Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Carrying her in crying

90 replies

Comeonchristmas · 27/09/2022 10:06

Dd, 4 has just started pre school, two mornings per week. Every time we go, she won’t go in and cries when I hand her over and shouts for me and I have to leave. Feel so unbelievably shit doing this, is it normal? Am I doing the right thing or damaging her by forcing her away from me?
Teacher says she’s fine when in, Dd says she likes it when there but that she just wants to be with me
What would you do?

OP posts:
FlamingoQueen · 27/09/2022 12:22

Something I’ve seen online is that you draw a little heart on your hand and on hers so that if she is missing you she can give it a little kiss and think of you. If she is happy whilst there, then I would persevere a bit longer.
It feels horrible though, doesn’t it.

Bookworm20 · 27/09/2022 12:19

Just remembered with my 5th dc, went in fine but around age 5 started getting upset about school. Not dropping off but teacher would say he cried a bit today etc.
So we did the hug button. Which basically was I drew a little heart on his wrist each morning, and drew one on mine. And if he was feeling sad at school he was the press his hug button and I would feel it on mine and press back. It worked pretty much immediately. The first day we did it he came out of school, hadnt been upset he said as he pressed his button and knew i was hugging him back :)

Carouselfish · 27/09/2022 12:18

She doesn't have to go. She is terribly upset. Why force her to?
Listen to her OP.

Bookworm20 · 27/09/2022 12:15

Its so hard, I had one who did this and its heart breaking. however she was always fine once there, it was just the dropping off.

What actually helped was her going every day as mad as that sounds. As it then became just part of her weekly routine. And there was no fun days at home inbetween anymore, which was the issue as she preferred those to going into nursery. So taking that out as even an option seemed to help massively. Of course we then had fun times after nursery instead. I know your LO goes for 2 days, perhaps it might be better if those 2 days are together instead of spread out if they can't be increased?

The other thing which helped, but you say your nursery doesn't do but might be something you can suggest? Was each child was allowed to take in a soft toy each day, which was put into a little box by the door. So they were not allowed to keep them on them, but they were there in the room with them. The teacher did a little routine at the end of the day, holding each one up and asking whose it was which seemed to delight everyone and so they were all given back to take home again. The point of this, was so if one of the little ones got very upset during the day, or hurt themselves or just needed comforting over something, they could have their cuddly toy for a little while to help calm them. DD was just comforted by thefact her favourite teddy was in the room with her and never needed it after the first couple of days.

MilkToastHoney · 27/09/2022 12:14

Personally, I wouldn’t send her. It sounds like she’s clearly communicating to you she doesn’t want to go, regardless of if she’s ok when she’s there.
Mine never went to nursery/pre school and all very sociable and independent. At that age it’s natural for them to want to be with you.

Wishiwasatsoftplay · 27/09/2022 12:08

Comeonchristmas · 27/09/2022 10:53

@Icanstillrecallourlastsummer Tuesdays and Thursdays

So if I added another day, which do you think would be best? Then if I took it away again, wouldn’t she go back to being the same?
She’s very good with routines and knows it’s Tuesday and Thursday etc

Another vote for more often/
something said to me- if she is happy playing there, then she isn’t crying bc she doesn’t want to go, but bc she needs you to know she wants you to stay

Judijudi · 27/09/2022 12:05

this might sound strange but I was very shy as a child and I absolutely hated nursery and I still remember to this day how much I hated it but I started school when I was 4 and loved it

Natfrances · 27/09/2022 12:01

My little boy was like this when he was only going two mornings a week, he only really improved once he went more and stayed for lunch. Its such a big gap until they go again only doing a couple of mornings so they don't really get used to going.

SleeplessInEngland · 27/09/2022 11:52

If she's fine when she's there then, well, it's fine.

AloysiusBear · 27/09/2022 11:52

She’s a summer born, so only just turned 4, is it still too young? It’s a pre school that’s attached to the school she’ll go to, so I thought was a good introduction.

No, she isn't too young. The children at our preschool go from 2.5/3.

At home she has undivided adult attention, which children love. At preschool she will have to get used to 8 children per adult, which takes getting used to. Gymnastics is different as its a very directed activity. I actually think the child led free play approach of preschools actually is harder at first because they feel a bit lost and dont know what they are "supposed" to do and there are fewer adults to guide.

While this transition is tough, delaying it will only make starting school (even less adult time!) Even harder.

Misandre · 27/09/2022 11:51

Sew a little ribbon or button in a sleeve or pocket. Preferably one with hearts, or with her favourite animal on or something. That is her special secret to remind her of you. A particular focus or routine on arrival is a good idea.

I think she might settle better with an extra day, preferably Weds, to begin with. I think she would then probably be fine to drop down to 2 days, but if she isn't, wouldn't it be better to have her settled on 3 days than disrupted and upset on 2? I'm also inclined not to make a big fuss of her going and don't give her treats after for "surviving" nursery because that can reinforce that's it's negative.

I'm a bit skeptical of settings that don't let a preschooler bring in a transition toy.

Blahdeebla · 27/09/2022 11:48

Oops pressed send too early - he said his child in the end just shouted at him 'I KNOW' and he said it made him think that actually.... its OK to be nervous and having someone going on makes it worse, just let them be nervous and acknowledge thats ok. It really made sense to me and i hadnt thought about it like thay before - Maybe try not talking about it in the build up?

I do have sooo much sympathy for you though - could you ask them to give a quick call once she has settled so your mind can rest?

Goldbar · 27/09/2022 11:47

Big smile, goodbye kiss, dislodge cling-on. Then 'Bye bye, Mummy will be back to pick you up later' and sharp exit. It's the only way.

I've seen lots of this outside the reception classrooms in the past few weeks. Hanging around just prolonges it. If it makes you feel better, they're all mostly fine and playing happily 10 minutes later.

Blahdeebla · 27/09/2022 11:46

Comeonchristmas · 27/09/2022 10:15

@SummerHouse We do all that, I start the morning positively, talk about how she’ll see her friends, have fun, do painting etc and how I’ll just be cleaning at home. I get her a treat for afterwards when I get her or we plan somewhere fun to go afterwards or something fun to do at home etc.
She doesn’t *Have to go as I’m currently at home, but I’d really like her to and to enjoy going.

Rob beckett made a good point on his podcast, his child had the same thi

AloysiusBear · 27/09/2022 11:43

My dd is a daddy's girl too but somehow its like she can detect that it won't elicit the same response from him so doesnt bring all the drama!

jackstini · 27/09/2022 11:33

Comeonchristmas · 27/09/2022 10:15

@SummerHouse We do all that, I start the morning positively, talk about how she’ll see her friends, have fun, do painting etc and how I’ll just be cleaning at home. I get her a treat for afterwards when I get her or we plan somewhere fun to go afterwards or something fun to do at home etc.
She doesn’t *Have to go as I’m currently at home, but I’d really like her to and to enjoy going.

Don't tell her you're at home (even if only cleaning!)
She won't understand why she can't be there if you are. Tell her you are working whilst she will be playing

Second, have around for 1-2 minutes and look through the window - seeing she's fine will make you feel much better!

Comeonchristmas · 27/09/2022 11:32

@AloysiusBear Dh has to leave much earlier for work unfortunately, but I can imagine her being just as bad with him as she’s a real daddy’s girl 🙈

OP posts:
Twizbe · 27/09/2022 11:32

It's still very early days. I would try to up the days so she is there more days that she is not. At the moment she had 2 days there then a whole 5 before she goes again. She resets and goes back to the start in terms of settling and getting used to being away from you.

My 2 went 5 mornings to preschool in the year before school, even though I'm home.
It's all part of settling them ready for school.

AloysiusBear · 27/09/2022 11:28

Will she go in easier if her dad or someone drops off? Dd makes way more fuss for me than either childminder/dad/granny

I sometimes find identifying another kid and encouraging them to walk in together helps.

Try not to get dragged into drawn out processes of extra hugs and fuss, keep it cheery and brisk.

CasaDelSoot · 27/09/2022 11:28

4 is not too young for a pre-school attached to the school. Ours takes them from age 3 for 2 years before school (Scotland)
It smoothed the path to school well as it was just across the playground.

But I was definitely allowed to go in with mine every day at pre-school

pollina · 27/09/2022 11:26

You're taking the right approach. I had this with my eldest and I really let it linger on, stayed inside etc. Subsequent kids I said an encouraging goodbye and a kiss and nipped out much more quickly. In the long run it was better for them and they settled more quickly!

ehb102 · 27/09/2022 11:26

Sympathy.

It's the lack of control for them. Best way I know is to be massively confident and display that confidence that this is the right thing for them. Once you hit the leave button, execute the leave routine and don't look back.

Mummy's going now.
I love you.
I will.see you later
Kiss.
Bye!

And leave.

Comeonchristmas · 27/09/2022 11:24

@CasaDelSoot I'm not sure if that’s the reason, but we drop them with a bag at the door and the assistant takes them through to the classroom to the teacher
I’ve only been into the classroom once for the first parent meeting

OP posts:
Comeonchristmas · 27/09/2022 11:23

She’s a summer born, so only just turned 4, is it still too young? It’s a pre school that’s attached to the school she’ll go to, so I thought was a good introduction. She’s not shy at all and very friendly and outgoing (talks to everyone) but just seems to be really struggling with this and why has she always been ok at gymnastics without us being there but not here

OP posts:
CasaDelSoot · 27/09/2022 11:22

Are they still not allowing parents in because of covid @Comeonchristmas ?