Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Understanding death

58 replies

Sparklybutold · 26/09/2022 20:21

Had a triggering conversation with a work colleague about death. She is a seventh day Adventist. She explained how her faith explains that people die because it's pre ordained owing to either punishment or because god decided it was better for them to ‘sleep’ because they couldn't handle something that they could have gone through later in life. This was her belief for why my mum had died at the age of 35 when I was 2.

OP posts:
Sparklybutold · 26/09/2022 23:19

There was more...

After hearing her views she gave me some reading material. She also offered it to my colleague who is a Muslim woman stating that there's been a dramatic increase in conversion from islam to Christianity. She ended by saying she had done her part in trying to spread the word.

OP posts:
Sparklybutold · 26/09/2022 23:16

@KangarooKenny

The phrase ‘honouring your mum’ really struck a card with me. Thank you so much 🌸

OP posts:
Mysticguru · 26/09/2022 22:31

If you sat ten people in a room from different backgrounds, culture, religions and nationalities you'd get ten different answers.

So, for example, I know that when the body ceases to exist there's a realisation that this life was just a dream.

mamabear715 · 26/09/2022 22:26

WTF??? I bet she's one of those who doesn't take the hint to shut the fuck up, too. I had a 'friend' like that, very similar. She's not a friend any more. Hugs, OP.

MessyBunPersonified · 26/09/2022 22:24

I'm so sorry op.

After my son died I was harassed by a bunch of religious extremists who told me he would be stuck in limbo forever and never move on anywhere as I decided to cremate him. I'm talking calls, letter, doorstep visits etc within a couple of days.

These people think they are better than us, but they are nasty, insensitive arseholes. Take no heed Flowers

LowbrowVictoriana · 26/09/2022 22:19

C1N1C · 26/09/2022 20:39

While I'm more of an agnostic, bordering on atheism, I love how the number of comments above are that they're an idiot.

We have ZERO proof of ANYTHING after death, so how about keeping open minds?

Whatever anyone believes (and firm belief is the opposite of open mindedness)
the idiocy of OPs colleague was in her crass insensitivity.

Ship · 26/09/2022 22:08

CarolShields · 26/09/2022 20:30

Gosh I’m sorry you had endure that OP. I’m also sorry about your mum.

There are a couple of people on YouTube (will look them up & link) who have had near death experiences & watching them gave me some comfort.

Also the dad of the girl who ate the sesame-laden sandwich from Pret and died in front of him is very interesting. (Why can’t I remember his name??) He had a religious experience whilst she was dying - on phone so will have to close this page for a sec whilst I look for them

I’m interested in the dad at prets experience- we’re you able to find it?

urbanbuddha · 26/09/2022 22:06

Death is the only certainty in life and it can come at any time.
I would be tempted to say something to your colleague like you're sorry her religion is so rigid that she's unable to feel empathy and that you hope she never has a similar experience. But it's probably better just to ignore.
I'm sorry you lost your Mum at such a young age.

StoneofDestiny · 26/09/2022 21:45

It's her belief but it doesn't mean it's true. Ignore.

KangarooKenny · 26/09/2022 21:31

I’m so sorry your DM died so young. Ignore what she believes, people find comfort in many different ways, but she’s entitled her beliefs.
I find comfort in maintaining my mum’s family grave, it’s all I can do for them. I hope you have your own way of honouring your mum.

Gettingbythanks · 26/09/2022 21:25

I’d have asked her if she’d ever seen someone she loved die. This is why I steer clear of religious types, I’m a bit pissed off on your behalf … losing your mum must’ve been brutal, I’m sorry.

Floralnomad · 26/09/2022 21:25

What a load of absolute tosh , sorry for your loss @Sparklybutold .

Flaunch · 26/09/2022 21:20

Such a lot of religious belief are utter nonsense but this really does take the biscuit. What fucking ugly thoughts to choose to believe in.

I’m sorry you lost your Mum :(

Winnietheshite · 26/09/2022 21:20

Fuck that shit. I'm guessing she didn't lose anyone she cared about yet?

I used to believe in something. But then I lost two people in 12 months to cancer. Who were my age (40s). Sitting in their funerals, listening to God's plan just made me fucking angry.

RoseslnTheHospital · 26/09/2022 21:17

C1N1C · 26/09/2022 20:39

While I'm more of an agnostic, bordering on atheism, I love how the number of comments above are that they're an idiot.

We have ZERO proof of ANYTHING after death, so how about keeping open minds?

An open mind doesn't mean inventing stories about punishment or other justifications based on no evidence at all.

PinkBuffalo · 26/09/2022 21:16

Sorry you have had to deal with that op
As someone who lost my family all incredibly young as well and lived tough life I would find that actually offensive
Sending you a hug xx

FetlocksBlowingInTheWind · 26/09/2022 20:47

Hmm that was pretty insensitive of her. Try and just let it go out of your head.

Reminds me of after my dad died (I was 15) and the priest came round to talk to my mum, I was there too. I think he meant to be comforting but he said that my my dad was always going to die of cancer at 51, it was God's role for him and preordained (not those exact words). I thought that was a load of bollocks then and I still do.

smooththecat · 26/09/2022 20:42

Well, everything alive dies. It’s kind of part of it… Sorry about your mum, she didn’t do anything wrong, and neither did you.

Moonmelodies · 26/09/2022 20:39

Did they have any evidence for this belief?

C1N1C · 26/09/2022 20:39

While I'm more of an agnostic, bordering on atheism, I love how the number of comments above are that they're an idiot.

We have ZERO proof of ANYTHING after death, so how about keeping open minds?

JaneorEleven · 26/09/2022 20:38

im sorry for the loss of your Mum. Life is horribly unfair. Your work colleague is lacking in empathy and needs to keep her beliefs to herself. Please take very good care of yourself.

RoseslnTheHospital · 26/09/2022 20:35

What an incredibly insensitive thing to say, and holding unusual beliefs is no excuse. I hope you're able to brush it off and put it down to your colleague's unusual thinking.

Humans are terrible at understanding that things just happen, for no reason, just circumstances beyond anyone's control. It's not a judgement on anyone, or a punishment or some pre ordained odd coping mechanism or any other complex explanation.

FindingMeno · 26/09/2022 20:34

If you didn't ask for her opinion, and she knew of your loss, she really was being very insensitive.
If it was a general conversation we need to sift through and respect others belief systems - with the proviso that it's not personalised to a person who doesn't hold their beliefs.
I'm sorry this was upsetting.

PauliesWalnuts · 26/09/2022 20:32

That’s made me so cross. Our family GP told me the same when my mum died when I was 23. I still believe in God (I’m a really rubbish catholic) and I know I’ll see her again. But I’m under no illusion that as far as I’m concerned, we’ve just got shitty genes and she got cancer and the doctors couldn’t save her. If someone dies before their time, it’s due to bad genes, bad lifestyle (including my dad with industrial illness and leukaemia) or just horrible horrible bad luck.

You must really have missed not having her when you grew up, I’m so sorry.

TastesLikeFlavourlessFizz · 26/09/2022 20:30

Please try not to let this upset you.

Even if there was any merit in what she said, we can safely put your mum in the non-punishment, ‘sleep’ category. But there is no merit in it anyway. So we’ll just call this lady an insensitive twat and move on.

Sorry about your mum. Flowers

Swipe left for the next trending thread