Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

That Neurodiversity is becoming an issue

360 replies

mamainlove · 25/09/2022 21:05

Sorry about the thread title:

I have been umming and arrring posting this thread. I'm not able to be speak about this with family/friends (due to lack of knowledge about the area) and some colleagues, as I may seem like a monster if I shared my views.

But I currently work as a speech and language therapist for NHS. The Neurdiversity trend has really changed our practice which I feel may be detrimental to our young people with ASD.

To point out. The support for neurodiverse peopje is minuscule. Children with ASD receive the least amount of provision and if you have a co-morbid conditions, even less so as it's about changing the environment and not about specialist interventions.

Currently, my team are scrapping some of the "typical" interventions that children with ASD usually receive. The idea behind this is that we shouldn't be using interventions that follow a neurotypical path.. for example, if a child with ASD likes to stim with cars, we shouldn't change this (agree) but we shouldn't model and try to teach the children functional play skills, imaginative play, turn taking, "social skills", conversations as that is neurotypical expectations.

I am happy that there is an awareness of neurodiversity but I'm worried that there's a harm in reducing services for children with ASD. A little bit frustrated with the team as it appears that we all have to conform and it's making me reconsider my career choice.

I'm not sure how I could go around this or is the problem with me?

OP posts:
mamainlove · 26/09/2022 08:28

NDMum · 26/09/2022 07:04

Firstly it's autistic child not a child with autism, it's not an accessory like a handbag.
What you're discussing to me sounds like ABA approaches 🙄
So you think we should be trained like robots to "fit" into societal norms!

Some people (adults and children with ASD) prefer to be called an adult/child with Autism and the others prefer autistic child/autistic adult. shrug

OP posts:
PizzaFunghi · 26/09/2022 08:26

I do seem some of my difficulties as deficits, not differences. I want to be able to fit in. I also don't see why the world should change to accommodate me. What makes me so special? If I want to have friends, I need to find a way to deal with the situation and people in front of me. I don't expect anyone to particularly go out of their way to include me or change how they interact just to suit me - I personally would feel arrogant somehow, to think that my potential friendship or whatever was so important that others should want to see past my anxiety or weirdness or annoying traits or just lack of convention or conversational skills. I want to be able to be like other people and to fit in naturally, and yes, that might take a lot of work on my part and a lot of masking, but I also gain from it so it's worth it to me. And I'd need skills and teaching to be able to get there. If there were adaptations the world could make that affected absolutely no-one else, then yes, that might help. But realistically, that's not the case, and I don't see why anyone else would need or want to change for me. Other ways of interacting might be the norm, and if my language style or behaviours are different, I'm not easily going to fit in. I can choose to stay like that or I can choose to change, and both options are avialable and suitable to different circumstances. I think people who dont' want to change to fit in have that right, and there shouldn't be any recriminations against them for doing so, but they don't speak for everyone. And I'd be concerned if this then leads to reduction in services for those who do want a different way.

Teateaandmoretea · 26/09/2022 08:25

Surely like most things in life the truth is in the middle. People shouldn’t be forced into a certain set of behaviours or way of thinking but strategies to cope with situations and enable better communication will benefit some. Everyone should be treated as an individual and society should be far more accepting.

This bespoke approach would be more expensive so it’s easier for the NHS to operate at extremes. The cheapest extreme is to basically not offer anything, which according to the OP is what they are wanting to do.

VariationsonaTheme · 26/09/2022 08:20

There have to be limits to what we allow in terms of anyone’s preferred way of communicating, limited by a basic need to keep everyone safe. I’m currently working with a child who’s preferred method of expressing his frustration at not being allowed to do what he wants is to throw whatever is in his vicinity. Last week it was chairs, thrown without regard for the five year olds nearby. We could say he should be able to do what he wants all day, but that isn’t how schools work, it just isn’t. If we want schools that work that way, allowing everyone to follow their own interests, then we (as a society) need to invest in them. But it’s not going to happen. So in the meantime we need to keep everyone safe in the schools we do have.

firef1y · 26/09/2022 08:16

I really wish there was a like button on here.

What a lot of people don't realise is just how many ND people self medicate, whether that be drugs or alcohol. Alcohol really, really helps me deal with the NT world, when drunk I can deal so much better with socialising and the ADHD part of me really likes recreational drugs. Luckily, I really like to exercise (it's my hyper-focus) and know that is a really bad road to go down.
Then there's the depression, I was medicated by the doctor for decades, now I embrace who I am.i haven't had medication for years. I no longer have the stress (it's not stress exactly but that's the best way of describing it other than being like a pressure cooker) of holding in my stims, trying not to have meltdown, staying in noisy environments etc., so I don't need the antidepressants in the same way.

BadNomad · 26/09/2022 08:14

One thing that always becomes clear in these types of threads is that a lot of NT people don't think autistic people who can speak are autistic enough to talk about autism and therefore verbal autistic people should shut-up and let non-autistic people speak for autistic people who can't talk.

myleftventricle · 26/09/2022 08:04

5zeds · 25/09/2022 22:37

I think many people are worried by very articulate and verbal autistics speaking for less articulate or non verbal autistics and the spread of resources across the community.

At least it will actually be autistic people speaking for them instead of clueless people without autism who don't understand that forcing someone into years of masking (just so they fit in nicely and don't annoy the nice NT people) can have a really crap effect on your mental health and self-esteem in later year!

firef1y · 26/09/2022 07:46

Choopi · 26/09/2022 03:20

I've skipped from page 2 so apologies if I've missed something but I hate this 'how about the world changes", yeah it would be great if it did but until then what?

A family member of dhs with asd was taught by his shrink to parrot 'I don't feel comfortable with that' to anything he didn't want to do because the world should change to accommodate him. So at 16 he didn't feel comfortable at his school anymore and left. He didn't feel comfortable doing anymore education anywhere else. He didn't feel comfortable finding a job. He hasn't felt comfortable doing anything but sitting in front of a computer screen for about 6 years now. A smart person with lots to offer but given no support at all because the world should change for him. So he sits in his room waiting for the world to change.

My ds a teenager with asd. Develops anxiety, we take him to cahms. No help for him. The world needs to change for ds apparently. He doesn't need coping mechanisms so he can achieve his dreams of going to university to study languages and eventually move to Germany, he has to hope the world changes in the next 3 years. A smart top of the class student fluent in 3 languages at 15 who is desperate to go to uni, desperate to just be able to go to town with his mates without being crippled by anxiety gets no help because he has to wait for the entire world to change for him first before he can do these things.

I get help for my GAD. Not ds though because people like you are advocating for a sit around and wait for the world to change for you while life passes you by.

Fortunately we could afford private care for ds and he spent the summer going out with his mates. He is still doing great in school and he has learned what works for him and what doesn't. He is autistic not thick. He can and has learnt coping mechanisms that mean with continued help he will hopefully be able to fulfill his dreams and not end up shut away from the world because sometimes he feels uncomfortable.

People like me???
Oh you mean someone who has lived their whole life being autistic and trying to fit in to an NT world. Someone who actually knows how mentally exhausting and damaging it is to try and fit in. Someone who, had there been allowances made for her "wierdness" and odd behaviours, could have had a career. Someone who always desperately wanted to be normal, who didn't realise that her differences were something that could be embraced.
What seems to be forgotten in these conversations is that a large number of the now vocal ND community are women in my age group. We weren't diagnosed until late adulthood, the double whammy effect of the Rainman idea of what autism is plus "autism doesn't affect girls".
I spent 45 years knowing I wasn't like everyone else, desperately trying to be like everyone and yes wanting to be able to socialise like everyone else. I was diagnosed with various types of depression along with social anxiety disorder but never autism. I was medicated which didn't help, I learnt to hide my stims, to make it appear I was looking in people's eyes when they talked. I kind of know the constructs of conversation, only kind of, never quite know when it's my turn to talk, when a conversation has moved on etc.
When I finally got my ASD diagnosis 5 years ago aged 45 it was liberating. As the person who diagnosed me said, there's inherently nothing wrong with how I am, it's just the world is designed for NT brains and I'm just not wired like that.
Now I have my diagnosis, I've embraced who I am. If I need to stim, I stim (I still remember being thrown out of a job centre 20years ago because my stimming was "making people nervous", thank god that's improved now), if I need to put my earphones in I put them in. I no longer force myself to look People in the eyes.
I'm lucky I have a group of friends who know I'm autistic. I get invites to things and they know that just because I'm on the edge of a group or sitting quietly in a corner that doesn't mean I'm not enjoying myself. They know that sometimes it all.gets too much, they see the signs and help me.remove myself until I feel.calmer.
This is an example of the NT world "changing" to be more accessible to me a non-NT. I can still be myself I don't need to add to.my stress (and distress) by masking. But it's taken education on my part plus the whole group (all of us including me) working out how I can be included

Lougle · 26/09/2022 07:35

I tried to get support for my teen with ASD. SALT wouldn't see her, even to assess, because she was verbal. A private SALT, commissioned by the LA, saw her and deemed her 'average'. In fact, she had scores on the 98th percentile in some areas and the 0.4th on others. I complained. Finally, she was reassessed by another SALT who specialises in ASD and she was diagnosed with an expressive language disorder and given therapy, with that added to her EHCP.

I tried to get support for my older teen with ASD and LDs. I was told she was 'fine' because she'd reached 'Blank 4' level (could answer 'why' questions). I insisted on a Speech and Language assessment. She has a severe expressive and receptive language disorder, on the 0.1st percentile for both, and only understands language at a sentence level. She now has SALT in her EHCP.

My children need help to navigate the NT world. If they have the skills to do that, they can choose how much they engage with it. Without those skills, they are locked out from it.

How far do we go with 'acceptance'? My DD went to special school. You can't tell me that children licking windows (literally, not metaphorically) and being completely unable to communicate choice is something to embrace? You can't tell me I did wrong by wanting DD1 to be able to attend to an activity for more than 30 seconds at a time?

I want DD1 to have choice about where she lives, with who, and what she does. Even after years of specialist education, that will be severely curtailed by the difficulties she has interacting with wider society. She will be a danger to herself and others if left unsupervised, and will be in danger from unscrupulous members of society due to her vulnerability.

Choconuttolata · 26/09/2022 07:35

I am shocked. If it wasn't for PECS then DS wouldn't have learned to talk. He went from non-verbal to full self generated sentences using the PECS modelling. He also learnt to play with his siblings and peers by learning to play with adults first. He enjoys this connection with others. He is not forced to not be himself, he plays in his own way mostly, but he is encouraged to try things that he would initially not do due to fear, anxiety and lack of confidence. He is also given opportunities to feel positive about his achievements. DH also has ASD and didn't have enough intervention as a young child which affected his whole life and self confidence.

IncessantNameChanger · 26/09/2022 07:20

Well the finance model of sen education and white paper all want to move away from special.schools and ehcps.

I think the idea that the NT world is going to willingly bend to accommodate every ND and be able to provide enough care to do so isn't going to materialise. We get direct payments for respite but I can't find anyone who wants to do it. I'm not convinced that the same wages will suddenly be appealing once he hits 18.

This is the problem.with going with looking at the diagnosis and not the need. But people who don't belive in speech therapy I think the option will soon be gone anyway.

TigerRag · 26/09/2022 07:14

containsnuts · 26/09/2022 04:02

Surely the benefit of a diagnosis is to access support, treatment or interventions? Leaving people to get on with it as they are sounds like a backwards step to me.

If you get diagnosed as an adult, this is exactly what they do. We should have "adapted" by now, therefore, not worthy of support. And social services in my experience, are totally clueless. Them being clueless has led them to label me as "awkward". Yes, I'm awkward because I don't like loud noise or crowds.

hopelesslydevotedtoGu · 26/09/2022 07:12

I have autism, I have a child with autism, we are both 'high-functioning'.

Completely share your concerns OP. In particular it sounds like your team are following some half-baked ideological idea about 'celebrating diversity' rather than thinking about what would be best for the individual child.

My child WANTS to have friends and play with other children, but things like turn-taking and backwards-and-forwards conversations don't come naturally to her. With some practice, support and encouragement, she has some really good friendships now. If we hadn't helped her develop these skills she would not have friendships - you can't build a meaningful friendship if you are shouting over the other child constantly.

Sometimes she is feeling overwhelmed/ exhausted and needs some time to herself without the demands of interacting with others. That's where being supporting of her differences helps her - recognising that her autism means she can get overwhelmed at times, and knowing what will help her. Previously she couldn't recognise this feeling, and would end up screaming/ hitting/ throwing toys. We've helped her recognise this feeling, and now she tends to notice it early and either take herself off for some time alone, or tell us or her teacher that she is feeling overwhelmed and needs some time alone.

I wouldn't want to force a child to play with others if they really didn't want to, but it is very very helpful for that child to be able to communicate their needs and wants as much as possible. The best way to help them achieve that may involve some trial and error of different communication strategies.

I fear the new direction your team is taking may be an opportunity for the services offered to be cut and save money, in the name of 'celebrating diversity'.

I have autism and that brings me strengths, but my difficulty in holding a conversation is not one of them. Learning to wait for someone else to finish talking before interrupting has improved my life hugely.

Iamnotthe1 · 26/09/2022 07:08

Bearsporridge · 26/09/2022 06:55

This brings us right back to the situation only 30 years ago when parents were fighting the state to recognise that autistic children were entitled to any education at all.

But potentially worse if the state can say it's being done under the guise of anti-discrimination and is the end result of messages that originated within ASD activism groups.

There's an easy narrative here that could be created around releasing children with ASD from the shackles of mainstream education and giving them to space to just be who they are, embrace their diversity and never live with the weighty, discriminatory expectations of NT conformity again. The message would be easy to agree with: the reality would be very different.

NDMum · 26/09/2022 07:04

Firstly it's autistic child not a child with autism, it's not an accessory like a handbag.
What you're discussing to me sounds like ABA approaches 🙄
So you think we should be trained like robots to "fit" into societal norms!

Softplayhooray · 26/09/2022 06:59

I think you're coming from a good place of worrying about how ND kids might cope in school or later in life if they don't learn some of these more 'NT', for want of a better term, behaviours? I see what you mean. As a mum of two ND son's I think this to an extent sometimes but tbh I think the situation is very specific to the individual and to their ND and ND comorbidities.

I read your post as highlighting the lack of funding in neurodiversity which means there's not enough individual consideration and only one broad brush strategy being attempted which of course will always fail somebody.

Bearsporridge · 26/09/2022 06:55

Iamnotthe1 · 25/09/2022 22:42

Is an element of this just a hidden excuse for reducing funding and support?

Let's say that, currently, the majority of support available to children with ASD is focused on interacting in a NT environment (rightly or wrongly). Removing that as a "target" by stating that it's ableist to offer a child with ASD an intervention with that focus could be used to argue that no/few interventions are needed.

Coupling this with the statement that children with ASD cannot and should not be expected to reach the same developmental goals as NT children, a narrative could be created that a lot of the specified support in things like EHCPs is actually not required and the targets are wrong.

Following that thread through to it's conclusion, I could see Local Authorities making the argument that, if the child with ASD does not need to meet the sorts of targets set in EHCPs then some of the justifications for the EHCP (variance from peers, specific support needed, involvement from external agencies, etc.) will no longer be seen as valid because they could say that the child is: "fine as they are". Heck, the eventual end of the line conclusion could be: "It's ableist to ask children with ASD to attend mainstream schools."

This sounds to me that this is a move to reduce funded support for children with ASD hidden under the guise of equality and inclusivity.

This brings us right back to the situation only 30 years ago when parents were fighting the state to recognise that autistic children were entitled to any education at all.

Mumofsend · 26/09/2022 06:50

My autistic DD has private SALT funded through her EHCP as the NHS provision is so poor. Her therapist is wonderful and follows DD's lead. She also has a speech disorder, the NHS gave up on her when they couldn't support her speech disorder the 'usual' way due to her autism. She had 2 sessions in 3 years 😡

Pixnix · 26/09/2022 06:44

Shtfday · 25/09/2022 22:39

@Twizbe
I cant work out what is so bad about walls that NT would be so unable to cope if someone touches a wall.

If the child touched the wall in public who does this actually impact?

Im deaf and lots of deaf children are given targets on their plans such as lostening and wearing listening devices for 90% of the day. It is crazy to give these targets. Its setring children up to fail rather than create a supportive enviroment where information is accesible.

What would you think if a 30 year old man came up and hugged your house every day for 15 minutes?

Autistic children become autistic adults and their behaviours aren't so "cute" or "quirky" anymore - why wouldn't you take the time to teach them what's appropriate and what isn't, where possible, and support their sensory needs at the same time?

Ridley10 · 26/09/2022 06:44

My dd is autistic and gets barely any support from SLT. A few sessions a year. It’s not hugely meaningful as it’s all based around what a neurotypical person needs. Considering the amount of children who are neurodiverse you’d think there would be things in place but unsurprisingly another area where children with disabilities are failed.

sunshineflowerdaisy · 26/09/2022 06:42

Chrissmasjammies · 25/09/2022 22:57

@sunshineflowerdaisy that’s shocking - how does your trust justify that, it’s such a fundamental part of what an SLT does. What about the evidence base for that? What about duty of care? Regulatory requirements, keeping up knowledge and skills etc. it must be such a difficult way to work and very stressful for staff. I’m a publicly employed SLT and although our levels of service are very low that’s another level.

@Chrissmasjammies how does our trust justify what? Lack of therapy? They don't justify it - we have very minimal funding and staffing and can offer offer what we offer and they are happy with that and refuse all business cases 🤷‍♀️. Are you in the NHS / U.K. as it's quite common across the NHS!

hopelesslydevotedtoGu · 26/09/2022 06:32

Goatinthegarden · 26/09/2022 05:47

This is a fantastic comment.

There is so much to unpick in this conversation, but I’ll try.

Firstly, to operate as a society, everyone has to learn to meet somewhere in the middle. NT children also have to learn difficult skills and suppress certain desires in order to get along with others and operate in this world.

We must get better at accepting differences and accommodating the needs of others. However, I know many children who are ND who have impulses and desires which disrupts the rights and needs of others. I know ND children who hit and bite others through their frustration at not being able to communicate effectively. I have met NT children who believe they must put up with being hit and bitten because they understand their peer is ND and have been taught that they must accommodate them. That is not ok either.

Assuming ND children cannot, or will not, achieve a particular skill is doing them a massive disservice. Every ND child is different and will want to engage with the world in their own way. A child should not be forced to endure learning something that actively upsets them, but taking away opportunities to learn skills that will help them to interact with others is doing them a massive disservice.

Completely agree with this, excellent comments

HoppingPavlova · 26/09/2022 06:30

@Choopi Exactly - nailed it. Same with my (adult) child with ASD plus a trove of other letters. What is being advocated here would have meant they would not have been able to attend school let alone have done well. It would have meant no uni for them. It would have meant they were sitting at home rotting away versus being in a job well suited to them and where they are happy and feel good about using their skills.

In short, if you listen to the ‘no need for anyone neurodiverse to do anything that doesn’t fit them and it’s up to the rest of the world to accomodate them’, then they are seriously fucked as the rest of the world is not going to change. That’s reality.

autienotnaughty · 26/09/2022 05:53

The issue is as a society we have this perception of normal that we expect everyone to be. There's little allowance within that. So rather than accepting people as they are we expect them to change to make us feel more comfortable. Any service that leans away from this gets my vote. With regard to salt my ds had salt involvement for four years. He learnt language through his interests - reading, talking about favourite characters, playing I spy and posting games. There was no imagination games which he wouldn't have been interested in anyway. He mostly enjoyed sessions (unless he really wasn't in the mood)

Goatinthegarden · 26/09/2022 05:47

bippit · 26/09/2022 04:52

ADHD/ASD person married to ASD person here with young baby who is highly likely to be ND. Fully agree with you. There is a difference between owning your neurology and individuality vs massively lacking the skills that would make other people want to be around you. Eventually all these children will grow up and have to function in society.

Neither I nor DH were diagnosed as children and the opportunities we have lost due to our poor social and executive function are incalculable. We eventually learned by trial and error but how I wish I had had explicit instruction and training when I was younger. Of course there are positive and negative ways to do this, of course punishment and criticism are wrong, of course children shouldn’t be told to stop stimming etc.

I am ambitious and I want access to everything society has to offer. To do that I accept I need to explicitly address the areas where I lack the standard wiring. I want my kid to be proud of who he is and to be able to own it, but ideally he will also be able to code switch (“mask”) when needed. NTs also have to do this, albeit usually with less cost and pain. But we play the hand we’re dealt, and not giving kids access to every tool we can is not helpful or respectful to them.

This is a fantastic comment.

There is so much to unpick in this conversation, but I’ll try.

Firstly, to operate as a society, everyone has to learn to meet somewhere in the middle. NT children also have to learn difficult skills and suppress certain desires in order to get along with others and operate in this world.

We must get better at accepting differences and accommodating the needs of others. However, I know many children who are ND who have impulses and desires which disrupts the rights and needs of others. I know ND children who hit and bite others through their frustration at not being able to communicate effectively. I have met NT children who believe they must put up with being hit and bitten because they understand their peer is ND and have been taught that they must accommodate them. That is not ok either.

Assuming ND children cannot, or will not, achieve a particular skill is doing them a massive disservice. Every ND child is different and will want to engage with the world in their own way. A child should not be forced to endure learning something that actively upsets them, but taking away opportunities to learn skills that will help them to interact with others is doing them a massive disservice.