Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To find it hard to feel sympathy for certain scam “victims”?

158 replies

MayThe4th · 27/09/2022 08:46

I’m not talking about those who are taken in by bogus calls from HMRC, or their bank, or PayPal or Royal Mail and the list goes on. In Theory we should all know the signs and be aware, but it’s easy to see how some people can be taken in.

But I’m talking about those people who give hundreds of thousands to 419 scammers, or to scammers for winnings of a lottery they never entered. There was an article the other day about someone who fell for a bitcoin scam and within half an hour he had been scammed out of £400k.

I watched the tinder swindler on netflix and all I could think was wtf! I mean it would be one thing giving this man money, but these women went into debt for him.

And I can’t help but think that so many people fall for these kinds of scams purely out of greed.

They believe they will make the millions, they hope the bitcoin will pay off, the women in the tinder swindler were dazzled by the lifestyle.

If my husband spent the cost of my house transferring money to a Nigerian bank account it would be grounds for divorce.

IMO these kinds of “victims” aren’t the same as real victims of scams, the people who are prayed on by lowlife who rely on someone’s fear they will be arrested for not paying their taxes, or fearing their bank account has been hacked.

The 419 and tinder swindler scam victims aren’t really victims, they’re led by greed, and are prepared to lose whatever they have to to get what they want.

OP posts:
Justleaveitblankthen · 27/09/2022 12:36

I listened to one on the 'You & Yours' radio 4 lunchtime news a while ago.
What amazed me about this particular woman is that she blamed her bank entirely for allowing her to withdraw thousands of pounds.
Even though her Bank had previously contacted her several times attempting to warn her against this man and that he was most likely a gang of Scammers.

She refused to listen, demanded the right to withdraw her money.. Then tried to get her bank to pay it all back to her! She was adamant they were to blame.
Honestly, you couldn't make it up.
You can't reason with stupid.

maranella · 27/09/2022 12:25

YANBU OP. Every single one of these scams can be boiled to either:

  • a stupid person and their money are soon separated; and/or
  • there's no fool like an old fool.
Crikeyalmighty · 27/09/2022 12:25

@TheDogsDinner I can see you've read Take A Break . !!! You missed off the bit where they always describe him as absolutely gorgeous- matched by a picture showing a very average looking dude who I wouldn't trust an inch!

MayThe4th · 27/09/2022 12:23

I wouldnt be too scathing about people who are scammed, it could happen to you. Nobody is immune you know. Hope you never have to eat your words. no. It absolutely couldn’t happen to me.

As I said in my OP, I wasn’t talking about people who get drawn in by fake calls from HMRC/their bank/amazon/Royal Mail, I’m talking about people who get a spammy mail from prince john the 3rd who is desperately fleeing for his life and all he needs is some help to get his £20m out of the country or it will be lost for ever, and if you would just launder the money throug your account and give him £15000 to start the process then you will be given a 20% cut.

Or the euromillions saying you’ve won the jackpot even though you didn’t have a ticket.

And yes, the romance scammers. It’s one thing to be taken in by a personality, it’s quite another to give someone you’ve never met tens or even hundreds of thousands of pounds.

I guarantee you that if someone put a thread on the relationships board saying that their dh had given the family money to a Nigerian prince in the belief that he was only trying to make money for them, not a single person would say that he needed to be treated with compassion and that it can happen to anyone.

OP posts:
candycaneframe · 27/09/2022 12:23

girlfriend44 · 27/09/2022 12:21

scammers are getting cleverer all the time.

Hope you dont ever eat your words.

Again, they rely on the stupid

Unfortunately half the population suffer with below average intelligence. They're ripe for the picking

girlfriend44 · 27/09/2022 12:21

scammers are getting cleverer all the time.

Hope you dont ever eat your words.

candycaneframe · 27/09/2022 12:19

girlfriend44 · 27/09/2022 12:12

I wouldnt be too scathing about people who are scammed, it could happen to you. Nobody is immune you know. Hope you never have to eat your words.

Regarding ppl who give money away on line if you watched the programme in depth you will see they are lonely women. They are being paid attention to by men and it makes them feel wanted etc and they truly believe they are in a relationship.
One woman even had bought a wedding dress thinking she was going to get married. Even when her son intervened and told her what was going on she wouldnt listen.

Those with average+ intelligence usually don't fall victim to scams

They rely on the stupid

Ponoka7 · 27/09/2022 12:19

If you have Netflix watch 'rogue agent' without googling it first. It's a good film even without it being a true story. But you wouldn't believe that it could have happened. On one episode of Border Security an American man traveled from the US to Australia to track down a white Australian woman (Linda) who he had been sending money to. When he got there, the security wouldn't let him enter because they believed it to be a scam. He only could get in touch with a 'friend' (who was an African national) of hers. He'd only ever spoken to this friend. He was having none of it not being real. All the guards took time out to speak to him. He left Australia saying that he'll be able to sort it out with Linda once he was back home.

Abaiia · 27/09/2022 12:17

I do have sympathy for these victims of crime. People can't help it if they are born with a low IQ.

girlfriend44 · 27/09/2022 12:12

I wouldnt be too scathing about people who are scammed, it could happen to you. Nobody is immune you know. Hope you never have to eat your words.

Regarding ppl who give money away on line if you watched the programme in depth you will see they are lonely women. They are being paid attention to by men and it makes them feel wanted etc and they truly believe they are in a relationship.
One woman even had bought a wedding dress thinking she was going to get married. Even when her son intervened and told her what was going on she wouldnt listen.

psychomath · 27/09/2022 12:11

I don’t agree in the case of the tinder swindler. Most of the women were in love with him and he deceived them with help- he had a “bodyguard” and he had an “ex” and their child all in on it to fool these women about who he was. He had numerous fake websites and fake news published about himself that corroborated his false identity & fake passports/ID.

He also made one woman hide in her house with all the lights off while the supposed 'enemies' who were coming for him drove up her drive. In that situation, when you think some shady mafia person is about to break into your home and you're literally scared for your life, would you really think 'maybe my boyfriend's staging all this to trick me into giving him money in the future'? I admit I went into the documentary wondering who on earth would be so stupid as to hand over hundreds of thousands of dollars to a man they'd just met a month ago, but having seen it I actually can understand why they thought it was real.

RaRaRaspoutine · 27/09/2022 12:09

A side note that memes like "what is your pornstar name - take the name of your first pet + the name of the road you grew upon" are classics for getting your details. So many security questions are based on "firsts" like first best friend, first school, etc. Publishing your answers on a public forum is asking for trouble (sometimes I see them on here, too). A lot of people could do worse than think of the phrase "if it's too good to be true, it is".

Londongent · 27/09/2022 12:08

What is worse is that any company can register at companies house with any residential address in the country, as there are no verification measures in place.

Siepie · 27/09/2022 11:46

I was watching the Netflix documentary on Wirecard the other day. Big, complex money laundering operation. But the part that struck me most was that the (innocent) man whose address was being used as the company's registered address explained that he'd been approached on the street and offered £50 to sign paperwork without reading it. He spoke about this as though he still thought that was a perfectly normal thing to do! I can't think of any other scenario that screams "FRAUD" so obviously.

Sorehandsandfeet · 27/09/2022 11:44

TheDogsDinner · 27/09/2022 09:07

I agree.
They're either naïve or greedy.
I can never understand people giving money away so easily.
I also can't understand those women who fall for the flannel of a waiter young enough to be her son when she's on holiday, then act all surprised that he either buggers off before the wedding cake has even been cut, or they find he already has a wife and family and he hasn't been sending her money to his sick mother for an operation after all.
Usually found telling their stories in magazines.
I was feeling fat and frumpy when my best mate Linda suggested a week in Turkey to cheer me up.
We had only drank twenty darquiries when I noticed his chocolate brown eyes admiring me. The next thing I was in his masculine arms.
Marry me, my little cherry pip, breathed Stavros as we watched the sunset.
Yes, I squealed.
Now I'm broke and living in a tent in a field after Stavros disappeared with my life savings, my house and its contents.
Followed by a picture of a sad looking woman entitled ..Me now.

🤣🤣

Laughingravy · 27/09/2022 11:40

It's not that I don't have empathy but sometimes that can be pushed very hard.

I'm old enough to remember the Barlow Clowes affair in the late eighties. The company dealt in Government bonds and when the company went bust took hundreds of investors, mostly pensioners, money with it. In the end some got some money back because the Government accepted their oversight was too slack. The thing is B-C advertised in the same place as all the other bond dealers but offered a much better rate of return. So their clients ignored that the other 20 companies offered almost identical return rates and went with the one company that offered a lot better return. Caveat emptor went out of the window when tempted by money it seems.

A good friend started an online 'romance' chatting most evenings and messaging through the day with this guy. Thing is she'd been interested in the first place because he only lived half an hour away Yet he always had an excuse not to meet. After several months of this myself and a couple of other friends ganged up on her over a glass of wine and finally it sunk in. Luckily he never asked for money, I guess he just got his jollies from stringing women along, usually several at a time it turned out. And she's no fool normally.

Sandra1984 · 27/09/2022 11:36

vincettenoir · 27/09/2022 10:49

A lot of people who fall for these scams are lonely and vulnerable, even if their vulnerabilities are not immediately obvious. I appreciate that a lot of us wouldn’t fall for these kind of scams. But that doesn’t stop me feeling sympathy for the people that do. I think they are naive and prone to fantasy rather than motivated by greed.

Greed, loneliness, people pleasing, ignorance of technology (usually happens with old people), attention seeking and "not knowing your place in life" are all vulnerabilities. Romance online scammers don't chose the pretty successful stronger looking woman, they pick the non pretty mousy type who just widowed and tell her what she needs to hear. These people are con artists, they know their prey. The Tinder swindler was a convo of romance online scammer with gold digger. How you can jump in a private plane with a stranger you just met two days ago on the internet is mind boggling.

RaraRachael · 27/09/2022 11:36

I've been watching For Love or Money and the same scenarios pop up time and time again - illness of person or child, gold or similar being impounded, person being imprisoned etc etc. It plumbed new depths with them using the profile of a dead man 😓. The minute any of these supposed romeos asks for money, end it. These scams have been going on for years and with gullible people, will still continue. I've had Instagram requests from "good looking, religious, American widowers". Do I add them - no, of course not. I really don't have sympathy for the victims - if something seems to be too good to be true, it probably is.

ginghamstarfish · 27/09/2022 11:35

I can only feel sympathy for the elderly or those who are clearly vulnerable. A lot of it is caused by greed, vanity, stupidity, not usually poor and desperate people. R4 Consumer programme has these stories on every week, and they never cease to amaze me, particularly as there can't be many who haven't heard of these scams yet still fall for them. Also not sure why banks pay these people back most of the time, as the cost of this is surely borne by all the other non-scammed customers. There's a woman on Twitter who has great fun stringing along 'romance' scammers, BeckyHolmeshatesspinach, if you want to see these bastards having the piss taken out of them.

SleepingAgent · 27/09/2022 11:34

RudsyFarmer · 27/09/2022 09:27

I always assumed a lot of the bad decisions being made were by vulnerable people. Those with addiction issues, those with low intellect or those in their twilight years who were troubled with the beginning of dementia. I will absolutely always feel sorry for those victims.

Yes I would feel sorry for these people, especially as OP said with "official" scams pretending to be companies, some are very sophisticated now with proper logos, numbers and even correct spelling (which used to be such a giveaway).

However the romance scammers I just can't get my head around. Why would young, lithe Stavros want to marry Tracy and move to Darlington? Its mind boggling.

SleepingAgent · 27/09/2022 11:21

TheDogsDinner · 27/09/2022 09:07

I agree.
They're either naïve or greedy.
I can never understand people giving money away so easily.
I also can't understand those women who fall for the flannel of a waiter young enough to be her son when she's on holiday, then act all surprised that he either buggers off before the wedding cake has even been cut, or they find he already has a wife and family and he hasn't been sending her money to his sick mother for an operation after all.
Usually found telling their stories in magazines.
I was feeling fat and frumpy when my best mate Linda suggested a week in Turkey to cheer me up.
We had only drank twenty darquiries when I noticed his chocolate brown eyes admiring me. The next thing I was in his masculine arms.
Marry me, my little cherry pip, breathed Stavros as we watched the sunset.
Yes, I squealed.
Now I'm broke and living in a tent in a field after Stavros disappeared with my life savings, my house and its contents.
Followed by a picture of a sad looking woman entitled ..Me now.

Snort! That's exactly the story isn't it!

reachforthebloodymary · 27/09/2022 11:19

Londongent · 27/09/2022 09:22

I do feel sorry for anyone who falls for a scam and has their money taken, however it happens, even if they willingly transfer their cash. They didn't ask to be scammed, they are just foolish and naive.
On the other hand people need to be more aware not to click on links and hand over their personal details or account details to anyone.
Their will be a lot of scams going round soon asking you to provide account details to get the £400 energy bill refund, and their will be people who click on these links.
Their needs to be more education in general. Do not click on links in texts and emails asking for your details from any company you have not initiated contact with, even then check the real website first

I have just had the gas on in text form this morning

LadybirdsAreNeverHappy · 27/09/2022 11:19

My grandad got conned out a LOT of money by a young woman he met through his church. He thought he was engaged to her, bought her a ring and everything, paid for her to go to college, rent on an apartment which she said she was getting ready for them to live together in (said she needed money for furniture, repairs etc), said she needed money for wedding stuff like a dress, to send back to her family in a different country…all in all it was 100s of thousands of quid 🙈Eventually she dumped him very suddenly and left the country. On Facebook she was married to a man her own age less than a year later. We all thought it was fairly creepy that he would get engaged to a woman younger than some of his grandkids anyway but he had a lot of problems that made him vulnerable and in his 80s he was more so than ever.
A woman I know has fallen for some scams that most people would never ever fall for but she has autism and it makes her vulnerable. She was also being bullied online very badly and nobody knew for ages.
I kind of get what you’re saying but scammers cast their nets widely and some people that fall for them really can’t help it.

candycaneframe · 27/09/2022 11:18

I have no sympathy for any scam victims tbh, not just the greedy and stupid ones.

MissWired · 27/09/2022 11:14

TheDogsDinner · 27/09/2022 09:07

I agree.
They're either naïve or greedy.
I can never understand people giving money away so easily.
I also can't understand those women who fall for the flannel of a waiter young enough to be her son when she's on holiday, then act all surprised that he either buggers off before the wedding cake has even been cut, or they find he already has a wife and family and he hasn't been sending her money to his sick mother for an operation after all.
Usually found telling their stories in magazines.
I was feeling fat and frumpy when my best mate Linda suggested a week in Turkey to cheer me up.
We had only drank twenty darquiries when I noticed his chocolate brown eyes admiring me. The next thing I was in his masculine arms.
Marry me, my little cherry pip, breathed Stavros as we watched the sunset.
Yes, I squealed.
Now I'm broke and living in a tent in a field after Stavros disappeared with my life savings, my house and its contents.
Followed by a picture of a sad looking woman entitled ..Me now.

I know one woman who fell for this.

She was 50, divorced, went to Morrocco and married a 24 year old waiter and sold her house here first - twelve months later she was out on her ear, and he took her for every penny.

Now she rents a flat back here and is totally broke. She will rent for the rest of her life.

It boggles the mind.