Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To expect a call from the boss - turned down

85 replies

AndImFeelingBlue · 26/09/2022 11:30

Last few months boss has been prepping me for a big promotion. Lots of support. Lots of competition (internal and external). But also lots of 'no one could do this job better'.

I don't know why I listened so much as I knew he wasn't on the interview panel. But he's very senior and his opinion well regarded.

I started being an idiot and started thinking the job was mine.

We need the money. I am the earner in the house - I feel this pressure to provide for my kids and my DH (who does work but part time). I wanted to be the 'career one'.

Anyway - the recruitment consultant they'd hired in to oversee the process called me at 8am (OUCH) to say I hadn't got it. When I saw them calling at 8am I thought it would be good news - call before everyone gets in kind of thing. But it wasn't. It's gone to someone external with 15 yrs more experience.

No call from the boss. From the panel. From anyone. Just a hired consultant who said 'tough luck' and now I'm just getting on with my day, doing my job, and just had to go off a meeting early because I started to cry (I hid it).

Problem is they think I'm not ready, so me crying or being annoyed is only gonna make them think I'm immature.

I just have been working on this for weeks/months - I've read everything there is to read, prepared so hard, worked so many evenings, and has this boss in my ear saying how it's basically my job...

And now..nothing.

I had been saying to DH 'Ah the extra money is going to make us all be able to relax a little etc' and I just feel I've let everyone down.

Any words of wisdom. Do I just leave? Or try to? Or am I being spoilt? It was never my job. I just thought someone might call me to talk to me today.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
goldfinchonthelawn · 27/09/2022 16:55

LindseyHoyleSpeaks · 27/09/2022 16:28

Of course you don’t take the booby prize! No way would I do this - they don’t want you for the proper role but they’re happy to have you act up and then presumably do a handover to the new person. Honestly, get some self respect! They’ve treated you appallingly. Go off sick with stress or at least quietly quit and look for something else. Ask yourself why you’re happy to have the dregs. You are worth so much more!

I wouldn't see it that way. I'd see it as a chance to move up to the role elsewhere with solid experience. OP would deserve better pay, and should start applying for similar roles elsewhere at a higher salary once she's done this one for 6 weeks. I know loads of people who moved away from one workplace to get promoted and then moved back at a much more senior role than if they had stayed. It shows ambition.

LindseyHoyleSpeaks · 27/09/2022 16:28

Of course you don’t take the booby prize! No way would I do this - they don’t want you for the proper role but they’re happy to have you act up and then presumably do a handover to the new person. Honestly, get some self respect! They’ve treated you appallingly. Go off sick with stress or at least quietly quit and look for something else. Ask yourself why you’re happy to have the dregs. You are worth so much more!

Sophieagain1984 · 27/09/2022 15:59

Please stop asking if you're 'spoilt' - that's language for a small child expecting too many sweeties, not a grown adult talking about her career. Can you imagine a man using that sort of language about a potential promotion he'd done a lot of work towards?

Agree with this- it's not the right word or the right way to think about yourself. It's not spoilt not to want to be misled about your prospects of promotion nor to think twice before taking on an interim role in addition to your existing role. It might be useful to break down what you actually mean a bit.

badgermushrooms · 27/09/2022 14:10

Is your company known for being needlessly bureaucratic? I think asking you to interview again is a bit of a piss take to be honest but if they're always like this and the culture is to just roll your eyes and get on with it I might do it if I were you. But if you're offered the interim role, also start looking elsewhere while you're doing it - I think I would feel very huffy and resentful to get bumped back down after 4 months of doing a senior role well and it would inevitably come across in my work.

Please stop asking if you're 'spoilt' - that's language for a small child expecting too many sweeties, not a grown adult talking about her career. Can you imagine a man using that sort of language about a potential promotion he'd done a lot of work towards?

rookiemere · 27/09/2022 13:55

It is possible that your boss knows but is leaving time for you to get through your emotions on the outcome.

On the interim role, I'd firstly ask for feedback on your interview. I'd also politely ask if they were able to use your responses for the interim post. It may be possible that your responses didn't allow them to score you highly enough, but either way it's good to know.

If they definitively say you have to interview for the interim position I'd ask for a few days to think about what you want to do.

Youaremysunshine14 · 27/09/2022 13:47

No way would I interview all over again just for a four-month interim role! I'd be inclined to go back and say to HR that if I didn't demonstrate during the previous process that I could ably stand in as the interim person, I'm not sure there's much point going through it all again. Plus, you'll be doing two jobs, only for the new person to swan in and take over in Feb. Nah, bugger that, say no and keep looking elsewhere.

WireSkills · 27/09/2022 13:41

purplecorkheart · 27/09/2022 12:10

I probably would go for it in case the other person drops out. There own work place may make them a good offer to keep them.

^This.

It's odd that they want to re-interview you for a position that's a) temporary; and b) you've already interviewed for.

That said, we've lost a few potential employees lately to counter offers. There are so few employees to fill some jobs at the moment that counter offers are king. The one successful recruit we have taken on was counter offered too and told they would give him £10k more than we were offering, without even knowing what that was. He chose us for the potential for progression, not money.

There is a good chance that there will be a counter offer and the position will become available again.

The non-filling of your current role temporarily is the biggest issue. Do you have a team that your responsibilities could be shared amongst?

CantGetDecentNickname · 27/09/2022 13:37

I'd still ask to go through your interview with them to see which areas you did not perform so well on. It can help you to improve your answers for the next interview.

CantGetDecentNickname · 27/09/2022 13:35

I'd go for it and wait until you have it before telling them that you cannot do two jobs so will just be doing the new one for now and will happily hand the old one over to whoever is taking it on. Be firm about this as no-one can do two jobs for long without getting to burnout and they've no right to expect it. It may be that they will split your old job between several others which is fine. Just have good handover notes ready. This is a good opportunity for you to gain the experience and have it on your CV to either apply in the future (or if the new hire doesn't show) or apply elsewhere.
Good luck

Stripyhoglets1 · 27/09/2022 13:19

I'd say I'd do the interim role but not be interviewed again for it as seems pointless when you answered the questions last week!
I'd also be looking elsewhere while doing the interim role to see if you can put all your hard work to permanent benefit for you.

Lemons1571 · 27/09/2022 13:19

You also need to know if there’s anything that they want to see in an interview that you didn’t do last time. No point them interviewing you again then saying “oh you still didn’t show us evidence of x y and z”. You’re not a mind reader.

trilbydoll · 27/09/2022 13:13

I would say you are interested but I wouldn't be very enthusiastic about interviewing again - I'd say something like yes absolutely but is it possible for you to make your selection based on my performance in the interview last week?

Interviews are a huge drain on everyone's time so I'm sure the panel aren't desperate to watch you answer the same questions again!

Lemons1571 · 27/09/2022 13:09

icelolly12 · 27/09/2022 12:56

If you were aware that external candidates were being interviewed and that your manager wasn't on the panel I think ti was a bit arrogant to assume the position was yours tbh.

Imagine if you had got it and the other candidate posted here: fifteen years more experience blah blah but of course it went to the less qualified/experienced internal candidate. Too many jobs are earmarked fort internal candidates and the interviews just waste everyone's time.

It sounds like it was a fair process and the job went to the most suitable candidate.

She didn’t just assume though.

Management led her to believe that it was a foregone conclusion. Coffees where they had discussions about backfilling her role? Of course you would assume that you’re pretty much planned to be in the role.

AppleBag · 27/09/2022 13:05

If you were aware that external candidates were being interviewed and that your manager wasn't on the panel I think ti was a bit arrogant to assume the position was yours tbh.

Very helpful 🙄

Clarinet1 · 27/09/2022 13:02

Well, based on your previous update I was going to say that it sounds as if the company doesn’t really have a clear direction of travel planned in all sorts of ways and you might be well out of it but now I think take the interim role in the meantime - you could learn a lot and there’s nothing to stop you continuing to job hunt externally.

Then again, I have a bit of a history of being people’s second choice for jobs and getting brought back - the original hire didn’t work out/there was a second opening etc. A lot of what it really boils down to is how much you like the company which kind of bring us back to the first point!

Confusion101 · 27/09/2022 12:59

AndImFeelingBlue · 27/09/2022 12:07

OK - I would LOVE all your thoughts on this (esp @Lemons1571 as someone who has been through this)

The external person has many months notice on their contract and won't start until Feb 23. They have asked me to interview again to be the interim person (there may be other internal people who want the job too on temp basis). There is no plan for backfilling my current role so far so inevitably I would be doing both.

Better money for 4 months, experience but also a total shit show. And I don't want to have all that stress of doing 2 jobs for 4 months.

But will I look spoilt? Should I go for it in case the other person drops out or is rubbish and I have proven myself?

Also - interviewing us all again for the interim role. REALLY?

Any words of wisdom??

You could always go for the interview and still consider the job. by the time they ring you and offer you the job, you'll have had more time to think about whether the extra stress is worth the money for you and your family. It gives you a bit more time.

icelolly12 · 27/09/2022 12:56

If you were aware that external candidates were being interviewed and that your manager wasn't on the panel I think ti was a bit arrogant to assume the position was yours tbh.

Imagine if you had got it and the other candidate posted here: fifteen years more experience blah blah but of course it went to the less qualified/experienced internal candidate. Too many jobs are earmarked fort internal candidates and the interviews just waste everyone's time.

It sounds like it was a fair process and the job went to the most suitable candidate.

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 27/09/2022 12:42

In your shoes I’d take the interim role if offered and at the same time apply elsewhere

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 27/09/2022 12:40

I have had similar in my job. A promotion Id done everything to put the work in for, and had people saying was mine. Also really need the money - I’m a single parent.

Didnt get it - two others deemed to have “done more” although that seemed very subjective.

My problem is I’m sort of “over ready” for the job - I’ve been deemed ready for it for about 3/4 years but never quite as good as some one else, apparently, and now been overtaken.

I’m going elsewhere. Can’t stay there stagnating and becoming less and less promotable.

HangOnToYourself · 27/09/2022 12:39

I would probably take it if offered as it gives you some experience on your cv of doing the role so you can be looking externally in the meantime. Bit ridiculous to interview again for it tho, I would also contact them and ask if your previous interview cannot be used

AppleBag · 27/09/2022 12:32

I would go for it but make sure at least some of your old job is being covered by someone else or else work out how you can prune your old role to make it doable with the new one (presumably there's a bit of duplication somewhere).

I would also be unhappy to be interviewed again. Have you had any feedback beyond that the other person had more experience? Was there anyone else in the running internally who might legitimately expect to be considered for the interim role or are they just ass-covering?

Lemons1571 · 27/09/2022 12:16

Yes to going for it, blow them away with how good you are (appreciate this is bloody difficult mentally as you’re only one day in). Anything could happen - the new starter might be hedging their bets with other interviews and never start at all. You’ll be gutted then if a different internal candidate gets this role on a permanent basis.

No to doing both jobs at once. They need to reallocate sensibly and have a plan for doing so. Or drop non essential tasks for 4 months (probably find no one misses them)

Is there anyone there that you can have a confidential chat with, about how all this is being handled?

MrsArrDee · 27/09/2022 12:16

Go for it. I'm in an interim post now covering for my manager who is on secondment. If you get it, you will learn so much in a short space of time. The experience you'll gain is invaluable.

Milesty1 · 27/09/2022 12:15

But I would absolutely want some assurance that they will try and cover some of your old role somehow, maybe someone lower down that wants to step up?

Milesty1 · 27/09/2022 12:14

Ooh just saw update. I would definitely express interest. Maybe you could contact HR and explain you have already interviewed and can that interview not be used? I don’t see why not if it’s exactly the same role