Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

And now Italy

138 replies

Pampapuddlepoose · 26/09/2022 15:43

Italy has just voted in it's most right wing prime minister since Muesli.

IANBU - This whole thing is starting to look scarily like the build up to WW2
AIBU - Stop worrying and go and do something useful.

I'm going to stop reading/watching the news. It's scaring me and I can't fk anything about if anyway. I'm not trying to scaremongering, I'd just like some other opinions.

OP posts:
Melassa · 26/09/2022 19:12

Kissingfrogs25 · 26/09/2022 19:01

The Italians have not had a chance to vote for years alex please stop talking bollox yourself! They have had to put up with an EU engineered technocratic government!

You are talking bollocks.

Melassa · 26/09/2022 19:10

Kissingfrogs25 · 26/09/2022 18:52

Draghi was a technocratic leader placed there by the EU to keep the right wing wolves at bay. It could never last, as he was not actually elected. He was a human sticking plaster.

I am not in the least bit surprised by this result, Italians have been desperate to leave for years. I never forget going to Florence after brexit, and trying to get used to the idea and all the waiters and taxi drivers congratulating me! As if I personally had dragged us out of the EU on my own. The same happened in the Netherlands, France and Sweden over the years in different forms. My polish friends have since joined the sentiment.

They said the UK always leads the way, and brexit was no different!

It was truly the most surreal of conversations, and coming back here it was white hot heat of anger from the 48% that voted to remain, and yet in Europe so many were delighted.

Italy will leave now. They have been lining up the lira for years now, and I remember there was always a plan, so I guess we might see it now.

Lol. Since then most Italians have seen what a shitshow the U.K. has become and are horrified by the idea. I live and work with Italians every day and apart from one errant taxi driver in 2016 (can you see a theme?) no one has thought Brexit was a good idea. It was all “what were they thinking?!” Obviously reinforced by the parade of loons in U.K. politics which just confirmed that madness had beset the normally pragmatic Brits.

Kissingfrogs25 · 26/09/2022 19:06

"Technocracy is inherently opposite to a pluralistic view of politics. At its core is the assumption that there is one solution to any problem and experts are the people who know the best way to arrive at that solution. There is no room, in this vision, for conflict or accommodation between opposing interests and values – that is to say the essence of politics and the essence of parties, which are supposed to represent the different segments of society.

As political scientist Lorenzo De Sio argues, technocratic leadership removes responsibility from both parties and voters. Parties give up their role of making hard choices in the allocation of resources. This way, decisions appear to be taken out of the political realm – even though, in reality, the allocation of resources always entails a political decision about who gets what – even when that decision is made by experts on the basis of their supposedly superior knowledge"

You could argue a technocracy cancels out real democracy altogether.
There is no accountability

Not unlike the EU political structure.

Kissingfrogs25 · 26/09/2022 19:01

The Italians have not had a chance to vote for years alex please stop talking bollox yourself! They have had to put up with an EU engineered technocratic government!

colddayinhell · 26/09/2022 19:00

What has she said that is so terrifying OP?

Kissingfrogs25 · 26/09/2022 18:59

Italians have basically been muzzled until now. This explains why:

"Italy loves technocrats. The latest proof is the decision to install Mario Draghi, former governor of the Bank of Italy and former president of the European Central Bank, as prime minister. This followed the resignation of Giuseppe Conte, who lost the support of one of the parties that formed his parliamentary majority.

The Italian president, Sergio Mattarella, when asking Draghi to form a government of national unity, said it would be too much of a risk to hold elections at this point in the pandemic. The idea is that this administration should focus on the immediate pressures of COVID"

theconversation.com/mario-draghi-is-italys-addiction-to-technocratic-leaders-a-cause-for-concern-155336

Alexandra2001 · 26/09/2022 18:58

@Kissingfrogs25 Yeah course they will, just like you were treated like the Messiah after Brexit... all bollox.

EU is more popular than ever, Le Pen had to say she'd stay in to stand a chance and still had her arse handed to her, same with Meloni, only 24% of voters supported her, in a very low turn, pissed off Draghi being booted out.

Sometimes i do wonder if ever been to mainland Europe.

EmmaH2022 · 26/09/2022 18:56

Geneva12 · 26/09/2022 18:03

Yes. And after they have listened then the left need to take on board what people are saying and not call them racist, bigot, thick and stupid for having an opinion that is not the same as them.

Exactly.

Alexandra2001 · 26/09/2022 18:53

FOJN · 26/09/2022 17:47

Would you be so worried if it was the most left wing PM ever, or would that not concern you as it would be more in line with your political leanings?

I know it's bizarre that people seem to think anything left wing is benevolent at best and benign at worst. I think I'm correct in saying that extreme left politics claimed far more lives in the 20th Century than extreme right wing politics.

If your referring to Stalin, he wasn't left wing, he wasn't even a communist, he was a murderous dictator who killed anyone from either side who he deemed as a threat, including communists.

He used Marxism to gain power, after that anything goes.

He held power as General Secretary of the Communist Party of the Soviet Union (1922–1952) and Chairman of the Council of Ministers of the Soviet Union (1941–1953). Initially governing the country as part of a collective leadership, he consolidated power to become a dictator by the 1930s. Ideologically adhering to the Leninist interpretation of Marxism, he formalised these ideas as Marxism–Leninism, while his own policies are called Stalinism

Kissingfrogs25 · 26/09/2022 18:52

Draghi was a technocratic leader placed there by the EU to keep the right wing wolves at bay. It could never last, as he was not actually elected. He was a human sticking plaster.

I am not in the least bit surprised by this result, Italians have been desperate to leave for years. I never forget going to Florence after brexit, and trying to get used to the idea and all the waiters and taxi drivers congratulating me! As if I personally had dragged us out of the EU on my own. The same happened in the Netherlands, France and Sweden over the years in different forms. My polish friends have since joined the sentiment.

They said the UK always leads the way, and brexit was no different!

It was truly the most surreal of conversations, and coming back here it was white hot heat of anger from the 48% that voted to remain, and yet in Europe so many were delighted.

Italy will leave now. They have been lining up the lira for years now, and I remember there was always a plan, so I guess we might see it now.

Crunchingleaf · 26/09/2022 18:47

Geneva12 · 26/09/2022 18:03

Yes. And after they have listened then the left need to take on board what people are saying and not call them racist, bigot, thick and stupid for having an opinion that is not the same as them.

Also I have always been left leaning, however I would be just as against having a far left government as a far right government. Either extreme is not a good place for the majority of citizens.
Representing the best interests of those in your constituency seems to alien to majority of politicians in many countries.

KalaniM · 26/09/2022 18:44

Actually do quite like muesli, but have stopped eating it because far too many raisins. Overnight oats with defrosted fruits of the forest gets my vote.

Melassa · 26/09/2022 18:43

Scianel · 26/09/2022 17:14

I'm not massively surprised. They had a shit old pandemic and Draghi was hugely unpopular.

Draghi was hugely popular and it wasn’t him in power during the pandemic, it was Conte.

Many people didn’t bother voting as the little bickering politicians brought down the government and the only credible person in parliament. All the rest are complete clowns and people are fed up with them so have abstained from voting. The ones who did vote in droves were the older demographic and “angry young men” like DP’s friend’s son whose rebellion phase involves becoming a rabid racist.

I was out much of the day yesterday and there were very few people at the polling booths. It was one of the lowest turnouts in years.

Meloni is a serial liar who adjusts her
lie based on the audience. Much like Boris I suppose. One silver lining is that fuckface Salvini’s party got trounced. We’ll see how long this lasts, Meloni is a skilled liar but not capable of running an engine, let alone a country. I suppose it depends on who is in the wings subsidising her and advising her. Hate and bigotry has deep pockets, as we’ve seen elsewhere.

walkingonsunshinekat · 26/09/2022 18:41

Pampapuddlepoose · 26/09/2022 15:43

Italy has just voted in it's most right wing prime minister since Muesli.

IANBU - This whole thing is starting to look scarily like the build up to WW2
AIBU - Stop worrying and go and do something useful.

I'm going to stop reading/watching the news. It's scaring me and I can't fk anything about if anyway. I'm not trying to scaremongering, I'd just like some other opinions.

She isn't yet PM, she isn't particularly right wing (her party is a member of the Conservative grouping in Europe, as were the Tories) and i'd be more worried about Truss & the current Tory party, far more right wing on Europe (Italy doesn't wish to leave the EU or the euro), immigration, social welfare and public spending.

Plus Italy can and will have another GE if she starts to mess things up, they've had 60 Govts since WW2 but even so seem better Governed than we are.

CaptainBarbosa · 26/09/2022 18:36

wackamole · 26/09/2022 18:32

I can't see Italy staying in the EU, I think they will Itexit 😂

That seems complicated; could they not simply Italeave?

That said, Giorgia Meloni's party, Fratelli d'Italia, is considered "(soft) eurosceptic", but they do not call for Italy to leave the EU. Mostly, they want to influence the EU to move away from federalism toward confederalism. Meloni is also Chairperson of the multinational European Conservatives and Reformists Party (ECR), which also campaigns to reform the EU, giving more power to the individual countries and governments and only using "pooled sovreignty" when it's the best way to achieve a truly common goal. ("Lead not Leave", anyone?)

Italeave is far better sounding, I vote for that (the name, not the overall political movement)

wackamole · 26/09/2022 18:32

I can't see Italy staying in the EU, I think they will Itexit 😂

That seems complicated; could they not simply Italeave?

That said, Giorgia Meloni's party, Fratelli d'Italia, is considered "(soft) eurosceptic", but they do not call for Italy to leave the EU. Mostly, they want to influence the EU to move away from federalism toward confederalism. Meloni is also Chairperson of the multinational European Conservatives and Reformists Party (ECR), which also campaigns to reform the EU, giving more power to the individual countries and governments and only using "pooled sovreignty" when it's the best way to achieve a truly common goal. ("Lead not Leave", anyone?)

HRTQueen · 26/09/2022 18:32

psychomath · 26/09/2022 17:39

this would be the equivalent of UKIP
receiving 25% of votes

Didn't they receive 13% of the vote in 2013 or whichever year that election was? I know that's only half as much, but in terms of shockingly high vote share for previously fringe parties it's not so different from 25%?

The received 13% in the 2015 election hence why Cameron panicked and decided to call a referendum (with the vast majority of MP’s supporting)

fringe parties often do well in local elections

13% is quite different from 1/4 of the electorate (plus the votes for other right wing parties)

thankfully our politics don’t tend to sway to far left or far right but then neither did Sweden’s

Riverlee · 26/09/2022 18:29

Just saw this on the news. Depressing.

waffless · 26/09/2022 18:28

Exactly, extreme views are the worrying situation. The left are crazy giving blanket entrance to people without checks at the borders or saying there should be not borders. Then complain about poverty, lack of housing, schools and gangs coming to out countries. Any person even asking basic questions is a racist. When what most people are is not against immigrants but the lack of checks. If you want first world it became to be for a reason. The rise of the so called far right is the consequence of the loony extremists of the left.

Lulu1919 · 26/09/2022 18:16

I love Museli

Skodacool · 26/09/2022 18:15

RJnomore1 · 26/09/2022 16:14

Well your autocorrect gave me a brief smile but you do have to wonder where peoples brains are really.

Me too, but I did wonder whether it was autocorrect or deliberate

jetadore · 26/09/2022 18:05

First they came for the granola…

Geneva12 · 26/09/2022 18:03

Beamur · 26/09/2022 17:31

The Left need to start listening a bit harder to the public and actually address some of the social issues driving the rise of popularity in right wing politics. This will continue otherwise.

Yes. And after they have listened then the left need to take on board what people are saying and not call them racist, bigot, thick and stupid for having an opinion that is not the same as them.

briancormorant · 26/09/2022 17:58

It is the 'open door' immigration policy that is hard for many to accept.

Contrasting with natural humanitarian feelings is the question: "Why if you live in such a bloody awful country such as Albania or Syria do you not stay and work to put right"?
Sure, it will be hard. Many places did it. France had a revolution as did Ireland. So have many others.
Do the patriotic thing. Go back and fight for your countries.
See Ukraine right now!!

FigTreeInEurope · 26/09/2022 17:57

Ha, the Salento want independence from Italy. In Piedmont they want a separate country for anything north of the Po. Italy's politics is as bonkers as the way they drive. Yesterday, I listened to a farmer passionately tell me about how fratelli d'italia would free us from the EU, and whilst talking, he convinced himself the country couldn't afford it, and "them in Rome" are too corrupt to run the place independently anyway. At 84, and still ploughing his fields, I respect the guys views, but it'll be 90% drama and they'll be howling for change within 18 months. The most mature thing in this country is the wine. I love it, but it's bonkers.

Swipe left for the next trending thread