Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To find it hard to feel sympathy for certain scam “victims”?

158 replies

MayThe4th · 27/09/2022 08:46

I’m not talking about those who are taken in by bogus calls from HMRC, or their bank, or PayPal or Royal Mail and the list goes on. In Theory we should all know the signs and be aware, but it’s easy to see how some people can be taken in.

But I’m talking about those people who give hundreds of thousands to 419 scammers, or to scammers for winnings of a lottery they never entered. There was an article the other day about someone who fell for a bitcoin scam and within half an hour he had been scammed out of £400k.

I watched the tinder swindler on netflix and all I could think was wtf! I mean it would be one thing giving this man money, but these women went into debt for him.

And I can’t help but think that so many people fall for these kinds of scams purely out of greed.

They believe they will make the millions, they hope the bitcoin will pay off, the women in the tinder swindler were dazzled by the lifestyle.

If my husband spent the cost of my house transferring money to a Nigerian bank account it would be grounds for divorce.

IMO these kinds of “victims” aren’t the same as real victims of scams, the people who are prayed on by lowlife who rely on someone’s fear they will be arrested for not paying their taxes, or fearing their bank account has been hacked.

The 419 and tinder swindler scam victims aren’t really victims, they’re led by greed, and are prepared to lose whatever they have to to get what they want.

OP posts:
HobnobsChoice · 27/09/2022 09:40

There was something in the money pages of the Times a few weeks back where a man was trying to send more money to scammers having already lost somewhere between £150 to 200k. He was convinced this time the person would be able to get back his money. It was both sad and illuminating that the chap in this case was furious that the bank had blocked him from sending even more money. I suspect he was quite desperate and probably very worried and not thinking properly.
www.thetimes.co.uk/article/ec980bd4-1fc8-11ed-8cc0-b6d3f6238a92?shareToken

Sweetmotherofallthatisholyabov · 27/09/2022 09:39

I always think of victims of domestic abuse. Sometimes they're smart educated women too, I don't understand how you stay if someone hits you, but I accept that it happens. I suppose it's the same for scammers. They identify a vulnerability in someone. I assume for every victim they have 20 or 30 didn't work out and walked away.

ThighMistress · 27/09/2022 09:39

I agree. I have great sympathy for people scammed by texts saying they haven’t paid their tv licence or clever scams in which they purport to be your bank, but a lot of victims are purely greedy.

The Tinder Swindler “victim” lost me when she went on the plane date with his ex and their child - I mean wtf? If this bloke had been a delivery driver and had done this you’d run for the hills, so why tolerate it when you think the date is a millionaire? Er, wait a minute, because he’s a millionaire… ?

Also in the Telegraph there is a weekly financial sob story. One person the other week had “invested” (given) £300k or thereabouts to some fund which promised spectacular returns. In spite of their bank urging caution they went ahead, lost all their money and wanted the Telegraph to get the bank to reimburse them. They were just greedy! Also you can see the opportunity for fraud if a bank is always obliged to make good people’s idiocy. I could give half a million (which is just lying around in my bank account Hmm ) by arrangement to a friend and then claim I’d been scammed.

ChilliBandit · 27/09/2022 09:39

TigerRag · 27/09/2022 08:48

It's not just you. There's a programme on BBC One in the morning called For Love Or Money (I think) and can't understand why people would give away so much money to people they don't know. I mean, if a random person came up to you in the street, you wouldn't give away that much money.

I binged watched this during mat leave and I am afraid I did judge some of the people. One woman had given away all her savings and then some so her and her children were now relying on food banks. I judged hard. I wouldn’t even hand over thousands to a family member if it meant my child went hungry. Priorities were all wrong.

Another rather unpleasant man refused to believe the gorgeous woman 30 years his younger was a scammer using an innocent woman’s photos even when faced with a mountain of evidence. This included a video call with the poor woman whose photos were being used, who confirmed it wasn’t her he’d been talking to. He was so rude to the presenters too. He was so full of himself.

JumpinJacques · 27/09/2022 09:38

JumpinJacques · 27/09/2022 09:29

Omg I was watching this one day last week and couldn't get over that one of the women sold her house (way under market value too) to send money to her "boyfriend", the bank even flagged it as fraud/scam and made her speak to the police about her withdrawing such large amounts of money but she was so convinced she lied about what/who it was for! Absolutely crazy.

I just remembered as well, the worst part was she was handing over wads of cash to people coming to her house, all different men and women and handing over £5-10k at a time to these randomers she didn't even know!

Westfacing · 27/09/2022 09:33

illiterato · 27/09/2022 09:24

@Londongent and then there’s me refusing to click on the fedex link to pay the import duty ( because, duh, clearly a scam and I’m not that stupid) while at the same time thinking that that parcel from the US really should have arrived by now 🤣

I had a card in my letterbox, my surname was misspelt, postcode wrong, almost illegible handwriting, and website address to log on to to pay customs charges. I put it in the bin - months later I learned that a US friend had had a parcel she'd sent me returned to her.

Why our customs wanted to charge me I've no idea as the contents was only a few artisan teatowels!

illiterato · 27/09/2022 09:33

Sounds like you had initiated contact with them before then...

yeah- it was legit ( albeit I didn’t know who the courier would be so hadn’t had direct contact). Just made me laugh that I was thinking I was being all savvy and fedex are like “look lady, do you want this stuff or not?” Good job I didn’t block them or I’d never have got it. But i think it is probably a wider issue that if you’re expecting something and you get a courier link you might just click on it without thinking.

WalkingThroughTreacle · 27/09/2022 09:31

Victim blaming at it's finest. It's easy to look at scam victims in isolation, roll your eyes and think "how stupid can they be"? However, scammers are just playing a numbers game. There are 8 billion people on the planet and whilst many of them are switched on there will always be plenty who are lacking in critical thinking, naïve and too trusting, desperate or otherwise vulnerable. It takes as much effort to send a phishing email or sms to a million recipients as it does to send it to one. Scammers know if they cast their net wide enough they will eventually catch a few fish. That's why their scams invariable look laughably unsophisticated to you and me - they don't need much finesse because the pool is so large. Doesn't mean we should mock the poor fish that get caught though. Blame should stay were it's deserved - with the criminals.

JumpinJacques · 27/09/2022 09:29

TigerRag · 27/09/2022 08:48

It's not just you. There's a programme on BBC One in the morning called For Love Or Money (I think) and can't understand why people would give away so much money to people they don't know. I mean, if a random person came up to you in the street, you wouldn't give away that much money.

Omg I was watching this one day last week and couldn't get over that one of the women sold her house (way under market value too) to send money to her "boyfriend", the bank even flagged it as fraud/scam and made her speak to the police about her withdrawing such large amounts of money but she was so convinced she lied about what/who it was for! Absolutely crazy.

illiterato · 27/09/2022 09:28

@MayThe4th no- I’d be pissed off but I think there’s a big difference between “ hello I am duke Jeffrey of Lagos. Please send 5k to get a share of my late mother’s inheritance” and love scams which are more targeted/ patient/ sophisticated.

my nanny unfortunately fell for a love scam. Fortunately I found out before she lost too much money but while it was frustrating, her circumstances meant that I understand why she fell for it- she desperately wanted to believe it. I think she was more upset that it wasn’t real than about the money. She was devastated.

MayThe4th · 27/09/2022 09:27

Westfacing · 27/09/2022 09:21

The romance ones always puzzle me - often they are educated women with good jobs etc.

A memorable one was a woman who was engaged to be married to someone who had inherited a big house in Paddington, it was all long and complicated, and ended in tears for her (not sure if she lost money) all over someone she never actually met!

I know someone whose son has conned loads of women by inventing a fictitious life. He has told them his mother died and left him loads of money, has borrowed money from them left right and centre and has several of them on the go at once.

And the most bizarre thing aside from them giving him money, is the fact that they all know about each other, know that he’s a compulsive liar, and yet they all stay with him. Why?

OP posts:
RudsyFarmer · 27/09/2022 09:27

I always assumed a lot of the bad decisions being made were by vulnerable people. Those with addiction issues, those with low intellect or those in their twilight years who were troubled with the beginning of dementia. I will absolutely always feel sorry for those victims.

Londongent · 27/09/2022 09:26

illiterato · 27/09/2022 09:24

@Londongent and then there’s me refusing to click on the fedex link to pay the import duty ( because, duh, clearly a scam and I’m not that stupid) while at the same time thinking that that parcel from the US really should have arrived by now 🤣

Sounds like you had initiated contact with them before then...

illiterato · 27/09/2022 09:24

@Londongent and then there’s me refusing to click on the fedex link to pay the import duty ( because, duh, clearly a scam and I’m not that stupid) while at the same time thinking that that parcel from the US really should have arrived by now 🤣

MayThe4th · 27/09/2022 09:24

lannistunut · 27/09/2022 09:17

You're all heart, OP.

People can be naive, silly, easily led, foolish. It doesn't mean they are not deserving of sympathy when a fraudster takes advantage of them.

It isn't only clever people who deserve compassion. You're just unkind.

Oh don’t be so disingenuous. So you’d feel compassion for your husband if he paid all your savings into a Nigerian prince’s bank account then? No didn’t think so.

OP posts:
Londongent · 27/09/2022 09:22

I do feel sorry for anyone who falls for a scam and has their money taken, however it happens, even if they willingly transfer their cash. They didn't ask to be scammed, they are just foolish and naive.
On the other hand people need to be more aware not to click on links and hand over their personal details or account details to anyone.
Their will be a lot of scams going round soon asking you to provide account details to get the £400 energy bill refund, and their will be people who click on these links.
Their needs to be more education in general. Do not click on links in texts and emails asking for your details from any company you have not initiated contact with, even then check the real website first

illiterato · 27/09/2022 09:22

I think these scams show that scammers are good at telling people what they need/ desperately want to hear. Like, this sounds harsh, and I’m definitely not in diamond billionaire league either, but none of the tinder swindler victims were in the league of who a diamond billionaire would be dating- he definitely wouldn’t be on dating apps. But those women wanted to believe they were that league- i mean, who wouldn’t? And yes, the possibility of this exciting, glamorous life was probably very appealing. We’re they gold diggers? I feel that’s a bit harsh- he was also very charming and pretty good looking- he wasn’t a fat old diamond billionaire 🤣

there’s a lot of research about how people think in stories/ narratives and our subconscious discards facts or observations that don’t fit that narrative. I think love scams are evidence of this.

Westfacing · 27/09/2022 09:21

The romance ones always puzzle me - often they are educated women with good jobs etc.

A memorable one was a woman who was engaged to be married to someone who had inherited a big house in Paddington, it was all long and complicated, and ended in tears for her (not sure if she lost money) all over someone she never actually met!

lannistunut · 27/09/2022 09:17

You're all heart, OP.

People can be naive, silly, easily led, foolish. It doesn't mean they are not deserving of sympathy when a fraudster takes advantage of them.

It isn't only clever people who deserve compassion. You're just unkind.

TigerRag · 27/09/2022 09:16

FuriousCheekyFucker · 27/09/2022 08:59

I have family who complete every clickbait phishing question on Facebook - you know the type, ones that are gathering your personal info:

"Name the last Band T Shirt you wore"
"What was your favourite holiday"
"What was your first car"
"Do you remember your childhood telephone number"

ad infinitum.

Funny old thing, these are the same people who are constantly being "hacked" and having to change their account details.

I've stopped telling them, just wasting my breath, I don't even roll my eyes any more.

There was (I don't think I've seen him on here) someone on a few forums I used to post on who'd ask questions like this. He got banned on a few forums for it and would just keep coming back again and again.

Marvellousmadness · 27/09/2022 09:14

They were just being incredibly naive. And pretty dumb really

Marvellousmadness · 27/09/2022 09:14

Those women who claimed they were victims of the tinder swindler bhahahhaa

No they weren't

Goosygandy · 27/09/2022 09:13

Wow!

Amazing lack of empathy. I can only wonder at the lack of self esteem and the neediness that lead women to give up so much for a dream of love. Some of the older women that fall in love with twenty year old young men and believe their stories I have much less sympathy for. That seems predatory more than lonely.

The Tindler Swindler women were all successful in their own right. I thought they fell in love with him and it's not that surprising given we're conditioned to believe in the big romance to our detriment (some day my Prince will come bollocks).

BogRollBOGOF · 27/09/2022 09:12

I once heard that scamming works by preying on a want: the desire for love, money, just to avoid trouble...

Some scams are more understandable than others, like exploiting a current scheme to confuse people into a vulnerable position. Others like laundering money for Nigerian princes are fairly mindboggling, but not all people are intelligent, analytical and sound of mind, and even people that are can have weak moments.

TheDogsDinner · 27/09/2022 09:07

I agree.
They're either naïve or greedy.
I can never understand people giving money away so easily.
I also can't understand those women who fall for the flannel of a waiter young enough to be her son when she's on holiday, then act all surprised that he either buggers off before the wedding cake has even been cut, or they find he already has a wife and family and he hasn't been sending her money to his sick mother for an operation after all.
Usually found telling their stories in magazines.
I was feeling fat and frumpy when my best mate Linda suggested a week in Turkey to cheer me up.
We had only drank twenty darquiries when I noticed his chocolate brown eyes admiring me. The next thing I was in his masculine arms.
Marry me, my little cherry pip, breathed Stavros as we watched the sunset.
Yes, I squealed.
Now I'm broke and living in a tent in a field after Stavros disappeared with my life savings, my house and its contents.
Followed by a picture of a sad looking woman entitled ..Me now.