Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To find it hard to feel sympathy for certain scam “victims”?

158 replies

MayThe4th · 27/09/2022 08:46

I’m not talking about those who are taken in by bogus calls from HMRC, or their bank, or PayPal or Royal Mail and the list goes on. In Theory we should all know the signs and be aware, but it’s easy to see how some people can be taken in.

But I’m talking about those people who give hundreds of thousands to 419 scammers, or to scammers for winnings of a lottery they never entered. There was an article the other day about someone who fell for a bitcoin scam and within half an hour he had been scammed out of £400k.

I watched the tinder swindler on netflix and all I could think was wtf! I mean it would be one thing giving this man money, but these women went into debt for him.

And I can’t help but think that so many people fall for these kinds of scams purely out of greed.

They believe they will make the millions, they hope the bitcoin will pay off, the women in the tinder swindler were dazzled by the lifestyle.

If my husband spent the cost of my house transferring money to a Nigerian bank account it would be grounds for divorce.

IMO these kinds of “victims” aren’t the same as real victims of scams, the people who are prayed on by lowlife who rely on someone’s fear they will be arrested for not paying their taxes, or fearing their bank account has been hacked.

The 419 and tinder swindler scam victims aren’t really victims, they’re led by greed, and are prepared to lose whatever they have to to get what they want.

OP posts:
isthismylifenow · 27/09/2022 11:10

JudgeJ · 27/09/2022 10:01

Maybe there needs to be some free-to-use reverse image software so that people can check the lovely person whose photo they have.

Photo Sherlock.

Came in very very useful when I decided to join Tinder.

DahliaMacNamara · 27/09/2022 11:10

Sure, it's easy to feel we'd never fall for the most blatant cons when we don't need to. And to be smug about not clicking on the dodgy link you got sent, or not inadvertently putting your data out there for scammers to gather, all that. I still worry that the next level of scam will be the one that catches me out. So I try really quite hard not to judge.

FuriousCheekyFucker · 27/09/2022 11:08

mam0918 · 27/09/2022 10:41

People always state this, its fearmongering... I have yet to encounter a single facebook game that has any infomation that could be used against me.

People are NOT getting my bank details from finding out my fantasy name is Prince Purple Smith (childhood pet, tshirt colour, grandmothers maiden name - actually true go steal my identity, I'll wait...) litrally that is not information you could use to get access to anything.

I would love to see people phone up and give the bank that though trying to get access, they call center workers would be pissing themselves with laughter.

You really don't understand how doxxing works then.

A large volume of small snippets of information to build and steal a profile - plus other friends and families linked accounts. You might consider giving away Grannies Maiden Name being insignificant - but if your children gave away their Grannies maiden name, and their accounts were linked to yours?

Crack on though, you know best.

Fenella123 · 27/09/2022 11:00

We're only now starting to unpick the complexity of why people believe what they believe to be true - TLDR brains are complex and imperfect.
Pretty much everyone has done something they shouldn't have - eaten that extra pudding, spent more than they could afford, snapped at an innocent person, slacked at work when they know it'll create more to do later on.
This is just the SuperSize version of Unhelpful Brain Steer You Wrong.

YES it's maddening, but getting mad gets nobody anywhere. We need to understand the process where critical faculties come online - or fail to! - and what society can do to help with that.
Particularly - how to deal with stubborn and perverse beliefs ("he really loves me and will bring the money back").
But the thing is, nobody wants to be a victim because THAT MEANS THEY ARE PUBLICLY KNOWN TO BE WEAK AND GULLIBLE and nobody wants that! As mammals we have an evolutionary interest in not being the first on the prey list!

Discovereads · 27/09/2022 10:56

The 419 and tinder swindler scam victims aren’t really victims, they’re led by greed, and are prepared to lose whatever they have to to get what they want.

I don’t agree in the case of the tinder swindler. Most of the women were in love with him and he deceived them with help- he had a “bodyguard” and he had an “ex” and their child all in on it to fool these women about who he was. He had numerous fake websites and fake news published about himself that corroborated his false identity & fake passports/ID.

One woman, he had proposed to her and they were engaged before she sent him a penny. She’d been literally house hunting for a place to live together. Another was a close friend of his theyd spent an entire summer travelling around Europe together before he borrows money, then paid back twice what he owed her before he then borrowed more and more which he never paid back.

It wasn’t greed but emotional attachment.

TheLongGallery · 27/09/2022 10:51

SIL fell for a scam, basically fake shares and parted with 3k over the phone. To be honest she is thick as pig shit and dreadful with money. We have attempted many times to help her with finances when she has bewailed her situation. We have given up now. MIL has also been scammed but that’s because she does not understand technology at all.

I also have zero sympathy for parents who put their credit card details on devices and then Little Johnny spends thousands on cosmetics in game. I actually don’t think refunds should be given. Because you the parent did not password protect your card or worse you let your child have it.

JacketPocket · 27/09/2022 10:51

mam0918 · 27/09/2022 10:41

People always state this, its fearmongering... I have yet to encounter a single facebook game that has any infomation that could be used against me.

People are NOT getting my bank details from finding out my fantasy name is Prince Purple Smith (childhood pet, tshirt colour, grandmothers maiden name - actually true go steal my identity, I'll wait...) litrally that is not information you could use to get access to anything.

I would love to see people phone up and give the bank that though trying to get access, they call center workers would be pissing themselves with laughter.

Actually, lots of those 'games' have been shown to be troll farms. They ask those questions because the answers are often the answers to security questions, to reset your email/banking/paypal etc. It's not a single step to clearing out your savings, but with systematic data harvesting they can build up pictures that make it easier for you to be the target of a scam or identity theft.

BertieBotts · 27/09/2022 10:50

This is quite a good summary

vincettenoir · 27/09/2022 10:49

A lot of people who fall for these scams are lonely and vulnerable, even if their vulnerabilities are not immediately obvious. I appreciate that a lot of us wouldn’t fall for these kind of scams. But that doesn’t stop me feeling sympathy for the people that do. I think they are naive and prone to fantasy rather than motivated by greed.

KassandraOfSparta · 27/09/2022 10:44

free to use on Google, right click and select view with Google lens.

mam0918 · 27/09/2022 10:41

FuriousCheekyFucker · 27/09/2022 08:59

I have family who complete every clickbait phishing question on Facebook - you know the type, ones that are gathering your personal info:

"Name the last Band T Shirt you wore"
"What was your favourite holiday"
"What was your first car"
"Do you remember your childhood telephone number"

ad infinitum.

Funny old thing, these are the same people who are constantly being "hacked" and having to change their account details.

I've stopped telling them, just wasting my breath, I don't even roll my eyes any more.

People always state this, its fearmongering... I have yet to encounter a single facebook game that has any infomation that could be used against me.

People are NOT getting my bank details from finding out my fantasy name is Prince Purple Smith (childhood pet, tshirt colour, grandmothers maiden name - actually true go steal my identity, I'll wait...) litrally that is not information you could use to get access to anything.

I would love to see people phone up and give the bank that though trying to get access, they call center workers would be pissing themselves with laughter.

JudgeJ · 27/09/2022 10:40

KassandraOfSparta · 27/09/2022 10:03

What, like Google?

But is the reverse image search free to use? When I've looked there's been a charge to use it. If it is free then good!

Crimeismymiddlename · 27/09/2022 10:10

I read a while ago that the people who fall for romance scams generally have a high self esteem and low emotional intelligence. They are probably desperate for love but also really think some fit young person would find them attractive while most people would know it’s a scam.

KassandraOfSparta · 27/09/2022 10:03

JudgeJ · 27/09/2022 10:01

Maybe there needs to be some free-to-use reverse image software so that people can check the lovely person whose photo they have.

What, like Google?

KassandraOfSparta · 27/09/2022 10:02

I don't think the banks will repay. When you make a transfer online on a laptop or through the app it first confirms there's a match with the names you have provided, and there are also warnings telling you not to proceed unless you are sure.

If people are determined to send money to "Major Smith" who just happens to be using the account of his "friend" in Ghana, then hell mend them. There;s no legislating against that sort of stupidity.

JudgeJ · 27/09/2022 10:01

Maybe there needs to be some free-to-use reverse image software so that people can check the lovely person whose photo they have.

Georgeskitchen · 27/09/2022 10:01

78 year old gran marries the 26 year old handsome hunky African man. " we are so in love"
Once he has his visa we can be together for ever
Sure you will love !!

Isaidnoalready · 27/09/2022 10:01

I remember reading about this woman trying to demand the bank give her money back that she willingly sent they even flagged it too her told her not to do it contacted the police who agreed it was a scam but it was ultimately her money and her decision the bank got into trouble for calling the police (she complained the bank agreed there was an overstep) then when it turns out they were right she is demanding her money back life savings how will we cope "heartless bank" headlines

Utter madness

JudgeJ · 27/09/2022 09:59

ThighMistress · 27/09/2022 09:39

I agree. I have great sympathy for people scammed by texts saying they haven’t paid their tv licence or clever scams in which they purport to be your bank, but a lot of victims are purely greedy.

The Tinder Swindler “victim” lost me when she went on the plane date with his ex and their child - I mean wtf? If this bloke had been a delivery driver and had done this you’d run for the hills, so why tolerate it when you think the date is a millionaire? Er, wait a minute, because he’s a millionaire… ?

Also in the Telegraph there is a weekly financial sob story. One person the other week had “invested” (given) £300k or thereabouts to some fund which promised spectacular returns. In spite of their bank urging caution they went ahead, lost all their money and wanted the Telegraph to get the bank to reimburse them. They were just greedy! Also you can see the opportunity for fraud if a bank is always obliged to make good people’s idiocy. I could give half a million (which is just lying around in my bank account Hmm ) by arrangement to a friend and then claim I’d been scammed.

The banks need to stop using our money to repay people who have been scammed if there is no fault on the part of the bank, they shouldn't be used as an insurance company.

ChilliBandit · 27/09/2022 09:58

@KassandraOfSparta - In the one I saw, they got the woman whose photos had been used on Zoom. She explained the photos were taken about 10-15 years ago when she’d been modelling. It was still very obviously her though but the arse of a man was incredulous and basically said the woman on the call was too old and ugly to be the person he’d been talking to.

TheYearOfSmallThings · 27/09/2022 09:55

I agree, in cases where the victim has mental capacity to manage their own finances. It is different in the case of vulnerable or elderly people, and I am particularly worried that the insistence on banking, pension and benefit transactions being carried out online pushes these groups into territory they are not equipped to navigate safely.

But in cases where a mentally competent adult's family and bank has warned them they are being scammed and they send their money anyway?! I find it hard to be sympathetic when they are crying for a refund from the bank later.

Sandra1984 · 27/09/2022 09:53

I had a work colleague in her mid 30’s, smart IT professional get scammed on ok Cupid by some “very handsome US army type based in Afganistán” . He scammed her out of 60000 pounds. I could never believe this “smart” friend could fall for that BS but she did. Deep. She was not pretty at all and had a very lonely life so she was an excellent prey. Scamming is all about targeting peoples vulnerabilities. I’ve been debating myself between feeling sorry and not sorry for her. I mean… how can you give so much money to a stranger on the internet? Mind boggles.

KassandraOfSparta · 27/09/2022 09:49

Even on occasions when they do a Zoom call with the person who's had his photos stolen the women don't get it. You have this Dutch logistics manager or whoever saying that he's never spoken/emailed her before and that he knows photos have been stolen from Facebook, and the British woman is still not accepting that her American marine boyfriend isn't real.

VickyEadieofThigh · 27/09/2022 09:44

TigerRag · 27/09/2022 08:48

It's not just you. There's a programme on BBC One in the morning called For Love Or Money (I think) and can't understand why people would give away so much money to people they don't know. I mean, if a random person came up to you in the street, you wouldn't give away that much money.

I've watched all of those and still find myself shaking my head in disbelief - one woman (in her early 80s, I think) saying "But I love him!" of a person she had never met, who was - of course - entirely fictional and to whom she had shovelled all she had.

Sweetmotherofallthatisholyabov · 27/09/2022 09:41

He didn't bring her on a date with his ex and child- they all got on a private jet together. I assume if he took her to dinner down the road with them red flags would be flying but if you've never been part of an Uber wealthy set you're a fish out of water and she was calmed by the exes presence- he must be a good guy if his ex still sees him.