Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To join my uni's Pakistani Society even though I'm not Pakistani/Asian?

161 replies

Ahsoka2001 · 27/09/2022 12:40

I'm back at uni doing an MA for one year (straight after finishing undergrad, I'm 21) and wanted to join at least one society despite being very busy.

There's a few I tried in first year and didn't like (e.g. board games society only had niche games no one knew and not the classic ones) and the sports societies are all quite expensive.

In second year, I made friends with an amazing girl who had Pakistani heritage and in fact led the Pakistani society till she graduated last year. She was very proud of her culture and just knowing her has made me quite interested in learning more about the country/people. So I thought joining this society would be a nice way to do that and meet some new people. But would it be odd to do this as someone who's White British?

The website does say "This is not exclusively for Asian students, all are welcome" but I'm wondering if this is just a formality and in reality it would be a bit odd? Not sure...

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Hibernationsetting · 28/09/2022 23:20

Mumsnet is obsessed with “safe spaces”

I do not think some of the commenters here have experience of these sort of uni societies. They are not usually safe space style environments to talk of direct challenges etc, but cultural and social gatherings, parties and outings.

i think it’s fine and I’m glad you enjoyed it.

Ahsoka2001 · 28/09/2022 22:19

I should clarify we went to a shisha place.

OP posts:
Grandeur · 28/09/2022 22:16

TheWayTheLightFalls · 28/09/2022 21:29

There is so much to unpack there @Grandeur it’s practically a branch of Ikea. Worth a quiet think about othering, the forms it might take, the various ways it can look?

I don't need a quiet think, thank you. I've witnessed the othering first-hand many times 🤷 Not saying it's exclusive to that particular demographic or that they all do it, but without going into detail, I have seen it first-hand on many occasions. Thanks for your input though!

Ahsoka2001 · 28/09/2022 22:16

Piglet89 · 28/09/2022 20:03

OP I would just do this seriously. If they say all are welcome then all are and I bet the food at their events will be bloody amazing.

I did end up going to tonight's event :)

The President made me feel really welcome, her White-British boyfriend came along so I wasn't the only one. My race was barely acknowledged beyond the odd joke (e.g. me and the boyfriend were sitting close to some super hot lights and the President said of course the ones not built for heat are getting hot). Everyone spoke to me the exact same way as fellow Pakistanis.

I didn't really ask questions about Pakistan but learned some interesting things from hearing other people talk. Was one of those atmospheres where you can sort of switch between conversations and no one minds. Lots knew my friend too when I mentioned her so there's that link established. I'd say 95% of everything said was in English, very little Urdu/Punjabi.

OP posts:
TheWayTheLightFalls · 28/09/2022 21:29

There is so much to unpack there @Grandeur it’s practically a branch of Ikea. Worth a quiet think about othering, the forms it might take, the various ways it can look?

Grandeur · 28/09/2022 20:53

TheWayTheLightFalls · 28/09/2022 20:15

I've always been under the impression that people from Asian (Indian, Pakistani, etc) backgrounds prefer to stick together, and tend to "other" people from different races.

Wow.

Obviously not all. But having grown up in a very diverse area my (and a lot of other peoples!) observation is that they tend to prefer sticking with people of their own culture and heritage 🤷 Not saying there's anything wrong with that.

Hoppinggreen · 28/09/2022 20:41

Grandeur · 28/09/2022 20:01

I'm surprised at the amount of comments saying "go for it, they will love someone from another background joining in."

I've always been under the impression that people from Asian (Indian, Pakistani, etc) backgrounds prefer to stick together, and tend to "other" people from different races. So for that reason if it was me, I'd personally feel quite awkward being one of the few non-Asians there.

They might be polite to your face, but wondering why you're there behind your back.

Bloody Hell

beastlyslumber · 28/09/2022 20:36

Grandeur · 28/09/2022 20:01

I'm surprised at the amount of comments saying "go for it, they will love someone from another background joining in."

I've always been under the impression that people from Asian (Indian, Pakistani, etc) backgrounds prefer to stick together, and tend to "other" people from different races. So for that reason if it was me, I'd personally feel quite awkward being one of the few non-Asians there.

They might be polite to your face, but wondering why you're there behind your back.

Racist. You're saying that Asian people are duplicitous and liars.

TheWayTheLightFalls · 28/09/2022 20:15

I've always been under the impression that people from Asian (Indian, Pakistani, etc) backgrounds prefer to stick together, and tend to "other" people from different races.

Wow.

Piglet89 · 28/09/2022 20:03

OP I would just do this seriously. If they say all are welcome then all are and I bet the food at their events will be bloody amazing.

Grandeur · 28/09/2022 20:01

I'm surprised at the amount of comments saying "go for it, they will love someone from another background joining in."

I've always been under the impression that people from Asian (Indian, Pakistani, etc) backgrounds prefer to stick together, and tend to "other" people from different races. So for that reason if it was me, I'd personally feel quite awkward being one of the few non-Asians there.

They might be polite to your face, but wondering why you're there behind your back.

Jarstastic · 28/09/2022 19:49

I don’t see why not. I wouldn’t see the issue with say a Japanese society, so why should it be different.

Beechview · 28/09/2022 18:25

beastlyslumber · 28/09/2022 18:06

I think it's extremely racist to assume that the group members can't speak for themselves. OP asked, and they responded that OP would be very welcome.

It's racist and paternalist to assume that they must be lying or don't have the wit to discourage OP if they don't want her there. They're not children.

I'm so sick of this woke racism crap. You're trying to divide people by the colour of their skin and you think you're doing good! Stop it.

So true. It's because of this attitude that we have a divided and not integrated society.

Olinguita · 28/09/2022 18:23

Message and ask but generally I think this is ok. I'm white British but I was a member of a certain Asian society at uni, but it was directly related to my degree AND it was very clear that the society was for the appreciation of arts, film, music, celebration of cultural festivals etc rather than specifically being a safe space for members of that ethnicity to connect. You may know this already but Pakistani music is some of the most wonderful in the world. Look up Coke Studio Pakistan and be blown away by the beautiful blend of contemporary and traditional sounds from around the country. And look up a band called Vital Signs too - iconic! I hope South Asians on this thread don't mind me "explaining" Pakistani culture - I hope it is clear that it is coming from a space of pure appreciation and admiration rather than wanting to barge into your spaces

beastlyslumber · 28/09/2022 18:06

I think it's extremely racist to assume that the group members can't speak for themselves. OP asked, and they responded that OP would be very welcome.

It's racist and paternalist to assume that they must be lying or don't have the wit to discourage OP if they don't want her there. They're not children.

I'm so sick of this woke racism crap. You're trying to divide people by the colour of their skin and you think you're doing good! Stop it.

Ahsoka2001 · 28/09/2022 16:17

Angryinvain · 28/09/2022 15:17

Hi OP.

im also a Uni student and understand what it’s like trying to find a society you want to join.

pakistan is a beautiful country with such an interesting history and culture. I’ve always wanted to go and have always been in awe at it. Anyone who I know who has been has said it’s absolutely breathtaking!

But im going to be completely honest with you and say that I would probably feel a bit off towards someone who isn’t Pakistani and has no direct links to Pakistan joining the society. Yes, they do social events and get togethers and it sounds like a lovely group to join, but ultimately it is targeted towards giving students who are Pakistani a group to belong to, where they can join in and meet others. It gives a sense of belonging for students who might not know anyone else. They won’t explicitly say this and it sounds like they have been lovely and inviting towards you, but some group members may feel like you’re invading their space.

as long as the entire group are happy and comfortable with someone non Pakistani joining then that is fine! It sounds like a lovely group :)

I’m irish/british- and if my uni had an Irish society, I would join that. I can relate to having irish family, aswell as similar culture (following Gaelic sports, Irish music, irish dancing). Even if we didn’t talk about Ireland 24/7, it’s a group of people who will experience similar things and will have relatable experiences. Of course if someone non Irish wanted to join that wouldn’t be a problem, but what if lots of non irish people wanted to join and then suddenly the society isn’t an irish society but just a general society instead? And if those people who had no links to Ireland wanted to use the society as a chance to learn about Ireland and Irish culture, it would be lovely of them but ultimately the other group members didn’t join the Irish society as teachers or to teach and educate others. They joined to meet other people who they can relate too. I wouldn’t mind teaching someone else or educating them as long as they were genuinely respectful and interested (eg, not joining on the sole stereotype that Irish people drink a lot and they want to go on wild nights out) but I know some people would possibly feel a little put out by being used to educate someone

its great you’re considering this so much and you sound like you’re trying to be sensitive and not cause upset which is lovely, and there have been several opinions on this thread from Pakistani people who wouldn’t mind. And ultimately that’s what matters here, nothing else! I know you’ve contacted the society already and they were really welcoming- as long as everyone is comfortable with it and happy for you to be there then it should be fine. As long as you’re respectful and don’t use it for your own advantage (eg the film situation although I know you said you’re not doing this anymore which is good).

the only thing that matters here is what the Pakistani society members think about it. If they are genuinely happy for you to be there then that’s fine, but be prepared for other students to think it’s a bit unusual that you’re joining. x

I guess it is one of those things were even if most members (committee included) don't see a problem, there might well be a few who wouldn't like it. But I guess I'd only be part of that issue if there are already other non-Pakistanis in the group. And of course it depends who I end up talking to. If the group is say 200 members (not sure how big it actually is) I'll never get to talk to everyone.

Thanks for the awesome answer anyway.

OP posts:
Tonty · 28/09/2022 15:29

PeekabooAtTheZoo · 27/09/2022 13:18

I’m sorry I think you should let them have their space without a white person barging in.

Don't be silly! it's a society that explicitly states it's not exclusively for people of that heritage. Everything isn't about white v black.

Angryinvain · 28/09/2022 15:17

Hi OP.

im also a Uni student and understand what it’s like trying to find a society you want to join.

pakistan is a beautiful country with such an interesting history and culture. I’ve always wanted to go and have always been in awe at it. Anyone who I know who has been has said it’s absolutely breathtaking!

But im going to be completely honest with you and say that I would probably feel a bit off towards someone who isn’t Pakistani and has no direct links to Pakistan joining the society. Yes, they do social events and get togethers and it sounds like a lovely group to join, but ultimately it is targeted towards giving students who are Pakistani a group to belong to, where they can join in and meet others. It gives a sense of belonging for students who might not know anyone else. They won’t explicitly say this and it sounds like they have been lovely and inviting towards you, but some group members may feel like you’re invading their space.

as long as the entire group are happy and comfortable with someone non Pakistani joining then that is fine! It sounds like a lovely group :)

I’m irish/british- and if my uni had an Irish society, I would join that. I can relate to having irish family, aswell as similar culture (following Gaelic sports, Irish music, irish dancing). Even if we didn’t talk about Ireland 24/7, it’s a group of people who will experience similar things and will have relatable experiences. Of course if someone non Irish wanted to join that wouldn’t be a problem, but what if lots of non irish people wanted to join and then suddenly the society isn’t an irish society but just a general society instead? And if those people who had no links to Ireland wanted to use the society as a chance to learn about Ireland and Irish culture, it would be lovely of them but ultimately the other group members didn’t join the Irish society as teachers or to teach and educate others. They joined to meet other people who they can relate too. I wouldn’t mind teaching someone else or educating them as long as they were genuinely respectful and interested (eg, not joining on the sole stereotype that Irish people drink a lot and they want to go on wild nights out) but I know some people would possibly feel a little put out by being used to educate someone

its great you’re considering this so much and you sound like you’re trying to be sensitive and not cause upset which is lovely, and there have been several opinions on this thread from Pakistani people who wouldn’t mind. And ultimately that’s what matters here, nothing else! I know you’ve contacted the society already and they were really welcoming- as long as everyone is comfortable with it and happy for you to be there then it should be fine. As long as you’re respectful and don’t use it for your own advantage (eg the film situation although I know you said you’re not doing this anymore which is good).

the only thing that matters here is what the Pakistani society members think about it. If they are genuinely happy for you to be there then that’s fine, but be prepared for other students to think it’s a bit unusual that you’re joining. x

yasminisa · 28/09/2022 14:26

I'm Indian, and back when I was at uni, I joined the Chinese society, Caribbean society, the Singapore society, Russian society. All because they gave out food that I wanted to try. I had a ball, and made a lot of friends. Do it OP!

beastlyslumber · 28/09/2022 14:19

That's great OP. Go along and meet some people!

And yes, MN is not a good place for these kind of questions as it's full of woke racists who think people of different ethnic origins shouldn't mix.

user1494050295 · 28/09/2022 14:16

If they get funding from the university then they are obliged to be inclusive

Butchyrestingface · 28/09/2022 14:15

No, I don't speak any second language unfortunately. Did you see my most recent update with the society's response, etc?

Yes, just seen it. Looks like it's toe in the door time then!

Ahsoka2001 · 28/09/2022 14:14

Butchyrestingface · 28/09/2022 14:13

If that's what the group is for then saying "Everybody welcome" on their webpage is really fucking strange. Why do you suppose they say that?

Maybe the university's non-discrimination policy demands it?

The last person who tried to say 'fuck off men and white people' regarding her university society's meet-ups got into a spot of bother and made the national news a few years ago...

@Ahsoka2001 Do you speak Urdu or Punjaba or any other relevant language?

No, I don't speak any second language unfortunately. Did you see my most recent update with the society's response, etc?

OP posts:
Butchyrestingface · 28/09/2022 14:13

If that's what the group is for then saying "Everybody welcome" on their webpage is really fucking strange. Why do you suppose they say that?

Maybe the university's non-discrimination policy demands it?

The last person who tried to say 'fuck off men and white people' regarding her university society's meet-ups got into a spot of bother and made the national news a few years ago...

@Ahsoka2001 Do you speak Urdu or Punjaba or any other relevant language?

WagathaChristieMystery · 28/09/2022 14:08

gnilliwdog · 27/09/2022 13:10

Message them and ask? Could be a great way to learn about music, art, film, history etc of the culture.

I agree with this. It would potentially be a really interesting opportunity to learn about Pakistani culture.