Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To stand on road to stop parents parking illegally

259 replies

ChimneyPot · 26/09/2022 15:52

Parking at our primary school has been hazardous for years. There is a crossing guard on the main road at the school gates but not on a side road lots of kids have to cross. Parents park on the double yellow lines at the junction of the side road blocking lines of site for pedestrians and cars trying to turn in and out. This often results in the road getting blocked and cars reversing back on to main road.
School sends repeated communication to parents without impact and has asked local authority for bollards and this is under consideration but hasn’t happened yet.

I used to collect my DC from the gate because of the risks but DC wants to be more independent and meet me further away.

I started asking parents not to park and the junction but have been largely ignored so I have started standing on the edge of the road to prevent people parking and this has been effective.
Today someone I know signalled to me to move but I smiled and shook my head and they had to park a few metres down the street . They are not happy with me.

AIBU to block the road?

To stand on road to stop parents parking illegally
OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
ivykaty44 · 01/10/2022 19:17

This plumbers experience of getting an ecargobike supposed expectation

food is delivered by bike Just eat do that it’s often quicker in built up areas that get congested by drivers. Advantages are no parking issues - like the plumber above taking 40 minutes to find a parking spot

sainsbury also do online delivery by cargo bike, as it’s cheaper and quicker in some areas - but not all areas and not all deliveries- some are by van They look cool

London taxi service by cargo bike

cars are still useful, but not for every trip & often other modes of transport can be quicker and more efficient for shorter journeys under 6/7 miles

ivykaty44 · 01/10/2022 19:01

RedAppleGirl You’re clearly showing yourself to be a militant driver - it’s driving and no other transport will do

not one single mode of transport will be adequate for every journey, some can be walked, cycled or get a bus and sometimes use a car. It’s not an all or nothing. A mixture of transports can be used, even for one journey

whilst we have militant drivers like yourself that insist that everything has to be by car or if it can’t be by car then everything has to be by cycle, solutions to pollution, congestion and health will not be solved

SnackSizeRaisin · 01/10/2022 18:25

RedAppleGirl · 01/10/2022 13:43

This kind of action enforcement should be left to the authorities not vigilantes.
The authorities control the roads and the space around the roads, they should deal with the offenders.
Maybe have a school meeting with parents to discuss the best way forward, rather than indirect cycle to school initiatives for the handful of people living nearby or direct confrontation.
I know at DD's primary there is adequate parking in the adjoining small housing development. However, it's been deemed resident only despite being a public space. Unfortunately, people still drive and park there, causing resentment and arguments.
These parking spots could be time limited to start and finish times. Shared use.

Dp has always parked away from this area, it's a bit hectic.
I do feel lots of primary schools are old and outdated, the funneling into the stairs, small gates, it's all a bit 1930's football stadium. Schools need modernizing inside and out.

I'm very pro cycling but I think you have a point. The problem is that a minority of stupid parents make it dangerous for children to walk and cycle, which then worsens congestion and parking. Of course there are some parents who have to drop off by car although I don't think that is very many here (primary school in a town, most children are within 1 mile). Some people just should have picked their closest primary school instead of one further away.

Schools should be designed so that there is an area to drop off children by car that is away from the main entrance. The main entrance should be a pedestrian and bike only area (or residents cars only). That would mean it was safe to approach the school on bike and foot, enabling more to make healthy and environmentally sound choices.

It won't be possible everywhere but is possible in many places.

Angelinflipflops · 01/10/2022 17:20

Redapple, I agree alot of schools do need modernising, lots of secure cycle parking for a start.

RedAppleGirl · 01/10/2022 13:43

eastegg · 01/10/2022 13:14

So do you think OP standing on the double yellow lines to stop this hardcore from parking there is a good idea? Presumably yes, if you think fining them is ok. Remember it’s a double yellow at a junction.

This kind of action enforcement should be left to the authorities not vigilantes.
The authorities control the roads and the space around the roads, they should deal with the offenders.
Maybe have a school meeting with parents to discuss the best way forward, rather than indirect cycle to school initiatives for the handful of people living nearby or direct confrontation.
I know at DD's primary there is adequate parking in the adjoining small housing development. However, it's been deemed resident only despite being a public space. Unfortunately, people still drive and park there, causing resentment and arguments.
These parking spots could be time limited to start and finish times. Shared use.

Dp has always parked away from this area, it's a bit hectic.
I do feel lots of primary schools are old and outdated, the funneling into the stairs, small gates, it's all a bit 1930's football stadium. Schools need modernizing inside and out.

Angelinflipflops · 01/10/2022 13:41

Resample, plenty of parents cycle to work

Roomba · 01/10/2022 13:23

The Head of ds2's school tried standing in the zigzag lined space with a few staff and parents. It worked for a couple of days. Cones, traffic wardens handing out tickets and publishing photos of offeners' cars had failed before that.

But the Head unfortunately ended up in a very sweary fist fight with a driver who almost ran him over, and he had to resign! A shame as he was a great teacher, but had a moment of madness over people just not caring if they kill or injure a small child.

flagwaver · 01/10/2022 13:20

The whole issue of entitled parents is staggering, when my late OH was involved in spending time on the village speedwatch, trying to keep the village safer from idiots, some of the worst offenders were parents speeding to school because they were late. When they got a letter from the police they would often expect the fact that they had bred a child to absolve them from any speed limits yet were a child injured, or worse, by a speeding motorist they would expect 'something to be done'.

eastegg · 01/10/2022 13:14

RedAppleGirl · 01/10/2022 13:07

I'd rather be behind the times than in cloud cuckoo land. The cycle to school initiatives will not be adopted by the majority. Do the parents then cycle off to work? Do the builders, and tradespeople cycle off to work too?
Do the food deliveries now come on a bike with a basket?
Do you understand parents will drop at school-work-pickup-go to any number of other engagements during the day before and after school?
Are we to cycle to these engagements?

There was still a hard core group of parents who drove right up to the school gates. Even if there is the infrastructure for parking a significant group of people won't use it.

This is where fines are useful, clear provision has been made and parents still ignore, time to adopt punitive measures.

So do you think OP standing on the double yellow lines to stop this hardcore from parking there is a good idea? Presumably yes, if you think fining them is ok. Remember it’s a double yellow at a junction.

eastegg · 01/10/2022 13:10

queenofthewild · 01/10/2022 12:43

DS's primary was less than 2 minutes walk from a supermarket which was happy for parents to use their car park for drop offs and pick ups.

There was still a hard core group of parents who drove right up to the school gates. Even if there is the infrastructure for parking a significant group of people won't use it.

Spot on.

RedAppleGirl · 01/10/2022 13:07

Angelinflipflops · 01/10/2022 12:24

Redapplegirl - increasing kids cycling to school is the complete opposite of limited thinking. Relying on cars for transporting kids is incredibly limited thinking, your behind the times

I'd rather be behind the times than in cloud cuckoo land. The cycle to school initiatives will not be adopted by the majority. Do the parents then cycle off to work? Do the builders, and tradespeople cycle off to work too?
Do the food deliveries now come on a bike with a basket?
Do you understand parents will drop at school-work-pickup-go to any number of other engagements during the day before and after school?
Are we to cycle to these engagements?

There was still a hard core group of parents who drove right up to the school gates. Even if there is the infrastructure for parking a significant group of people won't use it.

This is where fines are useful, clear provision has been made and parents still ignore, time to adopt punitive measures.

ivykaty44 · 01/10/2022 12:56

RedAppleGirl

strange then that children cycle to school in other countries with hills included.

your attitude that a child would be cycling 150 miles before school is ridiculous, a stage of the tour is not the same as cycling 5 miles to school - which is perfectly doable by a teenager, even including a 5% hill into the bargain and of course going home will be much easier as it’ll be downhill

driving 13 miles extra every day is not healthy for anyone, especially the passengers

queenofthewild · 01/10/2022 12:43

DS's primary was less than 2 minutes walk from a supermarket which was happy for parents to use their car park for drop offs and pick ups.

There was still a hard core group of parents who drove right up to the school gates. Even if there is the infrastructure for parking a significant group of people won't use it.

Angelinflipflops · 01/10/2022 12:24

You're!

Angelinflipflops · 01/10/2022 12:24

Redapplegirl - increasing kids cycling to school is the complete opposite of limited thinking. Relying on cars for transporting kids is incredibly limited thinking, your behind the times

Angelinflipflops · 01/10/2022 12:20

Ilovedriving- I appreciate some life style decisions are made out of necessity rather than choice but I would do anything to avoid a long car commute that involved kids school drop off/pick up

RedAppleGirl · 01/10/2022 11:26

ivykaty44 · 30/09/2022 19:05

RedAppleGirl You’re missing the point

the secondary school children could be riding to school solo, no need for anyone to be taking them if the infrastructure was put in place.

Instead of car parking put into already tight streets around a primary school, which is what you see as the solution

I'm not missing the point. There are not many children going to be riding to school. Where we live there are 2 hills en route which are used for international cycling. No one's children are going to be riding a Tour de France before and after school.
Apart from this fact, transport is used to make other journeys in the meantime. Bundling the journeys together.
This idea of riding to school or increases in cycle use is the exact kind of limited thinking and budget-wasting councils embrace. Which end up costing money, and lives, and are a monumental strain on our villages, towns, and cities' road networks. Absurd.
The school's issue needs looking at, we could have time-limited parking, however that would need parents to actually just pick up the children quickly.
Tbh some schools also need rebuidling-modernizing, part of that would mean adequate provisions for drop off and pick up. It's not the 1950s as Mumsnet keeps preaching.

ivykaty44 · 30/09/2022 19:05

RedAppleGirl You’re missing the point

the secondary school children could be riding to school solo, no need for anyone to be taking them if the infrastructure was put in place.

Instead of car parking put into already tight streets around a primary school, which is what you see as the solution

LakieLady · 30/09/2022 12:18

CatLadyDrinksGin · 26/09/2022 15:54

It’s the same at every school in the country and is a problem that you won’t solve. Some parents are lazy and selfish.

This!

My SIL and her husband lived in a house near a school. The house was down a long narrow driveway between 2 other houses and couldn't be seen from the road.

Nearly every day in term time, he would either be blocked in or blocked out of his drive by people dropping off their kids at the school.

One day, he got out of his van and asked the parent parked across the drive to move, because he needed to get to his house. The parent insisted that there wasn't a house down there and refused! They then put signs on both walls at the entrance saying "Private Drive - Access required 24/7"

A few days after that, their daughter had to get someone to move their car so she could get to work. Unbelievable!

RedAppleGirl · 30/09/2022 12:04

ivykaty44 · 30/09/2022 10:09

Facilities around schools especially primary need upgrading.

problem is every time they upgrade roads, more congestion is the result. It’s a bit like solving the obesity crisis by putting an extra hole in the belt to hold the trousers up

differ solutions need to be implemented

perhaphs if the majority of children walked or cycled then the roads would be safer and then more children could walk and cycle.

lically we have a few active travel buses for walking and cycling

but some parents are scared as the drivers are dangerous….so won’t use these methods

Walking depends on how far away you are from the school. DP has a double drop of secondary, then onto the primary. The whole journey is a 13-mile round trip. The first drop is 5 miles away, then 4miles, then back home.
The idea that people are going to waltz to school without a care in the world because it naice for the children and the environment isn't realistic.

ivykaty44 · 30/09/2022 10:09

Facilities around schools especially primary need upgrading.

problem is every time they upgrade roads, more congestion is the result. It’s a bit like solving the obesity crisis by putting an extra hole in the belt to hold the trousers up

differ solutions need to be implemented

perhaphs if the majority of children walked or cycled then the roads would be safer and then more children could walk and cycle.

lically we have a few active travel buses for walking and cycling

but some parents are scared as the drivers are dangerous….so won’t use these methods

SavoirFlair · 30/09/2022 08:10

I’m sorry @RedAppleGirl but I fundamentally disagree with you.

We are not going to pave over our villages and towns to create designated school car parks that will be used for 30 mins of a weekday, and actually may or may not be used because some “frazzled” parents may still choose to park on double yellows or across a drive to shave off 20 seconds on their “performance” commute.

More and more people work from home. This makes school runs markedly easier in terms of flexibility (not having to be there physically at 08:55). If you’re an in-person worker who turns up to a workplace: then the conversation needs to be had with employers.

Not endangering other children’s safety because someone wasn’t grown up enough to get an extra 5 mins from their employer to allow them to drop off their kids safely.

OriginalUsername3 · 30/09/2022 08:01

ILoveDriving · 28/09/2022 18:52

What is really frustrating about this thread is the assumption that people parking to drop their children are lazy. Believe me, I'd love to be a sahm or work from home, but my circumstances mean I have to commute an hour to and from.work. That means with two children to drop and collect from school,.it's all very tight for time. I have to drive them. We'd all rather not.

I have parked in spaces where I shouldnt and I've been shouted at by mums wearing yellow jackets waving plackards around and insulting me. These mums are fortunate enough to be sah parents and have time for such things.

If you genuinely care about safety, then work politely with all parties - parents, schools, drivers and pedestrians to find a workable and compassionate solution for all. Don't throw random accustaions about how inconsiderate and lazy parents are to drive. I certainly don't feel lazy. I am constantly frazzled and always in a rush and would rather not be. I'd love there to be nice parking spaces or turning points available, or a community walking bus I could drop my children to before going to work, but those things don't exist.

Parents who drive and sometimes have to park where they have to park are usually neither lazy nor inconsiderate. They may well be stressed, frazzled, very hard working (not lazy) and need some compassion.

I think some of the mums at my school that shout insults and stomp about in yellow jackets at drop off time are also church attenders who spout kindness and compassion on a Sunday morning. The irony.

You being busy it not an excuse for children's lives in danger.

RedAppleGirl · 30/09/2022 07:52

eastegg · 29/09/2022 09:35

That strategy will not work

What strategy? I didn’t suggest a particular strategy, just that it would need to involve people driving less. Of course it will have to, what else are we going to do, knock houses down to make parking spaces?

As for your idea of redesignating areas single yellow, again, let’s go back to what the OP is about, which is double yellows on a junction next to a school. There’s no way that can or should be redesignated anything, as it’s simply not safe to stop there as it blocks the view of children trying to cross. That should be something we can all agree on, but no, apparently not.

The working parents on here who drop and dash, have you tried leaving home earlier and finding parking further away from the school? School drop off isn’t the crack of dawn is it, so can’t you build in a slightly earlier leave time? As I’ve said up thread, when I had to travel a lot and make sure I got to work on time I used a breakfast club. To do that I left home at 7.35. What time do you leave in order to look for a safe parking space I wonder?

Dp leaves at 8-15 ish and drops one at one school and one at the other. Then he goes on to work. As far as I know, he parks away from the school in a tiny village car park and walks. The comprehensive school has great drop-off and pick-up points.
I leave for work at 6 am when I'm in the office and arrive back at 7-8 pm.
The fees for the breakfast club were £90 per week for 2 children. That's not viable long-term for every parent. In fact it is absurd.
Facilities around schools especially primary need upgrading.
Or they need rebuilding somewhere more appropriate for modern society.

PeachyPeachTrees · 29/09/2022 16:18

It's the same around our primary school. Parents park on the literal corner with double yellow lines and if they'd bothered to look there's usually a space a few metres away. They are double parked, over driveways, on the zig zags...everywhere. Sometimes the traffic warden comes and hands out fines but they do it the next day anyway. It's a losing battle.

Swipe left for the next trending thread