Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to believe rich people should contribute much more?

696 replies

marcusian · 27/09/2022 13:16

A bit tongue in cheek, but given that its almost impossible for poorly paid workers including care workers and nurses to strike, and that the government have given people earning over £100K a massive pay rise, what other ways could the most wealthy be made to pay?

My idea: - a new LUXURIES tax (think 50% VAT) on things ordinary people cant buy, like superyachts, airplanes, £10K+ dining tables, a box at wimbledon, £500+ handbags, £100+ football boots!

AIBU - No - they should pay more and heres my ideas how they should do it!
AIBU - Yes - leave wealthy people alone, its not their fault

AIBU to believe rich people should contribute much more?
OP posts:
XingMing · 27/09/2022 15:05

When countries like Portugal court well-off retirees with residency and tax of 7% global income provided you can buy property above a certain threshold, and they do, then you don't have to be incredibly bright or super-wealthy to understand the the appeal. And losing those tax payers in sufficient number would hurt, big time.

MarshaBradyo · 27/09/2022 15:04

mmmflakycrust81 · 27/09/2022 15:01

I will wave their greedy arses goodbye at the airport.

I bet. But you’d also then lose the tax they used to pay. Will you pick it up?

Where’s the missing tax coming from

mmmflakycrust81 · 27/09/2022 15:04

Its been proven by countless data analysis that rich people do not leave anyway. Its baseless scare mongering to allow them to keep hoarding wealth.

JessesMum777888 · 27/09/2022 15:04

FayeGovan · 27/09/2022 13:24

£100 football boots doesn't make you in the super rich category, it makes you a parent of a football mad kid.

This !!
my son has £100 boots , I have £5 primark work shoes.

frostyfingers · 27/09/2022 15:03

I work for a company that sells luxury goods - tax those more, people stop buying and I lose my job. Multiply that a few thousand times and that’s lots of jobs lost, more people claiming benefits and who pays for that?

I’ve no idea where the middle ground is but it needs to be found.

mmmflakycrust81 · 27/09/2022 15:01

MarshaBradyo · 27/09/2022 14:58

Ok you sound like you’d like to take a lot on tax and get them back in some way. When they leave to somewhere more favourable what will you do then?

I will wave their greedy arses goodbye at the airport.

mmmflakycrust81 · 27/09/2022 15:01

No, people cant all go and work full time, because childcare costs are through the roof.

A full time minimum wage salary, with NO pension contributions or student loan, is £1378 take home.

How much do you think a full time nursery placement costs?

People do not work part time because they are lazy or feckless but because it is literally unaffordable.

I love how talks on how to ensure those with the most wealth are paying their fair share quickly descends into blaming the poor.

If Directors and CEO and top level management are making high salaries but they have staff who need topping up with benefits, then they are not paying those staff enough.

TooManyMoronsHere · 27/09/2022 15:00

Topgub · 27/09/2022 13:50

Rich people don't worker harder than non rich people

Lots of them don't work at all.

They also don't contribute more They just take more

They get and stay rich mostly through exploitation and greed

Sure

MarshaBradyo · 27/09/2022 14:58

mmmflakycrust81 · 27/09/2022 14:32

'Leave rich people alone'

HAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHA

No. Make them fucking pay more.

Ok you sound like you’d like to take a lot on tax and get them back in some way. When they leave to somewhere more favourable what will you do then?

XingMing · 27/09/2022 14:58

Actually @Willowswave I think you will find that excise and duty and VAT on tobacco and alcohol sales make a large contribution to the exchecquer each year. Sin taxes are increased to discourage consumption, and this has worked quite well on cigarettes but for a long time smokers more than funded the entire NHS.

Badbadbunny · 27/09/2022 14:54

BlueMongoose · 27/09/2022 14:48

The bet way is to tax income, with those on the highest income paying the highest marginal rates, AND to tax wealth. One example of how things have been changed and distorted in favour of the wealthy- presently there is no inheritance tax on land- the tories abolished it. So if your parents work hard to build a business, when they die, the value of it is taxed. If they just inherit land and do nothing but collect rent all their lives, it won't get taxed when they die. Also, in the past, unearned income (like interest, share dividends, etc.) was taxed at a higher rate than the income people got via working (this used to be called 'unearned increment'). Now it's the other way round. So much for rewarding hard work, eh?

There is IHT on land. However there is business asset relief against IHT for businesses run by the deceased. So you got that wrong. www.gov.uk/business-relief-inheritance-tax

The rate of income tax is exactly the same whether the income is earned or unearned. There's no difference. Perhaps you are thinking about NIC which is only charged on wages and unincorporated business profits, and not on pensions, interest, rents or dividends???

Willowswave · 27/09/2022 14:53

Smokers cost UK society £17billion a year.

Heavy drinkers of alcohol cost the UK £21-53 billion per year (£3.5 billion of that comes out of the NHS budget).

Know who doesn’t pay a lot of tax? Heavy drinkers and heavy smokers.

DH works 18 hr days, and pays more than £100,000 per year in tax. The only public service we use is bin collection and lamp posts.

What about smokers and drinkers pay for the costs of their crap lifestyles, and stop expecting hard working financially successful people to pay for it?

XingMing · 27/09/2022 14:53

Except that there is no scope to offset the cost of childcare, which is astronomic in the UK, against earned income. Changing that alone would make FT work worthwhile for so many part time staff.

PolarPolly27 · 27/09/2022 14:53

mmmflakycrust81 · 27/09/2022 14:32

'Leave rich people alone'

HAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHA

No. Make them fucking pay more.

You can't make them do anything.

MarshaBradyo · 27/09/2022 14:52

Badbadbunny · 27/09/2022 14:46

The idea is that there'll be more top earners, all of which will be paying a bit less, but the overall tax revenue is higher. Basically, stop the higher earners leaving the country, encourage foreigners to move to the UK, and encourage people not to do aggressive tax avoidance by not over-taxing them in the first place.

A smaller percentage taxed on more high earners brings in more tax than a higher tax on a smaller number of them!

Bad I probably was unclear and agree with you

I more meant to those who are posting people shouldn’t earn high amounts - when we lose that tax take who picks it up instead?

Badbadbunny · 27/09/2022 14:51

@iekanda

saying “make the rich people pay more” is as stupid as saying “make the poor people work more”

But a "poor" person working part time, maybe 16-25 hours per week CAN work more to earn more money. No reason at all why most able bodied people can't work full time hours of 35-40 hours per week. We have too many people who aren't working full time hours and claiming benefits when they have an alternative!

BlueMongoose · 27/09/2022 14:48

KvotheTheBloodless · 27/09/2022 14:41

It's not at all straightforward to 'just' tax luxuries - there are millions of people worldwide who work to produce these luxury items, often on very little money. If you tax luxuries too much, you hurt the industry, and if you hurt the industry, you hurt the workers. There's also a geographical element - you don't want to drive the super-rich away from the UK, as they contribute a huge chunk of our tax revenue!

The bet way is to tax income, with those on the highest income paying the highest marginal rates, AND to tax wealth. One example of how things have been changed and distorted in favour of the wealthy- presently there is no inheritance tax on land- the tories abolished it. So if your parents work hard to build a business, when they die, the value of it is taxed. If they just inherit land and do nothing but collect rent all their lives, it won't get taxed when they die. Also, in the past, unearned income (like interest, share dividends, etc.) was taxed at a higher rate than the income people got via working (this used to be called 'unearned increment'). Now it's the other way round. So much for rewarding hard work, eh?

Topgub · 27/09/2022 14:48

Well off people pay less tax as a proportion of their income.

equalitytrust.org.uk/news/britains-poorest-households-pay-more-their-income-tax-richest

Badbadbunny · 27/09/2022 14:47

mmmflakycrust81 · 27/09/2022 14:32

'Leave rich people alone'

HAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHA

No. Make them fucking pay more.

And then they beggar off abroad and UK gets nothing from them.

Badbadbunny · 27/09/2022 14:46

MarshaBradyo · 27/09/2022 14:31

Just looking at the tax burden if you decrease the tax take from the top earners by ensuring they don’t earn so much - then who picks up the difference?

The idea is that there'll be more top earners, all of which will be paying a bit less, but the overall tax revenue is higher. Basically, stop the higher earners leaving the country, encourage foreigners to move to the UK, and encourage people not to do aggressive tax avoidance by not over-taxing them in the first place.

A smaller percentage taxed on more high earners brings in more tax than a higher tax on a smaller number of them!

Lunar270 · 27/09/2022 14:45

girlfriend44 · 27/09/2022 13:59

Its equal. we could have all come up with Facebook or any other ideas that make money but we didnt did we?

Seriously, you're using a an example that happens to 0.00000001% of people to try and make a point?

Back in the real world most people aren't looking for TNBT but to get a well paying career so they can live comfortably. In this respect the odds are well stacked up against them.

Madamecastafiore · 27/09/2022 14:45

Where is the research that the investment bankers etc are fuck ups, they don't get paid what they do for being fuck ups, they get fired (and believe me it's easier to fire an investment banker who isn't performing than a doctor or public sector worker who fucks up and costs someone their life).

Yes some people have chosen career paths after obtaining degrees where they earn less. This isn't the fault of those who earn more.

And it's very very easy to say you'd be happy to pay more when you're not paying out in tax each month what the average person earns in a year.

The workforce went to shit when people figured out due to In work benefits they'd be better off not working as many hours. The benefits have to come from taxes and if you cut your hours you aren't paying so much tax but it has to come from somewhere. Wages have stagnated due to lots of things over the past 15 years but employers have been able to get away with not paying a living wage due to the government topping up earnings.

Itsbadbitchoclockyeahitsthickthirty · 27/09/2022 14:45

Leakingroofagain · 27/09/2022 13:28

Not everyone has the same opportunity. If you're lucky enough to be born into a family who can privately educate you, get Uncle Crispin to give you a job in his law firm, leverage family and school networks to progress your career then it's dandy. But if you can't afford to go to uni or have to work three jobs while you're there meaning your grades slip, or don't have networks to help you get a decent job, or have to drop everything to care for relatives because there isn't a good social care provision, then it's a very different story.

I had a state education, went to uni on a student loan, did a masters on a private loan, paid it back from working 2 jobs that I applied for totally organically, never got a penny from my parents for anything other than shelter and food. Now I’m wealthy from doing a difficult job that pays well.

Tell me where I was “lucky” compared to you?

Topgub · 27/09/2022 14:44

Capitalism and the illusion of eternal growth and wealth is literally destroying the planet.

But yeah.

Leave those poor rich people alone.

iekanda · 27/09/2022 14:44

mmmflakycrust81 · 27/09/2022 14:32

'Leave rich people alone'

HAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHA

No. Make them fucking pay more.

I think the whole point is that they do pay more. As well as what Toomuchschool has put about income tax - below - the same logic applies to VAT. VAT is 20%.

£10 handbag includes £2 VAT
£500 handbag includes £100 VAT
So there is already lots of revenue coming from luxury items. If you put some sort of supertax on them, people will just buy them abroad.

start of quote
Toomuchschool · Today 14:22
I had a play around with the tax calculator, and was astounded how much tax higher earners pay a year:

Earnings - Tax
£100,000 - £27,433
£400,00 - £164,950
£800,000 - £344,960
£1,000,000 - £434,960

Imagine paying £434,000 in tax EVERY YEAR and holding down a job that beasts you body and soul, and still having people griping at you for not paying enough.

I think think this country already does quite well out of higher earners. I’m guessing that’s why the government is trying to attract them.
end of quote

saying “make the rich people pay more” is as stupid as saying “make the poor people work more”

Swipe left for the next trending thread