Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To join my uni's Pakistani Society even though I'm not Pakistani/Asian?

161 replies

Ahsoka2001 · 27/09/2022 12:40

I'm back at uni doing an MA for one year (straight after finishing undergrad, I'm 21) and wanted to join at least one society despite being very busy.

There's a few I tried in first year and didn't like (e.g. board games society only had niche games no one knew and not the classic ones) and the sports societies are all quite expensive.

In second year, I made friends with an amazing girl who had Pakistani heritage and in fact led the Pakistani society till she graduated last year. She was very proud of her culture and just knowing her has made me quite interested in learning more about the country/people. So I thought joining this society would be a nice way to do that and meet some new people. But would it be odd to do this as someone who's White British?

The website does say "This is not exclusively for Asian students, all are welcome" but I'm wondering if this is just a formality and in reality it would be a bit odd? Not sure...

OP posts:
Arewerelated · 27/09/2022 13:50

@LateAF I'm Roma so yes 😊 there wasn't a roma society at my university as far as I know? I have stopped going to certain roma events because they're overrun by well-meaning white people who are 'interested' etc etc.
It's more the annoyance of having to explain x y z, or dispell certain beliefs that they have, or answer silly questions. It's not my job to educate people, I just want to spend time with people like me, away from racism or tourism.
The OP is here asking for opinions and I've given mine, I don't think there's anything the matter with that.

beastlyslumber · 27/09/2022 13:49

Ahsoka2001 · 27/09/2022 13:46

@beastlyslumber it is a great idea but the other posters are right that I should leave it up to them rather than use it as an excuse to raise awareness of my work venue. I didn't think of it in that way and I'm sorry.

You don't have to apologise to me! I don't really see the problem with saying, hey I work in a cinema, would it be a good idea to show some Pakistani films there? Honestly cannot imagine who would take offence to that.

Porcupineintherough · 27/09/2022 13:48

PeekabooAtTheZoo · 27/09/2022 13:18

I’m sorry I think you should let them have their space without a white person barging in.

If that's what the group is for then saying "Everybody welcome" on their webpage is really fucking strange. Why do you suppose they say that?

Smellyoldowls22 · 27/09/2022 13:48

We had a non-Jew at our Jsoc. Called him our token Goy, all was well.

ItsVeryHyacinthBucket · 27/09/2022 13:47

Just email them and ask, and while you're at it suggest the screening idea in the same email. That way it's all upfront and either they'll love the sound of it and welcome you in, or they'll be able to put you off without embarrassment on either side.

Ahsoka2001 · 27/09/2022 13:46

@beastlyslumber it is a great idea but the other posters are right that I should leave it up to them rather than use it as an excuse to raise awareness of my work venue. I didn't think of it in that way and I'm sorry.

OP posts:
BellePeppa · 27/09/2022 13:45

Try it and see. I find Asian culture very interesting and would be keen to join such a society if I were at uni (I’m white British too), especially as it says all are welcome.

beastlyslumber · 27/09/2022 13:43

I don't see why you shouldn't go along. You'll soon find out if you're not really welcome!

I don't see the problem with screening Pakistani films either - it sounds like a great idea.

LateAF · 27/09/2022 13:43

Ahsoka2001 · 27/09/2022 13:38

@PeekabooAtTheZoo @LateAF not for profit. We'd be making no money out of it. And if that's how you feel I'll abandon this idea completely. Actually - yes, let's rub the film screening idea out. I won't be arranging anything with them.

You should join, and have fun. You’ll be welcomed there. But I wouldn’t make event suggestions at all, at least not for the first year or so of membership. That will likely rub people up the wrong way- I know it would do that to me. Ethnic minorities are always being told how to do things better by white people, that when it’s done in your own space it can be very frustrating. I’m sure they can manage to organise events themselves.

Phos · 27/09/2022 13:40

Dinoteeth · 27/09/2022 13:28

You managed to put into words what I was thinking. Let them have their space to use their own language and discuss issues you don't understand.

Trying to attend is like a man turning up at a womens group.
The women might 'be kind' and welcoming but it very quickly becomes a mixed sex, women no longer have their own space and the women who it's intended for stop going.

Have you been in/to any of these societies?

Ahsoka2001 · 27/09/2022 13:39

@properdoughnut I agree, let's forget the film screening. Bad idea.

OP posts:
Ahsoka2001 · 27/09/2022 13:38

@PeekabooAtTheZoo @LateAF not for profit. We'd be making no money out of it. And if that's how you feel I'll abandon this idea completely. Actually - yes, let's rub the film screening idea out. I won't be arranging anything with them.

OP posts:
Phos · 27/09/2022 13:38

I don't think it's odd. Isn't the point of these societies to celebrate their culture and be open to people who want to respectfully be part of that and not some clandestine "us vs them"?

I'm a white British atheist and felt very welcome at the Islamic Society at my uni. And before anyone tries to jump down my throat for daring to join, I was doing Middle Eastern Studies and was told to join by coursemates.

Ahsoka2001 · 27/09/2022 13:37

OK, when I said about the film showing I didn't mean for profit. It would be a FREE SCREENING and we'd make no money out of them.

OP posts:
LateAF · 27/09/2022 13:37

Dinoteeth · 27/09/2022 13:28

You managed to put into words what I was thinking. Let them have their space to use their own language and discuss issues you don't understand.

Trying to attend is like a man turning up at a womens group.
The women might 'be kind' and welcoming but it very quickly becomes a mixed sex, women no longer have their own space and the women who it's intended for stop going.

Are either of you ethnic minorities? If so, did you regularly attend or help organise your university’s cultural societies? Because what you’re saying does not tally up with my experience of these type of societies. Having a respectful and open minded white person there will not take detract from the cultural space. These societies are a celebration of culture and having people from other cultures appreciate your own only brings a sense of pride.

IsAinmDummm · 27/09/2022 13:32

Can you ask your friend who was in the society last year for her advice?

TheMoops · 27/09/2022 13:31

I think finding out the focus and purpose if the group is important.
Not all societies are about people having a safe space. Some of them are more even focussed and about promoting their culture so will welcome anyone who is interested.

Dinoteeth · 27/09/2022 13:28

Hoppinggreen · 27/09/2022 13:22

I agree.
The society sounds like a way of people from that culture being in a place they feel comfortable with others from a similar culture. You haven’t experienced it, you will look like a tourist

You managed to put into words what I was thinking. Let them have their space to use their own language and discuss issues you don't understand.

Trying to attend is like a man turning up at a womens group.
The women might 'be kind' and welcoming but it very quickly becomes a mixed sex, women no longer have their own space and the women who it's intended for stop going.

gnilliwdog · 27/09/2022 13:28

LateAF · 27/09/2022 13:23

Yeh ignore my previous post - I hadn’t seen this post. Don’t join if this is your motivation. They don’t need your “mutual benefit” white saviour shit.

It is true that if you want to join a group of minority students you couldn't expect to organise their events. It's a place for them to lead and structure as meaningful to them. I imagine you could be supportive and interested in learning, but maybe you will be restricted to taking part in some activities. You could show support by attending film screenings, but not organise them, I suppose.

TriedAndBested · 27/09/2022 13:27

I'm Indian and I don't see why not. If I was in an Indian society I wouldn't mind anyone else joining (as long as I didn't become the minority there again possibly).

x2boys · 27/09/2022 13:26

I don't think they would be able to say its exclusively for Asian students would they?
I know we have an Asian elders group in my area and they were told they had to be inclusive so now it's just an elders group ,but an Asian one in all but the name .

gogohmm · 27/09/2022 13:26

Dd is in the Korean society, though that's about music and drama series I think. It will be fine but I would expect to be culturally sensitive eg conservative dress cover wise with emergency scarf in case, jeans and tunic top is fine, skimpy skirt and crop top not so much

Banana2079 · 27/09/2022 13:25

What a stupid comment
the comments from people of colour in here such as myself are encouraging her to join
what us your background?
diversity is good and plenty of us want to see other cultures join in on our discussions and worries and show interest, it’s helpful to us

seriously

properdoughnut · 27/09/2022 13:25

Ahsoka2001 · 27/09/2022 13:17

@gnilliwdog this is true, film is a big one out of those for me, huge film fan and never seen Pakistani films. I actually work with a film society (outside the uni) who recently opened their own venue and are looking to work with uni societies. So I could arrange to show some Pakistani films at the venue with the society for example, benefitting both of us. This isn't exclusively my idea, my boss was telling me to go round suggesting this to societies at Freshers' fayre.

Well then do that you don't have to join the society to do that

frazzledasarock · 27/09/2022 13:25

My DD joined the Islamic society at university and so did her friend (she’s white and not Muslim) who lives in the halls with her. Nobody batted an eyelid and they gave her freebies and welcome bags along with my DD. There’s also a student who is Sikh who’s joined the Islamic society because he wanted to make friends he was up front about it and was heartily welcomed aboard.

they are planning a desserts and coffee afternoon apparently and everyone is going along.

so go along and ask if you can join the Pakistani society.

it’s a fun way of getting to know other students and socialising.