Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To join my uni's Pakistani Society even though I'm not Pakistani/Asian?

161 replies

Ahsoka2001 · 27/09/2022 12:40

I'm back at uni doing an MA for one year (straight after finishing undergrad, I'm 21) and wanted to join at least one society despite being very busy.

There's a few I tried in first year and didn't like (e.g. board games society only had niche games no one knew and not the classic ones) and the sports societies are all quite expensive.

In second year, I made friends with an amazing girl who had Pakistani heritage and in fact led the Pakistani society till she graduated last year. She was very proud of her culture and just knowing her has made me quite interested in learning more about the country/people. So I thought joining this society would be a nice way to do that and meet some new people. But would it be odd to do this as someone who's White British?

The website does say "This is not exclusively for Asian students, all are welcome" but I'm wondering if this is just a formality and in reality it would be a bit odd? Not sure...

OP posts:
Ahsoka2001 · 27/09/2022 14:52

@LauraAshleyDuvetCover exactly. I think maybe my best bet would be to try out some of their social events but avoid talk sessions more designed for them to discuss their shared cultural experience (assuming they do these).

OP posts:
LauraAshleyDuvetCover · 27/09/2022 14:51

I think sometimes there's a difference between events (open to all, get as many bums on seats as possible) and meetings if they're used for 'cultural support'.

Having said that I'm no expert, my experience of national societies (other than being invited to friends' events) was with Dutch Soc which only really involved watching football. Grin

(As a side note, I think official university societies do have to be open to everybody. I know at some universities the CU, or Jewish Society etc, might not be an official society if they make actually being that religion a condition of entry.)

SlashBeef · 27/09/2022 14:50

Go for it. We had white people in the Afro Caribbean society at uni. This is something white people will tell you isn't OK but the rest of us are happy to have you!

madasawethen · 27/09/2022 14:49

dottypencilcase · 27/09/2022 14:40

Not at all! Pakistanis don't have a chip on their shoulders- they'd welcome you and be more than happy to share their Pakistani-ness with you!

Are you Pakistani?

Ahsoka2001 · 27/09/2022 14:48

@madasawethen sorry. Just wondered if the group was another uni society or a different type of group is all.

OP posts:
TheWayTheLightFalls · 27/09/2022 14:47

As others say - it depends. Some socs are open to all and have events that are fun in themselves or interesting for both those within the culture and those who want to learn more. Some are, overtly or otherwise, wanting to be more closed. I’m Jewish and once went to a lovely Friday night dinner at Oxford Chabad house. All fine until I got up to say thank you and leave and was practically asked for my hand in marriage by the chap I’d been sitting across from.

Your friend is in a good position to advise.

madasawethen · 27/09/2022 14:45

Ahsoka2001 · 27/09/2022 14:36

@madasawethen was this group a uni society? I'm not sure how much this Pakistani society talks about culture and issues with this country, etc. but past events advertised on their social media are things like bowling, shisha outings, nights out, etc. Probably should have mentioned this earlier tbh

You're not getting it. I'm telling you how it is and you're questioning me. Your white privilege is showing.

They're advertising so other Pakistani can join.
Plus your boss thinking it's a good idea to use these people for his business.

LIke I said, don't do it.

Sallyh87 · 27/09/2022 14:44

I think this is a space for people of a similar background to discuss their experience and maybe some of the challenges they face and bond over similarities. They will probably run events as well which are generally open to other people and might be of interest to you.

If there was a womens society and a man wanted to join, I think people would be affronted by that.

I think joining would be strange but maybe I’m wrong.

WhiskerPatrol · 27/09/2022 14:44

I think it would be very weird for you as a non-Urdu-speaking white British person who has never been to Pakistan to join this society, and actually quite selfish and intrusive. If you want to learn more about Pakistan, plan a trip there and/or sign up for Urdu lessons.

dottypencilcase · 27/09/2022 14:40

PeekabooAtTheZoo · 27/09/2022 13:18

I’m sorry I think you should let them have their space without a white person barging in.

Not at all! Pakistanis don't have a chip on their shoulders- they'd welcome you and be more than happy to share their Pakistani-ness with you!

dottypencilcase · 27/09/2022 14:39

Dinoteeth · 27/09/2022 13:16

Honestly Op I think it would be a really odd thing to do.

The Asian group is somewhere for people to discuss their own culture and family issues in their native language.

Must be plenty of other groups to join.

Codswallop!

Op please join- the Pakistanis in the group will be pleased to have you there as someone who genuinely wants to find out more about the country/people. Join and make your mind up then. I joined so many societies at Uni to get a feel for the people/places/interests. I stayed with the ones I liked and left the ones I didn't. No one said anything or died. Go!

Ahsoka2001 · 27/09/2022 14:36

@madasawethen was this group a uni society? I'm not sure how much this Pakistani society talks about culture and issues with this country, etc. but past events advertised on their social media are things like bowling, shisha outings, nights out, etc. Probably should have mentioned this earlier tbh

OP posts:
madasawethen · 27/09/2022 14:34

I wouldn't.
I'm an immigrant and belong to a group as such and yes we do talk about culture, food we miss, things that annoy us about the country we moved to.

I don't know whose bright idea it was to allow natives of the country to join but it changed the entire dynamic. You mention anything negative about the country, the native gets overly offended and starts arguing how we're wrong to feel that way.

So no, don't join.

Needmoresleep · 27/09/2022 14:33

University societies usual need a diversity and inclusion officer if they are to receive SU funds. They need to be inclusive.

Most societies will welcome those interested in their culture. So join.

Dd belongs to a cultural society because several of her friends come from that country. There has never been any hint that she is not welcome, indeed the opposite. Last year she was appointed D&I officer.

Dixiechickonhols · 27/09/2022 14:31

If it clearly says it’s open to all give it a whirl. If you feel awkward then don’t go again.
Brought back memories of my first week at Uni. My corridor mate got me from shower - there’s some people to see you. I stood there dripping wet and a group of students I’d never seen before said you’re not Chinese! Indeed I’m not and had never said I was. They had gone down list and were randomly calling unannounced on people with surnames that could be Chinese?! They didn’t ask me to join Chinese society they just left. We thought it was hilarious.

Ahsoka2001 · 27/09/2022 14:28

@Zott hope your DS enjoys. Admittedly, I think Japanese Society would be a more popular choice for white students due to anime, etc. I doubt he'll be the only white person there whereas I might well be the only one at a Pakistani society.

OP posts:
Siepie · 27/09/2022 14:28

Ask them! I'm a lecturer and I popped into the societies fair to drop off something for my subject's society. A student came up to me and the student I was talking to (both white) to offer us sweets and advertise the Chinese Society to us. A lot of cultural/national societies want to celebrate their culture with other people.

If you ask and they seem unsure or reluctant, then respect that.

Ahsoka2001 · 27/09/2022 14:26

@gannett all great points, thanks for posting.

OP posts:
MessyBunPersonified · 27/09/2022 14:26

TimeForANameChangeAgain · 27/09/2022 14:24

Messy Bun why so confrontational? I think op was responding to a particular idea mentioned by another poster. I don't think there is anything sinister even in offering to show movies. When I was at uni that would have been really appreciated but now of course you can find everything online.

Because op is trying to join this society to use it for her own means.

It happens all the time, and its exhausting.

BarkminsterBlue · 27/09/2022 14:25

I think a lot of posters don't have much experience of university societies. I would go along to an event, OP. You will soon get a feel for whether or not you are comfortable there, and whether the other members are comfortable with you. I had a devoutly Catholic friend at university who ended up on the exec of the Jewish Society.

MessyBunPersonified · 27/09/2022 14:24

Ahsoka2001 · 27/09/2022 14:20

@MessyBunPersonified if my true motivation really was the work venue, why would I still want to join after scrapping the idea (which for the record was an afterthought)? If you don't believe the motivation stated in the OP is true, then there's not much I can say to prove it. Very hard to prove you're telling the truth on the Internet.

I actually work with a film society (outside the uni) who recently opened their own venue and are looking to work with uni societies. So I could arrange to show some Pakistani films at the venue with the society for example, benefitting both of us. This isn't exclusively my idea, my boss was telling me to go round suggesting this to societies at Freshers' fayre.

Sure it was an afterthought, just a massive coincidence that this afterthought happened after your boss told you to do this exact thing 🙄

gannett · 27/09/2022 14:24

Despairingof · 27/09/2022 14:21

Presumably at the moment they are raising money for the floods so maybe start by helping with that and go from there.

Exactly this.

If you're really that interested in Pakistani culture you'd know that the first priority right now will be the immense humanitarian catastrophe their country is facing.

Ahsoka2001 · 27/09/2022 14:24

@Despairingof very true. My friend I mentioned before started a fundraising page for that and I donated £10. She messaged me instantly to say thank you and she really appreciated the gesture.

Ohh - and I forgot to mention. I was clubbing with her and some other friends back in February when she turns round and says "You need to come on an Asian night out with us!" I'm not sure if she meant the Pakistani society but it's possible. And I also bumped into her doing a Palestine Solidarity society street protest once and she beckoned me to come over and join. I was the only white person there at the time and none of them seemed to mind.

I should probably just ask her as other posters say.

OP posts:
TimeForANameChangeAgain · 27/09/2022 14:24

MessyBunPersonified · 27/09/2022 14:17

Your true motivation became clear within 5 or 6 posts.

Messy Bun why so confrontational? I think op was responding to a particular idea mentioned by another poster. I don't think there is anything sinister even in offering to show movies. When I was at uni that would have been really appreciated but now of course you can find everything online.

gannett · 27/09/2022 14:23

Nothing wrong with you wanting to learn about a different culture OP (as a POC myself). But actually joining a specific group meant for people from that culture is dicier territory. Not that you absolutely mustn't do it - some of this will depend on the specific group dynamic. But most of it will depend on whether you, as a white person, can navigate a Pakistani space with sensitivity.

This means ascertaining whether it's OK first. Why don't you chat with your friend who led the group? Seems the obvious first person to ask. If you email the group directly they may feel they have to say yes just to be polite. If you feel uncomfortable asking your friend, that's a sign!

If she says it'll be fine etc and you do end up going, don't be a tourist. Don't expect the other members of the group to act like unpaid guides or teachers, they don't owe you anything. When they talk about issues their community faces, don't barge in with your "different perspective". Don't treat their culture like some shiny toy - yes, you might love the film and the food but are you also going to be invested in and an ally to the Pakistani community when it comes to racism and marginalisation? Don't be like one of those white people who bangs on about how much of a rap fan they are, then shies away from going on a BLM protest.

If you don't feel you can do that you're perfectly able to learn about Pakistani film and culture online and in libraries.