Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask about investment bankers

105 replies

draydee · 26/09/2022 12:18

My DS wants to be an investment banker.

I would like to support him, but is it true there is a lot of nepotism in this industry? Or can an higher level apprenticeship or university suffice if you don't have connections?

Also why do they incite such vitriol?

Is it true they barely sleep and burn out?

I would like to give him the full picture from the experiences of others.

OP posts:
maxelly · 26/09/2022 13:59

Ok well don't panic, he's 16, he's got at least 5 years really before needing to make any truly critical decisions. At this age it's all about encouraging ambition and passion for me, plus getting the best GCSE and A level results they can, rather than worrying too much about degree and subsequent career choices. Yes schools careers advice can be mixed but really I think at his age it's more about understanding his strengths and weaknesses, likes and dislikes etc rather than pinning him down to any one specific career. I know they're much dirided but the psychometric tests and things they can usually offer are good for this kind of thing even if you then have to take the 'you are 100% suited to being a tree surgeon' bizarre advice they can spit out with a pinch of salt. If his schools careers don't do this you can do some for free online, myers briggs or the '16 personalities' is a good starter for ideas.

And rather than trying to get him to pick his 'job' now, can you help him work out what is it that appeals about the things he's mentioned, investment banking and accountancy, is it the high salary, the fast paced working, working with numbers and data etc? What other careers would also fulfill these things? What are the requirements for those careers, alongside investment banking and accountancy, what can he pull out as common themes e.g. maths a level, a degree, IT skills etc.

A levels in Maths and Geography are a really good start, can you help him by thinking through what it is that is putting him off the idea of uni, if it's common myths around loans and affordability etc then you can do some research with him on that so he has the facts. If it's more that he doesn't feel academically strong enough, then what are his other strengths and what careers can he look at to maximise those... If it's mainly earning good money he's thinking of then IT roles are probably a really good one to look at, it is possible to do quite well without going to uni if you have the skills and again there are a huge, huge range of different types of role, it's not all coding and software development, there's cyber-security, hardware, networking, operations, user experience, testing, data analysis - lots of apprenticeships too.

Kissingfrogs25 · 26/09/2022 13:57

Also why do they incite such vitriol?

You can earn a lifetime's salary in a single year. Put simply.

Getoff · 26/09/2022 13:56

There's no harm in aiming for the top jobs, even if it sounds too competitive. Even if you fall short, you'll still be in a position to out-perform people who didn't even try.

Jessibeth · 26/09/2022 13:55

I used to work for one of the big US investment banks (in comms and PR). Most bankers have undergraduate degrees, masters and/or MBAs (sometimes all three!) from the top Unis…often European e.g. the Sorbonne, or places like Harvard and Yale. A female banker I was friendly with had a BSc in Maths from Brown and an MA in advanced maths (with honours) from Cambridge.

I don’t mean to sound negative but if he doesn’t want to do A-levels, it isn’t the place for him. The competition is ferocious and they pick the best of the best.

As someone said though, it is important to differentiate between working in an investment bank and being a banker. There’s a huge difference and other roles can be interesting and much more accessible.

Kissingfrogs25 · 26/09/2022 13:54

Dogtooth · 26/09/2022 13:49

Does he really know what it is? I don't think you can make it without a degree. Is he just fantasising about easy ways to get rich? He needs a bit of philosophy I think - what matters most in life, what gives life meaning, how important is money and what should you be prepared to do for it...

He might be interested in business more generally, which I think is much easier to get into without a degree.

I've known a few people who worked in the city. Bright people, felt like they were owned by their companies, but made a calculation that it was worth losing their 20s and 30s to accumulate wealth for an easy life after that. Works fine if you don't lose your mind, drop dead from stress or mind missing out on decades of your life in the meantime.

Some of the people I knew were pleasant, but higher than average proportion of twats - from cocaine and arrogance. Also with very little spare time, you can't really invest in relationships so it becomes a bit transactional - they wanted high status girlfriends without having to put much work in, basically.

I disagree, and I have decades of personal experience.

IB can offer the most wonderful life style, especially if you can move into hedge funds and smaller funds that offer a much better life/balance. I would say there are plenty of opportunities to have a fantastic life, it is not all working to the bone on coke!! That was the 1980s version.
Outside of Goldmans and Citi etc, there are plenty of sweet spots that sit side by side with a more balanced home life (and still extremely well paid by any standard)

Getoff · 26/09/2022 13:54

Summarising the advice from the video, as I remember it from last time I watched...

  1. To get a top job, you need the right degree
  2. from an elite university
  3. for which you need all A and A* grades in A-levels
  4. in the right subjects
Regarding point 2, In the video Gary discusses a girl he know who went to Manchester Metropolitan University, who not only did not understand the difference between that and Manchester University, she didn't even know they weren't the same institution.
Kissingfrogs25 · 26/09/2022 13:50

**Needs to READ Economics

Dogtooth · 26/09/2022 13:49

Does he really know what it is? I don't think you can make it without a degree. Is he just fantasising about easy ways to get rich? He needs a bit of philosophy I think - what matters most in life, what gives life meaning, how important is money and what should you be prepared to do for it...

He might be interested in business more generally, which I think is much easier to get into without a degree.

I've known a few people who worked in the city. Bright people, felt like they were owned by their companies, but made a calculation that it was worth losing their 20s and 30s to accumulate wealth for an easy life after that. Works fine if you don't lose your mind, drop dead from stress or mind missing out on decades of your life in the meantime.

Some of the people I knew were pleasant, but higher than average proportion of twats - from cocaine and arrogance. Also with very little spare time, you can't really invest in relationships so it becomes a bit transactional - they wanted high status girlfriends without having to put much work in, basically.

Kissingfrogs25 · 26/09/2022 13:49

Your son needs to be Economics op.
Does he have an A or A* star in maths at A level? That would be a good starting point for him.

Kissingfrogs25 · 26/09/2022 13:47

Op he won't even get an interview without an amazing and glittering degree from Oxford, Cambridge or Harvard or similar, at masters level minimum and that might get you an interview if you are of the best calibre. Being well qualified won't be enough, you also have to have high energy, capable of serious and fast decision making and be razor sharp. You don't get paid millions to be average.

Yes you work hard (you can do long hours in any job) but you will be extremely well paid and have opportunities that would not be available elsewhere.

If he hasn't achieved straight As in his A levels and is not going to a world class university then he might be better attempting the research route or similar.

Everyone wants to be an investment banker but very few make it. I have been married to one for twenty years, and you need nerves of pure steel and energy to match.

draydee · 26/09/2022 13:47

@bakehimawaytoys hmm not sure about the HBO series lol - I want to watch it now!
But yes I wanted to get the full picture from others who have experience in IB, as I heard about the realities.

@TheMoops Thank you for that advice. I really appreciate it.

What degrees are good for getting a professional career in finances and analyst type roles, that are well respected?

OP posts:
TheMoops · 26/09/2022 13:36

The thing is I think careers advice is dismal. Is there a way to pay for professional careers advice?

His school should be providing him with independent careers advice from a qualified Careers Adviser - if they aren't then they are failing in the statutory duty.

You can pay for this privately if you think your school is failing this this area but beware that basically anyone can call themselves a careers adviser. Look for someone who is qualified to at least a level 6 in advice and guidance but preferably someone who holds a postgraduate qualification in Careers Guidance with professional accreditation.

edwinbear · 26/09/2022 13:35

I work in IB, although not technically an investment banker, I sell interest rate derivatives, but based on the trading floor. DH was an FX trader for nearly 30 yrs (we met at work). There's no nepotism involved, in fact banks are very keen on diversity and inclusion these days, it's much improved from when I started, as one of about 5 women on the floor.

He'll absolutely need a degree, if he wants to trade, most of it is algo based these days, so maths and IT are what they look for. Hours can be brutal as a junior, but as you become more senior, becomes less so - as the juniors do the number crunching. It's not a terribly secure career - DH and I have had 3 redundancies between us, but it can be very lucrative. Bankers are absolutely despised though so he'll need a tough skin!

MrAutumnal · 26/09/2022 13:33

Based on my experience with close family members, there’s no way to get these roles without straights A’s and a 1st class degree at a Russell Group uni or Oxbridge. There will then be additional training such as CFA. Having gone to the right school, playing the right sports etc. also helps. Not saying it’s never happened but I don’t know any IBs who got their via an apprenticeship route.

Huge salary, very long hours (being at your desk from 6.30am) and aggressive competitive environment. Lots of rounds of redundancies. Most IBs I know did it until 40’s then went to do other roles. All very wealthy.

bakehimawaytoys · 26/09/2022 13:31

Has he been watching the HBO series Industry by any chance?

I have friends in investment banking and not in a million years would i encourage my kids to get into it. Widespread drug abuse, brutal performance management and an incredibly high burnout rate. It's especially tough at the junior end. There are other ways to make lots of money.

Puppypads · 26/09/2022 13:31

He is highly, highly unlikely to get into IB without a university degree. I worked in Equities/IB for 15 years. There are occasional exceptions- eg star traders who came in via a non conventional route but most of us were either via the graduate program or lateral hires (poached from another bank).
To be honest it sounds like he doesn't really know what 'investment banking' is. You can work in an investment bank as a banker, trader, analyst, strategist, programmer, HR professional...
The traditional I-banker is usually on a sectoral team eg tech. They work with clients on fund raising, mergers and acquisitions, restructuring of debt etc. lots of power points, spreadsheets, legal docs.
The markets businesses (fixed income, currency, commodities, equities) sell the debt/shares in listed companies to institutional clients.
He will need to be highly numerate, articulate, driven, efficient, and willing to cancel plans pretty much every weekend as some deal looms. He will have to be prepared for the possibility of burnout within 2-3 years. If he makes it to VP after 5 years or so, things get better and he hands over the shit-work to some other poor graduate.

draydee · 26/09/2022 13:30

@Getoff yes exactly why I am posting!

My grandfather was a nuclear engineer, but he is long gone and all the other people with very high paying, interesting professional roles have retired now.

I don't want to let him down by not being able to guide him in a career that he wants to do.

OP posts:
candycaneframe · 26/09/2022 13:27

draydee · 26/09/2022 13:00

Thank you for your replies. I just think that health is wealth and work/life balance in an interesting is more valuable.

He doesn't want to go to university he wants to do a higher level apprenticeship after A levels.

The thing is I think careers advice is dismal. Is there a way to pay for professional careers advice?

He has also mentioned accountancy.

@maxelly he is 16 and starting to think about A level subjects. He is definitely doing Maths and probably Geography and he doesn't know the third subject to do.

I need to ask other people, as I had no guidance and after doing a core subject at uni, I went from one dead end job to another. I didn't have a clue and I don't want that to happen to him.
So although it is early for him to be thinking about careers I am glad that he is asking for guidance.

Well if he doesn't want to do a degree he doesn't really want to become an investment banker.

Getoff · 26/09/2022 13:23

Should have explained, the video specifically addresses the point that most people don't understand what they have to do to get very high-paying jobs.

draydee · 26/09/2022 13:23

@Longbin where do you find open days/weeks?
As I said I have no idea how to navigate professional careers and the schools don't seem to help.

OP posts:
Getoff · 26/09/2022 13:20

Here's a youtube video from someone who started as a trader and retired after about six years. (Although in another of his videos he says that's no longer possible due to changes in the industry.) He was from a poor London background, and only knew what he had to do to get the job because the parents of his Indian schoolfriends told him.

Longbin · 26/09/2022 13:14

@draydee I work at an investment bank but I am not a trader.

I'm not sure if you can go into trading without a degree, you definitely couldn't when I left uni. Other areas would be possible if he could get an apprenticeship but he would need to be applying for open days/weeks now

draydee · 26/09/2022 13:00

Thank you for your replies. I just think that health is wealth and work/life balance in an interesting is more valuable.

He doesn't want to go to university he wants to do a higher level apprenticeship after A levels.

The thing is I think careers advice is dismal. Is there a way to pay for professional careers advice?

He has also mentioned accountancy.

@maxelly he is 16 and starting to think about A level subjects. He is definitely doing Maths and probably Geography and he doesn't know the third subject to do.

I need to ask other people, as I had no guidance and after doing a core subject at uni, I went from one dead end job to another. I didn't have a clue and I don't want that to happen to him.
So although it is early for him to be thinking about careers I am glad that he is asking for guidance.

OP posts:
maxelly · 26/09/2022 12:44

How old is your son OP? It's great to have ambition (whether that's to earn really good money or have a 'prestige' career or work in a specific industry), but the best way to encourage him (assuming he's teens or early 20s) is to encourage him to keep his options open, as at this age they really can have quite narrow views, half of their possible careers options they have no idea whatsoever even exist or don't even exist yet (the world of work is changing so quickly), and they can get strange fixed ideas in their heads, my brightest child who was encouraged by school to consider law wrote it off entirely because she (erroneously) thought being in law meant being a barrister and having to do stirring public speeches in court all the time. When she realized the vast range of different legal careers there are she pivoted and did a law conversion after her first degree, it all worked out great and she now works in mergers and acquisitions for a huge corporate law firm, she basically never even has to set foot in court and certainly no '12 good men' speeches Grin.

My advice to you (and him) would be to get the best grades possible in school, choosing subjects that he is good at and enjoys but also keep his uni options open. Then go to the best uni he can, not necessarily choosing the subject most closely related to what he thinks he'd want to do for a job (with the exception of medicine/dentistry/vet medicine and maybe some forms of engineering you can basically always convert to a more vocational course with a masters or other post-grad study) - yes if he's sure he wants law do law or accounting do accounting, but it's not necessary and if he actually ends up finding it boring and not what he wants then it's a bit of a waste of uni time...

Neolara · 26/09/2022 12:37

Both my brothers were investment bankers after uni. They got paid squillions but basically had no life other than work for about 10 years. They barely saw their kids when the were little. Both now work in other areas and have very interesting jobs with much better work / life balance. They also have enormous houses in very posh parts of London.

Swipe left for the next trending thread