Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

That Neurodiversity is becoming an issue

360 replies

mamainlove · 25/09/2022 21:05

Sorry about the thread title:

I have been umming and arrring posting this thread. I'm not able to be speak about this with family/friends (due to lack of knowledge about the area) and some colleagues, as I may seem like a monster if I shared my views.

But I currently work as a speech and language therapist for NHS. The Neurdiversity trend has really changed our practice which I feel may be detrimental to our young people with ASD.

To point out. The support for neurodiverse peopje is minuscule. Children with ASD receive the least amount of provision and if you have a co-morbid conditions, even less so as it's about changing the environment and not about specialist interventions.

Currently, my team are scrapping some of the "typical" interventions that children with ASD usually receive. The idea behind this is that we shouldn't be using interventions that follow a neurotypical path.. for example, if a child with ASD likes to stim with cars, we shouldn't change this (agree) but we shouldn't model and try to teach the children functional play skills, imaginative play, turn taking, "social skills", conversations as that is neurotypical expectations.

I am happy that there is an awareness of neurodiversity but I'm worried that there's a harm in reducing services for children with ASD. A little bit frustrated with the team as it appears that we all have to conform and it's making me reconsider my career choice.

I'm not sure how I could go around this or is the problem with me?

OP posts:
NDMum · 26/09/2022 14:38

I've just remembered why I deleted my old account, I have no idea why i signed up again!

SheldontheWonderSchlong · 26/09/2022 14:07

Lovelyricepudding · 26/09/2022 12:58

And please don't police my language here because nobody asked me or my ds's opinion when they did the poll that decided what the 'autistic community' does or doesn't say.

When I hear people reference the 'autistic community' now I think 'Borg': You will be assimilated. Just one opinion is allowed as the true opinion of The Community (though what is the right one does vary depending on who is quoting The Community). This in no way reflects the diversity of opinions I hear from autistic individuals in real life - some of whom prefer to be called individuals with autism, aspergers, on the spectrum - and quite a lot call themselves 'aspie'. In reality the 'autism community' is a specific online community that regulates it's membership and the language it uses. Disagree and, like many autistic individuals I know, you will be forced to leave. How this community operates is similar to other social media groups that become echo chambers and is result of how the Internet operates.

Thank you for saying this! When I see in Facebook groups everyone arguing about wording and what the "community" has agreed on I'm struck by the thought that no one has asked me, or anyone ND that I know. I certainly don't feel that being ND makes me part of a community, and I wouldn't want to be a part of a community that polices the language you use to describe yourself anyway!
Borg indeed!!

mrsparsnip · 26/09/2022 13:40

I have not read the whole thread. I am sorry. However, is this really a matter of funding and resources? That is to say, are 'experts' now saying, 'Hey, you're neurodiverse. That's cool. You don't need support; the rest of the world just needs to accept, include, adapt a little!'

If this is the case, then many, many more people will be let down. The people will be let down not because they are ND, but because the world is not inclusive and accepting. My eldest son needed visual supports because he could not communicate effectively or quickly enough to make his needs known. He still needs to signal to others to give him time to process information and to formulate a response. He needs therapies for his autism and for his serious mental illness.

Yes, we should accept neurodiversity, but I think these cuts to services are not primarily based on greater acceptance and inclusion; they are based on finance

PizzaFunghi · 26/09/2022 13:38

Lovelyricepudding · 26/09/2022 12:58

And please don't police my language here because nobody asked me or my ds's opinion when they did the poll that decided what the 'autistic community' does or doesn't say.

When I hear people reference the 'autistic community' now I think 'Borg': You will be assimilated. Just one opinion is allowed as the true opinion of The Community (though what is the right one does vary depending on who is quoting The Community). This in no way reflects the diversity of opinions I hear from autistic individuals in real life - some of whom prefer to be called individuals with autism, aspergers, on the spectrum - and quite a lot call themselves 'aspie'. In reality the 'autism community' is a specific online community that regulates it's membership and the language it uses. Disagree and, like many autistic individuals I know, you will be forced to leave. How this community operates is similar to other social media groups that become echo chambers and is result of how the Internet operates.

I find that even with the forum here for ND people. I occasionally stray in there and usually come right back out. It doesn't reflect me or my views on things and isn't a place I'd want to feel like I belonged. Others are so happy that it is there and get support from it. There are many very different perspectives out there on how/whether to interact or fit in with society, and some of the ones that are becoming most prevalent and known about are not necessarily ones that resonate with me.

Shtfday · 26/09/2022 13:35

@MangyInseam
Do you speak for the deaf community?
We adapt everyday for hearing people. Having Clear speech is actually a disadvantage as even our own families rarely realise how hard we have to work at lip reading and guessing the conversation.
Having clear speech is pure luck and regardless of if speech is clear or not we have all been through countless hours gruelling and unpleasant speech therapy.

My childhood was full of struggles and therapies and believing i was broken as a deaf person. Trying my best to hide my deafness. Not once was I given BSL but this would have actually helped me.

Finding BSL and the Deaf community is life changing and I am proud of my identity and language.

The issue here is NT thinking they know ND and what is best for them. Autistic treatments have left many adults with trauma and not the benefit others perceive. While my speech may be more appealing to hearing ears it wasn't worth the trauma it created but I am seen as an oral success in hearing peoples view. You may believe the treatemnts to make Autistic more like you are great but you dont get to feel the impact on autistic people.

Schools are not inclusive to many people with differences. in fact they likely only cater for 1% the joe blogs average person. There are many ways that schools could change and work for all. Univeral learning for all concept is very interesting.

Many children will benefit from strategies that improve communication. BSL, English, PECS, Brail, ACC, colour overlays, ear defenders, stress toys etc should just be used and available for all. Who knows which children will find things that enhance their lives.

madasawethen · 26/09/2022 13:24

The reality is no one really knows what is right with regards to asd.
Some new bit of research will appear and a clever marketing team will promise its the magic wand everyone is looking for.

Programs need funding and what do they base the funding on?

If this years experts feel doing nothing is best, then funding will be cut.

Its wishful thinking that the world will change for anyone who is different.
It's never going to happen.

The masking no masking has gotten a bit ridiculous.
Every masks. everyone.
We do it to fit in different environments. It's normal and part of human survival.

Nothing really just comes to people. Everything is learned through modeling, trial and error, explicit instructions.

Both my sister and I are autistic. I'm also deaf and have adhd and ocd.

Deaf people are treated like shit. It used to make me furious and go off on people.

Going off on people meltdown really isn't acceptable.

So now I decide if I'm talking or listening to people or not. It's stressful to try to read lips.
Forced eye contact having to stare at people's mouths.
If I don't feel like it, I'll write a note.

So what I'm saying you that work in this area will never find something that will tick all the boxes. Government programs by design want that.

You can argue as much as you like about right ways and wrong ways.
It doesn't matter at all because nobody has any secret knowledge or answers to this.

5zeds · 26/09/2022 13:04

The autistic “community” seems to involve an awful lot of policing and heckling, vetting and excluding….tedious.

Lovelyricepudding · 26/09/2022 12:58

And please don't police my language here because nobody asked me or my ds's opinion when they did the poll that decided what the 'autistic community' does or doesn't say.

When I hear people reference the 'autistic community' now I think 'Borg': You will be assimilated. Just one opinion is allowed as the true opinion of The Community (though what is the right one does vary depending on who is quoting The Community). This in no way reflects the diversity of opinions I hear from autistic individuals in real life - some of whom prefer to be called individuals with autism, aspergers, on the spectrum - and quite a lot call themselves 'aspie'. In reality the 'autism community' is a specific online community that regulates it's membership and the language it uses. Disagree and, like many autistic individuals I know, you will be forced to leave. How this community operates is similar to other social media groups that become echo chambers and is result of how the Internet operates.

pullpullpullthattail · 26/09/2022 12:33

I totally agree @Crunchingleaf. I'm ND (ADHD, not ASD). I have reasonable adjustment at work so I can do my job, but my job is still extremely fucking hard because I have to work in a NT system. I can just about cope, but to do so I need strategies, a toolkit.
It's useful for those with HF ASD to be able to explain how they view and interact with the world so others can begin to understand and adapt, but their experience will be very different indeed to those with significant communication and functional impairments, who without support would not be able to cope and would to put it bluntly be unsafe.

turbonerd · 26/09/2022 12:33

Further, since I didn’t understand social codes and some rules for interaction - and because I «switch off» (and have meltdowns later) for YEARS I put myself in unsafe situations, lost important work opportunities, wasted years with «depression» which was wrongly medicated, and - extreme I know- nearly got killed.

After I started to read and learn coping mechanisms, how to «manage» myself according to the challenges I’ve had, things improved. Strangely, having a severely autistic and LD child has saved me, because I simply do not have to try and function socially to the same extent because she needs a different rhythm in life.

Also, NT people helped me and us to a huge degree.

This «only an autist will know what it is like to be autistic» makes me think No Shit Sherlock; but that doesn‘t mean that other people cannot contribute meaningfully to the discussion.

Crunchingleaf · 26/09/2022 12:25

When reading this thread you have to wonder if ASD is a useful diagnosis at all. The Spectrum is so broad. Especially now that things such as severe, low functioning and high functioning are deemed unacceptable to say by some. The reality is my DS experiences are just that my DS experiences.
DS was a late talker and we followed the HANAN approach. Do people really think this was me teaching him to mask. He was like a new boy when he learned to talk. Finally he had a way to really share his inside world with those around him. Before he learned to talk communication was far more needs based. If he was thirsty he might bring me to the fridge and guide my hand to what he wanted. Or other times he would meltdown and I had figure out what was wrong and I didn’t always get it right. We don’t buy into eye contact being necessary for communication a teacher in early days mentioned it and I knew from reading experience of others that many found it distressing so I told the teacher this.
When my EX wanted us to do something about stopping DS from stimming again I knew from reading of the experiences of others that this was not a good approach. One person’s account broke my heart. The way they stopped hand flapping was by repressing their excitement (they flapped when excited like my son does).
I am not ND as far as I know. I do know my child though. I know when he is struggling and when he is happy. I know he wants to travel the world, live in different countries and although his future career changes all the time he is keen to go to university and get a degree in science. I see my job as his parent to help him reach his potential whatever that may be, teach him skills to make managing the world around him easier.
In everyday life NT people can make some allowances for their ND friends and family. However, they can do this because they know that individual. I can’t use my experience of DS as a roadmap to how to treat autistic kids or adults in general. Realistically there is only so much NT people can do because the spectrum is so broad and the needs of the people within the spectrum are so varied.

turbonerd · 26/09/2022 12:20

ofwarren · 26/09/2022 09:15

I wish I could like this comment a million times

I disagree.
several here have stated they are nd themselves and STILL want help with learning skills, including communication.

several have children on different parts of the spectrum, and it is clear that the help needed and the level of skills they can learn is vastly different depending on how their autism is.
many of us are very worried that the hard fought for support will go away, because of the loud voices saying we should just accept all nd behaviour and accomodate it, rather than teaching the children skills they are able to learn so that they can have as much independence as is safe for them.

licking the tiles in the supermarket is not safe. Not being able to communicate if you are in pain is not safe. Not caring whether you are dressed or naked regardless where you are or with whom, is not safe.

by all means: advocate for high functioning verbal autistic people, but do not let that take away from the ones who both want and need other kinds of help and care.

myleftventricle · 26/09/2022 12:15

BadNomad · 26/09/2022 09:43

Yes, they're talking about their experiences as NT parents raising a child with autism. But they can only assume to know what their children's experience is from an observational point of view. They don't actually know what it feels like to have an autistic brain, they don't know what it feels like to think with an autistic brain, they don't know what it feels like to be autistic.

People will say "my child likes this, that and the other" because it looks like they like this, that and the other, but they can't know that is actually what their child is experiencing. Whereas verbal autistic people can say "actually, I just behave that way because I thought that was what was expected of me." Masking. Acting. Pretending.

I'm not saying only autistic people should have opinions on this, but people are sooo nasty about autistic people with voices because their opinions on autism are so different to their NT opinions on autism.

But the only people who know what it's like to be autistic are people with autism.

This in bucketloads.
And just because some of us with autism can manage to function independently and hold down jobs, doesn't mean that our autism is 'mild' and easy-fucking-peasy. What people don't see is the struggle that goes on in our heads, all the coping mechanisms we have to put in place just to function in a way that's socially acceptable, or how we beat ourselves up because we fail like failures.
Oh, and the whole concept of people shouldn't treat us as if we're special (as PP's friends apparently do) - it's not treating us as if we're special, it's treating us like human beings with feelings! PP's friends are obviously decent and value her. That's what decent people do. You wouldn't refuse to make accommodations for a visually-impaired person or someone in a wheelchair - you'd do it because it would be the right thing to do. So why does being autistic seem to mean that we should have to struggle?
(This thread is yet another frustrating one)

Lovelyricepudding · 26/09/2022 12:05

Only read half the thread but OP I think I get what you mean and agree. There seems be a suggestion NT kids do not need to learn social skills, how to play cooperatively, learn how to speak, how to behave etc etc and therefore somehow to teach anything to autistic children is ableism. That autistic children do not need to grow and learn, to benefit from guidance and therefore any attempt to do so is forcing them to mask and not be their 'authentic selves'. ALL children need to be taught skills.

As for leaving children unable to communicate because they have 'communication difference', sorry but how dare people suggest their 'lived experience' is sufficient to deny the help my child needs! My child had five sounds at 2. These cries of 'ableism' would have denied her investigation and treatment for glue ear and verbal dyspraxia because 'it is her authentic autism'. Her meltdowns were not sensory or masking, they were frustration at inability to communicate. Fortunately we could afford private SALT to overcome this - which she loved going to.

Now she is at the top end of primary I am sure these same voices would tell me I must give into her demands, that her NT brother must learn to live with the house laid out exactly as she wants because autism. No, it is OCD and accommodating these things harms her by making her OCD worse.

Children with autism are still children. They still need to learn stuff and be taught it. They are still affected by other conditions. And they still need to live in the world as it exists.

Kennykenkencat · 26/09/2022 12:03

A family member of dhs with asd was taught by his shrink to parrot 'I don't feel comfortable with that' to anything he didn't want to do because the world should change to accommodate him. So at 16 he didn't feel comfortable at his school anymore and left. He didn't feel comfortable doing anymore education anywhere else. He didn't feel comfortable finding a job. He hasn't felt comfortable doing anything but sitting in front of a computer screen for about 6 years now. A smart person with lots to offer but given no support at all because the world should change for him. So he sits in his room waiting for the world to change

Did no one offer him alternatives. To look around at what he might be interested in instead of just leaving him to figure it out all on his own.

I think this is where teaching children to conform to the NT misses the opportunity for the ND to play to their strengths.

My own Ds is ND and has social anxiety.
He sits in his room on his computer but he learns different things that take his fancy or have suggested he looks into.
His income comes from online working. Stuff he can dip into and out of He can spend weeks on one thing, then he switches to something else, then something else, then back to something he has done before.

It isn’t 9-5 type work and it’s not everyday but he is slowly getting better at things and he likes when he profits from something and sees the money in his account.

Whilst building his confidence in working we are slowly tackling his social anxiety

PeekabooAtTheZoo · 26/09/2022 11:52

Arrgh I am ND not NT. Stupid autocorrect

PeekabooAtTheZoo · 26/09/2022 11:51

I am NT, I had SALT as a child, and I feel the same way as @SideEyeSally and I think learning how to mask so you can choose to do it in some situations is an essential survival skill. I want a rulebook of social norms so I can fit in and make friends and not draw attention to myself and communicate effectively.

I also wonder if you have considered opening a private practice so you can help people in more depth using the approach you prefer?

My son is on the three year waiting list for SLT in my area and I will be mightily pissed off if we get to the appointment and they refuse to actually help him because of some bullshit ideology that only represents people who shout the loudest and therefore don’t need SLT help.

fiftytontheresa · 26/09/2022 11:44

@sunshineflowerdaisy I don't disagree at all about it being about budget cuts and saving money.
But, look at all those on this thread who seem to agree that interventions to support those with ASD to communicate in a NT world are not right? I think there are issues from both sides.

sunshineflowerdaisy · 26/09/2022 11:39

BadNomad · 26/09/2022 10:02

The services being cut is not about autism. It's about money. If it was actually about ASD, they would replace these services and programmes with ones that are more appropriate and useful. But they're not doing that. They're just using the autism community's voice as an excuse to save money.

Exactly.

A lot of people are getting tied up in knots about ASD but in reality (as another SLT in the NHS) services are being cut left right and centre for just about everyone.

Dementia - send an info sheet.
Stammering - redirect to a website and tertiary centres.
Stroke - don't do much rehab, all about the 'functional skills' you have retained.
Dysphagia - no therapy, texture modification and discharge.

Some is ok, some not. It's happening across the NHS.

BryceQuinlanTheFirst · 26/09/2022 11:37

5zeds · 26/09/2022 11:19

My DH is black and I am white, our son obviously is mixed ethnicity. I care passionately about inclusion and fighter against racial prejudice. The people I care most about in the world face racism. But it's not for me to speak over black voices, I don't know more than their lived experience.. But in this scenario you would be talking over (though I think it’s more being allowed to talk at all) someone who had “passed” as white and in some cases hadn’t even known they weren’t until they were adult. Would that individual know more about receiving racism than someone with a black partner and bi-racial child?

As far as the allocation of resources goes, my observation is that the resources available to classic (Kanner) autistics high or low functioning (that is with or without LD) are now shared with a larger group including Aspergics and self diagnosed adults, and that flubbery edged group “nd”, and on the whole the less verbal and less able are now receiving little or nothing. Their situation was always more extreme and the consequences of not receiving support always more terrifying.

I understand what you're saying, what they would know is different. My son was diagnosed autistic at 2, he has a different profile to someone getting diagnosed at 45, but that doesn't mean I wouldn't listen to their experiences of feeling different and struggling.

Choopi · 26/09/2022 11:36

mamainlove · 26/09/2022 09:07

In all honesty. It doesn't sound like you received the support for your ASD when you were younger. If you did have the support you would have been supported to understand and recognise moments of distress and find ways to manage these (with your choice!).

Exactly this. You can go off on one firefly because you don't like my opinion but giving ds the tools to achieve what he want to achieve is important imo. He wants to be with his friends, he wants to go to uni. He wants to work for the UN. He is 15 and well able to articulate what he wants(in 3 different languages). Giving him the tools to achieve these things hopefully means that even if the world doesn't change in the next few years he will still be able to achieve them. Like I said in an ideal world sure things would change but what is ds supposed to do in the meantime. You say you are 45 with no career? Ds doesn't want that for himself, he has seen first hand with dhs relative what happens if you opt out and sit around waiting like Cahms advise. If he can and is willing to learn how to best manage in the world he is actually living in shouldn't he be given the opportunity to do that?

Since we got him help privately I have never seen him happier and more self assured. He has the confidence to know that he can travel 30km away from us alone, navigate buses, navigate ordering a coffee with his friends, navigate shopping etc He can go on a 2 night sleep over at his friends house and come home tired but so proud of himself. Sometimes when he is going off to do something new he looks like he is off to face a firing squad but when he comes home having done it he look like he has won the lotto. Getting help, learning how to manage his overwhelm has allowed him to do this. It's hard, no doubt but for ds he feels it is worth it and it is always him driving it. I am listening to an autistic person, I'm listening to my son and I am responding to his needs.

PizzaFunghi · 26/09/2022 11:32

RelationshipOrNot · 26/09/2022 10:55

Because communication is easier for neurotypical people. Apparently you can readily understand tone of voice, facial expressions, subtext, body language, figurative language, can communicate well by phone, can interpret ambiguous statements using contextual information and usually be right, and so on. Many (most) autistic people have trouble with at least one and in many cases most or all of those things. Why should we have to be the ones to adapt our natural communication process when we have difficulty with communication by definition?

well with this new definition that it's all 'communication differences', then you don't have to. It's up to the person whether they want to communicate with those that do it differently, or not. If they are equally good ways of communicating, then people can equally learn the other person's way, because supposedly one is not easier or better, it's just more common...

It sounds silly to put it that way, because for many people, it's not true. There is a communication difficulty in that it IS harder, not just a difference, and there's no shame in that. I don't see why giving that person the tools to try to understand the rest of the world is such a bad thing.

I also wouldn't want all communication to be adapted; there is a huge richness to communication with tone of voice, expressions, figurative or poetic language, amusing ambiguity etc. As it happens, I don't find those areas difficult at all; my diversity is more sensory or anxiety based. I know that others do, and there are times when adapting language is very helpful. But much richness can be lost at the same time, and sometimes learning to understand what people are saying in that way can be beneficial or even enjoyable.

5zeds · 26/09/2022 11:19

My DH is black and I am white, our son obviously is mixed ethnicity. I care passionately about inclusion and fighter against racial prejudice. The people I care most about in the world face racism. But it's not for me to speak over black voices, I don't know more than their lived experience.. But in this scenario you would be talking over (though I think it’s more being allowed to talk at all) someone who had “passed” as white and in some cases hadn’t even known they weren’t until they were adult. Would that individual know more about receiving racism than someone with a black partner and bi-racial child?

As far as the allocation of resources goes, my observation is that the resources available to classic (Kanner) autistics high or low functioning (that is with or without LD) are now shared with a larger group including Aspergics and self diagnosed adults, and that flubbery edged group “nd”, and on the whole the less verbal and less able are now receiving little or nothing. Their situation was always more extreme and the consequences of not receiving support always more terrifying.

fiftytontheresa · 26/09/2022 11:16

I think the post earlier about waiting for the world to change is pretty spot on. It is changing, but not at a pace that means every child teen (and adult) with autism will be able to reach their true potential.
It's interesting that the OP talks about not being able to document "communication difficulties" , instead must state "communication differences". Yet in many of the posts on this thread by people with ASD, they do mention communication difficulties or finding communication difficult.
The cruel but stark fact is that right now people with autism (or any type of ND) need to be able to function in a world built mainly for NTs, so they need a "toolkit" of how to navigate this. Not by not being themselves, but as an earlier poster beautifully put it, trying to round off the square edges a bit.

5zeds · 26/09/2022 11:02

You can't teach a young child with ASD that "This is orange. Say orange". If they get it at all, they might never generalise that understanding to everything orange, but think you mean that felt pen must be labelled orange. this isn’t my experience at all. In fact colours were entry level to communication in our experience.