Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think this is male fantasy about periods?

139 replies

OneOfThoseOldFashionedWomen · 26/09/2022 21:16

Trending there is a post about the reality of heavy periods, and yet every time I load MN there is faux advertising of women (of course thin and pretty and acceptably diverse) all hanging out in their pants by a window, looking back with a coy smile.

I'm sure there will be shouts of its advertising of course it needs to be aspirational/alluring etc, but this is MN, why can't the advertising be more honest?

OP posts:
C8H10N4O2 · 27/09/2022 08:08

Oh come on OP - surely when the cramps start the first thing you do is invite all your equally lovely model friends to dance around in your knickers by the bedroom window?

MrsLargeEmbodied · 27/09/2022 08:04

i think a recent advert i saw is changed, with red blood instead of blue, and women curled up on their beds

Paigeycakey · 27/09/2022 08:03

CakeMonster1 · 26/09/2022 21:56

I think period product advertising is just misleading anyway full stop (unless it's just me)

They show people diving off diving boards, doing yoga and swimming, sprinting, jumping in trampolines (ads for tampons)

Seriously? Please say I'm not the only one that suffers heavy bleeding and darent move when I'm on for fear of leaking, let alone diving board/swimming. Christ if I go in water (even the bath) when menstruating it looks like a re-enactment of jaws or some horror movie.

Maybe see your GP. Your period should not be continuously flowing whist in the bath. Even if im heavy my flow practically stops... I am get a couple of clots and slight excess but that's it.

georgarina · 27/09/2022 08:01

Noteverybodylives · 27/09/2022 06:04

YABU they’re hardly going to sell their period pants if you have women looking miserable and leaking period blood down their legs.

Of course it’s not representative of the majority of women but it’s like all adverts.
You won’t find anyone looking sad and they’ll all be very attractive as that’s what encourages the consumer to buy their products.

Agree with this. It's just advertising. Male hair loss products don't show miserable bald men either.

Redqueenheart · 27/09/2022 07:32

It is interesting, I had the same reaction when I saw this advert and it is bothering me to see it every time I come to this site.

CrystalCoco · 27/09/2022 07:26

Yeah it's not woke, it's not even diverse in the models they've chosen.

Not at any age have I hung around in my knickers with other girls/women and when I saw this advert I thought it especially ridiculous that one of the girls is in just her bra and knickers.

I don't think I'm particularly prudish or a fuddy duddy, I think this advert is just plain wrong.

Softplayhooray · 27/09/2022 07:04

1dontunderstand · 26/09/2022 21:18

Completely agree

Yeah completely agree and jeez Mumsnet having just seen that period pants advert the OP posted...what are you thinking?!

My eldest son learned about periods when I had a very unexpected heavy one with terrible cramps (stuck on a cross country train!!). It was distressing even for him! I explained what it was so he wouldn't worry and seeing it with his own eyes has literally made him ask if girls his age will go through this as he thinks it's awful. He is very sympathetic and will now be the boy who hands over his jumper not laughs if a female classmate gets caught out and needs to hide a leak. That's what we need, boys having this normalised from when they are young and being empathetic about it.

Tbh that Mumsnet ad looks like one of those male fantasy style things where women always just hang out giggling in their pants when they have sleepovers.

PotatoHammock · 27/09/2022 06:15

YANBU I read once that something like 70% of women think that their periods are heavier than average, presumably because of advertising like this (because that's not how averages work!)

But I would find some hideous, sycophantic "keeping it real" advert even more infuriating (especially if they based it on dainty, delicate chocolate cravings. I don't know why that particular cliche gets to me so much. I guess it reduces women down to such bland, two dimensional, simplistic creatures- give 'em a square of chocolate, that'll shut them up)

Noteverybodylives · 27/09/2022 06:04

YABU they’re hardly going to sell their period pants if you have women looking miserable and leaking period blood down their legs.

Of course it’s not representative of the majority of women but it’s like all adverts.
You won’t find anyone looking sad and they’ll all be very attractive as that’s what encourages the consumer to buy their products.

lljkk · 27/09/2022 05:48

is it really different from draping a luscious woman across a sports car, showing fancy cars driving on empty roads in beautiful places, showing the smiling lady clean up her disgusting child to flog washing powder, showing the grateful healthy cat eagerly eat the kibbles. All advertising is selling a fantasy.

Marmite17 · 27/09/2022 05:42

Rightsraptor · 27/09/2022 05:27

Who on earth stands by a window in their underwear like that?

I'm not far short of 70 now but I always pull the blind down in my bedroom until I'm properly dressed.

Also no need for period pants now but did wonder why my mum found ads funny. 🤔
Had little lesson on how to use suspender type thing with pad attached. At around age 9.
Fortunately stick on pads were a thing by 11.But didn't give me wings.
Lovely to think that my mum had the same sense of humour, all those years ago, that I and most other women have now.

Rightsraptor · 27/09/2022 05:27

Who on earth stands by a window in their underwear like that?

I'm not far short of 70 now but I always pull the blind down in my bedroom until I'm properly dressed.

Marmite17 · 27/09/2022 05:00

Funniest thread I've read in a while. Thank you all who posted!

NumberTheory · 27/09/2022 03:38

To me, it’s the ageism that I see in this, not sexualisation.

The issue with this advert on here is that it’s an image aimed at teens, not mothers 25 - 50 (which is my guess at who is on MN who might buy period pants). And that’s kind of insulting to put that on here. We know we aren’t “trendy” and don’t “matter” to companies who want to seem trendy. So if they aren’t prepared to acknowledge us in their advertising why the fuck are they trying to get us to give them our money? They can FOTTFSOFATFOSM

I don’t see this as a male fantasy at all. I don’t think most men want reminding that women are on their periods and don’t find period pants particularly attractive.

For the teen age group I think the image is somewhat aspirational and staged to try and show the various designs in decent light in a single photo. So not a real life depiction but not outrageously ridiculous as advertising goes.

But while it is definitely not something I would do now, as a teen I certainly had sleep overs where we were hanging out in our underwear while doing various other things - from getting ready to go out to getting ready to try out our femme fatale personas on the boys in the other room. And I would have done that while on my period too (though wearing a tampon and a teddy not huge knickers).

I really disagree with the posts suggesting it isn’t realistic because they don’t look miserable and curled up in pain. While lots of women do have significant issues with pain, bloating, flooding, etc. and almost all have some pain at some point, the vast majority of the time the vast majority of women don’t. It’s just as bad for women to tell people it’s all awful when it isn’t as to suggest it’s always fine when it isn’t.

PrimRoseHillfanny · 27/09/2022 03:30

The last thing men fantasies about are women's periods, even with fancy pants on.

PeloFondo · 27/09/2022 03:26

wackamole · 27/09/2022 02:51

We need something that acknowledges periods are different for every woman/girl but no matter how you’re feeling, these period pants will get you through, helping you feel as comfortable as possible while still looking great.

Agreed. Given that they're selling pants, it makes sense to show how the pants look on someone's body. But you'd think using multiple models grouped together (or, more realistically, a split panel showing each model separately) would give them a chance to showcase different body types, include thinner/fatter, younger/older, larger/smaller women wearing the pants. Perhaps one or more models with a visible disability. The pants apparently start at XS and go up to XXL, which is a UK size 20, but the models all have pretty much the same body type.

(OTOH, the point of an ad is to get talked about, so all attention is "good" PR.)

They definitely come up small. I wear a 16 bottom half and needed the largest size so I guess that's why the models are not larger

wackamole · 27/09/2022 02:51

We need something that acknowledges periods are different for every woman/girl but no matter how you’re feeling, these period pants will get you through, helping you feel as comfortable as possible while still looking great.

Agreed. Given that they're selling pants, it makes sense to show how the pants look on someone's body. But you'd think using multiple models grouped together (or, more realistically, a split panel showing each model separately) would give them a chance to showcase different body types, include thinner/fatter, younger/older, larger/smaller women wearing the pants. Perhaps one or more models with a visible disability. The pants apparently start at XS and go up to XXL, which is a UK size 20, but the models all have pretty much the same body type.

(OTOH, the point of an ad is to get talked about, so all attention is "good" PR.)

TheLassWiADelicateAir · 27/09/2022 02:51

KangarooKenny · 26/09/2022 21:50

At least they aren’t roller skating in white shorts !

This is worse. At least roller- skating, even in white shorts, is something some girls might do.

aloris · 27/09/2022 02:32

The Bodyform response to the spoof ad is hysterical.

CactusBlossom · 27/09/2022 02:28

Surely a more realistic ad would be a woman tucked up in bed with a hot water bottle and a bottle of gin?

aloris · 27/09/2022 02:28

It's very "male gaze." A group of thin, pretty young women all hanging around together laughing in their underwear. And, strangely, posed as if someone has walked in on them laughing together in their underwear, and they're all happy about it and cheerfully show the interloper their rear ends.

Extremely strange.

Fraaahnces · 27/09/2022 02:12

It’s up there with teenage girls having pillow fights in their negligees while having sleepovers. Meanwhile, the add underneath makes up for it for male stereotypes too. Equal opportunity stereotypes today Mumsnet.

To think this is male fantasy about periods?
Musti · 27/09/2022 02:06

ScottishLavender · 27/09/2022 01:54

Why? It's the correct word. Just because it seems that you've not heard of it, doesn't make it wrong. 🙄

The thing is you want things to be relatable in ads. This speaks to no one because no one hangs out in their knickers during their periods. Some are fine, some are in pain, some leak, some it means they haven’t conceived which for some is great news and for other bad news.

Periods aren’t something that brings people together for fun.

so the advertisers haven’t understood the brief and it is patronising for people on this site. They’re on this site because they want to speak to other humans going through the same stuff as them. Sort it out mumsnet

ThistleSifter · 27/09/2022 02:03

I thought the same thing earlier op.. it’s like some kind of unusual period party/sleepover situation; most odd

ScottishLavender · 27/09/2022 01:54

SausagePourHomme · 26/09/2022 22:14

sorry just reading the word menarche has made my fanny heal over.

Why? It's the correct word. Just because it seems that you've not heard of it, doesn't make it wrong. 🙄

Swipe left for the next trending thread