONE pays tax. Buy food? It is taxed. Own a car? You're paying tax. Eating in a restaurant? Taxed.
Buy clothes. Taxed.

Don't be daft.

SwordToFlamethrower · 29/09/2022 10:55

Absolutely they should pay more tax. Without question.

MarshaBradyo · 29/09/2022 10:46

It gets more problematic when tax the rich means people just leave.

Those tax receipts need to be picked up. By whom

We need a strong FS in the U.K. and the services sector contributes massively to GDP

That means being attractive in pay

MsPincher · 29/09/2022 10:32

Linning · 29/09/2022 10:09

I don’t think people who can afford it say “why should I give ANY of my money away?” I think they say though “I am already giving in fact 10, 100, 1000, 1 million time more of my money than most will ever do in their lifetime, so how much do YOU (person who is complaining about rich not paying enough) give? Do you give as much as you can? Does everyone who is not working and receives from the system is genuinely doing everything they can (within their abilities) to find work and pay their way back into the system and doing everything they can to give back to poorer than them?”

Those with much much less than you usually don’t say why should I give any of my money away, and are happy to tax the rich because they don’t see themselves as rich enough to fall into the group that would be giving any money back, so of course they say “I would pay back if I was rich” but don’t even think about paying even more in taxes or giving away their meager savings or foregoing small luxuries, even though if you look at it from a global point of view, they are on the richest side of poor and therefore should technically similarly do their part to the max and help give back to poorer than them but often very much don’t. Like we say, it’s easy to be generous with other people’s money.

You, yourself, even admit that you don’t do what you can for others who earn less and have less than you, yet are point your finger at the rich (who likely donate and pay more in taxes than you have) so why don’t you do your part first. Why always pass the bucket to the next person higher up? I am happy to pay higher taxes than most because I am in a privileged position but I am not happy to be expected to fill the bucket when so many who can fill the bucket (and ironically wish for the bucket to be filled) purposefully don’t see it as their job to help fill the bucket and when currently more people take from the bucket than give back into it even though many of them have the capacity to give back into the bucket through the work force.

We are all reading what you said but you never give figures even when asked. You are talking about making minimum wage higher but not talking figures (what would be the right increase for you?) , nor explaining why you think that would help the problem or what kind of limitation that could have?

Nobody is trying to be mean but you are talking about facts and pointing fingers but purposefully not quantifying anything, and I don’t know if it’s because you don’t know the figures yourself or if it’s because they wouldn’t add up in favor of your argument but it’s hard to grasps what you are suggesting when you purposefully withhold figures and keep things vague.

Agreed. When people say “tax the rich” they often mean “tax someone who isn’t me but give me a share of the proceeds”. It’s not sustainable- we all need to contribute to society if we can. Or else it starts to break down and no one wants to anymore.

People who pay less than about the level of the 40% rate of tax are net gainers from the system- some obviously more than others. The idea that this section of society is somehow being cheated isn’t true, quite the opposite. They are not paying their way. That doesn’t mean they should pay their way necessarily, but we should recognize that they are not rather than proceed as if they should get more and more.

As a child of immigrants brought up in a council estate, I recognize that we have a lot of opportunities in the uK. The state should do certain things yes, but we also need to take responsibility for ourselves.

Blossomtoes · 29/09/2022 10:22

That said, I have had exceptional care for breast cancer from the same hospital.

I’m glad. That doesn’t help your mil and all the others like her, though. Getting very old was always a bum deal but it’s a horror show now.

MsPincher · 29/09/2022 10:14

samyeagar · 28/09/2022 16:17

This is why there is a global shift to the right in western nations. It has gotten to the point where the basis for traditional shaming tactics have become so broad as to no longer have any real meaning. Attempting to shame people for otherwise reasonable positions is having the opposite affect.

I think that’s right. Especially with the whole gender nonsense I think a lot of people are put off anything which seems “woke”. To be fair it also means a lot of people are thinking about things more rather than just taking the “acceptable” position. Which has to be a good thing.

Linning · 29/09/2022 10:09

Topgub · 29/09/2022 06:24

@XingMing

Jeeze. How very mean girls. I hope your mil is OK.

@Linning

Yes. As I said. We all need to do more globally. I'm definitely not thinking of my own situation. I dont need more money. I dont think the uk needs more money either. We could definitely afford to pay a global levelling tax

Its a common tactic though. Those who can most afford it saying pfffft. Why should I give up any of my money? Those with much much less than me don't.

Bit hollow

And as usual no one is actually reading what I've said. Too quick to jump to personal offence and join the mean girls clique

I even literally said more than once that increasing wages is far better than taxation.

Much easier to ignore the salient points that can't be argued with though.

I don’t think people who can afford it say “why should I give ANY of my money away?” I think they say though “I am already giving in fact 10, 100, 1000, 1 million time more of my money than most will ever do in their lifetime, so how much do YOU (person who is complaining about rich not paying enough) give? Do you give as much as you can? Does everyone who is not working and receives from the system is genuinely doing everything they can (within their abilities) to find work and pay their way back into the system and doing everything they can to give back to poorer than them?”

Those with much much less than you usually don’t say why should I give any of my money away, and are happy to tax the rich because they don’t see themselves as rich enough to fall into the group that would be giving any money back, so of course they say “I would pay back if I was rich” but don’t even think about paying even more in taxes or giving away their meager savings or foregoing small luxuries, even though if you look at it from a global point of view, they are on the richest side of poor and therefore should technically similarly do their part to the max and help give back to poorer than them but often very much don’t. Like we say, it’s easy to be generous with other people’s money.

You, yourself, even admit that you don’t do what you can for others who earn less and have less than you, yet are point your finger at the rich (who likely donate and pay more in taxes than you have) so why don’t you do your part first. Why always pass the bucket to the next person higher up? I am happy to pay higher taxes than most because I am in a privileged position but I am not happy to be expected to fill the bucket when so many who can fill the bucket (and ironically wish for the bucket to be filled) purposefully don’t see it as their job to help fill the bucket and when currently more people take from the bucket than give back into it even though many of them have the capacity to give back into the bucket through the work force.

We are all reading what you said but you never give figures even when asked. You are talking about making minimum wage higher but not talking figures (what would be the right increase for you?) , nor explaining why you think that would help the problem or what kind of limitation that could have?

Nobody is trying to be mean but you are talking about facts and pointing fingers but purposefully not quantifying anything, and I don’t know if it’s because you don’t know the figures yourself or if it’s because they wouldn’t add up in favor of your argument but it’s hard to grasps what you are suggesting when you purposefully withhold figures and keep things vague.

MsPincher · 29/09/2022 09:45

ExpectMore · 29/09/2022 06:49

@Topgub

I even literally said more than once that increasing wages is far better than taxation.

There's nothing stopping an individual negotiating a wage increase with their employer? We don't need the government to do it for them nor to set rules to make it happen. Doing so just creates an inefficient system, which just be funded, and this requires more tax (relatively) to operate.

And if they're unable to negotiate a higher rate with their current employer, there's nothing stopping the vast majority of people of finding an alternative employer.

Clearly there are a few exceptions to this rule (for example, criminal barristers {whose strike I support, unlike the other strikes happening at present}, although even then it could be argued that they could find alternative employment and the demand-supply curve economics would eventually rebalance the system).

It wouldn’t though because criminal barristers depend on legal aid rates fixed by government. So the market is distorted. Also if no good criminal barristers, people won’t get a fair trial which has economic costs but not immediate obvious ones.

MsPincher · 29/09/2022 09:42

To be honest I wonder if we might be better to allow tax deductible medical insurance as it takes pressure of nhs.

Swipe left for the next trending thread