Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To find it hard to feel sympathy for certain scam “victims”?

158 replies

MayThe4th · 27/09/2022 08:46

I’m not talking about those who are taken in by bogus calls from HMRC, or their bank, or PayPal or Royal Mail and the list goes on. In Theory we should all know the signs and be aware, but it’s easy to see how some people can be taken in.

But I’m talking about those people who give hundreds of thousands to 419 scammers, or to scammers for winnings of a lottery they never entered. There was an article the other day about someone who fell for a bitcoin scam and within half an hour he had been scammed out of £400k.

I watched the tinder swindler on netflix and all I could think was wtf! I mean it would be one thing giving this man money, but these women went into debt for him.

And I can’t help but think that so many people fall for these kinds of scams purely out of greed.

They believe they will make the millions, they hope the bitcoin will pay off, the women in the tinder swindler were dazzled by the lifestyle.

If my husband spent the cost of my house transferring money to a Nigerian bank account it would be grounds for divorce.

IMO these kinds of “victims” aren’t the same as real victims of scams, the people who are prayed on by lowlife who rely on someone’s fear they will be arrested for not paying their taxes, or fearing their bank account has been hacked.

The 419 and tinder swindler scam victims aren’t really victims, they’re led by greed, and are prepared to lose whatever they have to to get what they want.

OP posts:
Puzzledandpissedoff · 27/09/2022 14:06

This is literally the equivalent of telling a victim of sexual assault that they asked for it by wearing a short skirt

Not really, no, because while it's perfectly reasonable to expect that you shouldn't be attacked just because of a short skirt, the same hardly applies to sending £££££ to someone you've never heard of in the hope you'll collect on a batch of promises of whatever type

LadybirdsAreNeverHappy · 27/09/2022 14:05

LadybirdsAreNeverHappy · 27/09/2022 14:03

As I posted earlier, my grandad was badly ripped off by a much younger woman he was “engaged” to. He was bipolar (untreated) and in his mid 80s. His wife was a long time gone and his son had just died. I would imagine he was lonely and when he met this woman and she showed an interest in him he was probably flattered. I don’t know why it didn’t seem to occur to him why a young attractive woman wanted to be with an elderly man. He made a bad decision for selfish reasons but she targeted and manipulated him. He lost most of his life savings, his kids lost their inheritance. Legally nothing could be done. It devastated him and he died shortly afterwards.
I don’t think most people are lonely either and not to the extent that some elderly people can be. Going to bingo or whatever doesn’t replace a wife or husband.

Posted too soon. Meant to say maybe it is greedy but they don’t deserve the consequences.

LadybirdsAreNeverHappy · 27/09/2022 14:03

FrozenGhost · 27/09/2022 13:02

Even the romance scams I see as being greedy in a way. These people want to be in a relationship with a younger, very attractive person, with little to no effort on their part. Are they lonely? Yes, aren't we all. But if that was the main problem, they'd join a club and make friends with people the same age.

As I posted earlier, my grandad was badly ripped off by a much younger woman he was “engaged” to. He was bipolar (untreated) and in his mid 80s. His wife was a long time gone and his son had just died. I would imagine he was lonely and when he met this woman and she showed an interest in him he was probably flattered. I don’t know why it didn’t seem to occur to him why a young attractive woman wanted to be with an elderly man. He made a bad decision for selfish reasons but she targeted and manipulated him. He lost most of his life savings, his kids lost their inheritance. Legally nothing could be done. It devastated him and he died shortly afterwards.
I don’t think most people are lonely either and not to the extent that some elderly people can be. Going to bingo or whatever doesn’t replace a wife or husband.

LoveBluey · 27/09/2022 13:57

Even the ones that seem plausible are so frustrating. Along the lines of the Royal Mail click this link to pay a redelivery fee one. My MIL keeps falling for them despite us constantly explaining why you shouldn't click on links, provide passwords or make payments.
The latest one she fell for was the WhatsApp message saying hi mum I've lost my phone, on my friends number save this one etc. I asked why on earth her children who are both married and live within 5 minutes of her would send her messages from a friends phone rather than their spouse (whose numbers she knows) or just pop round and see her.
She just doesn't stop to think whether it's genuine or could be a scam.

Puzzledandpissedoff · 27/09/2022 13:44

I always assumed a lot of the bad decisions being made were by vulnerable people

So did I, but then I wised up and came to realise that many only develop a narrative of vulnerability after they've been caught out

It's not as if there's any lack of information about various scams, and even those still unsure can access advice, but countless stories confirm that even the direst warnings are roundly ignored because the target knows better

Certainly it's a shame, but there's only so much can be done to protect people against themselves and not everything can have a happy ending

kw1091 · 27/09/2022 13:44

“They took everything from me”
No they didn’t, you gave it to them.

stripeyzeb · 27/09/2022 13:32

I used to think the same until one day I nearly got sucked into a low level scam. I have a good education, work in a professional role and I figured I was wise to this stuff but I was amazed at how easily I was nearly taken in.

Basically, my Facebook account got hacked and Facebook wasn't responding to my messages so I put a message on Twitter and asked if anyone knew of another way to get the issue resolved. One of my Twitter followers (who I didn't know/never chatted with before) sent me a DM to say their friend works in this field and would definitely be able to help. They gave me an Instagram name so I messaged this 'friend'. 'The friend' replied straight away to say he could help, would need a screenshot of the Facebook name/account and his standard fee was £50.

I ended up chatting back and forth with him, fully believing he could help and it wasn't until he asked for the £50 to be sent via western Union, that I suddenly realised I was being scammed!

Thankfully I didn't give him any personal info (or money) and I immediately blocked him. He then used another account to message me to demand the £50 as he'd apparently already done the work. Not a chance mate!

But the point is, for 20 or so minutes, I fell for it and it was because I wanted a fix so badly, that I bypassed my own internal warning system.

To be honest, I don't understand how people can get to the point of giving tens of thousands of pounds away but I DO understand now that it's very easy to get sucked in. Given the right circumstances and 'story', I think most people could be tricked in some way.

By the way, later discovered that the Twitter follower who suggested their 'friend' was actually the same person I spoke to on Instagram. 😳

ChilliBandit · 27/09/2022 13:21

I had a very intelligent client get taken in for millions by a very elaborate targeted scam. I feel sorry for him, the scammers were incredibly sophisticated. I also have lots of sympathy for those less tech savvy and vulnerable taken in by text scams or pressure calls.

I have less sympathy for the romance scams especially those with children who give their savings to a romantic partner

dottypotter · 27/09/2022 13:14

Starfreeze · 27/09/2022 13:06

100per cent this!

This is a really horrible thread!

Exactly what a horrible post to start. What was the point? Ok so your superior OP you wont ever get scammed bully for you.

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 27/09/2022 13:06

I suppose there are a number of Venn diagrams that could be used to categorise all people, with various criteria:

very intelligent/averagely intelligent/low-intelligence/severe learning difficulties or suffering from dementia

scrupulously honest/decent enough/a bit shifty/thoroughly crooked

Anybody could fall into any one of the first and also any of the second, and the 'right' combination is what leads many people to be scammed.

Also, don't forget the added element of people who are so unintelligent that they don't know that they are very unintelligent - or realise that many other people are much smarter than they are.

Starfreeze · 27/09/2022 13:06

lannistunut · 27/09/2022 09:17

You're all heart, OP.

People can be naive, silly, easily led, foolish. It doesn't mean they are not deserving of sympathy when a fraudster takes advantage of them.

It isn't only clever people who deserve compassion. You're just unkind.

100per cent this!

This is a really horrible thread!

Theluggage15 · 27/09/2022 13:04

It’s not victim blaming at all. The majority aren’t victims they’re just greedy.They’re choosing to throw their money away so absolutely nothing like wearing a short skirt and being raped. How offensive.

FrozenGhost · 27/09/2022 13:02

Even the romance scams I see as being greedy in a way. These people want to be in a relationship with a younger, very attractive person, with little to no effort on their part. Are they lonely? Yes, aren't we all. But if that was the main problem, they'd join a club and make friends with people the same age.

CapMarvel · 27/09/2022 12:59

LongLivedQueen · 27/09/2022 12:57

You didn't read the OP, did you? Or any follow ups.

That is an offensive comparison and you should be ashamed of yourself

I did read it and no I'm not.

Loads of people in this thread are 100% victim blaming and it's a fucking shit thing to do.

FrozenGhost · 27/09/2022 12:58

Yay! Let's all sneer at victims with less awareness/ technical savvy than some people.

This is literally the equivalent of telling a victim of sexual assault that they asked for it by wearing a short skirt.

Its nothing like that though. People are caught up in these scams through pure greed. So it's more like someone robbing a house, then complaining that they got caught.

LongLivedQueen · 27/09/2022 12:57

CapMarvel · 27/09/2022 12:52

Yay! Let's all sneer at victims with less awareness/ technical savvy than some people.

This is literally the equivalent of telling a victim of sexual assault that they asked for it by wearing a short skirt.

You didn't read the OP, did you? Or any follow ups.

That is an offensive comparison and you should be ashamed of yourself

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 27/09/2022 12:56

tineye.com is another free reverse-image searcher.

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 27/09/2022 12:55

I always assumed a lot of the bad decisions being made were by vulnerable people. Those with addiction issues, those with low intellect or those in their twilight years who were troubled with the beginning of dementia. I will absolutely always feel sorry for those victims.

Yes, and the sickest thing is that these are the people the scammers are actively looking to exploit. Most of us, without those certain vulnerabilities, chuckle and shake our heads at pathetic scams pretending to be from the UN, but addressed to 'Hello Dear' and with appalling spelling and grammar mistakes, alongside laughably unrealistic scenarios; BUT this is all deliberate and very carefully thought-out.

Scammers don't want to waste their time with people who are initially curious but then quickly see through them; they want people who are gullible enough to be taken in by their absurd opening gambit and who will thus likely stick with them all the way until they've lost all their money.

Yes, there's also often an element of greed - but I wonder how many non-vulnerable people would be just as greedy if they thought it was actually true and/or they could get away with something. None of us seeing the Nigerian princes promising us $120 million decline to respond purely because we think we don't deserve that much money just for helping them!

CapMarvel · 27/09/2022 12:52

Yay! Let's all sneer at victims with less awareness/ technical savvy than some people.

This is literally the equivalent of telling a victim of sexual assault that they asked for it by wearing a short skirt.

LongLivedQueen · 27/09/2022 12:50

girlfriend44 · 27/09/2022 12:12

I wouldnt be too scathing about people who are scammed, it could happen to you. Nobody is immune you know. Hope you never have to eat your words.

Regarding ppl who give money away on line if you watched the programme in depth you will see they are lonely women. They are being paid attention to by men and it makes them feel wanted etc and they truly believe they are in a relationship.
One woman even had bought a wedding dress thinking she was going to get married. Even when her son intervened and told her what was going on she wouldnt listen.

IT couldn't though, that's the thing. I'm never going to send money to a Ghanain prince, or to a US army vet silver fox down on his luck. I'm not going to "invest" in crypto or marry an Algerian waiter. I'm not going to click on the link in the text supposedly from my bank and I'm not going to transfer the money to a new bank account gained from an email....

Lets not pretend we are all just as likely to get scammed. People need to take responsibility.

TigerRag · 27/09/2022 12:48

I thought I was being scammed a few weeks ago. Got an email on a Sunday from Royal Mail saying that my parcel would be delivered. Yes, I was expecting something but with them not working on a Sunday, thought it was a scam.

I did get my parcel on the Sunday.

Ariela · 27/09/2022 12:43

My friend's dad got scammed for about £6K. They'd cased the joint really well, and knew he worked at a university. They researched past students and picked a couple of names that had graduated in business management a good few years ago, but didn't appear on the role of alumni that had reached great heights, and were not on LinkedIn.

They sent an email along the lines of 'I don't suppose you remember me and Fred from (business management course and year)' , but we have left (merchant bank ) and started up our own investment company (name registered at Companies House, no trading information as new company, FCA registration 'applied for') and we are looking for investment in our portfolio. When at (merchant bank) we realised an average of (believable % margin) on our investments, and we have started (Company name) because we feel we can obtain a better return for our investors than can be obtained from (large merchant bank),. SO far our fund has grown considerably in just two months, see attached info (masses of printouts). If you'd like to invest, I've attached the form.
Followed by a couple of phone calls, so he invested £3k, and they sent monthly fake printouts for a few months showing good but believable growth, then phoned him again and asked if he'd like to invest in a new portfolio - so another £3k...however they rang again and he was unsure, so they got a bit insistent and at that point he thought it could be a scam, but up till then he was sure they were not.
It was of course a scam.... once he checked with FCA, which he should have done in the first place!

LuckyLil · 27/09/2022 12:41

More often than not unless they have some sort of mental health issues a lot of people who fall for the scams you mention are (I hate to say it) usually motivated by underlying greed because they think they've won lots of money. There are also people who are very lonely and suddenly have a stranger paying them constant attention trying to be their friend and gain their trust, and they believe this person is real and trustworthy. 419 isn't new but the scammers have to work a lot harder now to be convincing. It's hard to understand how anyone in their right mind could fall for it but some people are not in their right mind and vulnerable. They are so convinced by the scammer and so invested that even their loved ones can't get through to them it's a scam. The scammer will isolate them and tell them it's strictly confidential and they mustn't discuss it with their family. We had an elderly aunt who lost money to a scammer and measures were put in place that the bank had to contact her son if she turned up at branch wanting to withdraw money. A while later her son got a call from the bank while he was away working to tell him his mum was in the bank wanting to withdraw several thousand pounds but was very cagey about it and couldn't tell them what it was for because it's confidential. They asked him should we give her the money and he said no of course not! Don't let her withdraw it! The bank didn't give her the money but that's how they isolate the vulnerable to try and stop their family finding out what is going on.

thecatsthecats · 27/09/2022 12:39

In a similar vein, I am always curious about catfishing, because the relationships all seem to be very intense, but also really superficial.

You only EVER see messages saying "I love you", "I'm always there for you", "You're beautiful" etc.

Nothing with any sort of depth or substance. Just words that don't mean a lot without actions behind them.

I always wonder if they don't agree for the personal stuff to go on TV, but then I have friends IRL who get suckered in on a similar basis, without any sort of meaningful connection.

ItsaMetalBand · 27/09/2022 12:38

I worked with a woman who was scammed by her Turkish waiter fiancé. We had collected for her card and it was literally days before she was supposed to fly out to get married and he fucked off, with her entire savings.

Her maid of honour decided that in order to get over her heartbreak, they'd continue on holiday as planned. Where she met another Turkish waiter, and was engaged to him less than a month later and began sending him money and a phone and all that sort of stuff...

A waiter that dh got talking to when we were on holidays said that they all have several British girlfriends (and wives at home) and it's just a way of life for them - that they work 6 months of the year, no unemployment benefit so the cash they reap from their scamming sees them through the winter months. I think his view was that if they are stupid enough to believe the declarations of love mere days into meeting then they deserve all they get. I saw that the way I was treated respectfully because I was with DH compared to say, a group of girls on a holiday put me right off holidaying Turkey tbh.