Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Carrying her in crying

90 replies

Comeonchristmas · 27/09/2022 10:06

Dd, 4 has just started pre school, two mornings per week. Every time we go, she won’t go in and cries when I hand her over and shouts for me and I have to leave. Feel so unbelievably shit doing this, is it normal? Am I doing the right thing or damaging her by forcing her away from me?
Teacher says she’s fine when in, Dd says she likes it when there but that she just wants to be with me
What would you do?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
orangenzaft · 27/09/2022 17:00

Awww I actually think your dd will be fine, we had a nanny and the awkwardness when my toddler used to scream her head off and attach to my leg in the mornings when I left for work.
About 30 mins after I left I'd get pictures of her being absolutely fine.

I still feel sorry for my nanny who, 8 years later, I'm still happily in contact with and dc is absolutely fine! Dd can't even remember it. I remember cleaning snot off my trousers on the knees after she'd rubbed her teary little face on them when I got to work though!

Zofloraqueen27 · 27/09/2022 16:45

This is hard for both mum and child. I even felt sad and guilty the second time around when I took my grandson to nursery on my way to work. I should have known/felt better at the nursery but still felt sad leaving a toddler there. I used to wait behind the window and was reassured when I saw him running off towards the Wendy house within seconds of me leaving.

When my son first went to school I would to tell him I would leave the front and back door wide open for him so he knew home would always be there and available for him. This seemed to reassure him and it worked, so easing his anxiety about never going home. Happy to say he is okay now - a six foot very burly ex squaddie.

Wishiwasatsoftplay · 27/09/2022 14:38

I think the nursery worker just meant- she is finding the act of separation hard in itself, and is seeking reassurance for that, not necessarily that she is anxious about the whole time there

can’t stay, obviously, but probably doesn’t need op to either- crying, particularly the sobbing that is typical at the school gate is meant to communicate distress obviously, but doesn’t necessarily need to be fixed- the distressed child is communicating distress, the adult is making sure the child knows their distress has been heard, and then the separation still happens- it’s enough for the child to feel safe, iyswim

Gruffalogruffalogruffalo · 27/09/2022 14:28

@Wishiwasatsoftplay What do you mean? That she needs her to know? Op can’t stay though 🤷🏻‍♀️I’m in a similar situation with my Dd, so interested in the replies

dutyfirstselfsecond · 27/09/2022 13:49

It's hard but keep going. She will be at school in a year so needs to adjust now

rainbowandglitter · 27/09/2022 13:44

I agree with upping her days. I would also suggest getting one of your hairbands and spraying it with your perfume for her to have on her wrist or in her hair for the day so it feels like you're always there.

Soontobe60 · 27/09/2022 13:38

Comeonchristmas · 27/09/2022 10:18

@Icanstillrecallourlastsummer I keep it all positive and say how it’s a couple of hours to be with her friends etc. The teacher says she sits on her lap for a little while and is fine. It’s her fifth day now and the last two she’s cried more and said she doesn’t want to go. It’s only two days per week

She’d probably be better going every day tbh. Its the breaks between sessions that are adding to her settling in.

Musti · 27/09/2022 13:36

She’s fine as soon as you leave her so I wouldn’t worry about it. I remember my eldest doing the same when I left him but I would watch and very quickly he’d stop crying and be all happy.

it would definitely help to go more often as I found the times when there had been a break more difficult

CantGetDecentNickname · 27/09/2022 13:27

Mine after having been to nursery regularly did this when starting pre school. I checked with the teachers and sure enough, they were fine the moment I left. After two weeks of feeling terrible guilt for leaving them, I asked why they were doing this when no other kid was and they were now much bigger than at nursery where they hadn't done this. I said it was a bit embarrassing. The next morning they cheerfully announced "I've decided I'm not going to cry today" on the way in and went in happily after that.

A friend used to tell me tales of having to prise the children off her legs when trying to get them to go in. I honestly think they do it because they can and it gets a great reaction from whoever drops them in. Being matter of fact, cheerful and with a short goodbye is the best tactic.

Curlygirl06 · 27/09/2022 13:03

My eldest was like this, and her son was just as bad but I was prepared this time!
He cried when I came round to their house as he knew I was taking him to nursery. He'd start crying and saying no nursery mummy the minute I walked in, but as the weeks went on he'd start crying later, i.e. when we got in the car, when we got to the car park, when we got to the door etc.
I was bright and breezy, have a lovely day, see you later but it was hard. I used to ring nursery to check he was ok when I got home.
One day he was upset when he went in and an assistant picked him up and took him in. He was leaning over her shoulder, and crying don't leave me grandma, I love you, please don't leave me, proper tears and snot and it broke my heart. I left, realized I'd left something in there so I went straight back in WITHIN SECONDS, and he was happily playing with the trains. They all do it, just keep going!

SlouchingTowardsBethlehemAgain · 27/09/2022 13:01

Actually I find it very reassuring reading this thread. My DC cried at being left until age 6. I had wondered if we had failed to achieve a secure attachment and what had I done wrong. None of the other kids cried like mine. Now here I am reading that loads of kids do it - so maybe I did not fuck up the secure attachment. My DC is all grown up now and a confident, successful academic.

Smineusername · 27/09/2022 12:52

Ask her what she wants to do. I'd let her stay home if it was me, they aren't little for long xx

Kanaloa · 27/09/2022 12:50

However I will say I’m not a fan (despite having worked in a few) of nurseries that don’t let parents into the room where their child is. Just for me personally if I was looking at it as a parent I’d only ever choose a setting where I would be dropping off and picking up in the place where my child was actually spending all their time. Just a personal thing - plus I’ve always found the nurseries I worked in where parents aren’t allowed into the room don’t tend to be the ones with staff who are engaged with/comforting the kids and nice tidy environments with inviting activities set up and modelled.

Mischance · 27/09/2022 12:43

Maybe she is just too young. Just a thought. Children develop at different rates, and this also includes their ability to deal with separation.

Kanaloa · 27/09/2022 12:43

She only goes six hours a week and has only been doing it for a tiny amount of time - she is still adjusting. I would give her a couple more weeks to let her settle. I find it takes children who only do a couple/few sessions a bit longer to settle.

Soozikinzii · 27/09/2022 12:43

Icannoteven · 27/09/2022 10:42

I'm going to go against the grain here and say DON'T talk about it/big it up beforehand and don't be overly cheery.

This approach makes drop off into a BIG THING. It's too much build up. You're giving her too much time to go over it in her head. Make it seem as small an event as possible and stay neutral. No one wants to be cheered along when they are feeling anxious about a situation - it just creates mixed feelings.

Don't talk about drop off or preschool before hand. When you get there, try and keep the momentum going - just don't stop, if possible. make sure she is holding her thins, march her to the door and before she has time to think, turn around and leave with a quick wave. Let the member of staff distract her in the moment.

I agree with this approach. Going on about it might be making it worse . Just drop her off in avnice cheery manner ask a member of staff to distraction her in some way and maybe they can send you a picture of her half an hour later without telling her doing something fun to put your mind at rest .

Popaholic · 27/09/2022 12:41

My dd changed nursery age 3 and 10months and it was a nightmare - she just hated being left there. This from a child who went cheerfully to her old nursery every day having settled in age 11 months. So I knew it would be fine and within 4 weeks she absolutely loved it.

Make the handover short and sweet; don’t sympathise with her upset. Just a happy smile, “have a lovely day”, hug, wave, turn and walk away. Same every day.

Also my son did part time nursery aged 2 and I was advised he would like it a lot more if he went FT so I increased my working hours and paid for FT and he LOVES it now. It was an almost instant transformation. I think it’s because he didn’t miss anything - stories, activities, friends, birthday cakes, things that lace one day to the next. The staff build anticipation of fun things and then… they are not there for them.

so do consider FT, it may help !

PartyHelp · 27/09/2022 12:40

I think she is fine and will get better over time.
I also think 2 mornings per week may be making it harder for her to settle as she isn't there enough. Could she do 2 full days, or 3 days?
She really isn't that young, if she was born 4 weeks earlier she would likely be in school full time by now (assuming you are in England)!

LSSG · 27/09/2022 12:37

Icannoteven · 27/09/2022 10:42

I'm going to go against the grain here and say DON'T talk about it/big it up beforehand and don't be overly cheery.

This approach makes drop off into a BIG THING. It's too much build up. You're giving her too much time to go over it in her head. Make it seem as small an event as possible and stay neutral. No one wants to be cheered along when they are feeling anxious about a situation - it just creates mixed feelings.

Don't talk about drop off or preschool before hand. When you get there, try and keep the momentum going - just don't stop, if possible. make sure she is holding her thins, march her to the door and before she has time to think, turn around and leave with a quick wave. Let the member of staff distract her in the moment.

I agree with this, also it's a bit like trying to talk her out of her feelings otherwise. Empathise about how tough it can be for her being apart if she brings that up at home, at nursery keep it brief, and cheery.

I also second doing more days a week. Every day is a lot but I think a minimum of three works better.

Name1232 · 27/09/2022 12:36

Drop off as quickly as possible, most calm down as soon as the parents are out of sight but the longer the separation takes the more upset they get.

latenightpartyrings · 27/09/2022 12:34

DD had awful separation anxiety and was like this all through nursery and somewhat in Reception. Consistency in sending her in along with the staff being welcoming was important. As long as they are happy once in you needn't worry about them staying sad. A 'hug button' (have seen various mentions here of physical and drawn on symbols) was much more effective than I thought.

She still doesn't like leaving us but is happy going to and in school.

Natfrances · 27/09/2022 12:32

We also did the heart on the hand thing when he started school, this was a complete game changer. Things were different from that day on. Crazy!!

ApolloandDaphne · 27/09/2022 12:30

My DD started school at 4 and was very tearful. We gave her a photo of DH and I to hold and take in with her and it helped her a lot to see us and be reassured. The teacher was on board with this and encouraged her to put it away once she was inside. She soon managed without it. It was just about familiarising herself with the school setting and feeling comfortable there.

northstars · 27/09/2022 12:29

Sympathies, we had the same and although it’s normal, it was so difficult. We read the book “The Kissing Hand” a lot and that helped, but ultimately it just took time for DC to settle in. Preschool is so important and really helped my DC get used to routine before starting primary (both of mine did 4 mornings a week from age 3). Just stay calm and confident, don’t let your child pick up on your anxiety…. It’s early days and I’m sure things will be very different after a couple of weeks.

FlamingoQueen · 27/09/2022 12:23

Sorry - posted mine without seeing the comment above!