Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To expect a call from the boss - turned down

85 replies

AndImFeelingBlue · 26/09/2022 11:30

Last few months boss has been prepping me for a big promotion. Lots of support. Lots of competition (internal and external). But also lots of 'no one could do this job better'.

I don't know why I listened so much as I knew he wasn't on the interview panel. But he's very senior and his opinion well regarded.

I started being an idiot and started thinking the job was mine.

We need the money. I am the earner in the house - I feel this pressure to provide for my kids and my DH (who does work but part time). I wanted to be the 'career one'.

Anyway - the recruitment consultant they'd hired in to oversee the process called me at 8am (OUCH) to say I hadn't got it. When I saw them calling at 8am I thought it would be good news - call before everyone gets in kind of thing. But it wasn't. It's gone to someone external with 15 yrs more experience.

No call from the boss. From the panel. From anyone. Just a hired consultant who said 'tough luck' and now I'm just getting on with my day, doing my job, and just had to go off a meeting early because I started to cry (I hid it).

Problem is they think I'm not ready, so me crying or being annoyed is only gonna make them think I'm immature.

I just have been working on this for weeks/months - I've read everything there is to read, prepared so hard, worked so many evenings, and has this boss in my ear saying how it's basically my job...

And now..nothing.

I had been saying to DH 'Ah the extra money is going to make us all be able to relax a little etc' and I just feel I've let everyone down.

Any words of wisdom. Do I just leave? Or try to? Or am I being spoilt? It was never my job. I just thought someone might call me to talk to me today.

OP posts:
Timetoeat · 26/09/2022 13:19

Hi, sorry you didn't get this job this time. I think it was unfair of your boss to tell you that it was "Basically your job" if they actually had no input into the decision.
Feel upset and annoyed for a day. Tomorrow, start again. Think about if you would like to look for a job that you missed out on ,elsewhere, or stay where you are,and gain more experience.

ThirtyThreeTrees · 26/09/2022 13:18

I was in the same boat a few months back. Everyone told me that I was pretty much guaranteed the role.

I was gutted but when I say who was appointed, it was clearly a more experienced choice so it was easier to accept.

I did however ask for a pay review as past of the feedback sessions and got one.

Be totally positive in how you handle this and tey pay negotiation. Don't mention anything negative etc.

tinglymint · 26/09/2022 13:14

I feel your pain as I had similar!

Lots of encouragement from my manager and his manager. Told I'd be great blah blah blah.

Found the lengthy interview process quite stressful.

They hired someone external who was technically in a more senior role to me (they'd been in it 6 months, then put on furlough, then made redundant). He interviewed really well.

Turns out he's not as amazing at the job as they thought he'd be and his probation was extended after he received a few tellings off from our manager.

I privately gloat.

XmasElf10 · 26/09/2022 13:06

Ouch I bet that stings.

I'd suggest being gracious to the new guy but also looking around for other opportunities. Normally the best way to improve pay / reach the next level is to apply externally. It's totally crazy but most companies have much better budget to offer as part of recruitment than promotions. Certainly my budget for recruitment to replace someone who left always let's me offer more salary than I could ever have given the outgoing team member.

Good luck!

GnomeDePlume · 26/09/2022 12:54

That is tough.

The advice to take today to feel what you feel then to get back on tomorrow is good.

I have had similar happen. Boss walked out one day and I was left to cover her role and my own for the better part of two years. I was eventually promised an improvement to my package. After a few months I got an increase of less than £3k to do two people's jobs.

Has the senior manager been using you to take some of the load off him? Seen that happen all in the guise of mentoring.

Eventually I left the company and got a pay increase of 50%.

PaterPower · 26/09/2022 12:54

The successful candidate may not accept, or might be convinced by their current employer to stay with them. It’s not necessarily all over yet.

But I agree with the PP suggesting that you start looking at external opportunities.

HangOnToYourself · 26/09/2022 12:53

First of all please dont feel you have let anybody down. You are being so hard on yourself but ultimately you cant control these things. I'd consider your next steps based on how much you want to stay with your current organisation. If you arent that fussed I'd look at external postings, moving companies is generally the best way to get a decent pay rise anyway

SleeplessInEngland · 26/09/2022 12:53

LoisLane66 · 26/09/2022 12:48

If your DH worries about money, why doesn't he pull his finger out and get a full time job?

This is MN at its worst. The OP hasn't written in regarding her DH, just that she's sad not to have gotten a job and the lack of follow-up from management.

Leftbutcameback · 26/09/2022 12:51

That's such a tough thing to happen, and you're not being unreasonable to expect a call from the boss. To at least commiserate with you. Is it possible your boss doesn't know yet?

LoisLane66 · 26/09/2022 12:48

If your DH worries about money, why doesn't he pull his finger out and get a full time job?

SleeplessInEngland · 26/09/2022 12:43

That's tough. It at least souns like you lost out to someone who would be good at it rather than office politics.

AgathaMystery · 26/09/2022 12:42

I absolutely agree with giving yourself to grieve the 'what if' - I was in an almost identical position myself in July & I wanted the job so, so badly I could taste it. It didn't help that everyone at the organisation seemed to want me so, so badly too. It was a grueling experience & when I got the email to say I hadn't got it I absolutely fell apart for the whole day - and for about a week actually. It has taken me a long time to move on & actually, i'm not there yet.

Your boss will be feeling mortified for you. I know they will - they just don't know how to reach out. It did help me that some of my panel rang me, they didn't need to and it showed a bit of class and empathy - I am sorry they haven't reached out to you.

I also wanted to say I am sorry about the financials too. 'My' job would have been life changing for us & as it is, we are now staring into a void really. I'm so sorry - it really is so dangerous to allow ourselves that little chink of hope isn't it? I totally empathise with you & I really feel for you. Allow yourself a wallow for this one, you've earned it x

nettie434 · 26/09/2022 12:41

It's a real shame about the job but you shouldn't feel you have let your family down when an external candidate with much more experience was appointed. It's great that your boss has so much faith in you but as he wasn't on the interview panel, he won't have seen the applications. He let you down by giving you the wrong impression that the job was yours. He could do with a refresher course on equal opportunities and good employment practice. Your DH has let you down because there is too much reliance on your earnings in your household.

You are clearly ambitious, hardworking and talented. You will get promoted in the future.

Always2ndtime · 26/09/2022 12:33

I was in a similar position just over a year ago.

Boss had put in their notice, prepped me for taking over. Interviewed and someone else got given it out the blue (they had an awful reputation).

Worst thing was I had to "cover" the position for 3 months due to a delayed start date. Basically feeling I wasn't good enough to be given the job but good enough to hold the Fort!

Then less than 12 month later, new person couldn't hack it, and I am now in the position.

Don't give up all hope, take all the learning opportunities you can. And when the time is right, you will get there!

Icanstillrecallourlastsummer · 26/09/2022 12:13

I can understand you are disappointed, but it was an interview process so the job was never yours. You should reframe though, this is not something you are lost, you've not let anyone down, it's jsut something you dont have yet.

I think if it were me I would take a little time to dust off my feathers and then look at what you want to achieve and, realistically, by when. If you can't see that advancement in your own company could you find it elsewhere? As others say, often the best route of progression is through changing employers.

As an aside, if you feel too much pressure being the "earner", could you OH pick up more work?

AloysiusBear · 26/09/2022 12:13

If the person who got the job has 15 years more experience than you, did you really have the necessary experience?

I think the lesson to be learned here is to always take this stuff with a pinch of salt, everyone else has their own agenda. Ask yourself what is on their agenda and how you fit into that.

jeaux90 · 26/09/2022 12:10

I'm sorry you didn't get the job. All of that hard work wasn't for nothing.

The best pay rise you can get is when you negotiate a new package, a new company, so once you've given yourself a chance to be sad or annoyed, get some feedback and start looking outside.

I've been in tech for 25 years and am senior, and the best way to get ahead in my world is 3 or 4 year stints, move up into a new company and then do it again.

Not sure whether that would work in your field but often the best salary increase you get is when you join new rather than promoted within.

mamabear715 · 26/09/2022 12:07

You've had some wonderfully supportive posts. I can't do any better, just sending hugs & letting you know that tomorrow will be different. You did well, hugs. x

Rosehugger · 26/09/2022 12:05

It must have been very disappointing, OP. Most people would now look for a job elsewhere - sometimes you get pigeon-holed as "not promotion material" in one place, and another workplace can be completely different. Often it just comes down to personalities. And sexism, still plenty of that around.

KitBumbleB · 26/09/2022 12:04

So sorry OP.

I was in a very similar position recently, all nudge nudge wink wink and then... rejected
Feedback was lack of experience despite my years of experience and the fact that they knew exactly what experience I had when I applied.

My point being, you may not get good feedback or closure, try and be proud if yourself for getting this far.

endofthelinefinally · 26/09/2022 12:01

Thank them for the interview and ask for feedback. Be gracious but start looking around for other opportunities. Maybe this wasn't your time, but your time will come.

CMOTDibbler · 26/09/2022 12:00

That absolutely sucks. I got through to the last 2 after a 6 month application process only to find that the person who got it was moving sideways from an unrelated position. And then I have to report into them, and support them in learning all the stuff that they never had to deal with.
I put a lot into the process, and the way the recruiting manager treated me after left a very bad taste in my mouth. But onwards and upwards and I have the confidence to apply for senior posts now - but outside the organisation

DisforDarkChocolate · 26/09/2022 11:57

I so know how you feel.

Give yourself 24 hours and evaluate where you're at. Do you need to train, volunteer, mentor, move on? Some places just don't recruit internally, especially when they have paid a recruitment consultant.

The preparation will not be wasted unless you let this get to you. Manage the disappointment we'll and it will improve your reputation. Good luck.

Shoxfordian · 26/09/2022 11:54

Ah that’s a shame op but you shouldn’t count your chickens in future for jobs. Put all your upset into applying for other jobs today, all your energy into a new job and you’ll get something else

Ziegfeld · 26/09/2022 11:52

Sorry OP, it’s horrid missing out on a job

If I were your boss, I would consider it great that you care about your career and put a massive effort in to this process. He obviously thinks you have good stuff because he’s encouraged you to go for it. However (unfortunately) male bosses in particular are very quick to judge women for being “too emotional”, especially if they think you might be directing any emotion in their direction.

If I were you, I would take the day to rage internally/at home, and then tomorrow when you have slept on it, make an appointment with him to ask him what other opportunities might be coming up and what more you can work on to get that promotion next time. It sends the message that you care, you are determined and you appreciate his help and his opinion.

Swipe left for the next trending thread