Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think if you are a family of 4 and struggling on £100k…

429 replies

LetMeSpeak · 26/09/2022 17:08

That it is purely down to mismanagement.

I saw a debate on social media and I also know a few people on 6 figure salaries, have extremely nice houses and cars. Yet complain that they are stuggling the same way others with less money. Aibu to think if you are really struggling even in this economy, a lot of it is due to mismanagement with your money?

OP posts:
toomychtiss · 26/09/2022 19:05

We earn a bit over 100k, do have a high mortgage but luckily not much childcare as dc in school. Do have some equity in property & decent savings but I would say that's because of when we got on the ladder as opposed to people younger than me on similar mismanaging.

mam0918 · 26/09/2022 19:05

orbitalcrisis · 26/09/2022 18:59

The problem is credit. The more you earn, the more credit you are offered and at the best rates, but buying things on credit is just as irresponsible when you're wealthy as when you are poor. I think other than a house, you should never buy something you do not have the money for. I'm poor and I paid cash for my car.

Are you me?

This is exactly my view of it... I have never used credit and never had a pennies debt in my life, if I cant afford to pay in cash I simply cant afford it and dont have it.

Poor on paper but never in debt (actually have savings).

HairyToity · 26/09/2022 19:05

I know a family with two children and I assume six digit income, they have committed to private school fees, expensive mortgage, and nice cars on lease. They are struggling at the moment. It is due to the fact they've always spent every penny, much on the drip, and keep running out if money before payday.

We're a decent income, notnsix digit, and always lived within our means. Been saving for a new bathroom for ages now, and making very little progress.

Cannotmakeadecison · 26/09/2022 19:05

I think 100k take home monthly pay is 5 and half grand so I can see how people who survive on a fraction of this would find it difficult to comprehend or sympathise with people who say they are struggling on such a high salary. However, as PP’s have been saying, it’s all relative. Large house, large mortgage, cars on finance, childcare costs all add up and any increase will affect their overall disposable income.

Having said that, I doubt many people would feel much sympathy for millionaires who complain about their financial struggles (and I’m sure they do have them!) so I suppose it’s all about your audience really. If you earn £100k and are struggling maybe only complain to your 100k earner friends and not your 30k earner friends would be my best advice.

Tomorrowisalatterday · 26/09/2022 19:04

We have a household income of £150k and a £1k/month childcare bill (used to be higher), a £2.5k monthly mortgage payment, we are fine for now but only because we make some unusual choices - no car, just bikes with child seats, no pets. If we ran a car and had a puppy as virtually everyone else does around here, we could still cover the basics but wouldn't have much discretionary spend

MzHz · 26/09/2022 19:04

Oh ffs! Stop looking at others and judging them because they don’t walk in your shoes! If all this bitter energy went into thinking how to help those even less fortunate than you instead of taking cheap pot shots at those with a bit more just imagine how it would feel!

The ruination of our country is complete. Divided over brexit, further divided over covid, now emascerated over energy/cost of living.

just fucking stop bitching and look at what you can do to help those who need it. If we all did a bit, it would help everyone. This is a war we’re all in, some houses sustain more damage, but it’s shit for everyone to varying degrees

takemetomybeach · 26/09/2022 19:03

So we are on £85k joint, pay £500 pcm childcare, £1500 mortgage (350k house, before you all get excited - that's how much mortgages are these days with a 10% deposit!!) and can afford one (out of school hols!!) holiday a year. There are 3 of us. And I work p/t (4 hours away from f/t) to bring down childcare costs.

What mismanagement are we doing? We share a car, I get no beauty treatments at all, we shop at Morrisons / Tesco / Lidl, I sit in 2 pairs of socks and 2 jumpers to WFH in the winter, we buy all clothes except shoes and underwear second hand. That's before all bills and food.

We save £200 per month - £300 if we're being super frugal.

It all adds up and things are fucking expensive. I just bought ham, cheese, bread, washing up liquid, yoghurt, snack bars and veg to chop up for my kids packed lunch - one weeks worth - that was £20.

How lower income / single parent families do it, I'll never know. If we had another kid we would seriously struggle.

£100k for a household income is not a huge amount, OP. Especially with 2 kids. It's all relative and all it takes is illness / a break up / the boiler to break for that £100k household to be in serious financial trouble.

If my boiler broke tomorrow we'd be fucked. It would take all of our savings.

surreygirl1987 · 26/09/2022 19:02

I am in a family of 4 with a £100k+ household salary. We are struggling. Childcare for my 2 kids (nursery) costs almost £3k a month in total (we both work full time). Mortgage is around £1800. Not much left over at the end of the month and we are very much living from pay day to pay day!

I know when my oldest starts school though we'll be okay - I'm not in any way trying to compare my situation to people who are struggling with no way out. We just have to cope for one more year.

Dox9 · 26/09/2022 19:02

PolarPolly27 · 26/09/2022 18:20

I don't think you're unusual. It's a myth that everyone increases their outgoings in proportion to their increasing household income. Some may for sure but definitely not all.

This. We have little over 100k income. We could easily spend it all on a bigger house and newer car but our 2 bed terrace and 8 year old mini are perfectly adequate. There's plenty in our budget we could cut back on if need be - mortgage overpayment, extra pension savings, holidays, home improvements. 100k should not be a struggle unless you have 2-3 kids in FT childcare.

Ragwort · 26/09/2022 19:02

I agree it's all relative and no doubt everyone is feeling the effect of rising costs ... but people still make choices - ie; why have 2/3 or more children? Why live in an expensive part of the country? Why have a pet that only eats expensive food? Hmm.

We have always been very careful and risk adverse, moved away from an expensive part of the country - yes, away from family and friends but meant we could buy a nice house in a much cheaper part of the country, agreed to have just one DC, never had pets etc etc.

It is very tone deaf to 'complain' if you are on £100K even if you are feeling the pinch.

camaleon77 · 26/09/2022 19:00

@lannistunut I know... And I am saying that after housing (in my case rent in a pretty shit area) there are not real choice left at all. No mismanagement to be had. No private shcools or second cars, or regular take aways. talking about 80,000 pounds. So 100,0000 (discounting taxes) cannot be that great, if you pay rent in London or childcare

ChilliBandit · 26/09/2022 19:00

@Penguinsaregreat never have, never will 🤷‍♀️

mam0918 · 26/09/2022 19:00

Yep, I have always been among the lowest earners in the country (never made over £12k per year) yet I have thousands in savings safety net (been homeless before and dont plan on ending up like that again) and feel like we want for nothing and lived like that fine for a decade.

We certainly dont live a life of luxuary, a holiday for us was ryanair and a cheap motel or a uk caravan park, I drive a 20 year old car and non of us have the latest Iphones or wear Nike airs etc... but we enjoy our life pefectly fine.

Granted when I got married and my partner moved in he brough his £18k income in too (although with 2 pregnancies in 3 years my self employed income has dropped for my previous £12k down to £6k now and added 2 more to our family).

Yet I feel much worse off now in general and like I struggle more even though our household income of £24k (double my old income) because he make decision I never would which I can see as bad finiacial choices.

Ontop of that our tax went up which takes a chunk too (as someone erning under £12k I wasnt previously taxed as I was under the minumum band).

I definately think my DH lack of money skills (such as buying a car with a loan he knew couldnt really afford and taking out an expensive phone contract and his expensive bloody hobbies) and thats the cruix of our issue.

So yes majoritively I believe its bad management (although tax sucks too) that drags people down. However trying to talk people like my DH out of throwing money away is like banging your head on a wall.

kimchifox · 26/09/2022 18:59

No - people tend to live somewhere towards the limit of their means though. What was affordable last year is much less affordable now. No matter how much you earn. For example I send one DC to a school that is not accessible on public transport and have to drive. When calculating the costs at the time it was doable. Now that petrol cost is eating a much bigger chunk of our monthly income. The mortgage has gone up - all the things we committed to and could easily afford 3 years ago / 8 years ago now take up a much bigger portion of our income because our income has not risen in line with our expenditure. Not because we are being slack with money.

Would you say is was good management to have insurance policies, life cover etc? That also costs money.

Also - perhaps you think everyone should just get the smallest possible house, live the most meagre possible existence, not have a pension. Where does the motivation to even earn 100k come from if you can never actually enjoy it or invest for the future? Sorry, but fuck that for a game of soldiers.

Lots of people on higher incomes will also have savings and investments - for the future / pension & not want to liquidate them to have to heat/eat now so will be trying to cut their cloth on things that aren't "necessities" - all the fun things in other words. So yes - you can be on 100k and still be finding it difficult.

If you had nothing and now you have even less - that is obviously a much much worse position to be in. But in your eyes is that also due to mismanagement of some sort??

Coucous · 26/09/2022 18:59

SleeplessInEngland · 26/09/2022 18:46

You could move to another area.

I’m not saying you should or that it wouldn’t be shit, but I think there’re wildly varying interpretations of ‘options’ on this thread.

I actually couldn't - I earn enough to live where I live.

orbitalcrisis · 26/09/2022 18:59

The problem is credit. The more you earn, the more credit you are offered and at the best rates, but buying things on credit is just as irresponsible when you're wealthy as when you are poor. I think other than a house, you should never buy something you do not have the money for. I'm poor and I paid cash for my car.

colddayinhell · 26/09/2022 18:58

YABU. Plenty of people earn a lot but pay very high rents and get no help. Plenty of people who don't earn a lot live in very big, low rent, social housing and are heavily subsidised by lots of benefits. Often they end up with similar incomes after essential costs. It's not as simple as high income = well off these days.

Mycatsgoldtooth · 26/09/2022 18:58

I’ll say this, having being skint skint eight years ago and now having had a bit of money for a few years, but in this economy having to tighten my belt, I’d much rather be tightening my belt rather then worrying if I’ll be able to buy a tub of Aptimil.

Flangelasashes · 26/09/2022 18:57

Knickerthief1 · 26/09/2022 18:43

We have a very good household income - around £150k a year, and we are always overspent. I can confirm that I am absolutely terrible at money management. I have made some good decisions - kept our mortgage low and didn't move when we could afford it. Instead I've spent more money on holidays and caravans and meals out and a hot tub and haven't saved anything. It's total mismanagement and I need to be better. I absolutely agree that it's ridiculous to be on our income and to be in this position, and I would never compare us to someone on an average income who is struggling. So yes I'm worried now and its my own fault and I'm trying to improve my money management. We do have choices that will improve things but then I struggle with the idea of doing a job I absolutely hate and not having the niceties that make it seem worthwhile. I'll no doubt get slated for this - and so I should. It's a bloody stupid position to be in.

I think that is refreshingly honest. More so than a lot of the posters here.

Fizbosshoes · 26/09/2022 18:56

Having more money almost always gives you more choices.
However I always think it seems really naive when people say "just move to a cheaper area/downsize" as a means of saving (or gaining) money.
Of course it makes sense to live in an affordable (to the individual ) area. But for a start, moving house is in no way instant and often there are upfront costs before you begin to see any savings/gains.
Secondly there is often a reason why an area might be cheaper - no train station/poorer transport options, fewer amenities, no secondary school etc.
So you could move to a cheaper area and have lower housing costs....only to spend the difference on driving to a station and parking, higher rail fares, spending more on fuel or bus fares to take kids to school etc.

Downsizing in the same area is dependent on having buyer for a large house (and I imagine fewer people are uprising at the current time)

People with expensive cars might be tied into lease deals with a financial penalty for ending the contract early, similarly (and I admit I do not know how private schools are set up) you might have to give a term notice if you took children out of school.

There will be some people on all incomes who can't manage their money properly, and people with higher incomes are likely to have wiggle room to turn things around (pp who listed their outgoings had several "optional" things but they may have been tied into contracts) but it's not as black and white to say 100k is definitely enough for any family of 4.

Subbaxeo · 26/09/2022 18:53

VatofTea · 26/09/2022 17:22

YABU massively to be judging and benchmarking. Chip on shoulder.

Focus on your own finances, other people on 100k or more are none of your business, stop counting other people's money or analyzing other people's budgets, it's rude.

Why is it rude to discuss on an anonymous internet site? I’d agree if you’re lecturing your friends about the cost of living and how they’re mismanaging but it’s reasonable to suggest there isn’t a lot of sympathy around compared to some who have it far worse. All sorts of issues are discussed on Mumsnet in a way that we’d never do IRL.

TokyoTen · 26/09/2022 18:51

I don't think you've thought it through because they may have very high outgoings which are difficult to control (e.g. mortgage, childcare, commute costs) so could find it difficult to cut back without drastic changes.

Plus, I and most other people never discuss salaries, how do you know what they are on, or is it a guess? And honestly if I was asked if I'm struggling by someone I'd say something like "yes it is difficult isn't it" because I don't want to seem a senseless twat so will be empathetic. In reality, at the moment, luckily it's not a struggle for us.

doobedooboom · 26/09/2022 18:51

Would be fine if you can just move and sell your assets in a couple of days. But that's not possible. You can't just sell your house if you are going to incur a £30k early repayment charge for example. And if you have school fees you have committed to the payment etc. Seems harsh to say these people have brought it on themselves simply because they like many others failed to predict the crisis.

toomychtiss · 26/09/2022 18:51

Sympathy and compassion are not finite resources.

amen

Penguinsaregreat · 26/09/2022 18:50

So can I ask, who is still going to vote Conservative?
Genuine question.

Swipe left for the next trending thread