Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

That Neurodiversity is becoming an issue

360 replies

mamainlove · 25/09/2022 21:05

Sorry about the thread title:

I have been umming and arrring posting this thread. I'm not able to be speak about this with family/friends (due to lack of knowledge about the area) and some colleagues, as I may seem like a monster if I shared my views.

But I currently work as a speech and language therapist for NHS. The Neurdiversity trend has really changed our practice which I feel may be detrimental to our young people with ASD.

To point out. The support for neurodiverse peopje is minuscule. Children with ASD receive the least amount of provision and if you have a co-morbid conditions, even less so as it's about changing the environment and not about specialist interventions.

Currently, my team are scrapping some of the "typical" interventions that children with ASD usually receive. The idea behind this is that we shouldn't be using interventions that follow a neurotypical path.. for example, if a child with ASD likes to stim with cars, we shouldn't change this (agree) but we shouldn't model and try to teach the children functional play skills, imaginative play, turn taking, "social skills", conversations as that is neurotypical expectations.

I am happy that there is an awareness of neurodiversity but I'm worried that there's a harm in reducing services for children with ASD. A little bit frustrated with the team as it appears that we all have to conform and it's making me reconsider my career choice.

I'm not sure how I could go around this or is the problem with me?

OP posts:
Chrissmasjammies · 26/09/2022 05:43

As an SLP and mum to an almost 5 year old girl with a mild learning disability OP you are right. When she was very small, and missed all her communication milestones we took her for assessment and got an initial diagnosis of ASD. Then earlier this year after further cognitive assessment she got a diagnosis of mild learning disability which to be honest seemed a much better match to her needs. I believe that’s her primary diagnosis. Over the 20 years or so I have been working I have seen diagnoses of ASD increase exponentially while we hardly ever now see a diagnosis of general learning disability. School classes for children with mild learning disabilities were closed and now everyone is under the umbrella of ASD. I believe there is a point where it’s best to call a spade a spade as they say, and describe a child in accordance with their primary need - learning disability. There are of course those with severe language disorders associated with ASD without cognitive impairment but in my experience (limited I do admit as I have not worked much in disability) they are clinically rarer. It’s exactly as you say. There is a huge trend and vested interest in putting everyone in under the one ASD umbrella. Thank you for starting this debate. It does these children no favours to be cohorted with those without co occurring difficulties. She has benefited so much from constant use of Hanen type strategies at home, reduced language, child led play, modelling turn taking and how to initiate a conversation, and I did introduce her to AAC also via an iPad app, which she took to fairly immediately, and recognised it as something she could communicate with. We are in Ireland and services are a mess, non existent, there is no statutory framework. Thank you for giving your perspective.

leavesonthegroundsoon · 26/09/2022 04:54

So do you mean they are reducing the services you have to offer for ASD children rather than replacing those services with other useful and more appropriate services. So really, the children are being offered less rather than an alternative?

bippit · 26/09/2022 04:52

ADHD/ASD person married to ASD person here with young baby who is highly likely to be ND. Fully agree with you. There is a difference between owning your neurology and individuality vs massively lacking the skills that would make other people want to be around you. Eventually all these children will grow up and have to function in society.

Neither I nor DH were diagnosed as children and the opportunities we have lost due to our poor social and executive function are incalculable. We eventually learned by trial and error but how I wish I had had explicit instruction and training when I was younger. Of course there are positive and negative ways to do this, of course punishment and criticism are wrong, of course children shouldn’t be told to stop stimming etc.

I am ambitious and I want access to everything society has to offer. To do that I accept I need to explicitly address the areas where I lack the standard wiring. I want my kid to be proud of who he is and to be able to own it, but ideally he will also be able to code switch (“mask”) when needed. NTs also have to do this, albeit usually with less cost and pain. But we play the hand we’re dealt, and not giving kids access to every tool we can is not helpful or respectful to them.

containsnuts · 26/09/2022 04:02

Surely the benefit of a diagnosis is to access support, treatment or interventions? Leaving people to get on with it as they are sounds like a backwards step to me.

FurryDandelionSeekingMissile · 26/09/2022 03:20

In short:

If mental health services can bastardise and selectively understand the recovery movement in order to refuse healthcare to the mentally ill, claiming it's for the benefit of patients and is what they asked for

then:

the same thing can happen in services for children with neurodevelopmental disability, using a bastardisation and selective understanding of the neurodiversity movement.

Yes, a small number of autistic adults might advocate for the abolition of any and all therapies aimed at helping autistic children adapt to the world, just as a small number of people with mental illnesses might advocate for the abolition of all psychiatric treatment. But I am confident that they are the minority, and that the majority of autistic advocates (perhaps excluding the self-diagnosed assessment-refusers who insist it's a difference, not a disability) aren't so extreme.

We fall into a trap if we allow services to get away with cutting costs and then saying "look over there, not our fault".

Choopi · 26/09/2022 03:20

firef1y · 25/09/2022 22:02

How about the rest of the world learn to fit in with us, rather than us having to go through the exhausting process of masking and trying to fit in with thr rest of the world???

I've skipped from page 2 so apologies if I've missed something but I hate this 'how about the world changes", yeah it would be great if it did but until then what?

A family member of dhs with asd was taught by his shrink to parrot 'I don't feel comfortable with that' to anything he didn't want to do because the world should change to accommodate him. So at 16 he didn't feel comfortable at his school anymore and left. He didn't feel comfortable doing anymore education anywhere else. He didn't feel comfortable finding a job. He hasn't felt comfortable doing anything but sitting in front of a computer screen for about 6 years now. A smart person with lots to offer but given no support at all because the world should change for him. So he sits in his room waiting for the world to change.

My ds a teenager with asd. Develops anxiety, we take him to cahms. No help for him. The world needs to change for ds apparently. He doesn't need coping mechanisms so he can achieve his dreams of going to university to study languages and eventually move to Germany, he has to hope the world changes in the next 3 years. A smart top of the class student fluent in 3 languages at 15 who is desperate to go to uni, desperate to just be able to go to town with his mates without being crippled by anxiety gets no help because he has to wait for the entire world to change for him first before he can do these things.

I get help for my GAD. Not ds though because people like you are advocating for a sit around and wait for the world to change for you while life passes you by.

Fortunately we could afford private care for ds and he spent the summer going out with his mates. He is still doing great in school and he has learned what works for him and what doesn't. He is autistic not thick. He can and has learnt coping mechanisms that mean with continued help he will hopefully be able to fulfill his dreams and not end up shut away from the world because sometimes he feels uncomfortable.

FurryDandelionSeekingMissile · 26/09/2022 02:39

FurryDandelionSeekingMissile · 26/09/2022 00:29

Many decades ago, in many different parts of the world, people whose difficulties had led them to come into significant contact with the psychiatric services and institutions of the time started to come together and discuss their experiences.

A lot of them had experienced compulsory treatment, sometimes abusive, often long-term. They might call themselves survivors, or mad, or something else, but they talked, read theory, wrote, and started to come up with alternative ways of thinking about and living with their difficulties.

One of the ideas come up with by one of these groups of people was "recovery" — recovery on their own terms.

They began to talk about "recovery" as a process, and not a process of moving from a state of insanity to one of sanity, but a process of working towards a life with value to the person living it. A life which, even if there were ongoing difficulties that doctors might prefer to treat with heavy, limiting medications, was nevertheless a life worth living.

People would look outside the psychiatric system that had pathologised them, drugged them to the point of torpor, locked them up, kept them in the system for decades, dismissed their unusual experiences as meaningless, and condemned them to a life as a sick person. Instead they would find value and meaning where they were able to. Some would still use psychiatric medications and support to some extent, others chose not to as far as possible.

Fast-forward a few decades, and healthcare systems of the world have suddenly had an idea.

If they can claim that they're now following the "recovery model" in accordance with service-user-led philosophy, they needn't provide expensive psychiatric and psychological healthcare to people with mental illness in the long-term. They can change their name from a "Community Mental Health Team" to a "Community Mental Health Recovery Service", take on only the most severe of cases for the shortest possible time, and discharge them when they still have many ongoing symptoms. Even if the patient doesn't feel remotely ready. Even if they beg not to be discharged yet. After all, the recovery model is about finding your own meaning in life even if you're still experiencing symptoms, right? About not being left to drift on under mental health services, a perpetual patient — so it's best you're pushed out of the nest to fly, even if your wings are still only stubs.

Don't blame the people asking to be treated like people, just because services use their ideas as a pretext to cut costs. Those on the front line who deliver services and those who need the services, we're on the same side — don't fall for it, when the powers that dictate how these things happen take our ideas and use them against ourselves and each other.

This is the post I mean.

It's a similar tactic.

Of all the people who have been under your service in the past, a subset have experienced damaging care. They may also come together with others who may not have had all the original sub-group's experiences, but who are interested in the ideas.Together they begin reject the mainstream consensus about their treatment, and start to develop alternative ideas about the best way to conceptualise the issue. This also includes a rejection of some of the more expensive things your service provides, often because they're coercive.

So you have a perfect excuse to do away with providing these treatments and services even on an optional basis, and can point to these activists as the reason (without providing any of the other things they ask for, if those are in your power). You don't have to do anything difficult like changing the way you provide services or changing the exact nature of the services offered, just stop bothering, and if anyone gets upset they'll blame the campaigners and activists and ex-patients, not the service. After all, the service was only responding to community activism…

Dibbydoos · 26/09/2022 02:32

I agree there is so little by way of service for children and its even worse for adults. My 21yo DD is likely to be ASD and maybe even ADHD based on our assessments (my DS is diagnosed ASD), but no way can we get her assessed via nhs and noone accepts private diagnosis. Ridiculous when once diagnosed I'll know how to help her.

As everyone will appreciate, there's always been neurodiversity, but now we're aware of it more and hence can offer support. Some scientists believe it is an evolution presumably due to the continuing exponential understanding of IT and AI.

FurryDandelionSeekingMissile · 26/09/2022 02:26

I think that the services are being led blindly by the neurodiversity movement

I think this is naive. They're not being led blindly, they're allowing themselves to be "led" with their eyes wide open, specifically towards particular ideas from neurodiversity activists which will allow the services to cut costs.

The moment neurodiversity activists are asking only for things that will be more expensive than the status quo, the interest in community engagement with the neurodiversity movement will evaporate.

See the example I gave above about the recovery movement — if services can use certain ideas originating in activism as an excuse for reducing services and cost-cutting, they will, and they'll claim it's a good thing because it proves they're responsive to wishes of the populations they claim to serve.

Changingnames20 · 26/09/2022 02:11

I completely agree with you OP - I think that the services are being led blindly by the neurodiversity movement which is whitewashing autism into being I just a difference and any intervention at all is labelled ‘being made to be neurotypical’.

It’s actually very scary as in reality it means many, many children with serious functional and language communication difficulties are just being sidelined, ignored and failed by everyone.

I got told by my son’s SLT recently that his communication difficulties ‘were just his autism’ and that he ‘might prefer’ not to communicate. So she is offering him nothing.

How dare other people assume that my son is ‘masking’ by not being able to talk or to understand language - and that to help him is ‘neurotypical expectations’. This is what the situation is now. They are just going to let him go and rot somewhere unable to communicate at all - it’s something that is so backward, so appalling, so against support for children with disabilities - because my son does have a disability - recognised in law - with this kind of damaging rhetoric.

Of course we shouldn’t be stressing any child - there are ways of supporting my son with language to enable him to communicate on his terms, in the way that he wants, in a way that gives him access and opportunities like any other person. But leaving my son to go through life without language - how bloody stressful is that going to be for him?

Thankfully I’ve ignored most of the privileged nonsense from mainly people who have the language themselves - somehow ‘speaking’ for those who do not… and have helped my son develop his language myself and he has so many more opportunties for it, he’s happier and more in control of his life - because he can actually ask for what he wants and understand others. But I meet people every day whose kids still don’t have that. Shame on us for letting these kids down.

IndianSummer78 · 26/09/2022 02:01

Exhaustedmoose · 25/09/2022 21:24

Shit that's scary OP. Really scary. They need to be taught how else are they going to learn to fit in with society and more importantly function in society and hold down a job with expected behaviours even if not natural to them? FFS

It's you who's scary. Mask and suffer in silence is your solution. How about accepting that some people are unfit for work due to their disabilities? And not pushing them to the point of total mental breakdown in order to prove it?

Diverseopinions · 26/09/2022 02:00

SpidersAreShitheads

Exactly!

SpidersAreShitheads · 26/09/2022 01:54

"Quite a number of friends whose children have ASD, young adults now, like my son, say that at school, something would happen, like they would ask their son: "What is your favourite meal?" and the teenager would say: chicken pie" and the mum would say, "They never eat chicken pie". It's maybe been suggested before as an option and the person will think: "What am I supposed to say this time?". To work communication strategies gave to cover social expectations, but also evolve with the interests of the child."

@Diverseopinions - this kind of thing used to happen all of the time, especially with DS and to a lesser extent, DD.

When the report from the Educational Psychologist for DD arrived, it listed her interests as including sewing, and playing guitar. DD had just come from a general music lesson in class where they were all introduced to playing guitars for the first time. She can't play guitar. We'd also done some sewing together at the weekend, which she was largely uninterested in. But asked and put on the spot, those are the two "interests" that she listed.

DS was even more bonkers. Every week they would have to write a diary on Monday morning about their weekend. DS would write about riding a bike - he can't ride a bike and has dyspraxia - same with playing football. Every week there was some kind of random activity listed. He had a "passport" thing for his class - he was in special school - and under his likes he had painting and art listed. He HATES art because again, with the dyspraxia he struggles to control pens/brushes etc. It's just about the pressure of having to list SOMETHING.

I used to have to explain to the school - repeatedly - that they couldn't take something that was said at face value because there's a very good chance it's just something to say, rather than being true. And yes, sometimes things were said which got me in trouble, and needed a swift explanation!!!

mamainlove · 26/09/2022 01:52

@Diverseopinions

I should be in bed but can't sleep!

I have never been too fond of PECS. The push is more towards a robust communication system- like high tec AAC's, PODD but again this requires more funding and money. However, there are some children with ASD who respond to PECS, particularly at the initiation stage.

Regarding ABA and language. In speech and language therapy, we wouldn't say to a child "This is Orange. Say Orange". We would encourage shared book reading, talk through play, modelling language, following the child's interests and so on.

OP posts:
Diverseopinions · 26/09/2022 01:48

I get the impression OP that the new initiatives might not be so much about not giving the individual the tools to fit in, but more about making teaching and modelling strategies as effective as possible.

user1477391263 · 26/09/2022 01:47

Just look at the deaf community. Many are forced to learn to speak verbally as children so other people can understand them. Many grow up and reject this in favour of signing and socialising with others who understand and accept them as they are. The way you are talking makes it sound like you see ND as disabled, defective, needing fixed.

The correct way to do things, surely, is to bring children up with their national sign language AND teach verbal communication (speech and lip reading) in the vernacular of the country where they live, even if it's just their second language. Deaf people are as capable of bilingualism as everyone else is.

I wish BSL was taught in all schools instead of French or German, actually (because sign languages are fascinating, and useful in some practical situations, and because with aging populations it might be additionally useful for some people in old age, in addition to the accessibility for deaf people issue).

But it's rarely taught, and we don't have enough teachers to mainstream instruction.

Getting the entire population of the UK to manage BSL is not going to happen in our lifetimes. And in the meantime, Deaf people will need to communicate in these situations as well.

SpidersAreShitheads · 26/09/2022 01:47

I'm not going to repeat a lot of views which have already been given here. All I will say is that there's a very big difference in teaching a child skills which are essential and that they can't do without, and teaching a child skills that make neurotypical people more comfortable. In my experience, most types of support or therapy focus on the latter.

There were comments earlier in this thread about teaching autistic people to have friends - some autistic people genuinely don't feel a need for this, and don't feel lonely. It's about identifying what are true, inescapable needs which should be addressed, and those things that neurotypicals think that everyone needs because they're incapable of seeing the world through a different lens.

It's useful to be able to mask, but it comes at a cost, and there's an increasing feeling of 'why should I have to?" among the autistic community. I guess some of the anger comes because it's very often not about accommodating our needs, but making us seem more acceptable to the neurotypical community. And if you compare this to other disabilities, maybe a wheelchair user, there's just not the same approach. We're not treated in the same way as physical disabilities, where accommodations are made and people understand that needs are different - and that's OK. For autistic people, it's all about making us as close to neurotypical as possible, even though that's just not the way our brain works.

There are some well-meaning parents of autistic children who push a harmful agenda unintentionally. ABA is the classic example. There's an enormous community of adults who say they were seriously damaged by ABA as a child, and yet it persists.

Being such a broad spectrum means that what's needed is an individual approach, and that takes time and money, both in short supply in our NHS provision.

For context, I have a DD and a DS who are autistic, plus I'm autistic/ADHD myself.

Diverseopinions · 26/09/2022 01:42

I think awareness of the different neurodiverse path is good and the new trend is probably based on research, and not a whacky new trend with no empirical basis. I'm somewhat against PECS. It's basically about making your child give over a card with a picture of what they want before you will give them what you have ten minutes before being passing them freely: bubbles; a favourite sensory toy. It basically presents communication as something artificial, rather than naturally evolving.

I've sometimes wondered whether, left to evolve conversation naturally, children who experience ASD would use words to try to meet their own needs, initially, and then, over time, use language to start to talk about a special interest, like music. I don't not what is being advocated in place of PECS, but it might be a system which combines some of the 'old ways' of encouraging communication, but simply be more personalised and responsive to the child's own initiatives.

Certainly, children with ASD will make sense of things which interest them. Communication strategies which are too rigid may fail. It is not so much not being able to use language, but more wanting to use language to advance a particular interest, for a lot of ASD children. I think that strategies which are responsive to the ASD child's interests work best. There is a danger that if you force a child to try to do talking in a set way, that you will put them off education and then it takes longer to reconnect them. This is what some Speech and Language specialists cite as the danger of ABA. It probably works well as a therapy for some ASD children, but certainly not all of them, and not much good if it increases their anxiety.

You can't teach a young child with ASD that "This is orange. Say orange". If they get it at all, they might never generalise that understanding to everything orange, but think you mean that felt pen must be labelled orange. In the same way, I think that exploratory play with Montessori type sets for fitting pegs to the number of holes, obviously works better for finding out 'one more is needed' than saying "This is 3 + 2, look, say 3 + 2" , before the child has an understanding of 1:1 correspondence.

As a mother of an adult with autism, I know that you have to give freedom to express thoughts, and to do it during the childhood years, otherwise there is a danger that the individual with ASD will think that communication is a game where you say what the other person wants to hear. The impact on that on the adult, who might later in their life be looked after in some kind of official care setting, is that they won't be able to self-advocate for their own needs. They will think "What happened?" is a statement saying " I am asking you a question, can you remember what you're supposed to say?" - a kind of game again, like PECS, or those endless question and answer sessions they do in special schools, or card games which the ASD teenagers probably don't know the meaning of, nor want to win.

Quite a number of friends whose children have ASD, young adults now, like my son, say that at school, something would happen, like they would ask their son: "What is your favourite meal?" and the teenager would say: chicken pie" and the mum would say, "They never eat chicken pie". It's maybe been suggested before as an option and the person will think: "What am I supposed to say this time?". To work communication strategies gave to cover social expectations, but also evolve with the interests of the child.

user1477391263 · 26/09/2022 01:42

I agree with the OP's concern.

One thing that really bothers me is the trend whereby online discussions of things like autism become dominated by people with high functioning autism, who then see extremely eager to censor and avoid public discussion of low functioning autism and the immense suffering it causes to the people themselves and to parents and caregivers.

Have seen parents trying to talk online about their struggles and difficulties, and being shut down, screamed at and insulted, being accused of not accepting their child's condition in the right way, being informed that the only reason their child is suffering is because they (the parents) are failing to accommodate the child properly... and so it goes on. It's horrible.

This article here by Thomas Clement (who is autistic with a high IQ, and has a brother who is also autistic but is not capable of independent living) sort of sums up my concerns about all this.
www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2019/aug/26/autism-neurodiversity-severe?fbclid=IwAR14AryBQWAa-6K8wvRSgJZarQWvM-NXBk_cxK6_6eIzEnIFz5geu9ww47I

pompomdaisy · 26/09/2022 01:35

My next door neighbour is ND. He doesn't mix and socialise with us but we understand why. He is a programmer and earns a packet jetting all over the world. In summer he plays the most fantastic instrumental music. He is part of our neighbourhood but in his own way. Why can't society let ND people be ND?

SideEyeSally · 26/09/2022 01:22

Feel free but bear in mind I am only one person. Being neurodivergent for me is like straddling two worlds. It is incredibly easy for me to go weeks days without showering, without really talking to people listening to my favourite podcasts, not dealing with life stuff and eating only processed carbohydrates. I also know that doing that for any length of time makes me depressed, I become aware I am being a bad friend/partner/daughter and guilt kicks in, I realise one afternoon that probably the people in the shop could smell me and then I feel shame.

I struggle to be 'normal' in a lot of ways but I am sure there are a lot of people out there like me who straddle both worlds and who are still affected by the 'prosocial' emotions like guilt and shame but struggle to keep up with the behavious that keep them at bay. I hate the thought of them being told they cannot have that help because it's ableist.

Someone up thread mentioned the radical body acceptance movement and there are parralells. I left those communities too because the attitude that wanting to loose weight was fatphobic, self-loathing and thst being fat was something people have no control over was so damaging to me as someone with a binge eating disorder. It made steps towards recovery seem immoral.

mamainlove · 26/09/2022 01:06

SideEyeSally · 26/09/2022 01:00

I was diagnosed with ASD and ADHD as an adult and find that I cannot meaningfullly engage with most of the autism community. I am very glad I have some ability to mask. The research looking at the negative outcomes on masking focuses on the costs (tiring, draining, anxiety provoking) but not the postivies (independence, access to a wider world, broader pool of social potential, less obvious target). I think a lot of autistic people are very bitter about the costs and want the benefits without them. While that might be the ideal it doesn't work in reality and you can't control other people's behaviour only your own. Getting angry at NT people for not rebuilding society to fit your needs isn't a pathway to change.

Also I fully agree that the vocal voices in autism (though I actually suspect they are the majority not minority) for whom autism is experienced as a difference are quick to silence autistic people or the families of autistic people for whom it is an extremely debilitating disability.

Helping a child learn skills which don't come naturally to them is not the same as telling them they are deficient or defective and I find the narrative that it is petulant and worrying.

This is very interesting. Thanks for sharing this. I have never thought that, as well as looking into the negatives of masking, there's no research into it's benefits. I hope you don't mind, but could I share this thought with my team? Not your post! But this thought of yours.

OP posts:
SideEyeSally · 26/09/2022 01:00

I was diagnosed with ASD and ADHD as an adult and find that I cannot meaningfullly engage with most of the autism community. I am very glad I have some ability to mask. The research looking at the negative outcomes on masking focuses on the costs (tiring, draining, anxiety provoking) but not the postivies (independence, access to a wider world, broader pool of social potential, less obvious target). I think a lot of autistic people are very bitter about the costs and want the benefits without them. While that might be the ideal it doesn't work in reality and you can't control other people's behaviour only your own. Getting angry at NT people for not rebuilding society to fit your needs isn't a pathway to change.

Also I fully agree that the vocal voices in autism (though I actually suspect they are the majority not minority) for whom autism is experienced as a difference are quick to silence autistic people or the families of autistic people for whom it is an extremely debilitating disability.

Helping a child learn skills which don't come naturally to them is not the same as telling them they are deficient or defective and I find the narrative that it is petulant and worrying.

turbonerd · 26/09/2022 00:57

Me three.
those communities seem to belong to some extraordinarily eloquent and verbose neurodivergents. They seem to reject the help and care from «NT» people whilst simultaneously demand more help and care, then decry it as ableism.

I am really angry about it today. Can’t sleep either. Thank you for posting op.

I am all for debate and constructive criticism of methods. Room for feedback and improvement. But even Temple Grandin had lots of help from NeuroTypicals to be able to utilise her genius fully - and then thrive independently in society. To acknowledge that does not take away from her Fantastic ability and incredible achievements.

mamainlove · 26/09/2022 00:53

5zeds · 26/09/2022 00:43

i don’t think intense (yikes!) 1:1 speech therapy is necessary in all situations but it’s probably more appropriate than play/eyecontact/stim policing and behaviour modification. My ds is severely language disordered and that has been a much bigger hurdle than his ASD.

The problem now is that significant language disordered children would not make much progress unless they have 1:1 direct SLT that is specific and tailored to their language difficulties. Modifying the environment (I.e. visuals, modifying language in the classroom, differentiated work) makes a difference but it's small. The real difference is the child having access to regular 1:1 direct speech and language therapy.

OP posts:
Swipe left for the next trending thread