Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think if you are a family of 4 and struggling on £100k…

429 replies

LetMeSpeak · 26/09/2022 17:08

That it is purely down to mismanagement.

I saw a debate on social media and I also know a few people on 6 figure salaries, have extremely nice houses and cars. Yet complain that they are stuggling the same way others with less money. Aibu to think if you are really struggling even in this economy, a lot of it is due to mismanagement with your money?

OP posts:
EllietheElephanti · 26/09/2022 18:49

I think the point is OP that someone with a family income of £100k is likely to have greater outgoings than a family on a lower joint income not because they are mos managing their money but because they may have a larger mortgage, more expensive holidays, schools fees etc.

Gyromitra · 26/09/2022 18:49

Coucous · 26/09/2022 18:44

A smaller house or less expensive house where? Houses in my area are 1.2 mil for a small house. That's not even affordable for most people. Rent is about 4K+ for a family of 4. Some people have no family around so rely on childcare. We need to get to work and school run easily - not everyone has to live like you.

You live in an area where a small house costs over a million pounds and are trying to persuade us you have no choice. You sound completely ridiculous.

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 26/09/2022 18:49

Well you’re maybe not struggling in the same sense that people who really can’t afford to heat or eat are.

But you are still entitled to complain about the government asset stripping the nation, doing nothing concrete about the cost of living crisis, in particular energy prices which it could help with a lot, and giving tax cuts to the very wealthy. Plus fucking the environment and insider dealing with their mates.

So no, you’re clearly not poor if your household earns that but you are entitled to complain about the government’s financial mismanagement and expect better from our so called leaders.

Nidan2Sandan · 26/09/2022 18:48

Ours is just shy of £100k, but DH has a work pension which takes a bloody great whack of his money, plus the tax man gets his big chunk.

Between us, money in our hand is more akin to a £50k income. We're in the london commuter belt so he can work in london so mortgage is £££. We don't have a massive house, no spare bedrooms..we could downsize and make the 3 kids share a room, but due to price increases it would cost us the same as we bought this house for so absolutely no point.

Our cars are older, the family car is almost 5 years old and DHs car (which he needs as he works shifts in emergency services and we have to drive to kids schools) is almost 13 years old.

We cant afford to go out, we dont spend on clothes and havent had a holiday since 2007. We so have areas we can tighten our cloth, tv subscriptions for example. But already shop is Aldi and watch money like a hawk.

Life is getting expensive for everyone, clearly it's a sliding scale but those who lived to their £100l salary cant just suddenly spend less. Selling a house and buying a new one for example costs thousands! Cars on HP cant be sold and giving the car back might not be an option as they might need that car. Not many bus services run at 4am when DH has to leave for work for example.

When we were on a £25k income we thought people on £100k would be off to Aruba every weekend and living on smoked salmon and caviar. Now we know that isnt the case.

I do know we are lucky with DHs pension, but fuck me not paying so much out each month would be nice.

WalkingThroughTreacle · 26/09/2022 18:48

Purely down to mismanagement?

No, I wouldn't say so. We have had a series of largely unforeseeable high consequence events (global pandemic, war in Ukraine etc) in a short space of time that have seen costs spiralling in a manner that simply wasn't anticipated. How do you propose families plan for every unimaginable or extremely unlikely economic eventuality?

Don't get me wrong, my concerns are very much for those at the bottom of the ladder but I don't think there's any fair reason to sneer at the better off who are feeling the squeeze. Sympathy and compassion are not finite resources.

Glowinglights · 26/09/2022 18:47

Ive voted YANBU but we are definitely feeling more stretched on this income as a family with 2 dcs.

I don’t feel we’re struggling as we have more options, cc available with loads of credit (now not used) so there is no fear involved, which makes all the difference imo.

But, yes, family income gets spend on all sorts and we are cutting back on expenditure since a few months. But there is no way we can compare with low income families as we’re not afraid - and that’s the key in this.

Samanabanana · 26/09/2022 18:46

That's our joint household income. We're not struggling but we're not rolling in it either. We don't own a giant house or have a ridiculous mortgage, we drive a ten year old Skoda. We don't spend crazy amounts of money on several foreign holidays a year, we don't have buckets of savings and the last week before pay day is always a bit tight. We have huge childcare bills which probably accounts for most of our disposable income. Obviously we're very privileged to have the money coming in but it all goes out again very quickly on not very exciting things!

SleeplessInEngland · 26/09/2022 18:46

Coucous · 26/09/2022 18:44

A smaller house or less expensive house where? Houses in my area are 1.2 mil for a small house. That's not even affordable for most people. Rent is about 4K+ for a family of 4. Some people have no family around so rely on childcare. We need to get to work and school run easily - not everyone has to live like you.

You could move to another area.

I’m not saying you should or that it wouldn’t be shit, but I think there’re wildly varying interpretations of ‘options’ on this thread.

Echobelly · 26/09/2022 18:46

I think a family of 4 in London with a large mortgage and the at least one child in FT childcare could actually be struggling a bit - certainly losing all their discretionary spending money when energy bills are factored in.

And it is a genuine economic issue that the government has not considered this - even if those households are just losing their discretionary spend and not enduring hardship beyond that, that's a lot of households not spending money on eating out, theatre, house decoration, building work, with the resulting impact on 1000s of small business, arts and culture.

monotonousmum · 26/09/2022 18:44

Around £90k joint income here. Around £80k until a couple of months ago, and very grateful for the increase.

One of us with student loan repayments (around £200/month). Mortgage isn't extravagant and luckily locked into a good interest rate for another three years. Massive gas/elec bill (I think we're over paying, but that just means I can afford to refuse the next DD increase). Nursery and after school coats. Travel into London over £500/month for one person, about half that for the other (thankful for hybrid working).

I know we're in a very fortunate position. We can still currently afford to save each month, and if bills more go up we can cut the savings and still pay the bills.

But I'm not going to pretend I'm finding it easy, because I'm not. This kind of money seemed like something of dreams a few years ago. But we don't have fancy holidays. Car is functional, not flash. And that's one car, not two. I shop second hand wherever possible.

I'm not starving, but it's a change in lifestyle that I don't like!

Dente · 26/09/2022 18:44

I see a lot of “ they could downgrade their lifestyles”.

Those on a low income trajectory could also choose to have less children?

why is the latter acceptable, but the former not ?

Coucous · 26/09/2022 18:44

Tanyaaah · 26/09/2022 17:25

Er, no they could not be in "just as much trouble" ffs. They have the option of moving to a cheaper house, selling a car, not going skiing. Those at the bottom do not.

A smaller house or less expensive house where? Houses in my area are 1.2 mil for a small house. That's not even affordable for most people. Rent is about 4K+ for a family of 4. Some people have no family around so rely on childcare. We need to get to work and school run easily - not everyone has to live like you.

Whatafeckinpalaver · 26/09/2022 18:43

FrownedUpon · 26/09/2022 17:18

People on six figure salaries with massive mortgages could be in just as much trouble as those on low salaries. It all depends on your outgoings and how much spare money there is to cover rising bills/mortgage.

Er no, they are not. People with 6 figure salaries might have to downsize and put their kids in state schools. They’re not going to have to live in and b&b and use a food bank.

Knickerthief1 · 26/09/2022 18:43

We have a very good household income - around £150k a year, and we are always overspent. I can confirm that I am absolutely terrible at money management. I have made some good decisions - kept our mortgage low and didn't move when we could afford it. Instead I've spent more money on holidays and caravans and meals out and a hot tub and haven't saved anything. It's total mismanagement and I need to be better. I absolutely agree that it's ridiculous to be on our income and to be in this position, and I would never compare us to someone on an average income who is struggling. So yes I'm worried now and its my own fault and I'm trying to improve my money management. We do have choices that will improve things but then I struggle with the idea of doing a job I absolutely hate and not having the niceties that make it seem worthwhile. I'll no doubt get slated for this - and so I should. It's a bloody stupid position to be in.

Bundlebungle · 26/09/2022 18:42

Yanbu. There is a lot of surface wealth, where people have all the trappings but with no actual savings to fall back on. It is important to build up enough savings to fund the bad times, before spending so much on the rest. All fur coat and no knickers, as my mum would say 😀.

lannistunut · 26/09/2022 18:41

Pengwinn · 26/09/2022 18:26

Shall we rip down half the housing stock in this country then so everyone can buy a small house? Or is it more reasonable to realise that people cut their cloth accordingly and when things change drastically it's not as easy as everyone tumbling down to the cheaper end.

If mortgage rates go up to 6% as currently forecast, prices will presumably start to drop anyway, so we won't need to downsize just down value.

Thanks very much Liz Truss and Kwasi Kwarteng!

emmathedilemma · 26/09/2022 18:38

what sort of houses are people buying?
well a 3bed semi detached bungalow in need of serious modernisation is in the region of £500k+ where I live so work out the mortgage on that and factor in childcare costs etc if you’re a young couple with kids!
oh, and I’m nowhere near London.

Dente · 26/09/2022 18:38

The issue is Those on £100k live within their means, and then the goal posts change; energy bills go up 100% etc. Now they are taking about increasing interest rates ; someone may have a mortgage of 900£ then their term ends and they are now paying £1300, so actually they might be struggling to pay fuel bills and do food shopping.
Its not as simple as “just downsizing” moving house is expensive! Estate agents and stamp duty etc.
Renters can at least downsize without losing too much.

Magn · 26/09/2022 18:37

Let's do a basic comparison of 2 parent 2 pre school child households.

Lower income from 2 earners part time - can mean housing association house, subsidised or free childcare, 1 car as can offset hours, child benefit.

Higher income household from 2 earners full time on £40k and £60k - full mortgage and house maintenance (probably astronomical for the same value house) +1.5k, full price childcare to enable them to work full time +2k, probably also need 2 cars and petrol and insurance to both get to work +.4k, might not get child benefit -.2k, likely student loans +.6k.

Conservative estimate for my local area gives an extra cost for the second household of around £4k a month post tax. At 40% rates you have to earn 5.6k per month to make up that difference which is around £67k a year. Extra. To get the same standard of living. This is even London or SE prices.

So assume they spend the same on food, holidays, birthdays, Christmas, one family could be on £30k and one on £100k and, for that period of time they would be in the same financial situation. That's ignoring the extra costs of free time - needing to pay extra for convenience, extra on DIY, not being able to shop around - or the extra NI, or any extra family help.

Obviously these are fairly extreme examples and I appreciate plenty of people on lower wages don't have those advantages. Equally the higher wage pays off in the long run. But if you'd accept the first family on £30k are struggling why wouldn't you accept the second family on £100k are without knowing the full picture?

pinok · 26/09/2022 18:37

I saw this on Twitter and thought it really summed up so many of the threads you see on MN where families on 6 figure salaries claim they struggle-

‘people who suggest that my £580k salary makes me a wealthy man simply aren't taking into account the costs associated with sending my four sons to Eton, maintaining a fleet of luxury SUVs and living in a flying castle’

😂

ChilliBandit · 26/09/2022 18:35

toomychtiss · 26/09/2022 18:31

@jumblemumblet so you get 23k a yr & rent is just under 10k a yr?

Council tax, energy, broadband must be another £300 a month at least.

Badhairday101 · 26/09/2022 18:35

I’m a single parent with an income of around 60k. When I was younger I thought I’d be loaded on that amount but in reality I don’t feel any better off than I did when I was on 18k. My expenses have gone up massively, people tend to live to whatever their income is.

toomychtiss · 26/09/2022 18:33

@Mycatsgoldtooth the ones I know who have the holidays, cars have lots of family help eg got on the ladder in their 20s, cash to do up house, move up ladder et.

ChilliBandit · 26/09/2022 18:32

Without childcare costs and student loan payments which total £1,500 a month I’d be laughing. As it turns out I’m working out how to keep a 2 yr old warm this winter. We do not mismanage money. One of us is an accountant 🙄 we are still going to struggle.

toomychtiss · 26/09/2022 18:31

@jumblemumblet so you get 23k a yr & rent is just under 10k a yr?