Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Niece + Nephew didn't say thank you for birthday money

137 replies

Irishfarmer · 26/09/2022 10:37

That pretty much AIBU that they didn't say thanks?

My niece + nephew both turned 18 in August. I posed them each a card with €40 but I never heard anything back. I was then down home at party over the weekend and met them. I was chatting to them and asked how their birthdays went, they celebrated together, and said 'did my cards arrive', niece 'ya it did', nephew just nodded. I'm a bit pissed off that they didn't say it did, thank you. It's a while since I was 18 but I am fairly sure I said thanks when someone gave me a card with money!

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
pfs · 03/10/2022 13:13

I doubt the money was stole from both cards. It just seems very unlikely

this, it amazes me the excuses that come up on mn over these situations. Like when a poster says she didn't get an invite people say ''perhaps it got lost in the post/''' MMm very unlikely.

Or when people don't get invites people say ''ask them why not.'' In real like it's never simple to do that and it looks needy.

Irishfarmer · 03/10/2022 11:35

I doubt the money was stole from both cards. It just seems very unlikely. They don't live in the same house they are cousins not brother/sister.

OP posts:
SparklingLime · 01/10/2022 09:01

I don’t understand “I have sent thanks and they have done too.“ @Canthave2manycats ?

Canthave2manycats · 01/10/2022 00:33

I don't recall ever getting a direct 'thanks' from any of my nieces or nephews for money sent to them for whatever. I have sent thanks and they have done too.

The one that slightly irks me is, a cousin's DD. Ordinarily we would have been invited to at least the evening 'do' but with Covid, it wasn't an option. However, 2 years + after the wedding, I am still waiting for a 'thank you' for the fairly generous present, even though my cousin has messaged to say that the gift has been used and much admired!

SparklingLime · 29/09/2022 01:23

Mariposista · 28/09/2022 21:45

I just don't get how anyone could do it. If writing a card and sticking it in the post is too onerous, couldn't they at least manage a quick 5 minute phonecall?

She’d love that, but only expects a text. When she raised it my sis gave her a little lecture on how fussing about thank yous is so wrong.

caringcarer · 29/09/2022 00:37

I never put money in cards anymore just pop it straight into their bank accounts. I hate rude children. My dgc get birthday gifts sent to them by all 4 of my sisters. I would be furious if my dd did not thank her Aunties. She usually sends a photo of birthday boy and the eldest writes thank you and youngest draws a picture and she writes on address and adds a thank you for your kind gift. My nieces and nephews all either text or ring to thank me for birthday money. Manners cost nothing and will get you a long way in life. There is just no excuse for rude ungrateful behaviour. Children should be brought up to thank those who do them a kindness, like open a door for them or make them a drink.

Batiqueattic · 29/09/2022 00:02

My niece & nephew were the same. I said (texted coz am a bit cowardly) the next gift you don't thank me for will be the last I ever send you. And it was. I still see them. We still get on. It's as tho it either didn't happen or that's just normal behaviour. Sad, really. They just seem apathetic about everything.

PermanentTemporary · 28/09/2022 23:21

I would actually prefer a phone call, both to me and to elderly relatives (I suppose I am the elderly relative now). Beats me how people can be ok not doing it.

Mariposista · 28/09/2022 21:45

SparklingLime · 28/09/2022 10:20

Exactly this. I feel so bad for my elderly mum when she doesn’t get any kind of thank you. It’s a real effort for her to buy, wrap and send a present and then… silence.

I just don't get how anyone could do it. If writing a card and sticking it in the post is too onerous, couldn't they at least manage a quick 5 minute phonecall?

simonwiseman · 28/09/2022 19:55

Can i be your God son..........I have never God parents 😓
But seriously, you should not stress, people just use and abuse.
It's honest people like you and I that keep the world steady. xx

simonwiseman · 28/09/2022 19:51

A recognizing would have been nice. But, the kids/young adults of today think they are deserved. Don't take it to heart, even though I know it hurts you, next year don't even give them cards.....what goes around etc.

Jill84 · 28/09/2022 19:46

I had a similar thing, have always given my god daughter birthday and xmas gifts. Went to alot of effort during the first lockdown to make her a lovely, pretty expensive, hamper delivered to her house for her 10th birthday (whilst on furlough, not earning A great deal) and didn't even get a thank you from her or her parents, so haven't given anything since. And they have stopped giving gifts to my kids too. Makes my life easier tbh, but still a shame! I thank everyone for gifts given to any of my family, its the way I was brought up!

SpringSparrow · 28/09/2022 16:08

I’d ask them if they’d actually received the money. My husband’s aunt sent my children cash in a card and the envelope arrived ripped with the money missing. I think it happens a lot.

ddl1 · 28/09/2022 16:01

LuckySantangelo35 · 28/09/2022 10:47

Why are there so many rude young adults??

I don't think that rudeness is linked to a specific age. Young teenagers are perhaps particularly likely to be rude (and always were) but I've known rude young adults, and rude older adults, and polite young adults, and polite older adults.

pfs · 28/09/2022 10:52

Why are there so many rude young adults

just look at this thread, mn and society in general, Rudeness comes at all ages love x

LuckySantangelo35 · 28/09/2022 10:47

Why are there so many rude young adults??

pfs · 28/09/2022 10:30

*Also it just doesn’t matter. If everyone else gave you hundreds of pounds for a gift and one auntie gave you £20 you still say thank you for my £100 grandma, thank you for my £20 auntie. Even if it was normal in your family to be given hundreds it doesn’t mean you don’t have to thank somebody for a ‘lesser’ gift.

I’d find it very rude and I’d be considering ending gift giving now - if they haven’t learned to say thank you by age 18 I doubt they’ll suddenly realise at 19*

exactly again an Irish person I received a laptop for my 21st, this was from all my siblings and my parents and it must have being 50-60 euro each at most.

My friends gave me a card whith about 150 euro between 8 of them or so at my 21st. But 500 quid-this never happens.

Last year at my birthday my mum sent me 2 cadburys caramel bars-about 3 quid in total and I was very grateful. Other years I got a euromillions ticket from family worth about a fiver and very grateful.

pfs · 28/09/2022 10:26

This year I didn't get one single thank you, like it's just expected I'll be sending it. I've told my DSs that this is the last year I'm doing it ( I don't have DC) and won't expect anything for birthdays either. It's so rude to not even get a thanks

I recall at aged 11 I went away on a week seaside trip with my mum's best friend and sister. Their 2 nephews came too-one aged 12, the other 17.

When we got back I was in my mum's friends house waiting to be picked up, the 2 nephews had gone home. My mum's friend was on the phone to her brother, father of the 2 boys, and she said ''we took your sons everywhere, cooked them dinner and bent over backways for them and not one thank you or they wouldn't as much as offer us 1 of their sweets when they bought them. You have raised 2 selfish ungrateful and spoilt sons''. And she hung up the phone.

I was shocked and said ''thank you for the holiday.''. She said ''you don't have to as you thanked us all holiday and even bought us a present, you have manners, it's my 2 nephews that don't and you don't have to apologise for them.''

SparklingLime · 28/09/2022 10:20

Mariposista · 28/09/2022 09:59

My gran sent my cousin money every Xas and birthday and she never got a thank you. Cousin lives in the USA so she rarely saw her, so a phone call would hardly have killed her (I still write thank you notes and will make my kids do it too).
Breaks my heart to think of my gran going down town to get the money out the bank and exchange it, knowing it will just be spent with no thank you.

Exactly this. I feel so bad for my elderly mum when she doesn’t get any kind of thank you. It’s a real effort for her to buy, wrap and send a present and then… silence.

Kanaloa · 28/09/2022 10:17

pfs · 28/09/2022 10:06

How do people in poverty manage that? Just get further into debt? Madness

again I am Irish and this poster is fill of shit, at birthdays we gave each other a lotto ticket or scratch cards or something small. I've yet to see anybody give or receive near to 500 quid as a present. It's nonsense.

Also it just doesn’t matter. If everyone else gave you hundreds of pounds for a gift and one auntie gave you £20 you still say thank you for my £100 grandma, thank you for my £20 auntie. Even if it was normal in your family to be given hundreds it doesn’t mean you don’t have to thank somebody for a ‘lesser’ gift.

I’d find it very rude and I’d be considering ending gift giving now - if they haven’t learned to say thank you by age 18 I doubt they’ll suddenly realise at 19.

pfs · 28/09/2022 10:15

I'm still waiting on a thank you from my cousin for her wedding present over a year ago so I'm guessing nobody says thank you any more

Weddings are somewhat different as you go to the wedding itself so it wouldn't bother me somebody not saying thanks and you leave the present there. But it's different when you post it especially to a birthday.

Thedogscollar · 28/09/2022 10:09

YADNBU @Irishfarmer
They were very rude. You receive a gift it's just basic good manners to say thank you.
I stopped giving my nieces n nephews birthday gifts at 21 years old. They were given £100. They are now adults and therefore do not require gifts every birthday.

pfs · 28/09/2022 10:06

How do people in poverty manage that? Just get further into debt? Madness

again I am Irish and this poster is fill of shit, at birthdays we gave each other a lotto ticket or scratch cards or something small. I've yet to see anybody give or receive near to 500 quid as a present. It's nonsense.

pfs · 28/09/2022 10:03

In Ireland it's customary to be extremely generous for big events and birthdays - think £500 for weddings and similar for big birthdays. For my neices and nephews I usually give around £100 each for big birthdays - I'm still considered a baby of the family so I get away with that

I am Irish and this is bollox. 500 quid for a big birthday wouldn't happen nor does it happen at weddings.

pfs · 28/09/2022 10:01

£40 is a bit tight for 18th birthdays to be fair (especially in Ireland where you seem to be based on euros and 'down home') but they still absolutely should have said thank you, both at the time you mentioned it and when they actually received it

no it is not and I'm Irish. 40 quid is almost 50 euro and most of my gifts at my 21st were not over 50 euro. Many give me 21 euro and I was very happy with that.

Swipe left for the next trending thread