Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to believe rich people should contribute much more?

696 replies

marcusian · 27/09/2022 13:16

A bit tongue in cheek, but given that its almost impossible for poorly paid workers including care workers and nurses to strike, and that the government have given people earning over £100K a massive pay rise, what other ways could the most wealthy be made to pay?

My idea: - a new LUXURIES tax (think 50% VAT) on things ordinary people cant buy, like superyachts, airplanes, £10K+ dining tables, a box at wimbledon, £500+ handbags, £100+ football boots!

AIBU - No - they should pay more and heres my ideas how they should do it!
AIBU - Yes - leave wealthy people alone, its not their fault

AIBU to believe rich people should contribute much more?
OP posts:
BigWoollyJumpers · 27/09/2022 17:19

and that the government have given people earning over £100K a massive pay rise

Going back to this original point. The government also gave every working person a pay rise by reducing the tax rate by 1%. They also cancelled the NI rise for everyone. They also gave low earners £150 off their council tax, and a £600 cost of living payment, more if you are elderly or disabled. We are all getting £400 off our energy bills. You could turn your argument around and say that the poorest are getting a huge pay rise? No?

Hearthnhome · 27/09/2022 17:17

Posted too soon

non actually think that

Hearthnhome · 27/09/2022 17:16

I have always been confused why people get offended when high earners say ‘I worked hard’

People assume the subtext is ‘harder than people who earn less’. I work with many high earners, non of them

ExpectMore · 27/09/2022 17:13

Lunar270 · 27/09/2022 13:25

Everyone has the opportunity to make money in this country for themselves.

True, but it's not equal and is heavily geared against the poor. Hence why people born into poverty remain there.

The rich do very well from a system that works in their favour. You can see this evidenced by the recent mini budget. And for the very rich, this is just amplified.

A better way of wealth redistribution needs to happen and not just talk from those members of the WEF. The great reset needs to happen but so far is just hot air.

The rich do very well from a system that works in their favour. You can see this evidenced by the recent mini budget

What do you mean by this? I don't think the recent mini-budget in anyway evidences a system that works in the favour of the rich.

If anything, it evidences the exact opposite as:

  1. lower income families got more cost of energy support (and rightly so)
  2. everyone got lower rate tax reductions - so equal?
  3. those that pay higher rate tax got it reduced from 45% to 40%... I mean, it's still 40% (ridiculously high) and all that is is them being allowed to keep more of their own money that they've earns rather than have to give away as much as they already do which is already - in both % terms and absolute terms - more than those in the lower income bracket!!

So how it stacked in their favour?!

ExpectMore · 27/09/2022 17:08

Aiionwatha · 27/09/2022 13:24

You talk as if the majority of people just happen to be rich through sheer luck. Most rich people actually had to plan, study, save and work hard, you know. And we already have some of the highest tax rates in the world for the wealthy.

Couldn't agree more!

I always get frustrated when people's envy turns their energy towards working out how to take more money of those that already contribute the most rather than working out how to better their own lives through hard work and study.

AchatAVendre · 27/09/2022 17:04

Two things to bear in mind.

Internet discussion groups always give a skewed impression, because most people working in 100k job or even 50k or 30k jobs full time don't have the luxury of time to post in them. Or if they do, they have to be very guarded in what they say, in case they are sacked. Less so for a relatively anonymous site like mumsnet but far more so for Facebook, Twitter, comments sections in the newspapers, etc..

Dividing people into "rich" and "poor" is straight out of the communist manifesto and far too left wing for the majority of hard working middle earners to support. If you really expect someone on say 70k pa in a stressful, difficult, highly skilled job to look at the deductions from their pay statement and go "oh there you are Mr Bloggs, who has barely got off his arse since school, I'll just GIVE you another 5% of my salary and be quite happy, you are living in cloud cuckoo land.

SeaSwimming22 · 27/09/2022 17:03

It’s capitalism. Nurses earn less because there is (usually) plenty of supply, because the barrier to entry is low-ish (academically). And they don’t boost economic growth.
On the other hand I’m currently trying to fill a role that is ~100k a year and I can’t find anyone suitable. Now looking at resumes from outside the U.K. It makes me mad that schools /unis aren’t producing the talent we need, whilst there are so many kids ending up in zero hour contract jobs. At the same time, it wouldn’t taken much for self starting kids (and indeed much older people) to figure out where the labour shortages (and salaries) are and upskill themselves. And relocate as required. That’s what I did.

Maverickess · 27/09/2022 17:00

BlackForestCake · 27/09/2022 16:44

If there were no rich people, who would pay the workers?

Good God, people are still saying things like this.

If there were no workers, who would the rich people live off?

Exactly, both sides rely on the other, without the 'workers' the money doesn't get made and without the 'rich' the workers don't get paid, or in fact there's no work to do.
The issue arises when the 'rich' start degrading the workers, those people whom they rely on, and telling them how shit they are, for not being like them and that leads to exploiting said workers because it's then a case of they deserve it so it becomes easier to do so in order to watch the bank balance grow.
No one gets rich in isolation, there's a network of other people that have helped it to happen, some of which will have been fairly compensated and some of which won't have been.
Opportunities can and do exist for anyone, but they can't exist for everyone or there's no bottom layers to hold up the rest and the whole thing collapses, we need the low paid workers to do this and the idea that they are less, that they are deserving of as little as possible is rooted in knowledge that they're essential to the cogs turning, but admitting that means you're admitting they're basically exploited and there might be a revolt so best keep them in their place so they'll keep doing as they're told.

candycaneframe · 27/09/2022 16:55

midgetastic · 27/09/2022 16:34

My friend - a nurse - worked her socks off saving lives , suffered life changing injury at work , worked through the pandemic

Are you really saying your dad did so much more than she that he's worth 5million more than her ?

You seem to think people are paid what they're worth

They're not

They're paid based on what they provide. Your friend, a nurse doesn't add financial value to an organisation and is therefore paid less than someone who has built their own business, or a footballer who earns their club millions in sponsorships

midgetastic · 27/09/2022 16:53

So no one who wants a reasonable life / enough money for a comfortable life should train as a nurse ?

That's a stinking attitude

Miajk · 27/09/2022 16:53

XingMing · 27/09/2022 16:49

@Miajk well, to part answer your question "how do some people get so rich?"

The Russian oligarchs who are arguably the most obvious target for oppobrium got rich in the post-Soviet scramble for Russia's immense mineral wealth. Power-politics and rampant corruption. Philip Green might slot in here but there are relatively few UK candidates.

Some people become fabulously wealthy because of their talent. Movie stars who earn millions for each picture, and more through their production companies. Similar with sportspeople and musicians. Talent, sound financial advice and good management... look at the Beckhams, Paul McCartney, Elton John, Ed Sheeran.

Some inherit wealth like the Duke of Westminster, who also operates a very successful (risk taking) property development business based on his ancestors land in the part of London that became the West End. There are not so many of those fortunes left intact.

And there are entrepreneurs like Richard Branson, Alan Sugar, Jeff Bezos and Elon Musk who created companies that they took public where the world's pension funds, insurance companies and institutional investors buy and sell shares on behalf of your and my pension savings.

This is obviously not the definitive answer but just for starters.

To be fair most of these examples are people who exploited people for their wealth + lots of tax evasion.

Jeff Bezos created a company in which people die in warehouses due to poor safety conditions, even in the USA.

The royal family stole wealth from lots of places, never bothered trying to make it right. And Charles won't have to pay inheritance tax. And the queen paid for Andrew's legal bills with more of that stolen money.

This is why laws need to change so scum like this doesn't benefit from harming others out of pure greed and nothing else.

XingMing · 27/09/2022 16:49

@Miajk well, to part answer your question "how do some people get so rich?"

The Russian oligarchs who are arguably the most obvious target for oppobrium got rich in the post-Soviet scramble for Russia's immense mineral wealth. Power-politics and rampant corruption. Philip Green might slot in here but there are relatively few UK candidates.

Some people become fabulously wealthy because of their talent. Movie stars who earn millions for each picture, and more through their production companies. Similar with sportspeople and musicians. Talent, sound financial advice and good management... look at the Beckhams, Paul McCartney, Elton John, Ed Sheeran.

Some inherit wealth like the Duke of Westminster, who also operates a very successful (risk taking) property development business based on his ancestors land in the part of London that became the West End. There are not so many of those fortunes left intact.

And there are entrepreneurs like Richard Branson, Alan Sugar, Jeff Bezos and Elon Musk who created companies that they took public where the world's pension funds, insurance companies and institutional investors buy and sell shares on behalf of your and my pension savings.

This is obviously not the definitive answer but just for starters.

SeaSwimming22 · 27/09/2022 16:49

I think the OP needs to define “rich”
and “workers”. The two are not mutually exclusive, not unless you are only referring to ultra high net worth folks as the rich. But the OP seems to draw the line at GBP100k which is ridiculous - as clearly everyone on this wage is a worker and will be into their dotage as pensions provide a poor income relative to work.

Bearsan · 27/09/2022 16:48

Yabvu. Why should averagely rich people, mostly working, expect to be responsible for everything that goes wrong in this country. I'm sick of all the in fighting.
If you want to do better financially/ buy a house/earn more money then read about it/study/do something instead of all this whining and blaming everyone else for having it easy.
Yes it's easier if you are born into wealth/an educated encouraging family with expectations etc.
But many others have done it themselves, I personally know plenty of examples.
People mostly have some spare money and what they do with it is their business. We will never have a perfectly fair society where everyone gets the exact same amount. Opportunities are still there if you cba.

BlackForestCake · 27/09/2022 16:44

If there were no rich people, who would pay the workers?

Good God, people are still saying things like this.

If there were no workers, who would the rich people live off?

Butitsnotfunnyisititsserious · 27/09/2022 16:39

midgetastic · 27/09/2022 16:34

My friend - a nurse - worked her socks off saving lives , suffered life changing injury at work , worked through the pandemic

Are you really saying your dad did so much more than she that he's worth 5million more than her ?

Well that's completely irrelevant. Chances are your friend trained for this role and went into it knowing the wages. The circumstances are different.

ItsDarkAlready · 27/09/2022 16:38

girlfriend44 · 27/09/2022 13:19

Leave rich people alone.

Why keep on at them? They already pay alot more in tax and give away money. Everyone has the opportunity to make money in this country for themselves. Good luck to those who do.

I doubt if you were rich you would want people telling you what you should be doing with your money and how you should be spending it?

Ok Borris, whatever 🤷

iekanda · 27/09/2022 16:37

midgetastic · 27/09/2022 16:34

My friend - a nurse - worked her socks off saving lives , suffered life changing injury at work , worked through the pandemic

Are you really saying your dad did so much more than she that he's worth 5million more than her ?

People aren't paid their worth. People are paid their salary/wages or the money they earned with their own company. Your friend's injury should be properly compensated - but that has nothing to do with a man who spent 40 years making 5 million. That's his earnings.

midgetastic · 27/09/2022 16:34

My friend - a nurse - worked her socks off saving lives , suffered life changing injury at work , worked through the pandemic

Are you really saying your dad did so much more than she that he's worth 5million more than her ?

iekanda · 27/09/2022 16:33

mmmflakycrust81 · 27/09/2022 15:01

I will wave their greedy arses goodbye at the airport.

If they have earnt their money, rather like Monkeybutt1's example below, you cannot call them greedy. What you mean is that they are extremely successful.

Monkeybutt1 · Today 16:21
My dads best friend went to a local comp school, did rubbish in his exams, left school and became a builder for a property developer. He lost his job and decided to the start his own company, which was financed with equity from his house so if he went bust he lost his house. He worked his arse off for the next 40 years building a successful company with a great reputation. He sold the company for 5 million, he has paid taxes all his life, nothing was handed to him. He deserves everything he has. He also doesn't own a yacht!

midgetastic · 27/09/2022 16:32

Seasidemumma77 · 27/09/2022 16:29

Have always believed everyone should pay same level of tax regardless of earnings, ie 10p in every pound across the board.

Only works if there is a universal basic income which is sufficient for basic living standard

Seasidemumma77 · 27/09/2022 16:29

Have always believed everyone should pay same level of tax regardless of earnings, ie 10p in every pound across the board.

Miajk · 27/09/2022 16:29

I don't think the silly taxation in the UK solves the issue.

The issue is why are certain people so rich?

Why do we make it easy for rich people to get richer and make it hard for poor people. Why are wankers bankers still paid silly amounts after causing the horrendous events in 2008 and the companies never being held responsible?

The corruption and laws need to change.

If anyone has fairly become wealthy, without exploiting people, with honest work, treating their employees well - let them keep it. Tax is a % so its already proportional.

What we need though is to stop making evil people rich and sort out the joke of a legal system we have in most places. Starbucks, Amazon, etc are laughing all the way to the bank with the pittance of tax they pay here despite the UK bringing in so much of their revenue.

XingMing · 27/09/2022 16:28

@Topgub £100k because that's where KK redrew the tax lines.

Of course, that doesn't make them oligarch-rich. But oligarchs and the international super-rich are not subject to PAYE tax codes. And they are highly mobile and WILL relocate to a more favourable jurisdiction if they need to. But they like London, and English country estates.

verdantverdure · 27/09/2022 16:23

I don't know anybody rich. Everybody I know needs their job.

However, when I first lived with my OH we paid bills as a percentage of our wealth and income and I think that's fair.

Most things are far cheaper for rich people than ordinary people if you think of it as a percentage of wealth.

So a person on an ordinary wage might be deciding not to have the heating on or to cut back on anything they can, and a multi millionaire might be putting in a new swimming pool that will cost thousands to heat.

Swipe left for the next trending thread