Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to believe rich people should contribute much more?

696 replies

marcusian · 27/09/2022 13:16

A bit tongue in cheek, but given that its almost impossible for poorly paid workers including care workers and nurses to strike, and that the government have given people earning over £100K a massive pay rise, what other ways could the most wealthy be made to pay?

My idea: - a new LUXURIES tax (think 50% VAT) on things ordinary people cant buy, like superyachts, airplanes, £10K+ dining tables, a box at wimbledon, £500+ handbags, £100+ football boots!

AIBU - No - they should pay more and heres my ideas how they should do it!
AIBU - Yes - leave wealthy people alone, its not their fault

AIBU to believe rich people should contribute much more?
OP posts:
ExpectMore · 28/09/2022 12:29

Topgub · 28/09/2022 12:15

@ExpectMore

@Turkey98

Didn't answer the question and her imaginary exame was just that. Imaginary.

It didn't give an example pf creating wealth that didn't exist.

It gave an example of swapping 2 bits of gold for apples.

The gold (wealth) wasn't created

There was no new wealth. Just wealth transfer

Which is the point you're determined to ignore.

Everyone cant be billionaires. There are too many people and not enough resources.

Everyone could probably be comfortable.

But only if the billionaires stop being billionaires.

And they (and you) don't want that

Cause its not faiiiiiiirrrrrrrr!!! Stamps feet. Itssss mmmmmyyyy mmmooonneeyyy

Petted lip

Thanks @Topgub. You've just evidenced at least the first point I was making. Have a nice day 👍

Hearthnhome · 28/09/2022 12:29

Topgub · 28/09/2022 12:15

@ExpectMore

@Turkey98

Didn't answer the question and her imaginary exame was just that. Imaginary.

It didn't give an example pf creating wealth that didn't exist.

It gave an example of swapping 2 bits of gold for apples.

The gold (wealth) wasn't created

There was no new wealth. Just wealth transfer

Which is the point you're determined to ignore.

Everyone cant be billionaires. There are too many people and not enough resources.

Everyone could probably be comfortable.

But only if the billionaires stop being billionaires.

And they (and you) don't want that

Cause its not faiiiiiiirrrrrrrr!!! Stamps feet. Itssss mmmmmyyyy mmmooonneeyyy

Petted lip

There was no swapping bits of gold for apples in the example though.

Thebestwaytoscareatory · 28/09/2022 12:28

ChangedNameAgain99 · 28/09/2022 10:53

My parents were barely literate immigrants and became rich. When they first arrived they worked in factories and foundaries. Trust me this country is full of opportunity - poor people are not stuck being poor they have so many more life chances than they realise.

and don’t talk to me about the cycle of abuse breaking free cos my father was physically and mentally abused but broke free.

Your example of individual progression does not mean it's possible at a societal level. The fact is that a capitalist society operates on a pyramid system and the only way it can remain function is to ensure there are enough people at the bottom to support those at the top.

You simply couldn't have a functioning capitalist society if every single person had the ability and opportunity to progress up the pyramid and so some form of suppression must exist.

ExpectMore · 28/09/2022 12:27

@Thesinisterdiagram

The wealthiest in society are those who have benefited the most from ‘the system’ we have created.

Whilst I disagree with your point, even if it were to be true, they've benefited as a result of of hard work and graft... an option which is open to everyone (medical exceptions aside).

Topgub · 28/09/2022 12:27

@Thesinisterdiagram

Your point has been consistently and conveniently ignored throughout

Higher earners some how contribute everything but take nothing and in no ay benefit from or make money from anyone else

ExpectMore · 28/09/2022 12:24

@Lassie76 @BecauseICan22

Well done to you. Enjoy your money

Seconded! We'll done!

Lassie76 · 28/09/2022 12:24

"Cause its not faiiiiiiirrrrrrrr!!! Stamps feet. Itssss mmmmmyyyy mmmooonneeyyy
Petted lip"

on the flip side

"I want what I've not earned! I'm ENTITLED to it even though I don't earn it or am not qualified for it! It's not fair! Give me free money! Take more from the wealthy! Stamps feet, etc etc"

As ridiculous as your post.

Lassie76 · 28/09/2022 12:19

"She has gotten more back from ‘the system’ than 99% of people."

She also paid IN more than 99% of people.

Itsmybirthday19 · 28/09/2022 12:16

So, assuming the poster who paid £400k tax on their share disposal paid higher rate CGT, the overall profit was £2m.

Shares are a bit of a gamble and it's reasonable to assume the PP invested a fair whack with no guarantee of a return.

Arguably comparable to betting on a horse or playing the lottery. Profits you don't pay tax on...

Would folk be this angry if that poster had won the lottery or got lucky on the gee-gees, I wonder?

Topgub · 28/09/2022 12:15

@ExpectMore

@Turkey98

Didn't answer the question and her imaginary exame was just that. Imaginary.

It didn't give an example pf creating wealth that didn't exist.

It gave an example of swapping 2 bits of gold for apples.

The gold (wealth) wasn't created

There was no new wealth. Just wealth transfer

Which is the point you're determined to ignore.

Everyone cant be billionaires. There are too many people and not enough resources.

Everyone could probably be comfortable.

But only if the billionaires stop being billionaires.

And they (and you) don't want that

Cause its not faiiiiiiirrrrrrrr!!! Stamps feet. Itssss mmmmmyyyy mmmooonneeyyy

Petted lip

Babymamaroon · 28/09/2022 12:14

People earning a few hundred grand are not rich. They are taxed to buggery and will have mortgages/school fees to go with it.

Yes, they're better off than many but they already cover their seat at the tax-grabbing dinner.

It's the truly wealthy tax-avoiders that need to contribute and start playing fair.

ExpectMore · 28/09/2022 12:03

Turkey98 · 28/09/2022 09:43

@topgub At 11:22 you asked exactlhy the following:

Can you give me an example of brand new wealth creation?

Something that created wealth that didn't exist previously?

Given that money is a made up concept anyway?


You now have that example. You are wrong.

Wealth creation for our foreseeable lifetimes is entirely possible for all. Given that wealth is created by innovation and effort - those who work hard and effectively by doing the most valuable work to increase wealth can always do so.

Why do you believe that people will stop producing art, movies, inventions and technological advance?

Clearly, in 150 billion years when the universe has died and the distances to travel are limited by physics I will agree - but then the people won't exist, so its meaningless, but say for the next 10,000 years wealth is purely limited by the population.

I agree with you @Turkey98. That's the question @Topgub asked and your example clearly demonstrates the point that wealth can be created.

@Topgub's issue is that either that they don't understand your example, they don't understand the principles upon which their own argument is based, and / or that they're just spouting random toxic divisory crap... my guess is that's it's all 3.

Thesinisterdiagram · 28/09/2022 12:03

Lassie76 · 28/09/2022 11:50

I've re-read the post and nowhere does the poster say they aren't getting much back. They said they put more IN than they get back, that is not the same thing.
Her 400'000 tax bill is more tax than low earners will pay in their entire lifetime in ONE tax bill.

I think you’re not understanding my point. She made enough money to pay £400,000 in tax, it sounds like she’s getting plenty back from ‘the system’. Her taxes go towards creating a country and society where she is able to make huge such amounts money. She has gotten more back from ‘the system’ than 99% of people. Would she have been able to make such wealth for herself if she lived in a country with no infrastructure, no roads, no police force, no educated workforce, no accessible healthcare?

The wealthiest in society are those who have benefited the most from ‘the system’ we have created.

Lassie76 · 28/09/2022 11:50

Thesinisterdiagram · 28/09/2022 11:45

If you made enough profit to pay 400,000 in tax how can you say you aren’t getting much back out of society? It sounds like you’re getting far more ‘out of it’ than most people could ever dream of. Maybe you aren’t getting tax money directly deposited into your account but taxes go towards creating a functioning country and society in which people like yourself are able to create vast amounts of wealth for themselves.

I've re-read the post and nowhere does the poster say they aren't getting much back. They said they put more IN than they get back, that is not the same thing.
Her 400'000 tax bill is more tax than low earners will pay in their entire lifetime in ONE tax bill.

Thesinisterdiagram · 28/09/2022 11:45

BecauseICan22 · 28/09/2022 11:24

We have just sold some shares, for what we've made on the shares in profit, we have paid £400,000 in tax. It doesn't mean we deserve special treatment or to be worshipped but fuck me people need to get a grip with the whining of 'the rich need to pay more!' No we really don't, we pump so much more in than we get out and there's no nepotism or inherited wealth here, it's hardcore work with next to no life while only working towards achieving.

If you made enough profit to pay 400,000 in tax how can you say you aren’t getting much back out of society? It sounds like you’re getting far more ‘out of it’ than most people could ever dream of. Maybe you aren’t getting tax money directly deposited into your account but taxes go towards creating a functioning country and society in which people like yourself are able to create vast amounts of wealth for themselves.

Lassie76 · 28/09/2022 11:34

BecauseICan22 · 28/09/2022 11:24

We have just sold some shares, for what we've made on the shares in profit, we have paid £400,000 in tax. It doesn't mean we deserve special treatment or to be worshipped but fuck me people need to get a grip with the whining of 'the rich need to pay more!' No we really don't, we pump so much more in than we get out and there's no nepotism or inherited wealth here, it's hardcore work with next to no life while only working towards achieving.

Be prepared to be flamed within an inch of your life while someone works out what you earned with your shares based on how much tax you said you paid. I'm sure some outraged person will be along in a minute to say you should have paid more tax, not had the shares in the first place, didn't work for them or don't deserve them, because, you know.......nurses and bin men etc.

Well done to you. Enjoy your money.

BecauseICan22 · 28/09/2022 11:24

Lassie76 · 28/09/2022 11:15

Also, who is "evading" tax?

They already pay MASSIVE amount of tax, stop acting as if the high earners are now somehow "evading" paying what they owe when they contribute more than anyone else in society already.
You are acting as if tax has been abolished for the high earners!

We have just sold some shares, for what we've made on the shares in profit, we have paid £400,000 in tax. It doesn't mean we deserve special treatment or to be worshipped but fuck me people need to get a grip with the whining of 'the rich need to pay more!' No we really don't, we pump so much more in than we get out and there's no nepotism or inherited wealth here, it's hardcore work with next to no life while only working towards achieving.

Badbadbunny · 28/09/2022 11:17

GottaGetOutofDairy · 28/09/2022 11:01

Same with the £50-£60k and £100-£125k income levels where there are circa 70% marginal tax rates. Nearly all my clients who fall into those income levels make additional pension contributions to get their taxable income down below the threshold. Because of that HMRC lose out because tax is paid on a lower level and they have to give pension tax relief too! So again, by wanting more tax they end up with less!

I get the 100k-120k bracket because of the loss of personal allowance.

But why the 50k-60k?

Tapered removal of child benefits.

Lassie76 · 28/09/2022 11:15

Also, who is "evading" tax?

They already pay MASSIVE amount of tax, stop acting as if the high earners are now somehow "evading" paying what they owe when they contribute more than anyone else in society already.
You are acting as if tax has been abolished for the high earners!

Badbadbunny · 28/09/2022 11:13

ChangedNameAgain99 · 28/09/2022 10:53

My parents were barely literate immigrants and became rich. When they first arrived they worked in factories and foundaries. Trust me this country is full of opportunity - poor people are not stuck being poor they have so many more life chances than they realise.

and don’t talk to me about the cycle of abuse breaking free cos my father was physically and mentally abused but broke free.

Indeed. I left school with no qualifications because it was a crap comp where I was bullied daily (inc physical abuse, theft etc, not "just" names). When I left, I took two low paid jobs, one being full time Monday to Friday and the other working in a shop on Saturdays and Sundays. Both were very low paid (below the NIC limit and before the NMW). Alongside working 50-60 hours per week, I did evening classes and self study to get my O levels, then A Levels and then I started doing accountancy exams (all self funded and using my annual holidays as study leave and for the exams). That was 8 years of hard graft, basically having no life besides working and studying. It all paid off when I qualified as an accountant and I now run my own practice.

Lassie76 · 28/09/2022 11:11

"Absolutely this. They may work hard too but they certainly got all the advantages of a privileged upbringing and all the contacts, right accent etc to get their jobs"

Drivel.
EVERY high earner I know came from a council background to working class parents.
It's such a lazy belief that "rich" people do nothing, have not earned their lifestyle, contribute nothing, had a privileged upbringing, have posh accents, "know" the right people etc.
It must be galling to accept that most of the time they simply worked their arses off, rose through the ranks in their profession through sheer determination, sacrifice and drive to the point of physical or mental exhaustion, and deserve every damn penny they earn.

So much hatred for high earners.
It seems ingrained in a lot of people that they are "owed" a certain lifestyle or bank balance.
How about tackling the other end of the scale where able people feel entitled to things they have never worked a day in their lives for? Where they contribute nothing to society?

How much more do you possibly WANT from high earners?
Most people on this thread are talking about high earners in terms of the >100K salary, NOT the yaught owning super rich hedge fund managers. And these people already pay VAST amounts in taxes.

Topgub · 28/09/2022 11:02

Interesting that people think it's OK to behave selfishly when it comes to evading tax but are absolutely disgusted when people behave selfishly when claiming benefits

Also I'm not bitter, jealous and I dont hate rich people.

It is possible to be critical of wealth inequality without any of the above.

Its a shame people jump to the defensive /insults

GottaGetOutofDairy · 28/09/2022 11:01

Same with the £50-£60k and £100-£125k income levels where there are circa 70% marginal tax rates. Nearly all my clients who fall into those income levels make additional pension contributions to get their taxable income down below the threshold. Because of that HMRC lose out because tax is paid on a lower level and they have to give pension tax relief too! So again, by wanting more tax they end up with less!

I get the 100k-120k bracket because of the loss of personal allowance.

But why the 50k-60k?

MarshaBradyo · 28/09/2022 11:01

Badbadbunny · 28/09/2022 10:50

Of course tax rates change behaviour. Only the very naive would think they don't. In fact, Gordon Brown's paymaster general, Dawn Primarolo said in Parliament that she didn't think sole traders would become limited companies "just to save tax", at a time when record numbers of sole traders were converting to limited companies because of the lower taxes for limited companies at that time! Talk about being naive, or maybe just deluded!

I am an accountant. I see behavioural aspects of tax on an almost daily basis, such as several IT contractor clients who moved abroad when IR35 was extended in 2017 and 2021. They were already considering moving abroad, but IR35 was the straw that broke the camel's back and they went! They now do the same work, for the same international firms, but the difference is that the UK Treasury get nothing from them, no income tax, no corporation tax, no NIC, and no VAT because they don't spend in the UK, no fuel/tobacco duties, etc etc. That's a massive "shoot yourself in the foot" moment for the UK Treasury who now receive tens of thousands less because they were too greedy and wanted a few thousand more! Tellingly, a couple of those have already emailed me considering returning to the UK now that the IR35 changes have been overturned as per the mini Budget announcement!

Same with the £50-£60k and £100-£125k income levels where there are circa 70% marginal tax rates. Nearly all my clients who fall into those income levels make additional pension contributions to get their taxable income down below the threshold. Because of that HMRC lose out because tax is paid on a lower level and they have to give pension tax relief too! So again, by wanting more tax they end up with less!

It's about time that The Treasury and HMRC actually accepted that behavioural issues are important re their taxation, but for the 20 year years, they've just stuck their fingers in their ears chanting "la la la" rather than accepting the reality and Dawn Primarolo's comments prove that!

Absolutely

Possibly hard to model I don’t know but I was surprised that it wasn’t part of the system which is static

Badbadbunny · 28/09/2022 10:55

Daftasabroom · 28/09/2022 10:40

£3 million won't buy you a super yacht, they start around £10 million. Most superyachts are owned by businesses and shell companies and registered in tax havens such as Monarco, the Camens, Cyprus, London etc.

Indeed, and it's well reported that Lewis Hamilton avoided paying VAT on his private jet by use of shell companies and buying it via the Isle of Man.

Swipe left for the next trending thread