Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Black Monday anyone? The tories should be in jail

994 replies

Upthebracket22 · 26/09/2022 06:51

The pound is now at its lowest point against the dollar since decimalisation in 1971 at 1.03. It’s probably going lower and the Bank of England will likely need to step in with an emergency interest rate rise today. Black Monday possibly?

All because of the mini budget on Friday. The Tories should be in jail. Especially if their rich backers were shorting the pound as it appears to get rich.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
14
BirmaBrite · 27/09/2022 10:05

That said he has a relentless work ethic and a ruthless streak that has helped him hit the ground on day one.

Has he considered a career in politics @vera99 ?

vera99 · 27/09/2022 10:03

potniatheron · 27/09/2022 09:54

That must be why Sweden are freaking out about their falling living standards and voting in droves for Sverigedemokraterna

Not sure Kier Starmer has the answer he also has embraced the neolib growth rhetoric he just has different ideas of how to bring it about (invest in unproven green industries as opposed to proven financial services which make up 15% of GDP).

It's all tinkering with deck chairs on Titanic as the West os dying as an economic powerhouse and has been since the 1920s. The postwar boom of the 60s was an aberration not a norm. The West is no longer competitive, our education standards in STEM are dire compared with Asia so we'll never catch up.

I'd say 30 more years of decentish living standards (we are already below South Korea and Japan in living standards) and then long term irreversible decline

Doesn't matter who's in power. These are bigger forces than party politics. Kier's Labour and Truss's Tories are both broadly centrist anyway.

I'll vote for Kier next time as he's a centrist and the Tories are out of ideas

Long term planning - my kids are learning Mandarin and have been told with certainty that if they want a good life they're best off working in Asia and just buy a property in the UK to rent as Russian and Arab oligarchs will keep prices high whilst pricing out the youth from property purchase

My nephew spent 5 years in China with his well-connected Chinese wife he set up four English language schools in Shenzen - after covid he lost them all and his wife and child are now back home here. It's a hostile place for foreigners now unless you are prepared to go full CCP shill mode and the government have banned foreign ownership in that sector. That said he has a relentless work ethic and a ruthless streak that has helped him hit the ground on day one.

vera99 · 27/09/2022 09:58

Alexandra2001 · 27/09/2022 09:50

Risky, she has already had one affair.

More than one by all accounts but I think this one is professional. There must be a sense of panic in the Truss camp - she has got rid of the wise old souls who can help and advise and is working on her native instincts whilst the rest of the world and many of her party look on aghast and the markets remorsefully vote with their best. 79-year-old Patrick Minford does not a brain's trust make. If he did go it and she pivoted (like she did with Brexit) she might just reassure the markets that there is an adult in the room but it would be the most significant screeching u-turn of all time.

Black Monday anyone? The tories should be in jail
MarshaBradyo · 27/09/2022 09:58

potniatheron · 27/09/2022 09:54

That must be why Sweden are freaking out about their falling living standards and voting in droves for Sverigedemokraterna

Not sure Kier Starmer has the answer he also has embraced the neolib growth rhetoric he just has different ideas of how to bring it about (invest in unproven green industries as opposed to proven financial services which make up 15% of GDP).

It's all tinkering with deck chairs on Titanic as the West os dying as an economic powerhouse and has been since the 1920s. The postwar boom of the 60s was an aberration not a norm. The West is no longer competitive, our education standards in STEM are dire compared with Asia so we'll never catch up.

I'd say 30 more years of decentish living standards (we are already below South Korea and Japan in living standards) and then long term irreversible decline

Doesn't matter who's in power. These are bigger forces than party politics. Kier's Labour and Truss's Tories are both broadly centrist anyway.

I'll vote for Kier next time as he's a centrist and the Tories are out of ideas

Long term planning - my kids are learning Mandarin and have been told with certainty that if they want a good life they're best off working in Asia and just buy a property in the UK to rent as Russian and Arab oligarchs will keep prices high whilst pricing out the youth from property purchase

Not sure Kier Starmer has the answer he also has embraced the neolib growth rhetoric he just has different ideas of how to bring it about (invest in unproven green industries as opposed to proven financial services which make up 15% of GDP).

Why would you vote for this as it doesn’t sound like you think it a better option

potniatheron · 27/09/2022 09:54

borntobequiet · 27/09/2022 08:29

Socialism is a failed concept, we learnt that lesson in the 20th century

Yet moderate social democracy has delivered good standards of living and equitable societies in many European countries, and did here under the last Labour government. (And no, Gordon Brown didn’t cause the world financial crisis in 2007/2008.)

That must be why Sweden are freaking out about their falling living standards and voting in droves for Sverigedemokraterna

Not sure Kier Starmer has the answer he also has embraced the neolib growth rhetoric he just has different ideas of how to bring it about (invest in unproven green industries as opposed to proven financial services which make up 15% of GDP).

It's all tinkering with deck chairs on Titanic as the West os dying as an economic powerhouse and has been since the 1920s. The postwar boom of the 60s was an aberration not a norm. The West is no longer competitive, our education standards in STEM are dire compared with Asia so we'll never catch up.

I'd say 30 more years of decentish living standards (we are already below South Korea and Japan in living standards) and then long term irreversible decline

Doesn't matter who's in power. These are bigger forces than party politics. Kier's Labour and Truss's Tories are both broadly centrist anyway.

I'll vote for Kier next time as he's a centrist and the Tories are out of ideas

Long term planning - my kids are learning Mandarin and have been told with certainty that if they want a good life they're best off working in Asia and just buy a property in the UK to rent as Russian and Arab oligarchs will keep prices high whilst pricing out the youth from property purchase

citroenpresse · 27/09/2022 09:53

re Tories winning next election inevitably it won’t be because people don’t want to vote for ‘socialism’ (I’m in NL - hardly a bastion of ‘socialism’ but the progressive tax system would probably terrify many Tories) but because they’ve recently attempted to rig the electoral system. The majority of the UK don’t vote Tory, Labour have been miles ahead in the polls for months. There’s absolutely no electoral mandate for these policies and no moral right (4th choice of her parliamentary colleagues?).

Alexandra2001 · 27/09/2022 09:50

vera99 · 27/09/2022 09:47

Wild rumours at this stage but talk of Truss courting Sunak !

Risky, she has already had one affair.

vera99 · 27/09/2022 09:47

Wild rumours at this stage but talk of Truss courting Sunak !

NoMichaelNo · 27/09/2022 09:41

I think Truss will be lucky to still be PM by Christmas, she’s not going to last until 2024.

vera99 · 27/09/2022 09:34

The biggest smear on Sir Keir was that he bought a field to act as a donkey sanctuary for his ailing mother.

www.opendemocracy.net/en/opendemocracyuk/i-met-keir-starmers-donkeys-and-they-told-me-something-about-him/

the80sweregreat · 27/09/2022 09:28

I agree that the media will put the Labour Party in a bad light and and by the next election it'll be business as usual. They will start a smear campaign.
Surrounded by conservatives myself , so maybe my views are a bit screwed up , but I can see this happening.
People still do not trust thrust them. I can see the daily Mail or the sun suddenly liking Sir Kier Starmer's polices either.

Alexandra2001 · 27/09/2022 09:27

Qisk · 27/09/2022 09:21

I am surrounded by people in my locality who will protest a little now, but in the run up to the GE will read the Daily Mail and Express and still vote Conservative. A significant number are blue collared workers. Mostly Brexiteers. They will only vote for someone they believe in and the press provides them with the 'truth'.

Depends on what happens over the next 2 years.

Falling bond values has a direct effect on pensions and investments, previous Tory voters wont forgive that nor much higher mortgage repayments and inflation, plus a devalued £ which they'll notice when they go on hols (if they have any money to do so)

Levelling up has also died a death, which the ex red wall seats will note.

The only way out for the Tories is an economic recovery but in a world heading for a recession, its unlikely the UK will buck that trend.

vera99 · 27/09/2022 09:26

ThinkAboutItTomorrow · 27/09/2022 09:12

I agree that a charm offensive on the right wing press is needed from labour.

However I'd like to think that voters will vote based on their lived experience of being horribly skint and with shit public services.

That didn't happen in 2019 despite the long decline in real wages and peoples standard of living but I can't imagine people will be fooled by the media this time?
But who knows.

But you can't charm the likes of Rothermere and Murdoch as they live their tax-free non-dom lifestyles in foreign climes punting their own values and interests. Labour though has a vast arm,y of young volunteers who are great at social media and that is a better route to get the message across, and door-to-door and phone banks. Expect massive spending on targeted digital if you are in a swing constituency, very little elsewhere. Sir Keir may be a tad dull - but he has a planet-sized brain, a relentless work ethic and a moral core and is an honourable man with robust family values don't let anyone tell you differently. The Tories are dripping in corruption and sleaze.

Qisk · 27/09/2022 09:23

ThinkAboutItTomorrow · 27/09/2022 09:12

I agree that a charm offensive on the right wing press is needed from labour.

However I'd like to think that voters will vote based on their lived experience of being horribly skint and with shit public services.

That didn't happen in 2019 despite the long decline in real wages and peoples standard of living but I can't imagine people will be fooled by the media this time?
But who knows.

100% guarantee they will follow the media.
The answer is simple. Starmer and his shadow cabinet need to win the media.
Like Blair did in 1997. That is what they have to do.
It is not good enough for the Conservatives to fuck up.

Qisk · 27/09/2022 09:21

Alexandra2001 · 27/09/2022 09:01

17pts in front of the Cons... perhaps the public have had enough of charismatic leaders?

The press have been slagging off Labour/Starmer and supporting Truss, yet here we are.

Long way to go & polls are fickle but according to market "experts" unless Kwarteng is replaced and the strategy reversed, expect more and damaging market reaction but if she reverses, she is toast..... hard rock anyone ?

Good article thanks for that.

I am surrounded by people in my locality who will protest a little now, but in the run up to the GE will read the Daily Mail and Express and still vote Conservative. A significant number are blue collared workers. Mostly Brexiteers. They will only vote for someone they believe in and the press provides them with the 'truth'.

Abhannmor · 27/09/2022 09:19

SleeplessInEngland · 27/09/2022 08:22

Liz Truss was not aiming for nor expecting any kind of honeymoon, she is not a people pleaser, she has eighteen months to turn things around for her voters, with no time to worry about how her policies are going down with the lefties.

Ah yes, those famously lefty financial markets.

That raving Marxist , Paul Donovan , chief economist of wealth fund UBS , says investors now see the Conservative Party ' as a Doomsday Cult'.

the80sweregreat · 27/09/2022 09:18

Vera is talking sense , but the Labour Party also need to win back the working and the lower middle classes too and it's a big ask for them to do this. They might succeed , but it won't be easy for them despite the current turmoil.
Many still don't trust them.

Qisk · 27/09/2022 09:16

AuntSalli · 27/09/2022 08:59

What a bit like new labour ?
so basically a more palatable version of the Conservative party is what you’re suggesting ?

personally I would like to see the return of a man where in a flat cap with a whippet under each arm and a racing pigeon circling above.

we need to return to the proper labour values for proper working class people and people need to be proud of been working class again.

that’s where it’s gone wrong for the Conservatives in my opinion everybody is aspiring middle class which makes middle-class meaningless and allows the upper class the 1% is to basically completely ride rough shot over them all.

if you have to work for a living you are working class I don’t care if you’re a doctor a lawyer or a candlestick maker if stopping work tomorrow would cause you financial problems you are working class. Get behind the working class parties that will work in your best interests.
The reality of that situation is about to bite for quite a lot of people when you are gonna realise you’re not quite as posh as you think you are

This is exactly what I mean ^
This is why Labour has problems.

ThinkAboutItTomorrow · 27/09/2022 09:12

I agree that a charm offensive on the right wing press is needed from labour.

However I'd like to think that voters will vote based on their lived experience of being horribly skint and with shit public services.

That didn't happen in 2019 despite the long decline in real wages and peoples standard of living but I can't imagine people will be fooled by the media this time?
But who knows.

vera99 · 27/09/2022 09:10

So they sacked the 30 years of experience well-respected head of the Treasury Sir Michael Scholar (who is having a well-earned holiday in Yorkshire apparently), framed it as a mini-budget to evade OBR scrutiny, are set to borrow huge amounts of money on top of an already hugely indebted nation to fund tax cuts and have refused to answer questions at the time of the biggest financial crisis in living memory. Well done Liz+KK you must have some secret knowledge that the rest of the world doesn't either that or you're properly cracker. At least Boris didn't smash up the executive who deliver policy.

The elephant in the room of course is the toxic Brexit one whose minister for opportunities JRM didn't find any apart from putting the imperial crown on pint glasses. The rest of the world of course finds that properly crackers and the Brittania Uncahined mob have gone for a double or quits bet.

On LBC last night a house seller was in tears because the chain had broken down owing to a mortgage offer being withdrawn in the chain as a direct result of the turmoil.

But on the bright side, Liz certainly knows what a woman is... as does Kwasi

MarshaBradyo · 27/09/2022 09:09

I am of the opinion Labour needs to reinvent itself if it is to win. It needed to do so before. Labour needs charismatic leaders and it needs to shake off some of its old associations. It also needs to own the narrative on moving centrist.

Starmer is pretty much doing this. He’s talking about being the centrist party and starting with a Blair quote.

It’s a bit borrowed - that and the green shift, so whilst not particularly inspiring it is a direction I prefer.

Notonthestairs · 27/09/2022 09:05

Thanks for that CNN article Qisk. Interesting.

ArseInTheCoOpWindow · 27/09/2022 09:03

Labour have the biggest lead since Blair. So much for a Truss bounce😂

Kier may seem dull, but l think people want security and safety atm, and this is what he represents. A 17 point lead isn’t going to go away fast. A

Im really liking Rachel Reeves.

Alexandra2001 · 27/09/2022 09:01

Qisk · 27/09/2022 08:53

I am of the opinion Labour needs to reinvent itself if it is to win. It needed to do so before. Labour needs charismatic leaders and it needs to shake off some of its old associations. It also needs to own the narrative on moving centrist. Until then the popular press narrative will always side with the Conservatives and it is the press that win elections.

Here is a sound CNN article that explains where the UK economy is within the space of one week. Inflation will remain higher than it otherwise would and with it also interest rates. My conclusion is a colossal error by Truss and Kwarteng, not a measured risk.

CNN Article

17pts in front of the Cons... perhaps the public have had enough of charismatic leaders?

The press have been slagging off Labour/Starmer and supporting Truss, yet here we are.

Long way to go & polls are fickle but according to market "experts" unless Kwarteng is replaced and the strategy reversed, expect more and damaging market reaction but if she reverses, she is toast..... hard rock anyone ?

Good article thanks for that.

AuntSalli · 27/09/2022 08:59

Qisk · 27/09/2022 08:53

I am of the opinion Labour needs to reinvent itself if it is to win. It needed to do so before. Labour needs charismatic leaders and it needs to shake off some of its old associations. It also needs to own the narrative on moving centrist. Until then the popular press narrative will always side with the Conservatives and it is the press that win elections.

Here is a sound CNN article that explains where the UK economy is within the space of one week. Inflation will remain higher than it otherwise would and with it also interest rates. My conclusion is a colossal error by Truss and Kwarteng, not a measured risk.

CNN Article

What a bit like new labour ?
so basically a more palatable version of the Conservative party is what you’re suggesting ?

personally I would like to see the return of a man where in a flat cap with a whippet under each arm and a racing pigeon circling above.

we need to return to the proper labour values for proper working class people and people need to be proud of been working class again.

that’s where it’s gone wrong for the Conservatives in my opinion everybody is aspiring middle class which makes middle-class meaningless and allows the upper class the 1% is to basically completely ride rough shot over them all.

if you have to work for a living you are working class I don’t care if you’re a doctor a lawyer or a candlestick maker if stopping work tomorrow would cause you financial problems you are working class. Get behind the working class parties that will work in your best interests.
The reality of that situation is about to bite for quite a lot of people when you are gonna realise you’re not quite as posh as you think you are