Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

People passing unhelpful comments!

110 replies

Lovetogarden2022 · 26/09/2022 15:13

This is a real bugbear of mine and it's so annoying I'm sure other people can relate 😂

Why do people feel the need to say unhelpful comments, either on here or on Facebook groups, but also in real life? It drives me mad!

For example, a few people have posted in our local group asking if there are any houses for sale under £450k, for example, and the comments underneath are "ha! You'll be lucky finding a nice property for that price round here!!"

Or another woman asked where the best place to park in town was that wasn't going to be busy or extremely expensive, and loads commented "come and have a look for yourself. Don't be so lazy" etc

The tip of the iceberg was this morning when I politely asked if anyone would be interested in coming to a public event I'm hosting and a friend said "nobody will come to that - there's something else on that weekend" (the other "event" she's referring to is happening miles away and would have no effect on my event 🤣)

It's just not helpful or constructive!!!!!

Does my head in! Is this normal or am I just being unreasonable 🤣

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
PeloFondo · 27/09/2022 14:28

One I get daily

"The first available appointment is the 15th October"
"Can you not do anything sooner?"
Well, no. Or I would have said that...

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 27/09/2022 12:34

OP: It's a recent-ish song. Post-2000 electropop. Female singer. There was a saxophone part in the chorus and something about "yellow" in the lyrics. I remember a green field in the video.

MNer1: Was it Yellow Submarine by the Beatles?

I clearly remember somebody on a TV quiz show being asked a question starting "Which male, British singer...." and they guessed at Madonna!

TigerRag · 27/09/2022 12:05

ShirleyPhallus · 27/09/2022 08:13

What’s the problem with giving an alternative date that you are available?

Because I wasn't asking about another date?

BadNomad · 27/09/2022 11:43

Q: "I'm trying to remember a film I watched years ago. It was a horror film starring Vincent Price, made in the 60s or 70s I think, and he was like a mad doctor who killed all the surgeons who operated on his wife before she died? And he had a weird crackly voice because he had an artificial voicebox or something. Anyone know what it might be?"
A: "Could it be Nightmare On Elm Street?"

Lol this reminds me of the "can anyone help me identify this song" threads on MN.

OP: It's a recent-ish song. Post-2000 electropop. Female singer. There was a saxophone part in the chorus and something about "yellow" in the lyrics. I remember a green field in the video.

MNer1: Was it Yellow Submarine by the Beatles?

MNer2: Coldplay - Yellow?

MNer3: It's Fields of Gold by Sting

10HailMarys · 27/09/2022 11:30

My particular favourite is when people very clearly set out criteria in their post, only for them to be completely ignored by people replying. For example:

Q: "Has anyone got any recommendations for high street jeans that come in a petite length, are high-waisted and slim-fit? I'm on a very tight budget and I don't want to order online."
A: "Cheap jeans are not worth it. I swear by these ones, they're only available from Net A Porter and they are £170 but you won't regret it. Don't think they come in petite but you could get them altered?"

Q: "I'm trying to remember a film I watched years ago. It was a horror film starring Vincent Price, made in the 60s or 70s I think, and he was like a mad doctor who killed all the surgeons who operated on his wife before she died? And he had a weird crackly voice because he had an artificial voicebox or something. Anyone know what it might be?"
A: "Could it be Nightmare On Elm Street?"

NippyWoowoo · 27/09/2022 11:18

ShirleyPhallus · 27/09/2022 08:13

What’s the problem with giving an alternative date that you are available?

I can see we have an offender here.

The question isn’t ‘is anyone free over the next week for something’ or ‘is anyone free over the next month for something’.

If someone says there’s something happening and gives a specific date, and asks if anyone is available, giving an alternative date is useless.

wilddreams · 27/09/2022 11:13

It's annoying on threads that are about low level every day annoyances to allow people to enjoy a light hearted vent. They are obviously meant to be fun but there's always someone who comes along and starts telling everyone they should cheer up and they can't be bothered to get wound up over little things. It seems totally uncalled for in a thread that clearly states is meant to be light hearted.

Hearthnhome · 27/09/2022 08:22

ShirleyPhallus · 27/09/2022 08:13

What’s the problem with giving an alternative date that you are available?

If some needs a lift on a particular date for a particular reason, offering another day isn’t going help.

’I have an interview on Monday, my car has broken can anyone give me a lift to town’

’i can on Thursday’ isn’t going to help someone get to an interview Monday.

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 27/09/2022 08:21

On next door..
Q- I've lost xyz, if anyone finds it please msg me.
A- if you haven't found it in a week's time, I'll come help you look for it. Slammed till then.
Why not just ignore!!!

As well as Trevor from Peterborough sharing a message about a dog that was lost in Sao Paolo in 2007 and urging everybody on his local group to "Please check your sheds" !

ShirleyPhallus · 27/09/2022 08:13

TigerRag · 27/09/2022 07:20

Asked a couple of years ago if anyone was free on a particular date for something. Someone replied with "I'm not free on that date but can do the week after". I wasn't asking about the week after!

What’s the problem with giving an alternative date that you are available?

IglesiasPiggl · 27/09/2022 07:56

ChocolateSpreadOnToast · 27/09/2022 07:11

Can anyone recommend someone for oven cleaning?

Clean it yourself.

Seen on my local fb group. Really, really helpful.

I'd love it if the OP replied "Well yes, but I am far too busy and important. I am also lazy. So, helpful as your suggestion is, I don't think it would work for me" 😂😂

TigerRag · 27/09/2022 07:20

Asked a couple of years ago if anyone was free on a particular date for something. Someone replied with "I'm not free on that date but can do the week after". I wasn't asking about the week after!

Justleaveitblankthen · 27/09/2022 07:18

You get this on the Amazon question and answer section:
"Does this hairdryer have a cool setting?"
"Sorry, I don't know. I sent it back"
Do they think it's against Amazon's law of the land not to answer a question about a purchase? 🤔

ChocolateSpreadOnToast · 27/09/2022 07:11

Can anyone recommend someone for oven cleaning?

Clean it yourself.

Seen on my local fb group. Really, really helpful.

Mumtobabyhavoc · 27/09/2022 06:05

Lovetogarden2022 · 26/09/2022 15:13

This is a real bugbear of mine and it's so annoying I'm sure other people can relate 😂

Why do people feel the need to say unhelpful comments, either on here or on Facebook groups, but also in real life? It drives me mad!

For example, a few people have posted in our local group asking if there are any houses for sale under £450k, for example, and the comments underneath are "ha! You'll be lucky finding a nice property for that price round here!!"

Or another woman asked where the best place to park in town was that wasn't going to be busy or extremely expensive, and loads commented "come and have a look for yourself. Don't be so lazy" etc

The tip of the iceberg was this morning when I politely asked if anyone would be interested in coming to a public event I'm hosting and a friend said "nobody will come to that - there's something else on that weekend" (the other "event" she's referring to is happening miles away and would have no effect on my event 🤣)

It's just not helpful or constructive!!!!!

Does my head in! Is this normal or am I just being unreasonable 🤣

Have you tried responding with, "God, you're fucking miserable." ?

Awoooga · 27/09/2022 05:54

On local FB pages -
‘I lost my iPhone in town today between the Tesco and the cafe please keep an eye out’ or something, the comments section is full of:
’Have you looked on find my iPhone?’, ‘What does it look like?’ & ‘it’s probably gone by now’. Urgh 🙃

MysteriesOfTheOrganism · 27/09/2022 05:37

I reckon there are all sorts of reasons. But I think a significant one is that many people feel as though any question is being directed to them personally. And surely making "unhelpful" comments in real life is a completely normal part of conversing? If a friend mentions in a one-to-one conversation something that you have no experience of, you don't stay silent; you say "I don't know - I've never done that." If it's a group conversation, then surely it's reasonable to chip in your own thoughts - "Oh, I never do that - far too much faff" - because a group conversation is owned by the group. Humans are relational beings - it's hard-wired into us, so engaging in a conversation that's happening around you is pretty normal. Like it or not, social media has become part of social conversation.

MN says it has around 7 million users. So when you ask a question here you're asking a question directly to a potential 7 million individuals. It's inevitable that you get unhelpful chatter in reply.

Rightsraptor · 27/09/2022 05:03

Thank you everyone. 3am is the worst for me when I wake and can't get back to sleep (frequently) and my thoughts turn to gloomy-catastrophic stuff. But you've given me a laugh today, so thanks for that.

I love the annoyance at the overhead helicopter - do they have any idea how much those things cost to get and keep in the air? Not a decision taken lightly.

There's always a smart arse who would've known exactly what to do in your shoes but I think that's just human nature, for some anyway. One infuriating exchange from when I was on Twitter (no longer as I saw the light): discussion about airport loos not having free sanpro/only having machines taking local currency when you've just landed etc. Man pops up and tells the women how they should always be on top of this, why no sanpro always in handbag/luggage? Absolutely no idea how flying can interfere with menstrual cycles, period arriving early etc. Well, that was us told.

As to purchases, wouldn't it be better to review them after one year or so? Then we'd all know how reliable/hard wearing whatever the thing is. But we'd forget, wouldn't we or we'd have lost interest. I also get infuriated by all the 'don't know, still in the box' type comments

LightDrizzle · 27/09/2022 05:02

”belong to a Facebook group for a particular holiday resort and the number of people who respond to questions with ‘Just Google it’.

God yes! I live on the Algarve and I’m on related English (and Portuguese) language Facebook groups for locals that also get enquiries from holidaymakers. This happens all the time.

Also if a British or Irish immigrant dares to ask on the English language group if anyone can anyone recommend a good place for a Sunday roast/ Indian meal/ fish & chips, others stampede to rage about why they’ve moved to Portugal if they want to live like Little Britons . Presumably they’d want Portuguese immigrants to the U.K. crucified for ever missing fish cooked over charcoal or bacalhau,.and as for the Portuguese here who frequent our local Italian, they should fuck off to 🇮🇹

Just recommend a good restaurant if you you know one FFS or scroll on.

expat101 · 27/09/2022 04:51

Friend of mine had a cat dumped at hers earlier this year. She tried everything under the sun to find its owner with no luck, and as it isn't getting on with her cats, she put up a listing to find it a new home.

Well stuff me, all the fanny wobblers came out on that post how she wasn't allowed to re-home it within 7 days, had she checked for a microchip, had she spoken to her neighbours, one fanny wobbler was starting her own movement on the post how she was being ignored! On and on they went about what she should be doing with this cat... but not one offered to re-home it for her.

Dishh · 27/09/2022 04:50

The MN Covid board is terrible for this type of thing - particularly now. If anyone asks a question about Covid, a response might typically be "I don't know anyone that thinks about Covid any more? I certainly don't! Is Covid still a thing?"

MoltenLasagne · 27/09/2022 04:37

I think some people genuinely do not understand how the Internet works. MiL is a case in point, she's on loads of FB groups and will always respond to posts because otherwise she thinks she's being rude and ignoring someone.

Luckily she seems to have found a few favoured groups now where everyone is the same and they all happily chat to one another about the fact they don't know and that's apparently supportive and not incredibly unhelpful. I think its rather sweet but have had to mute her!

Rosehugger · 27/09/2022 04:34

Aria999 · 26/09/2022 22:13

@Muststopeating

I had one of those too, I made the mistake of buying a 6 pack of toilet cleaner on Amazon. One of them wasn't sealed properly and the box came with bleach dripping out of the bottom.

I posted a review and it got deleted but honestly the think people would want to know if a seller is incapable of adequately packaging a bleach product.

That's because you need to review the seller not the product. Different section for packaging/delivery feedback.

Cuppasoupmonster · 27/09/2022 04:16

YANBU and it’s the same sort of poster that replies with their ‘witty’ comments
usually a bloke
usually middle aged
usually has something like ‘university of life’ on their Facebook page
when taken down a peg or two by another poster they get sensitive and angry
it’s usually women’s posts they reply to because they’re sexist and enjoy taking the piss out of the ‘little woman’ posting

LikeAStar1994 · 27/09/2022 04:13

Coastalcreeksider · 26/09/2022 19:10

We've recently had a couple of times where the air ambulance has landed very close to where I live, within minutes cue all the "why's the air ambulance landed here, anyone know what's happened?" On either Farcebook or Next-door.

I do chortle at the numerous replies of "It's an emergency" or "somebody is ill/injured" and quite often "mind your own business!"😆

Probably going to out myself here but on my local Facebook group people are always asking "Why's the helicopter out?" and complaining about it. I think the Admin are deleting posts regarding that now. Good. Because it got old very quickly and it's obviously out for a reason. Not just because they fancied taking it out for a spin.