Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask if DC actually become adults on their 18th birthday

139 replies

EttieWarbler · 27/09/2022 09:08

It's often said on here "they're an adult, it's their choice/decision" in response to someone asking about something daft or dangerous their DC is doing.

Now I know that in the eyes of the Law they're adults (except for uni funding of course) but how do you deal with them waking up on their 18th birthday an adult?

DD turns 18 in October and I'm pondering ...

OP posts:
RampantIvy · 27/09/2022 10:52

It's great to see a load of sensible and balanced answers on this thread.

Who are these mumsnetters whose DC miraculously become mature, confident, self assured and sensible adults at 18?

mam0918 · 27/09/2022 10:50

legally adults in most respects however I was having this convosation yesterday about how you cant tar all people by age.

Some geniuses have graduated uni before 13 (has happened) and can live independent adult lives, some adults have low IQs and the mentality of small children and some young teen girl can and do raise their own babies, yet some adults I know still dont know how to even hold a baby.

Thing are much more complex than just the date you where born on however unless your DS has notable learning difficulties etc... then in the eyes of the law he will now be held responsable as an adult to make his own choices/decisions and any consiquences as a result (crime, investiments/finaces, children, career etc... all on him now).

WillPowerLite · 27/09/2022 10:13

EttieWarbler · 27/09/2022 09:58

It sounds like OP is thinking more along the lines of boundaries, rules, parental authority etc

Yes, that's it. So my friend's DS was 18 last month and he now wants his girlfriend to stay over "but not in the spare room." They've only been dating 3 months but he's an adult now ...

My DD has a well paid part time job and I give her spending money too on the condition she saves X% of her wages. Can I continue to stipulate this when she's an adult?

By the way, I'm here for a chat not an argument!

Bf/gf staying overnight in their bedroom: that's one for the homeowner to decide. (I mean, I can't see why you would object- seems all sorts of counter productive- but if you do, it's your house, your rules.)

Your dd's money - you can make sensible suggestions, but of course she can do what she likes with the money that she earns.

BadNomad · 27/09/2022 10:12

What goes on in your house has nothing to do with his age. If you don't want his girlfriend staying over in his bed, you can say no. But it's not going to stop him having sex with her elsewhere. That is not something you get a say in. You can only hope you've raised him well enough to be safe and respectful.

Menora · 27/09/2022 10:12

I allow DD’s boyfriend to stay over. She’s 18.
She has known him for quite some time and if they were living away at uni, I would have no say at all of who was asleep with her! Also I would rather she’s at our house than some car park or something 😑 and I like her being at home

He helps out round the house doesn’t make a mess, even buys and cooks food. He is kind of part of the family now

our house is close quarters, a new build so I doubt there is any sex going on at night, her door handle is broken and the door doesn’t even close properly. Also I do trust her she’s sensible about being safe. I think they are actually just sleeping at night and if they have sex they more likely sneak in the house when I am at work and this would happen anyway if I banned overnights

TooMuchToDoTooLittleInclination · 27/09/2022 10:11

TheFeistyFeminist · 27/09/2022 09:39

My darling Dad sat me down and told me that as an adult I should make my own decisions. He hoped I would seek their advice, given their extensive life experience, and he would always attempt to catch me if I fell, or at least help me back up, but as an adult it was important to stretch my wings.

I remember our random and varied discussions about all sorts of things very fondly indeed.

He sounds lovely ❤️

I miss my Dad too xx

ancientgran · 27/09/2022 10:08

EttieWarbler · 27/09/2022 09:58

It sounds like OP is thinking more along the lines of boundaries, rules, parental authority etc

Yes, that's it. So my friend's DS was 18 last month and he now wants his girlfriend to stay over "but not in the spare room." They've only been dating 3 months but he's an adult now ...

My DD has a well paid part time job and I give her spending money too on the condition she saves X% of her wages. Can I continue to stipulate this when she's an adult?

By the way, I'm here for a chat not an argument!

I think the sleeping over things is very individual to the family, their beliefs and circumstances. As an example when one of mine was 18 he had a younger sibling who was 3 so I had to consider what the 3 year old was seeing and hearing. My biggest worry was a 3 year old who liked his girlfriends and then the girlfriend would disappear. In the end I had to say I didn't want girls round until he thought they'd be around for a while as it was unsettling for the 3/4/5 year old.

The saving, well I'm in this position now with 17 year old GC I'm raising about to turn 18. What I've done is talk to him about why it is a good idea to save, what a difference it will make to what he can do next summer when lots of stuff is being organised and how useful it will be to have money when he is at uni. We agreed a plan of spending money/short term saving (for fun next summer with first holiday abroad with friends to celebrate the end of school/long term saving. So for him it is a third for each. It will be interesting to see how that goes.

TooMuchToDoTooLittleInclination · 27/09/2022 10:07

L1ttledrummergirl · 27/09/2022 09:26

When they turn 18 they have autonomy over their lived. You can advise them, support them, guide them but no longer allow them(or not) to do anything.
You hope like hell that the things you've tried to teach them stay with them.

Well, that rather depends on where they want to live & how much financial support they require.

I don't care how old someone is, it's still my house.

x2boys · 27/09/2022 10:05

Outside of the mumsnet bubble where all 18 year old do Alevels and go to university, many 18 year old have no choice but to be an adult ,my niece, was just four months past her 18 th birthday when her mum died suddenly and she was left to look after her two younger siblings and was considered adult enough by the courts to do so ,she's 24 so not that long ago

sóh₂wl̥ · 27/09/2022 10:04

Some of that's going to be living under your roof rules.

You own the house if you don't want the girl friend over - well you can say no - but consequences might be you see DS less - or might not or dealing with fact they may try swap rooms trying to do it under your nose which you have to respond to.

My parenst had that rule - so I spent more time at DH parents house - he didn't understand my parents rule but I had much younger sibling they were also considering.

As you are giving DD money you can set rules again - though if she won't abide you can say fine - your spending money is what you earn and I'll save what I used to give you - though that's one is much more a discussion how to proceed.

Radiatorvalves · 27/09/2022 10:03

I’d say (as parent of a new 18 yo) that it’s evolution not revolution. He’s carried on going to school, doing homework, working on personal statement. He’s come home at 1.30 am too. And he obviously gets a say in things. But if I’m cooking dinner, I expect him to eat it. And usually he does, greens and all. I’m conscious that I probably have it pretty easy.

ancientgran · 27/09/2022 10:02

I don't think it should be a sudden change, I think if they have gradually been given more responsibility and accountability over several years it won't be an earth shattering event on their 18th birthday.

I don't know if that works for everyone but it seemed to with my 4.

EttieWarbler · 27/09/2022 09:58

It sounds like OP is thinking more along the lines of boundaries, rules, parental authority etc

Yes, that's it. So my friend's DS was 18 last month and he now wants his girlfriend to stay over "but not in the spare room." They've only been dating 3 months but he's an adult now ...

My DD has a well paid part time job and I give her spending money too on the condition she saves X% of her wages. Can I continue to stipulate this when she's an adult?

By the way, I'm here for a chat not an argument!

OP posts:
sóh₂wl̥ · 27/09/2022 09:57

I didn’t want them to live in some strange limbo of being an adult but still being treated like a child.

I do think that's a trap our own parents fell into - on plus side we got support well into our 20s downside few year later we were married and few years after that we were parents - and our own parents did struggle with that.

But my DP were forbidding things while I was at University and DH DP weren't as blatant they did expect him to fall into line even after our marriage.

skgnome · 27/09/2022 09:54

I don’t think is an overnight change… more a giving them less “parenting rules” as they approach adulthood and more “advice”
you cannot legally stop them from doing stupid stuff, but you can encourage them to think on what they do
but as others have said, it’s still your happy se your rules, so you can still have house rules

Goosygandy · 27/09/2022 09:52

Nope. Obviously they have much more autonomy than a fourteen year old. Also we can no longer have access to their medical records, educational supervisors etc. But they still need more support than a 30 year old, of course they do.

They don't have full cognitive maturity until they're around 25 for a start. Their support network consists of other 18 year olds, so not a massive pool of experience and knowledge.

If my 18 year old was struggling at university I'd probably go and see them to give some support. With a 25 year old I'd more likely be on the end of the phone. It's about a gradual reduction of support not falling off a cliff.

2bazookas · 27/09/2022 09:50

At 18 they become legal adults. It doesn't mean they mature overnight.

I've met quite a number of "adults" in their 30s and 40's who still hadn't grown up.... childish, immature and irresponsible.

TeeBee · 27/09/2022 09:47

Well my youngest son is 17. I don't 'allow' him or 'forbid' him to do anything but I do coach him. I regularly say to him 'well, you're nearly an adult so you do need to make the decision for yourself but have you considered x, y and z?' Generally I find this helps them make rounded decisions but he's still at home for me to help him mop up any mess he creates by making dodgy decisions if needed. I think you need to do it in a gradual way.

WallaceinAnderland · 27/09/2022 09:46

Yes they are all adults but, like all adults, their level of dependancy will vary.

Blix · 27/09/2022 09:45

Nothing changes overnight. You will have been making gradual changes in the way you interact, teaching them independance and guiding them to make their own decisions. Trust is still earned.
At 18 they are convinced they are fully mature and will never change but in fact I noticed a huge difference between 18 and 21 in my two DC.

Had an interesting conversation with DS26 last week. He has always liked cars and driving. He said he now fully agreed that insurers are right to weight premiums on 18 year old drivers as he has noticed a difference in himself and his attitude to risk as he has got older, noticably after age 24.
I couldn't resist pointing out that when he was 18 he was convinced insurers were wrong to make his premiums so high as he was the safest, most skilled driver in the world and would have dismissed anyone who said otherwise.

NiqueNique · 27/09/2022 09:45

I do agree though that helicopter parenting does young people no favours at all. Micro-managing things they should be sorting out for themselves takes away from their potential achievements and encourages them to think they can’t do things for themselves, that they’re not capable. That’s not a nice way to feel about yourself.

sóh₂wl̥ · 27/09/2022 09:45

Like everyone else says - it's a transition.

DD1 17 - she can and does get herself about - she also now dealing with dentist and GP appointments - making them going to them by herself - but we're there if she needs us.

I think counter to DH initial thoughts he is going on Uni open days with her - something my parents did in mid 90s and his didn't - and she is finding him useful.

She's not financial independent and I do wish she was more determined about future plans.

We don't say no to things - its much more a discussion why it may be a bad idea or not really possible like that or why they think it needs to happen.

MN is odd though teen before 18 there are many posts you are the adult tell them how it's going to be - then at 18 they are nothing to do with you - along side many more balanced posts.

NiqueNique · 27/09/2022 09:41

Yeah I’m not of that mould. Of course I was still going to house, feed and support my children, even if they were technically adults. They went off to university anyway so had to be quite independent of me as a natural consequence. My youngest who didn’t move away to study took a little longer to grow up but that’s only natural.

However my attitude towards them and my expectations of them did change - they were adults and they were expected to contribute as adults to our household. Whether that was a (nominal amount, tbf) towards rent/bills or in other ways depending on their circumstances. I didn’t want them to live in some strange limbo of being an adult but still being treated like a child.

TheFeistyFeminist · 27/09/2022 09:39

My darling Dad sat me down and told me that as an adult I should make my own decisions. He hoped I would seek their advice, given their extensive life experience, and he would always attempt to catch me if I fell, or at least help me back up, but as an adult it was important to stretch my wings.

I remember our random and varied discussions about all sorts of things very fondly indeed.

HeidiWhole · 27/09/2022 09:38

I think I understand what you mean OP.

The biggest thing for us was coming to a realisation that no, I can't actually stop them from doing anything anymore. By my own admission I've been a bit of a helicopter parent in the past (often for good reason due to some SEN issues).

I can advise but any consequences are on them now not me.

For example: I'd prefer them not to drink too much so don't buy excessive alcohol but now have to accept they can go and buy their own if they want and there's nothing I can do about it! It's hard when it's been something you have previously controlled - for want of a better word.

I find they need just as much 'parenting' as when they were little but more emotional rather then physical.