Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

That Neurodiversity is becoming an issue

360 replies

mamainlove · 25/09/2022 21:05

Sorry about the thread title:

I have been umming and arrring posting this thread. I'm not able to be speak about this with family/friends (due to lack of knowledge about the area) and some colleagues, as I may seem like a monster if I shared my views.

But I currently work as a speech and language therapist for NHS. The Neurdiversity trend has really changed our practice which I feel may be detrimental to our young people with ASD.

To point out. The support for neurodiverse peopje is minuscule. Children with ASD receive the least amount of provision and if you have a co-morbid conditions, even less so as it's about changing the environment and not about specialist interventions.

Currently, my team are scrapping some of the "typical" interventions that children with ASD usually receive. The idea behind this is that we shouldn't be using interventions that follow a neurotypical path.. for example, if a child with ASD likes to stim with cars, we shouldn't change this (agree) but we shouldn't model and try to teach the children functional play skills, imaginative play, turn taking, "social skills", conversations as that is neurotypical expectations.

I am happy that there is an awareness of neurodiversity but I'm worried that there's a harm in reducing services for children with ASD. A little bit frustrated with the team as it appears that we all have to conform and it's making me reconsider my career choice.

I'm not sure how I could go around this or is the problem with me?

OP posts:
Shtfday · 26/09/2022 22:54

I dont think they want to disconect from autistics with other issues through.
We get this accuesed of this alot in the deaf community that we are against others with other disabilities.
This is realy untrue as the deaf community has vast differences among its members. But it tends to get thrown at us when we question the lack of support deaf children get and the issues with makaton not be adequate. Its a way to shit us up and say our vies, knowlegde and expiences isnt valid.

Many SALT in my experience wont even listen to other perspectives. We have had families being denied support for hearing children unless families agree to implant.

When I read autistic perspectives o dont see anythibg to suggest they are disconecting from autistics with other conditions. Quite to opposite but you have to be open to really try amd see the world through the autistic lense

mamainlove · 26/09/2022 22:37

@Lovelyricepudding

I find it frustrating that Autistic Adults want to disconnect away from people who have Autism and a co-morbid condition (I.e: they are not purely Autistic and it's their LD causing issues).

I've said before on this thread and I'll say it again you can have a minimal verbal child/adult who has non verbal average intelligence and thus the ASD is the primarily reason.

Also, most tests are not equipped to capture the true intelligence of children/adults who are minimally verbal hence why a huge number of children with ASD (who are minimally verbal) are just diagnosed as having LD's without a thorough assessment of their true intelligence.

OP posts:
RainbowZebraWarrior · 26/09/2022 22:11

PizzaFunghi · 26/09/2022 21:28

Finally, a PP said something about rounding off the edges of their square peg to fit the round hole of 'normal life' No, it's about creating a square that neatly fits your peg.

For some people. Not for everyone. Some of us want to learn to get closer to fitting 'normal life' and that is what it might be about for us.

Hence earlier in my post I said not every ND person would feel the same.

I'm sorry that I signed off with that last quote. It went against what I stand for. We are not identikits.

I have a physical disability. I always say that Awareness is good, Belief is better, and Support requires both.

I think the same applies with Neurodiversity. But it absolutely goes to show that not all experiences of any medical conditions are the same. There will always be variations and severities. My apologies.

RainbowZebraWarrior · 26/09/2022 21:59

Shtfday · 26/09/2022 21:45

To fit a square peg in a round hole you have to shave parts of the person away this is damaging to the person. If you make the hole square through the amazing thing is both the square and the round peg will fit.

Agree. As per my previous post.

However, I totally acknowledge that people are at completely different stages of acceptance and reality of their own circumstances.

TrainspottingWelsh · 26/09/2022 21:51

Shtfday · 26/09/2022 21:45

To fit a square peg in a round hole you have to shave parts of the person away this is damaging to the person. If you make the hole square through the amazing thing is both the square and the round peg will fit.

Unfortunately it isn’t always possible or realistic to make the hole square. Of course if we put a bit of effort into really trying it would improve, but it’s never going to be a solution in itself.

Shtfday · 26/09/2022 21:45

To fit a square peg in a round hole you have to shave parts of the person away this is damaging to the person. If you make the hole square through the amazing thing is both the square and the round peg will fit.

5zeds · 26/09/2022 21:32

Part of the issue is a determination to separate learning disabilities from autism. So the problems faced by those with comorbid autism and LD are dismissed as being caused by the LD and therefore not relevant to the discussion of autism.
Sadly I think the original intent of the diagnosis of autism to highlight that these individuals might appear extremely limited but have normal or above normal capacity, is being lost.

PizzaFunghi · 26/09/2022 21:28

Finally, a PP said something about rounding off the edges of their square peg to fit the round hole of 'normal life' No, it's about creating a square that neatly fits your peg.

For some people. Not for everyone. Some of us want to learn to get closer to fitting 'normal life' and that is what it might be about for us.

FurryDandelionSeekingMissile · 26/09/2022 21:23

5zeds · 26/09/2022 20:51

i think if their are limited resources there are always going to be tensions. I don’t really understand why eloquent autistics would want to stop less verbal autistics from being represented in discussions.

Of course there are going to be tensions, especially if there are increased numbers of people wanting access to the same thing, but I'm not convinced that's what's going on with the SALT and related provision.

There are always movements for change, a wide range of people within those movements, and extremists within those movements.

Going back to the psychiatric survivors and the recovery movement that I mentioned earlier, there were people within those movements who wanted to abolish the system altogether. No psychiatrists, psychiatric drugs, psychiatric hospitals, forced treatment, no nothing. For anyone. Ever. There were also those that wanted very different systems, some quite expensive, and those who wanted reform of the existing ones

Taken over a broad span of time, those who wanted an end to all of it were probably a very small minority within the psychiatric survivor movement as a whole. They were part of a larger movement that wanted to think again about the best ways to think about and manage the kinds of problems that lead to psychiatric involvement, and had experienced the problems with the big mental hospitals and lifelong pathologisation.

It could potentially look like a big moneysaver for those who run services to shut down the hospitals, sack all the psychiatrists, and stop spending money on antipsychotics, and the best part is that you can say, "We're liberating people, giving them exactly what they asked for!" They can't do it completely, of course, because untreated mentally ill people are inconvenient to the general public, and because only a small minority even if psychiatric patients ever wanted the system completely gone. But what they have done is cut mental health inpatient provision way lower than what's needed, and cut outpatient provision to pretty much psychosis and imminent suicide only, all while trumpeting it as liberating and beneficial.

With ASD provision, many of the extremists aren't even those who would've been subject to the treatment they're campaigning against, which makes it more irritating, and makes it more tempting to blame the campaigners. But we know from other fields that it's perfectly possible for services to say "Yes, the extremists want all mental hospitals closed, but the extremists don't have the full picture, and we know hospitals are sometimes necessary, so we're not doing that". The problem is that it's just too tempting for Tories to cut and cut, and point to a group that's asking for something a bit like those cuts.

I'm no neurodiversity activist, and have reservations about parts of the theory and the way that these are expressed in online ND communities. I'm especially resistant to ideas which downplay the needs of some autistic people in favour of euphemistic words and other distortions of reality. But I'd like it if we could find ways for people, and carers of people, with difficulties in this broad area of autism to find commonalities, and I think it would be a mistake if we allowed services' cynical cherrypicking of neurodiversity ideas in pursuit of cost-cutting to drive the wedge even deeper.

NoYouSirName · 26/09/2022 21:22

I do see my autism as a disability. I just don’t see disability as equating to deficit or something negative. I see disability as difference. Deviation from the norm.

I don’t feel that disabled people including autistic people shouldn’t be supported. What I have an issue with is that the end goal is often to pass as neurotypical.

Accommodating disability costs money, as op very rightly said. Truly inclusive education costs money. Workplace adjustments cost money. Enabling autistic people to thrive costs money.

TrainspottingWelsh · 26/09/2022 21:19

Imo the problem isn’t whether nd people should or shouldn’t learn particular skills, or nd social conventions, or whom is best equipped to advocate amongst/ for nd people. It’s the fact society as a whole views us as a homogeneous group.
Yes perhaps a small variation between rainman and a small child in full meltdown, but otherwise we’re often judged to share similar personality traits, let alone any understanding that nd itself is a huge spectrum.

The important thing is why any nd person is learning something. As the mildest and least controversial example I can think of, it’s important I use coping strategies to control my overwhelming impulse to run with my shopping trolley and skid at speed the full length of supermarket aisles. Not because nd societal norms dictate 41yr old women don’t do that shit, but because I might hurt someone. And if I couldn’t control myself, or I found masking my impulse more distressing than avoiding the situation entirely it would be reasonable to limit myself to baskets and online orders.

Of course, most situations are far more important and complex, and don’t usually have a clear cut choice between two simple options. But the basic principle still applies, why are we doing it and is the outcome beneficial for that individual? However that won’t happen as long as there are assumptions we’re all basically the same person with variations on where we max out on a bizarre linear development chart that doesn’t exist.

Lovelyricepudding · 26/09/2022 21:10

5zeds · 26/09/2022 20:51

i think if their are limited resources there are always going to be tensions. I don’t really understand why eloquent autistics would want to stop less verbal autistics from being represented in discussions.

Part of the issue is a determination to separate learning disabilities from autism. So the problems faced by those with comorbid autism and LD are dismissed as being caused by the LD and therefore not relevant to the discussion of autism.

5zeds · 26/09/2022 20:51

i think if their are limited resources there are always going to be tensions. I don’t really understand why eloquent autistics would want to stop less verbal autistics from being represented in discussions.

Lovelyricepudding · 26/09/2022 20:43

changingnames20 one example of that was the reaction to that genetics study. Loads of adult/self diagnosed autistics condemning it out of hand. The 'autism community' demanded it be shut down. They completely disregarded the fact that autism is a feature of many genetic conditions - conditions that come with a range of other features including intellectual disability but also cardiac abnormalities, feeding or digestive issues, epilepsy etc which could all benefit from early identification and sometimes this may be life-saving for the individual. My daughter has a genetic condition and when identified the first thing the geneticist did was refer us to cardiology. Without the genetics we would have had no idea she was at risk of heart problems.

5zeds · 26/09/2022 20:40

There are of course those with severe language disorders associated with ASD without cognitive impairment but in my experience (limited I do admit as I have not worked much in disability) they are clinically rarer. are they? My understanding was that all iq levels were seen in this group and while there were more autistics with LD hi IQ individuals were not a rarity.

moominda · 26/09/2022 20:40

Changingmames20, great post and you're an amazing mum! I'm so sorry you were let down so much.

I have a pupil who's autistic and fairly able (MLD) but also has a very challenging speech difficulty. I can't believe he wasn't given a talker earlier. He finds it so complicated though that he's been using pecs more again recently. It's so frustrating for him. When he's calm he's so focussed and works so hard. When upset and frustrated it's so hard to help him and he'll loose the whole day. It has impeded his ability to play with his peers too as they've matured.

FurryDandelionSeekingMissile · 26/09/2022 20:39

5zeds · 26/09/2022 20:06

@FurryDandelionSeekingMissile i don’t agree but I’m not sure where to start really. For example a lot of public attention would go to this "new", more numerous group except they aren’t as far as I’m aware more numerous they are just louder, often refusing space to the indigenous population as so many invaders have before. How has the inclusion of aspergics and self diagnosed helped autistics (whatever their iq)? The resources I was talking about are for example support groups and local authority activities which are now almost entirely populated by a small subset of new style autistics many of whom are fiercely protective of their position and like cuckoos push their less able autistic natives out. Few understand anything about the lives and experiences of more classic autistics and have no intention of finding out but STILL want to be the only voice in the room.

It’s not about blaming more eloquent autistics it’s about describing what is happening and refusing to politely slink away.

5zeds if you're comparing the number of people who would've received a classic/Kanner autism diagnosis in the 80s and these days get an ASD diagnosis, with the number of people who would fit in your grouping of "Aspergics", self-diagnosed people, and the big broad church of ND, then I'd be extremely surprised if the former group was bigger.

The reason Asperger's syndrome was absorbed into autism in the DSM 5 (and I think ICD 11) is that it was determined that the only substantive difference between people with Asperger's and people with high-functioning autism was the existence or lack of speech delay in early childhood, which, in the support groups and activities you're talking about, would be increasingly irrelevant with increasing age.

If it's true that in your area, support groups and local authority activities that were previously set up for and used by people with "classic" autism and their families are now inaccessible or unhelpful for those people because of an influx of people with low autism-related support needs and people who've seen a TikTok and decided they're #actuallyautistic, then that's a problem, and either criteria should change or additional services should be provided.

I understand to some extent the frustration you're talking about — a similar thing has happened with public discourse on mental health, where a lot of time and attention and resources are pushed into restoring the economic productivity of people with mild-to-moderate depression and anxiety, while people with, say, schizophrenia, are ignored as much as ever.

I find your language a little odd, though, talking about invaders and natives and indigenous autistics. I'm unsure what you're trying to say. It certainly sounds like you're blaming this group for the reduction in services, presumably including the SALT provision the thread is about. But I don't see how that would work for SALT in the way you're saying it does with your local groups. What OP is describing with the SALT provision and similar services is far more likely to be cost-cutting with neurodiversity concepts as an excuse, rather than self-diagnosed or "Aspergic" toddlers invading Autismia, claiming the territory, and pushing out the indigenous Kannerite natives.

RainbowZebraWarrior · 26/09/2022 20:38

So many things at play here (hence so many differing - and quite heated - opinions)

  1. Underfunding and lack of understanding. The terminology and diagnostoc criteria change regularly. Some old school psychiatrists use the old diagnostics. This means some children and adults will slip through the net / be misdiagnosed / given incorrect support and coping strategies.
  1. Not all ND people present with the same symptoms / traits. This is fairly obvious. There are 3 recognised levels now. Yes, it's a spectrum, but some comments I've had directed at me personally (and seen on here) like "We are all on the Spectrum" are simply unhelpful.
  1. It's unhelpful to alientate a group of people who are disabled (and some have physical disabilities as well as ND issues) It is not a competition. Sadly, I've seen more than one post about how NT kids and adults are being dismissed as they "aren't disadvantaged" Always remember that if you are able bodied and NT, that while you will experience difficulties in your life, would you trade your job with a pittance of DLA or equivalent financially while also taking on board the disabling element of not being able to work due to crippling conditions you wish you didn't have?

Finally, a PP said something about rounding off the edges of their square peg to fit the round hole of 'normal life' No, it's about creating a square that neatly fits your peg.

moominda · 26/09/2022 20:35

Name changed as I do teach children with autism, from those who have barely any communication skills and significant learning difficulties to those who could be in mainstream but they need a lot of support with their emotional regulation skills. (Autistic and 'with autism' is interchangeable esp in our setting where we may have children with other diagnoses too. We also have staff with autism.)

I do agree with the OP; I appreciate that it's exceptionally complicated however. It's hard for you to communicate the wider implications of what you've been delivering for years and why, verses reducing this provision. Much of what you do supports what they'll access at school.

When I first started teaching in my setting I didn't appreciate how much sp and Lang contributed, nor even the OTs.

Yes we need to be flexible to individual need (the OTs are helpful here and we follow certain teaching approaches v different to mainstream- eg one of my pupils spent most of the year playing acid house on his keyboard before he started to join in my lessons. He eventually went to a mainstream school with a unit and did amazingly well!) but educational settings currently do have a focus on social interaction and communication, emotional regulation and the way staff transactionally support these (many places are following SCERTS)

I am concerned that I've seen a reduction over the last 10 years in both ratios for some cohorts as well as salt and OT support. My niece in the USA is autistic but wasn't diagnosed in order to remain in the mainstream system. The amount of salt and OT input she had (via health insurance) was staggering in comparison to what my pupils get access too.

Class sizes are much bigger here too.

Keiran the autistic advocate is good to listen to; he also is very clear that autism is a disability and shouldn't be seen as anything other than.

Changingnames20 · 26/09/2022 20:11

@5zeds completely agree. I’ve started to join some forums just so that I can speak up for autistic kids who aren’t ‘as able’. And it’s shocked me even more, most of the influential forums don’t have a clue about ‘classic’ autism. Absolutely no clue and yet they have all the power and influence of services and research on ‘classic’ autism. They are not just pushing any ‘severity’ of autism out - I don’t think most of the movement is really even aware of what it is anymore.

Changingnames20 · 26/09/2022 20:08

There are of course those with severe language disorders associated with ASD without cognitive impairment but in my experience (limited I do admit as I have not worked much in disability) they are clinically rarer.

My son had almost zero understanding of language (not even his own name) and only 10 words (non functional - numbers) at age 4 years. NO services offered after his official diagnosis at 3 years. If I had not given up my job and helped him, I’ve not idea what would have happened to him. He was labelled with learning disabilities - (which is fine he does have these) - which the neurodiversity movement won’t touch with a barge pole. It’s seen as ‘not autistic’ but most autistic children do have significant learning disabilities.

In reality my son was very able but had not been given the tools. I taught him basic maths myself - and now he is on par with his peers. He had to be supported to do this - with specialist ways of getting his interest and engagement, doing it in very small steps. No way could he get this from a school or the environment as it moves too fast for him.

He couldn’t use a spoon or be toilet trained until very late. Again - this is not something he would have just ‘picked up’.

This is the absolute tragedy of less services, less quality services, and the very strong wave of neurodiversity which says ‘just change some of the sensory environment but don’t help with anything else because you will be labelled harming’. That so many kids I believe have these abilities to function.

I do blame services AND the neuro diversity movement. I had hoped that the movement would be positive but in reality it’s turned into a very influential group who only see autism through the lens of adult functioning, talking people. And who cancel parents and services quite fervently. This is not a minority people!

5zeds · 26/09/2022 20:06

@FurryDandelionSeekingMissile i don’t agree but I’m not sure where to start really. For example a lot of public attention would go to this "new", more numerous group except they aren’t as far as I’m aware more numerous they are just louder, often refusing space to the indigenous population as so many invaders have before. How has the inclusion of aspergics and self diagnosed helped autistics (whatever their iq)? The resources I was talking about are for example support groups and local authority activities which are now almost entirely populated by a small subset of new style autistics many of whom are fiercely protective of their position and like cuckoos push their less able autistic natives out. Few understand anything about the lives and experiences of more classic autistics and have no intention of finding out but STILL want to be the only voice in the room.

It’s not about blaming more eloquent autistics it’s about describing what is happening and refusing to politely slink away.

stickygotstuck · 26/09/2022 15:22

PMK

FurryDandelionSeekingMissile · 26/09/2022 14:54

As far as the allocation of resources goes, my observation is that the resources available to classic (Kanner) autistics high or low functioning (that is with or without LD) are now shared with a larger group including Aspergics and self diagnosed adults, and that flubbery edged group “nd”, and on the whole the less verbal and less able are now receiving little or nothing. Their situation was always more extreme and the consequences of not receiving support always more terrifying.

@5zeds I'm not sure what resources formerly available to "classic" autistics you believe are now being shared with a wider group of "Aspergics" and self-diagnosed adults, but I assure you, there is almost zero support available for any adult who would fit the latter category, and precious little for children and young people in that group either.

Services to help autistic people with high support needs, non-speaking autistic people, or autistic people with learning disabilities (and their parents or carers) are not set up to provide assistance that is useful to adult autistic people with low support needs, without LD, and who can speak — that's never what those services have been for, and should not and cannot be what they are used for.

I don't understand how you think those resources are being used by adults with low support needs and inconspicuous communication difficulties. It's true that there's some very, very limited assistance coming from other pots for that group, but often what's asked for is things like adjustments from private organisations.

If a "high-functioning" autistic adult does, say, manage to somehow get a grant from Access to Work, and at the same time the government cuts SALT provision for non-speaking autistic children, it's unfair to blame the autistic employee for taking the children's resources, even if the government justifies those swingeing cuts by pointing to that piddling A2W grant as part of their spending on autism.

Autistic adults who generally seem to be sort of coping don't get a lot. Sometimes actually less than the standard NT person — even things like NHS mental health services that everyone is supposed to be able to access can be blocked off to you, if you have an ASD level 1 or Asperger's or high-functioning autism diagnosis — mainstream services will tell you they can't meet your needs because of your autism, but there is no service for autistic people in that category who have no LD.

When it comes to campaigning, awareness, public understanding of what ASD is — yes, I think some of the public discourse around neurodiversity is not reflective of the reality for many autistic people, and privileges a certain type of story from a certain type of person.

It's understandable that, since there's a whole subset of the autistic population who have a subtler presentation and have only been properly identified in the last thirty years (Asperger's syndrome entered the ICD in 1992), a lot of public attention would go to this "new", more numerous group, and especially, to the most extreme versions of the new conceptualisations of autism some of them put forward (since the extreme versions of things always get attention). And radical neurodiversity proponents who would advocate for abolishing all interventions to help autistic children communicate with the NT world would be the very extreme end.

I think it's playing into the hands of Tories and cost-cutters to blame either autistic activism, or high-functioning resource-hoggers, for the appalling cuts in services for autistic people with very high support needs and those who look after them.

User0610134057 · 26/09/2022 14:44

This is really sad and worrying
it sounds like what was being offered wasn’t always quite right but to take that away completely and not replace it with another approach is not right either.

as a mother of one (possibly 2) autistic dds, no I don’t want them to be who they’re not or be encouraged to mask in a way that’s detrimental to them. But part of me also feels they need to exist in this world and so it might be helpful for them to practice and be equipped with skills to help them survive/get on.