Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask about investment bankers

105 replies

draydee · 26/09/2022 12:18

My DS wants to be an investment banker.

I would like to support him, but is it true there is a lot of nepotism in this industry? Or can an higher level apprenticeship or university suffice if you don't have connections?

Also why do they incite such vitriol?

Is it true they barely sleep and burn out?

I would like to give him the full picture from the experiences of others.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
draydee · 26/09/2022 20:33

@NellyBarney so so helpful thank you. GMAT and BMAT I'm going to Google that! I think he would struggle with IT and has never shown any aptitude for it. But it is definitely worth encouraging him to look into it as another option.

OP posts:
red4321 · 26/09/2022 20:26

I personally think accountancy is harder than investment banking in the beginning, as for accountancy, you need to take several professional exams, so you work full time and then need to study all night, and get paid less than an investment banker, but it's a good qualification and can lead to good jobs.

I found my accountancy exams a lot easier than working in investment banking. But I was lucky to be at one of the large firms that paid for us to study full time for three months of the year. The exams were hard but it was like being at university in terms of socialising but with money.

I'd say it's also easier to get into a Big Four firm than most front office jobs at IBs. But it's a good all round career and you can go into some of the corporate finance or transaction support type divisions within accountancy firms. They don't pay as well as IBs but partners earn a fair whack and I found it a less pressured environment.

NellyBarney · 26/09/2022 20:20

OP, you asked how to go about finding apprenticeships/jobs offerings.
For apprenticeships, google the websites of the firms you are interested directly, most have a 'work for us' tap. If it doesn't say anything about apprenticeships, just email them directly and ask, or do a Google search. All Big Four (that's KPMG, Ernest Young, P&W and Delloite) offer apprenticeships in Accounting, but also in IT. So do most Investment Banks. These big names are massively competitive though, so it's worth to also look at smaller or less flashy firms, places like Nationwide, your local high street accountancy or building society. Or even thr local council for IT apprenticeships. If you tutor already, start practicing standardised tests, like the BMat and GMAT, it's these type of tests that come up at assessments (that's selection events).
If your ds decides to go to university first, subjects like maths and economics are always save options. If he goes to Oxbridge or Russel Group unis, there will be regular career fairs and events, called 'The Milkround', where firms present details of their graduate schemes. It's normal for school leavers or graduates to apply to dozens of openings, so a bit of thick skin and perseverance is important. Studying in a big city, not only London, but also Birmingham or Manchester, is an advantage as it's easier to go to interviews/get work experience/meet recruiting people. I personally think accountancy is harder than investment banking in the beginning, as for accountancy, you need to take several professional exams, so you work full time and then need to study all night, and get paid less than an investment banker, but it's a good qualification and can lead to good jobs. I still think the dand in IT is bigger and earning potential is better. IT in business means either coding (software engineering) or system architecture. System Architecture is much less specific (it's more a theoretical knowledge of what specific computers and software systems do/how they are useful for a company/what and where to purchase), but can lead to very well paid careers.

draydee · 26/09/2022 19:25

@carollo and @AndTwoFilmsByFrancoisTruffaut excuse my ignorance but how do you know how to start careers in these types of roles and even what is available? Did you have people guide you?

OP posts:
AndTwoFilmsByFrancoisTruffaut · 26/09/2022 19:16

carollo · 26/09/2022 19:05

OP, could I suggest your DS looks into fund manager roles? You can earn vast amounts of money (equivalent to investment banking) and the hours are generally 9-5.

I work for a hedge fund and the OP’s son would definitely need a degree to be a hedge fund manager and frequently, an MBA would be a requirement. Fund managers possess a v high level of education. They also start work earlier than 9am in my medium sized fund and often work long hours.

carollo · 26/09/2022 19:05

OP, could I suggest your DS looks into fund manager roles? You can earn vast amounts of money (equivalent to investment banking) and the hours are generally 9-5.

draydee · 26/09/2022 18:36

@mum2bee2022 For the money probably and because he's always been good xxx maths.

It's not just IB though, he said accountancy too. I just asked about IB here as I knew many would have experiences of it and would give the full picture. I thought accountancy was a better idea for him and from the replies here I think I was right.

OP posts:
draydee · 26/09/2022 18:29

@minipie yes I have been looking into these for him since he mentioned being an accountant. I read some of the testimonials and I thought they were really good.

The thing is I am sure every man and his dog applies and you can only try. I imagine the competition is fierce. You need a back up plan for your back up plan if he didn't get accepted by any of them.

I'm not sure who mentioned about their son doing an IT apprenticeship but thank you for the tip. It's great he found something he enjoys with a good salary.

My son has always had a flair for maths. I do pay for a tutor, so I'm not sure if that means he wouldn't be able to do Maths at Uni, as he can't have private tuition for a degree.

I'm not even sure what an IT career is? My DS isn't great at computers I don't think.

I vaguely know someone who is in risk analysis in a bank. I think he has a good work/life balance and is well paid. Not sure what degree you would need for that?

OP posts:
mum2bee2022 · 26/09/2022 17:40

Is he wanting to go into it for the money or does he have a genuine interest in financial markets/ economics etc. If it is just the money he is interested he may struggle.

Sandinmyknickers · 26/09/2022 17:35

draydee · 26/09/2022 15:42

Wow so many good insights. Thank you.

I don't think he should go to university without a profession and a solid career path in mind.

Also, what do people advise their children to do if they aren't A*, First class honours Russel University graduated, gifted academics but are intelligent? Are they all destined for unfulfilling jobs with piss poor salaries?

I completely disagree with the idea that you shouldn't go to uni unless you have a career path in mind.
I had no clue what I wanted to do, but had inklings of areas I was interested in, so went to uni with a subject that played to that. During and post degree, I experimented a bit with various industries and found one I loved. Without my degree I would have found it difficult to enter and having my first degree allowed me to get the relevant qualifications as a 1year masters while working and so I advanced quickly. I wouldn't have had the time or money or start from scratch and get a first degree at that point in time- but a masters was very doable.

urgen · 26/09/2022 17:25

My DS's friend aged 25 had an Economics Degree from
LSE and had two A*'s and an A.

They both went to a private boarding school but son's friend was as sharp as anything.
Knew that the company would have his life for x years whilst he was building himself up.

Works in London, has little spare time but knew this from the get go.

In a virtual fight or even a real fight I wouldnt bet against this chap. He is driven but very charming to me (so that's OK!)

You almost need to have it in your blood. As for that video - words fail me.
If you want to earn lots of money go for it but there will be a high price to pay for it.

You dont earn £200k plus for just turning up.

YumYummy · 26/09/2022 17:12

really? My experience is different. Definitely much easier later in life, with a supportive employer and being able to apply real world situations to hypothetical models. (DD was 6 months old when I started my degree and I worked full time throughout
I went to uni the month my DC started school and my DH graduated at 29. I have lots of friends unable to go later in life or able to go but have reasons not to.

TheMoops · 26/09/2022 17:10

I don't think he should go to university without a profession and a solid career path in mind

Actually university is perfect for academic people with no career path ( really outdated term anyway!) as it is a great opportunity to get a qualification, experience and be exposed to lots of different opportunities which enhance employability and gives people breathing space to make decisions while developing skills employers love!

80% of graduate jobs don't ask for a specific degree subject. They look for graduates who possess particular attributes and skills which tend to be developed as part of a university education.

deedledeedledum · 26/09/2022 17:08

Kissingfrogs25 · 26/09/2022 13:47

Op he won't even get an interview without an amazing and glittering degree from Oxford, Cambridge or Harvard or similar, at masters level minimum and that might get you an interview if you are of the best calibre. Being well qualified won't be enough, you also have to have high energy, capable of serious and fast decision making and be razor sharp. You don't get paid millions to be average.

Yes you work hard (you can do long hours in any job) but you will be extremely well paid and have opportunities that would not be available elsewhere.

If he hasn't achieved straight As in his A levels and is not going to a world class university then he might be better attempting the research route or similar.

Everyone wants to be an investment banker but very few make it. I have been married to one for twenty years, and you need nerves of pure steel and energy to match.

Oh stop it. I know friends dc who went to Bath, SOAS, UCL and Notts and even one who went to Bristol West of England who all got onto graduate schemes in the past 3 years.

deedledeedledum · 26/09/2022 17:03

@maxelly interesting your take on the whole Oxbridge thing. Exactly zero if the heads of global departments or Chief execs I know or know if of several leading IBs are oxbridge grads. Several are from South Africa, Australia and US (non Ivy) Swiss, French... the Brits are a mixed bag. I can think of one who went to a second tier Scottish uni, oh actually I can think of one Oxbridge grad come to think of it. But only one. I know two heads of a global division who didn't go to uni at all!

Worldgonecrazy · 26/09/2022 17:02

YumYummy · 26/09/2022 16:45

So what is stopping them getting one?
Having a mortgage to pay, looking after elderly parents, full time jobs, DC, life, it’s so much easier to get a degree when you are younger.

Really? My experience is different. Definitely much easier later in life, with a supportive employer and being able to apply real world situations to hypothetical models. (DD was 6 months old when I started my degree and I worked full time throughout. )

move known a couple of people who went from GCSE into work, then straight to MBA at a Red brick, though of course, they are quite exceptional at what they do.

Yo get back on point, I would encourage the young man to consider why he wants to work in IB, researching relevant hard and soft skills, and where he might fit. His research may well take him down a different avenue but at least it would be an informed decision and he can decide whether to get into work with an employer who is supportive of external examinations, such as relevant banking exams, or whether he really would be better going straight to university and focusing his efforts on making relevant connections there.

minipie · 26/09/2022 17:01

The only realistic option if he does not want to go to University is an apprenticeship. Big 4 offer this (School Leavers program)

Yes, I would really really recommend he looks at the opportunities offered by the big accountancy firms. They are trying to increase less traditional intake routes and do offer apprenticeships, also extensive (paid) work experience programmes. I think they may have options where they pay for your uni fees in return for you working for them during holidays and for a while afterwards.

As a qualified accountant he will always have a wide range of career options. I have known newly qualified accountants who shifted across to investment banking and were able to skip the early (most brutal) years of IB - if it turns out he is still interested in IB by that stage.

I agree with the comments upthread about IB, except for the drugs - not seen that.

Crikeyalmighty · 26/09/2022 16:58

@draydee if your young adult is not an A grade student but is bright and sharp I would advise them to go into IT via apprenticeship. My son is very bright and well rounded but has ADHD and although he got 8 decent GCSEs including a couple of As he struggled above that as he couldn't apply himself enough. He did an IT apprenticeship in Networks and comms plus a BTEC , has moved around a bit and at 24 is on £36k , works in London and is fantastic with clients with 7 years work now under his belt. He could probably earn a bit more but got told it's likely to be £40k within 18 months and he likes the MSP that he works for.

MsPincher · 26/09/2022 16:54

CookieDoughKid · 26/09/2022 16:48

It is a brutal industry and you need to be highly ambitious. As well as knowledgeable, numerical and agree to have no life. If no degree then you will need exceptional work experience doing something that proves your worth . A lot of Alpha personality in these job roles.

Yes it’s extremely competitive and lots of alpha males. Quite a few maths grads in my bank - does he like maths?

MsPincher · 26/09/2022 16:52

I used to work in an investment bank but not as a trader. I would say that it’s quite rare that I came across non oxbridge degrees never mind non graduates. Might just have been my bank though

Madamecastafiore · 26/09/2022 16:49

DH isn't an investment banker but works in banking (I used to work in investment banking) he advises students to do engineering degrees as they are looking outside of the usual economics graduates as it's a lot more to do with algorithms these days apparently.

He has advised DC to do IT he said they're literally crying out for decent committed IT staff and they're the ones getting the pick of the jobs and being paid bundles. DC of course isn't at all interested.

CookieDoughKid · 26/09/2022 16:48

It is a brutal industry and you need to be highly ambitious. As well as knowledgeable, numerical and agree to have no life. If no degree then you will need exceptional work experience doing something that proves your worth . A lot of Alpha personality in these job roles.

YumYummy · 26/09/2022 16:45

So what is stopping them getting one?
Having a mortgage to pay, looking after elderly parents, full time jobs, DC, life, it’s so much easier to get a degree when you are younger.

Madamecastafiore · 26/09/2022 16:43

There's a lot less nepotism these days. It's a lot less jobs for the boys and only hiring the crème de la crème with relevant degrees after pretty in-depth recruitment processes. Hours are long and the stress is off the charts.

ColeensBoot · 26/09/2022 16:41

Well there is a reason why the cockney phrase is 'merchant banker' for wanker.