Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Carrying her in crying

90 replies

Comeonchristmas · 27/09/2022 10:06

Dd, 4 has just started pre school, two mornings per week. Every time we go, she won’t go in and cries when I hand her over and shouts for me and I have to leave. Feel so unbelievably shit doing this, is it normal? Am I doing the right thing or damaging her by forcing her away from me?
Teacher says she’s fine when in, Dd says she likes it when there but that she just wants to be with me
What would you do?

OP posts:
Comeonchristmas · 27/09/2022 11:20

They don’t allow them to take toys/books in which I think is a real shame. Even on the first day one of the assistants didn’t want her to bring her teddy but relented as was the first day.
Parents have to drop at the door, they don’t allow us to go in etc 🤷🏻‍♀️

OP posts:
Newuser82 · 27/09/2022 11:16

It's really horrible isn't it? I had the same with my eldest and now again with my youngest. Makes me feel dreadful but I know it will be best for them in the long run.

TheBoxOfWhat · 27/09/2022 11:12

Ds2 used to cling to the railings, I used to call him suffragette. I would have to prise his hands off whilst holding his legs firmly between mine. I would hand over a flailing child, apologise and leave. The thing is I knew that the second he was inside he was fine because I could see him through the bloody window so why we had such a carry on I will never know.

He had gone to playgroup twice a week for 2 hours each, never had an issue. Ds1 had gone to the same preschool so the staff knew me, said lots of children do kick off and they definitely do and they are fine once they are in. I too am a sahm but wanted him to have all the benefits of preschool. I think 3 days in a row would be better than 2 for your DD. Stick with it.

DuneFan · 27/09/2022 11:11

We've just been through this. What has helped is to put photos on Tapestry (or whatever app your nursery uses) which the staff look at with him when he gets in, or to take a different book /soft toy/ etc from home to show them. It distracted him at drop off because he was keen to get in and tell them about it.

Ours is not a school nursery so may not work so well in a school setting (fewer staff?) He does 2 days like your dd.

It's so hard, I sympathise.

steelseries · 27/09/2022 11:11

Sympathy, OP. My DD did this when she was at a pre-school two days a week - also Tuesdays and Thursdays. We changed the days to consecutive ones, which helped, and then she really improved when she started to do 3 days.

If it's any consolation, it isn't always the case that it continues to school. My DD is in Y1 now and has always LOVED school, despite the busier classes. I think she struggled in the in-structured pre-school/nursery environment - she didn't know who to attach herself to or what to do. She is bright, and thrives in school when every day is split into 15 min chunks.

It's tough though, I know.

C152 · 27/09/2022 11:08

If she was crying continuously the entire time, from when you dropped her off to pick up, I would say she's too young/it's not the right environment for her. But as she's ok once you've gone, I would say just struggle through this period. Don't make a big deal out of her going and don't prolong the goodbye, as cruel as it seems and as much as it breaks your heart. Just say something like: 'Here we are, have a great day. I love you very much and I'll see you at 3pm (or whenever you pick her up)." Then turn around and leave without looking back. My ex never could get the hang of the quick goodbye (still can't) and used to drag it out for fucking ever, which upset our child even more.

CasaDelSoot · 27/09/2022 11:08

Yes I agree up it to 3 days. It's not enough of a routine for her if she's 2 days there and 5 days home. It will take a long time to feel "normal".

Also do you need to be somewhere when you drop her off? Could you stay and play a while and gradually reduce this to you just sitting near the door while she settles?
When my DC1 went to nursery there was a boy who didn't settle well and the staff made it a race to see who could get to the window first to wave and blow kisses, him on the inside or mummy on the outside! Worked a treat to ease separation.

Also could she take a transition object like a small soft toy that smells of home she can cuddle if need be.

She absolutely will settle, it just takes some children a bit longer and it's so heart wrenching for parents Flowers

eyeslikebutterflies · 27/09/2022 11:06

OP, huge sympathy. DS was like this, and he was like it (sorry) until year 2 of primary! He just found the separation really hard.

I'm going to go against the grain and say upping the number of days p/w doesn't make a difference. It didn't for my DS.

The things that helped: not making a big deal, positively OR negatively - being kind but being matter of fact; making a quick exit; having a super super empathetic teacher to hand him over to, who acknowledges rather than belittles their feelings, says yeah it's tough, come and have a cuddle, and right, let's get the books out / drawing started etc.

In yr2 of primary, I would literally "hand over" my DS to his class teacher: I'd put his hand in hers, and then I'd leave. He found that physical handing over massively helpful. She was a brilliant and kind teacher with a massive heart: that's what you need to find for your little one. They need to go from one person (you) to another person.

(DS's teacher also made me feel like there was nothing 'wrong' with my DS, whereas plenty of people DID make me feel that there was, including the eye-rolly parents of bullet-proof extroverts who'd barrel into class without so much as a backward glance.)

Turns out, years later, DS is highly sensitive and also super clever, and I think this has great benefits but also a lot of downsides. He's clever enough that "jollying" him along has never, ever worked, but he's sensitive enough that someone acknowledging how he feels and giving him a mechanism to live with those difficult feelings can do the job. He also appreciates calm, matter of fact-ness about things he finds difficult. "Yes, it's shit, but it is what it is, and this is what we'll do now," works for him far better than anything else I can do.

It's when people try to jolly him along / discount how he feels that he struggles - teaching him that it's OK to find things hard, but that he can come out the other side if he just sits with those feelings, is the most valuable lesson.

We do tend to live in a world that's not that great for sensitive souls, but they can find a way through, as my DS has done / is doing. You sound like a great mum, btw.

Sorry for the very long post! It just took bloody years before I realised all of this!!

womaninatightspot · 27/09/2022 11:06

My twins went through that phase after months of being fine. One would set the other off. I agreed with school nursery that I’d come in and read them both a story. It was quite sweet the way the other nursery children would gather round and listen too. Then Hug and kiss, cheery goodbye. Precovid don’t suppose it’d be allowed now.

Icanstillrecallourlastsummer · 27/09/2022 10:59

Maybe, but she will likely be used to the seperation by then and know the preschool much better. I would aim for 3 days at least. Then you can play it by ear.

SpringMum30 · 27/09/2022 10:59

All of my girls did this and I found it really tough emotionally. With that said all barring one of my daughters settled within a few weeks. My daughter who found it hard is summer born though and it was in the middle of the pandemic so lots of disruption.
All of my girls settled well into school though and I feel like it was good for them to overcome the separation anxiety in preschool and get used being amongst lots of other children, adults, routine etc.

Comeonchristmas · 27/09/2022 10:53

@Icanstillrecallourlastsummer Tuesdays and Thursdays

So if I added another day, which do you think would be best? Then if I took it away again, wouldn’t she go back to being the same?
She’s very good with routines and knows it’s Tuesday and Thursday etc

OP posts:
Icanstillrecallourlastsummer · 27/09/2022 10:50

Oh, and once she is over it/ settled I think it'd be fine to reduce a little bit if that works better practically.

Icanstillrecallourlastsummer · 27/09/2022 10:50

Comeonchristmas · 27/09/2022 10:46

@Icanstillrecallourlastsummer I'd ideally like her to go a couple of times per week. Would there be any point doing more days and then putting it back to two 🤷🏻‍♀️Wouldn’t she just become the same again? I really don’t know, I know that she’d be more upset going more often and at the moment, she can stay with me as I’m not working (teacher) I also do bits with her at home etc, I just wanted a gentle introduction to things and a couple of days in a different environment without me and with her friends

I think if she went every day it would help the seperation anxiety. But even if you upped it to 3 or 4 that would probably be better. At 2, presumably they are consecutive, she has almost a full week between them, and doesn't have enough chance to get used to going.

Thelnebriati · 27/09/2022 10:49

As she settles quickly and enjoys it, I'd just power through.

Icanstillrecallourlastsummer · 27/09/2022 10:48

2bazookas · 27/09/2022 10:40

Grit your teeth and keep taking her. As the school says, she does settle quickly.
You might try letting her choose and wear a little amulet round her neck under her clothes. Tell her it is like having Mummy right next to her heart.

Most preschools would definitely not allow a necklace. But it's reminded me that when DS started school I drew a little heart on his wrist which was a kiss from me, so if he felt sad he just had to look at it and remember I loved him. It really worked for him. Similar thing.

Mariposista · 27/09/2022 10:47

2 days is not really enough for her to see that it's a routine and part of her week/day. By the time the next day comes round, she has got used to being at home again.
In any case, keep it no nonsense. Kiss, hug, cheery wave and off you go. No fuss.

Comeonchristmas · 27/09/2022 10:46

@Icanstillrecallourlastsummer I'd ideally like her to go a couple of times per week. Would there be any point doing more days and then putting it back to two 🤷🏻‍♀️Wouldn’t she just become the same again? I really don’t know, I know that she’d be more upset going more often and at the moment, she can stay with me as I’m not working (teacher) I also do bits with her at home etc, I just wanted a gentle introduction to things and a couple of days in a different environment without me and with her friends

OP posts:
Comeonchristmas · 27/09/2022 10:44

@WhenDovesFly How long until
you upped to more days and how many days per week? For us the ideal is a couple of days per week

OP posts:
Canthinkofaname79 · 27/09/2022 10:44

There's a great book called the invisible string that might help

Icannoteven · 27/09/2022 10:42

I'm going to go against the grain here and say DON'T talk about it/big it up beforehand and don't be overly cheery.

This approach makes drop off into a BIG THING. It's too much build up. You're giving her too much time to go over it in her head. Make it seem as small an event as possible and stay neutral. No one wants to be cheered along when they are feeling anxious about a situation - it just creates mixed feelings.

Don't talk about drop off or preschool before hand. When you get there, try and keep the momentum going - just don't stop, if possible. make sure she is holding her thins, march her to the door and before she has time to think, turn around and leave with a quick wave. Let the member of staff distract her in the moment.

2bazookas · 27/09/2022 10:40

Grit your teeth and keep taking her. As the school says, she does settle quickly.
You might try letting her choose and wear a little amulet round her neck under her clothes. Tell her it is like having Mummy right next to her heart.

WhenDovesFly · 27/09/2022 10:38

My DD was like this when she started nursery 2 days per week. The staff would send me photos of her shortly after, happily playing with toys. DD improved when she upped to more days per week/

Icanstillrecallourlastsummer · 27/09/2022 10:36

Still, it won't be as scheduled as reception.

Btw, more often is meant to be loads better for seperation anxiety. The big gaps make it worse. Ideally every day, but short days, is the best. At least till she gets used to it.

Comeonchristmas · 27/09/2022 10:33

@Icanstillrecallourlastsummer It’s a class of 25 😫

OP posts: