Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

At work, I'm mute unless spoken to

64 replies

mutemute · 26/09/2022 19:43

I've always been really shy, but it's almost like I'm mute until I have permission to speak, and then I can be quite chatty and really enjoy talking to others. For example, in a meeting I can never just pipe up and say something, I'll sit there in silence with a smile even when there's something I want, or even need, to say.

As soon as someone directly addresses me, the wall comes down and I can happily chat away. It's so bizarre, I can't explain it or seem to do anything in the moment to help myself find my voice.

It's similar with things like going for lunch with colleagues. The whole team (around 5-10 of us) tend to go for lunch together when we're in the office. It's pretty much presumed everyone will go to lunch together (i.e. there's no - 'do you want to join us for lunch?' but it's more 'c'mon let's go to lunch'). If nobody directly asks me to join I won't, I'll stay sitting in the office and then once they've all gone I'll go off on my own and have lunch somewhere else by myself.

It's making me quite tearful to write this as it sounds so sad, but also kind of pathetic and helpless. I don't know why I'm like this :(

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
postxmasblues · 22/01/2023 13:02

Interesting. I am like this. I used to be a tv reporter before kids so I can definitely talk, but I can't do talks/teaching in front of other people or find it awkward to join in chats with other mums at school pick-up.

I just don't know what to say and I guess I have a fear of saying the wrong things. I hate having lunch with colleagues or going into a meeting, or going to parties I just get very nervous. Once I'm there I'm pretty ok but guess I have social anxiety.

SlipperyLizard · 22/01/2023 12:57

I’m exactly like this in meetings, despite being in my mid 40s and pretty senior. The longer I don’t say anything, the harder it is to start.

My “solution” is to make sure I say something early on to break whatever it is my brain is doing to me. Even something small, or at the same time as others (eg to join in agreement). It doesn’t always happen early on, of course, which case I’m a bit on edge waiting for my moment.

The more you practice, OP, the easier it gets. I’m still not someone who will ever dominate a meeting, but I don’t think people notice.

However, I could never join a book group or anything like that as I wouldn’t enjoy it & people wouldn’t see the “best” me. I’d never feel at ease.

MovieQueen12 · 22/01/2023 12:50

Asking people how they are and asking questions is also a good tip

WigglyGlowWorm · 22/01/2023 11:39

Yup, i’m the same. I find the ‘raising hand’ function in Teams can be quite useful though. It stops that awkward moment when two people try to talk at the same time and then there’s a pause before it inevitably happens again. Hate that.

Teriyakieverything · 22/01/2023 11:37

I agree that some of the onus has to be on the OP to do or say something to meet her colleagues half way.

Divebar2021 · 22/01/2023 11:26

I’m not saying that no or maybe I am I don’t know it’s tricky to explain. Whatever is driving her behaviour is very inward looking. It’s not that she doesn’t speak but she only speaks if spoken to, she sits separately and waits for someone to say “come and sit over here”. She will go to lunch with the group but only if they ask her to. She is placing the responsibility for her involvement on other people and the assumption is that other people are ok to do that. Perhaps other people are going through their own shit.
I didn’t want it to come off as snippy and I know if you say it a certain way in your head it could be read like that but that was honestly my view.

lljkk · 22/01/2023 11:16

They think you are comfortable in your own skin. They don't know that you're cripplingly shy. Could you approach one or 2 of the nicer people and be honest with them, you didn't mean to be aloof, you do like company of others, you'd like to come along at lunch, please could they invite you ?

ime, they will fall over selves trying to give you opportunities to be included

My office is too flipping social, ok, just chatty. Always complaints about same things. Tedious.

Teriyakieverything · 22/01/2023 11:02

So OP is trying to ask for advise for her particular issue, you are basically saying ‘don’t so selfish’ other people might have their problems to overcome too.

Divebar2021 · 19/01/2023 19:52

This is going to sound very unkind but I don’t intend it to be. It sounds very self absorbed. Nobody else gets to be shy around you because you’ve claimed it - the assumption is that everyone is fine to do the heavy lifting. Have you ever considered that other people may be feeling awkward or out of place or do you just assume everyone else is ok. You want to be invited to the party but you don’t want the responsibility of throwing the party yourself. If you are happy in your own company and don’t want to be included in group invitations then all well and good. If you actually want to be part of the group then start off by booking your seat with them. Nothing says leave me alone than deliberately parking yourself away from people who have been friendly to you.

MovieQueen12 · 19/01/2023 18:28

I am like this. I am very shy and self conscious which is why. Makes me sad too.

Parrotid · 19/01/2023 18:27

Firstworldprobs · 26/09/2022 20:43

“…It’s been great talking to you, thanks so much for your time! See you soon!”

”…Well, I am now going to go and get on with this to do list! See you soon!”

”…right, best get on - good to see you! Take care!”

”…Oof is it 10am already… I need to get going but thanks for your time! Bye!”

All of the above elicit breezy, natural ends.

Hope this helps

At work, I'm mute unless spoken to
SeasonalFeasts · 27/09/2022 01:41

I think it could be selective mutism. As I understand it, exposure therapy is the best thing to help with this, as it is an anxiety disorder.

I would suggest looking up selective mutism and having a read.

Marvellousmadness · 27/09/2022 01:30

You are aware of your issues
That's step one

So if you wanna change: change

Small steps. Every day.

Gagaandgag · 27/09/2022 01:08

You have literally described what I was like
at work too with colleagues. Self esteem is a large part and worrying what others think of you too. Have you ever considered you could be neurodivergent. Now I am older and am
no longer in these work situations I can reflect on them and other situations and believe I am probably autistic.

SpangledShambles · 27/09/2022 00:50

lannistunut · 26/09/2022 20:07

This is just cruel. No one, no one, deserves this punishment.

Haha my thoughts entirely. Why do management do this? Are there actually any measured benefits? Have any of the organisers if these hell days dared to do an anonymous survey about what ppl think about it? The results would be hilarious I’m sure.

BadNomad · 27/09/2022 00:45

It felt odd saying "who's coming for lunch" getting comments of yes/no/I'm off to the post office etc from the other three or four and nothing from her unless you specifically said "Jane, what about you?"
Now I don't know what's going on!

I agree. Keep inviting her. If she didn't want to join you, she would make an excuse not to. I think she does want to go, but just doesn't want to presume she is invited.

I have this too, I'm guessing as part of my ASD. Wanting to be part of the group, but not knowing how to be part of the group, and not knowing if people would rather I wasn't there because I'm sure they think I'm weird and unsociable. I just can't tell. It's a group/open invite thing. Like work Christmas dinners or birthday nights out. "Everyone is welcome" Are they though? Or does that actually mean just the people who are friends should go? I don't know if I'm counted as a friend. Probably not. It would be weird if I went then wouldn't it. I'll only end up standing in the corner on my own like a weirdo with everyone wondering why I'm there and probably thinking I lack awareness. Because I do.

People just seem to know how to do this stuff. Me, I'm just there. On the outside. Waiting to see if anyone talks to me. Not knowing when to talk, not knowing when to shut up, not able to tell if I'm annoying people, or if they're humouring me, or pitying me, or want me to go away.

Stopdropnroll · 27/09/2022 00:12

spiderontheceiling · 26/09/2022 23:25

I've found this really interesting as I think there's someone in our office whose like this.
I never know what to do. If a group of us are doing something and I ask her to join us, she'll smile and come along and sit with us but not say anything unless I or one other person ask her a direct question (none of the others seem to actively engage with her) & then she'll answer the question and maybe make another comment but not do anything to move the question forward.
Since becoming more aware about anxiety, ND and things, I've reduced how often I ask her to join us as I'm more senior than her (although not her manager) and was worried she was only coming/answering questions because she felt pressured to do so. After all, she never instigated anything or reciprocated and nor did she ever even stand up or make any other gesture to join us when a group of us were clearly off to do something or when I'd issued a general invitation. It felt odd saying "who's coming for lunch" getting comments of yes/no/I'm off to the post office etc from the other three or four and nothing from her unless you specifically said "Jane, what about you?"
Now I don't know what's going on!

Keep inviting her and then just let her join in as much as she wants to

spiderontheceiling · 26/09/2022 23:25

I've found this really interesting as I think there's someone in our office whose like this.
I never know what to do. If a group of us are doing something and I ask her to join us, she'll smile and come along and sit with us but not say anything unless I or one other person ask her a direct question (none of the others seem to actively engage with her) & then she'll answer the question and maybe make another comment but not do anything to move the question forward.
Since becoming more aware about anxiety, ND and things, I've reduced how often I ask her to join us as I'm more senior than her (although not her manager) and was worried she was only coming/answering questions because she felt pressured to do so. After all, she never instigated anything or reciprocated and nor did she ever even stand up or make any other gesture to join us when a group of us were clearly off to do something or when I'd issued a general invitation. It felt odd saying "who's coming for lunch" getting comments of yes/no/I'm off to the post office etc from the other three or four and nothing from her unless you specifically said "Jane, what about you?"
Now I don't know what's going on!

Glitterbomber · 26/09/2022 23:10

I’m exactly the same in meetings and don’t ask me how but I’ve managed to progress up the ladder to be a senior manager.

for me I think it’s a combination of low self esteem, imposter syndrome and also perhaps a contributing factor from childhood - I was constantly told that ‘children should be seen not heard’ and I remember excitedly trying to tell my parents things but getting told to ‘be quiet and go away’

Coybubbles · 26/09/2022 23:01

Well I find that food and drink is a good ice breaker….so if you’re going to get a coffee ask your colleague if they’d like you to get them one, or maybe bring some biscuits or cakes in one day and offer them. Everyone likes food.

Blackmetalmama · 26/09/2022 22:54

Chipsriceandgravy · 26/09/2022 20:21

Does anyone else like this struggle with ending conversations?

Even when I am chatting to a colleague whether in person or via Teams I am thinking how do I end this?! Not because I want to but because I don’t know how so I’m worried I miss a cue. I spend the whole conversation trying to think how to stop it so probably shut down conversations too early! My colleagues have a real treat on their hands with me!

Oh my goodness, this is me! As soon as the conversation begins I am thinking of how to end it. And I have probably prematurely ended many conversations because of this. As you say, it's not because I necessarily want it to end, I just don't want to miss that cue.

It's the same with messages, like whatsapp. If somebody messages me, before I reply I will already be thinking of how it'll end. I don't want it to be an abrupt end to the conversation, but I also don't want to carry it on when the other person wants to end it. So I end up being so awkward about it and it makes me avoid conversations.

BrokenCopper · 26/09/2022 21:43

I have selective mutism, but I think we behave slightly differently?

I was completed muted in secondary school when I came to this country. I didn't understand why I could not speak to anyone in school.

I tried so so hard over the years, I am 47 now and still affected by this. I have learned some techniques that helps, like asking questions, try to join in some conversations when my colleagues talking to another (very very hard). I can force myself to talk to others who I don't know well but I am muted again when I am in a group, question in my head can never come out. If I have to speak in a group, I can't speak correct sentences or making any sense. I avoid these situations whenever possible, I don't go to work social events, I don't go or eat lunch with anyone (mainly I need break on my own if I am in the office), I say none or minimal in our teams meetings and yes it has greatly impacted my career...

I can feel your frustration, I feel the pain most days and it's very draining working in an office.

I have not met anyone who behave the way I am and I hate it.

Sorry my post probably not helpful, just thought I let you know you are not alone.

KatRee · 26/09/2022 21:43

I'm another one who used to be like this. I'm a decade older than you and it's only really the last 5 -10 years that I've overcome it. I'm never going to be an extrovert, but I can speak up when I need to and I'm not bothered by my own behaviour in the way I used to be

What was the root cause of the issue for me was fear of rejection- so with the lunch thing I'd be thinking that if no one asks me directly, they don't want me with them and if I go without being asked I'm going to see the look on their faces ' oh shit we don't want you here!' Even if no one says it out load

What helped was CBT - I'd recommend seeing if you can get this - I've done a group CBT course via the NHS in the past. I also found the books 'overcoming low self-esteem' and 'overcoming social anxiety' very helpful

One of the most common CBT exercises is to set yourself goals in order of difficulty and build up to them. As you mention a kind of mutism where sometimes you feel you physically can't speak, maybe the lunch thing would be one to start with? You don't have to speak, you get up and go when the others do.

It's not an easy thing to overcome, it takes a lot of work, but I definitely recommend giving CBT a go

SnoopyNoseTits · 26/09/2022 21:37

Do you have any meetings over teams? Could you use the chat box to put your question?

also, why are you booking a seat away from your team?

Stopdropnroll · 26/09/2022 21:34

mutemute · 26/09/2022 20:44

@Stopdropnroll @APJ1 I do genuinely think I could have selective mutism, I can't explain it but it's like I physically cannot talk when I'm in certain situations. All I needed to ask in today's meeting was to ask a colleague 'Have you reviewed X yet?' and I couldn't do it. Then the next item on the agenda, someone directly asked me a question and I could answer it easily.

This is exactly what I would be like, I'd be saying the question over and over in my head but not actually able to speak. It only happens in some situations for me so if you met me you'd think I was a chatter box and not understand that I freeze in certain situations. I'm glad I've worked out what is going on with DD now so I can try and get her some help. There's some good SM pages on fb they might be a good place to ask for support ideas, it's very different to shyness and so not just a case of building yourself up to speak.

Sorry I can't be more helpful but I'm new to this journey as well, I've been more focused on helping DD with hers but with her if she has naturally spoken to someone freely then they become a safe person to speak to and she will always talk to them freely but if someone takes her by surprise and puts her on the spot over something she will reply but then not speak to them freely. It's a really tricky one as I basically have to tell people to ignore her and wait for her to come to them and speak and then she'll natter away to them!