Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

That Neurodiversity is becoming an issue

360 replies

mamainlove · 25/09/2022 21:05

Sorry about the thread title:

I have been umming and arrring posting this thread. I'm not able to be speak about this with family/friends (due to lack of knowledge about the area) and some colleagues, as I may seem like a monster if I shared my views.

But I currently work as a speech and language therapist for NHS. The Neurdiversity trend has really changed our practice which I feel may be detrimental to our young people with ASD.

To point out. The support for neurodiverse peopje is minuscule. Children with ASD receive the least amount of provision and if you have a co-morbid conditions, even less so as it's about changing the environment and not about specialist interventions.

Currently, my team are scrapping some of the "typical" interventions that children with ASD usually receive. The idea behind this is that we shouldn't be using interventions that follow a neurotypical path.. for example, if a child with ASD likes to stim with cars, we shouldn't change this (agree) but we shouldn't model and try to teach the children functional play skills, imaginative play, turn taking, "social skills", conversations as that is neurotypical expectations.

I am happy that there is an awareness of neurodiversity but I'm worried that there's a harm in reducing services for children with ASD. A little bit frustrated with the team as it appears that we all have to conform and it's making me reconsider my career choice.

I'm not sure how I could go around this or is the problem with me?

OP posts:
Lovelyricepudding · 27/09/2022 07:36

So examples on this thread of trying to separate LD and autism in people with comorbid conditions, or minimise their LD.

30% of people with LD have autism - this isn't a missed diagnosis where they are really actually highly intelligent. They actually do have LD. Nor can you separate and treat the two separately. Look at LD through an autistic lens? What about looking at autism through a LD lens? Where comorbid ND conditions exist they exist within a single person and they interact. They are not separate conditions but different aspects of the whole. And that person needs treating as a whole.

Shtfday · 27/09/2022 07:03

@BadNomad

Very well explained.

It is very fruatrated when both NT and ND children are not getting support they need. SALT is being cut and reduced left right and centre and has been happening for years.

Shtfday · 27/09/2022 06:49

5zeds

Actually i do see autistics in my spaces. I have have a lot of contact with all areas of the autistic community, including non verbal and complex needs.
And actually encouraging not using ear defenders still happens too frequently.

Is there enough support for any individuals, absolutely not. The current support is terrible but thar doesnt mean we should be not questioning and speaking up about inappropriate types of support.

Neome · 27/09/2022 05:54

I am the parent of a neurodiverse child.

This thread is important. It is painting a picture that is barely or rarely seen.

It has made me think ‘yes that’s true’ and ‘it’s a relief to know I’m not the only person who worries about that’ and ‘I’m not sure about that idea, oh I see that’s what they mean, that’s an important point’.

Every post I have read reveals someone who has really suffered.

Fundamentally it is about justice and about who is valued.

FurryDandelionSeekingMissile · 27/09/2022 02:37

I get frustrated by a lot of the neurodiversity orthodoxy as well… but they would be pretty much powerless to effect change if they were asking for things that cost more money. They're listened to when it saves money to listen to them.

So look to the decision-makers, what things they choose to listen to and what they choose to do, first. A corrupt or evil leader will pick the advisers that are useful to him. Knock out the advisers, he'll just get different ones and find something useful in them instead. He won't start behaving any better.

FurryDandelionSeekingMissile · 27/09/2022 02:26

I have a different perception of what's happening @Changingnames20, and I realise that for some reason the way I'm explaining my point of view on this topic is not persuasive.

Yes, it must be frustrating to see a vocal group of autistic people with less obvious difficulties advocating for conceptual changes and service changes that, if widely adopted, would not adequately serve others with higher levels of need for support. I think some of the ideas of the neurodiversity movement are well-meaning but short-sighted, some of them helpful to some and unhelpful to others, some too extreme and absolutist, some reflective of particular types of experience. And some of those ideas can, if selected carefully, be used as justification to reduce or remove services for people who really need them.

But if those advocates all blinked out of existence tomorrow, services for children who cannot yet communicate effectively would still be cut. A different excuse would be found, but they would be cut.

If the people that were getting heard were a different group, advocating for a totally different set of things, the powers that be would just find something in those ideas to justify cuts instead.

If, though, we had a government and health/developmental/social/educational services determined to invest in autistic people — all of them — and to find the best ways to provide the support they needed to develop to their fullest potential and lead the best possible lives, and the support their families need, then those services could equally well look to the neurodiversity movement for things that would augment, enrich and improve services for autistic people whatever their support needs.

I don't think the problem here is some autistic people and their ideas.

I think the problem is a lack of will to fund services, and the neurodiversity movement is just being used as a handy justification to cut services while appearing to be inclusive and responsive to "the community".

So they get away with it again, blame is efficiently directed in a convenient direction, and the rift between different groups of people with links to autism grows even bigger.

BadNomad · 27/09/2022 02:24

I think most NT people just have a different view of what autism is. It seems like you think "classic" autism is the only true autism and the rest are just autism-lite. Diet autism. Autism zero. It is all still autism, whether you like it or not. Our brains are different to NT brains.

My brother is autistic with a moderate learning disability, he will never live independently. I'm autistic with ADHD, I am his carer. My mother was autistic with nothing else (that we're aware of). You can be autistic and have other conditions that other autistic people don't have. But you know what we all have in common? Autism. Not learning disability. Not learning difficulties. Not dyspraxia. Autism. People are not less autistic because they do not have a learning disability. The learning disability means your son will have needs that I won't have. Equally, my ADHD means I have needs that your son might not have (unless he has ADHD then excuse me I missed that).

My friend has ADHD, but no autism, and although we have a lot of similarities, my issues are different because of my autism. But we both still have ADHD. I was never treated for my ADHD growing up and that really fucked up my life, so I do have sympathy for your son being let down because of the lack of support for his LD. But it really isn't an autism/ND issue that people's needs aren't being met. Your son is being dismissed because he is autistic, and so no one is addressing his LD needs. That is where your fight is. The same with every other co-existing condition. Autistic people with ADHD still need to have their ADHD addressed. It doesn't get absorbed by an ASD diagnosis. It does people no favours to lump their specific needs in with their autism.

I don't really agree with people self-identifying as autistic because that is open to exploitation. But it is understandable when the waiting list for assessment is 5 years. There is a lot wrong in this world. But autistic people are not your enemy.

IdisagreeMrHochhauser · 27/09/2022 02:10

I watched The Reason I Jump yesterday which really shows how much non speaking autistic people are underestimated. They said that now lack of language is being treated as a motor issue rather than a lack of cognition. Sorry if this has already been covered. Haven't RTFT.

Changingnames20 · 27/09/2022 01:55

@BadNomad The neurodiversity movement is actively attacking many forms of therapies, with very little to back this up except a lot of frenzied ‘it’s making them neurotypical’. That they are now attacking even speech therapy shows how extreme it has got. Professionals and researchers are now more concerned about appeasing the ideology than the child sat right in front of them.

…and neurodiversity it is doing nothing to support parents who are fighting even for the therapies that are ‘acceptable’ (which is less and less because there is now less research into what helps - neurodiversity is clamping down on anything that isn’t wholly positive and affirming).

The neurodiversity movement is also actively encouraging such a broad definition of autism that self diagnosed people are welcomed, and diagnostic criteria have been subjected to fierce criticism and so the diagnosis itself means less and less for people like my son. It has a direct impact. There is also less ‘room’ as there are now lots of people who would never have been diagnosed - and if they were it would be recognised that they had a very different presentation in Asperger’s. If you think these are similar you really haven’t met many ‘classic’ autistic people.

So on at least 4 counts the neurodiversity movement is actively restricting the tiny pool of services that did exist - and giving them the excuse not to do those that did.

At least before the neurodiversity ideology there was space for parents like me to unite, to fight for better services, and for people to understand.

So I am someone who is really quite angry at the neurodiversity movement and the negative impact it is having for my son. It’s very real and tangible.

It’s a great shame as if the movement had put those most severe in the forefront and actually really listened to them and their parents, and were humble enough to admit that no, not everyone is the same, and yes some kids really are more severe. And that the diagnosis is meant to reflect a degree of severity and difficulties with functioning and therefore access effective support. But however this isn’t about classic autism at all or my son at all. Sadly.

BadNomad · 27/09/2022 01:43

@Changingnames20 do you really think if the "ND movement" collectively said we "all autistic children should receive one-to-one therapy support for the first 10 years of their lives" that would happen? Of course it wouldn't. That would cost money. Doesn't matter that it would help tens of thousands of children. It's about money. The ND movement doesn't have any more power over this than parents do. The bottom line is cost. Not people.

BadNomad · 27/09/2022 01:37

Changingnames20 · 27/09/2022 01:25

@BadNomad
No autistic people like my son get zero services to be helped for anything. You are carrying on the very strong but completely unfounded narrative that there is a bunch of services out there making autistic kids stop stimming.
This isn’t.

Parents like me are tired of having to fight for a scrap of help. The neurodiversity movement has done ZERO to help me fight for help for my son.

The lack of services is not caused by the neurodiversity movement, though. Yet that's who people are directing their anger at here. It should be aimed at the government. The people holding the purse. They are the ones responsible for services or lack of and they are the ones who will scapegoat ND people because it is convenient.

Changingnames20 · 27/09/2022 01:35

Are you seeing non-verbal or minimally verbal autistics in your spaces? Why not?

Exactly. I went to a big autism conference recently. It was really smug about how it was totally by and for autistic people Not one single autistic person had communication difficulties. Not one had motor skill difficulties. No one talked about functional living, independent living, safety, safeguarding, autistic interests and passions, developmental delays, managing day to day living.

Absolutely nothing. From two whole days.

Absolutely appalling. When you think that approximately 1/3 of autistic people have communication difficulties, 1/3 learning disabilities, 1/4 epilepsy, 1/3 motor skill delays, (don’t quote me, very rough but about right!).

WHERE are these autistic people? Disappeared in our homes, with less opportunities, less help, less understanding, squashed out of their own diagnosis.

Gagaandgag · 27/09/2022 01:25

I think research ableism OP.
Also ABA therapy - I think your team are ensuring they aren’t moving towards this.

I think you and your colleagues just need to speak to parents and children/young adults and get their own personal views on what they would like support with!

Changingnames20 · 27/09/2022 01:25

@BadNomad
No autistic people like my son get zero services to be helped for anything. You are carrying on the very strong but completely unfounded narrative that there is a bunch of services out there making autistic kids stop stimming.
This isn’t.

Parents like me are tired of having to fight for a scrap of help. The neurodiversity movement has done ZERO to help me fight for help for my son.

Changingnames20 · 27/09/2022 01:19

Part of the issue is a determination to separate learning disabilities from autism. So the problems faced by those with comorbid autism and LD are dismissed as being caused by the LD and therefore not relevant to the discussion of autism.
Sadly I think the original intent of the diagnosis of autism to highlight that these individuals might appear extremely limited but have normal or above normal capacity, is being lost.

This is the nub of the problem. Well said!

To support someone we have to name it, recognise it and understand what is needed. Sadly I think we are actually getting worse as professionals and in the neurodiversity movement at understanding autism. In fact it is now unrecognizable - people who are diagnosed autistic can be so far apart as to make the whole diagnosis meaningless. When this happens, there is no support.

BadNomad · 27/09/2022 01:17

Btw us "HF autistics" aren't naturally "HF". Our ability to interact with the world is something we have learned from being shat on by the world. They are survival techniques we've picked up ourselves from going through negative experiences all our lives. All these loud mouth HF autistic people you are slamming have likely been victims of NT negativity all their lives, so yeah they want to fight on behalf of other autistic people because they don't want others to go through the shit they went through at the hands of this ignorant world. They are not the enemy of your children. But do carry on with your negativity towards them. Do keep on trying to repress them and any other minority that doesn't fit your normal.

BadNomad · 27/09/2022 01:14

Don't you think it would be useful for autistic children to being taught about NT people? How NT people think. What needs NT people have. Why NT people behave the way they do. And therefore what adaptations you as an autistic person need to make if you want to interact with NT people so they can be comfortable and understand you. Then the rest of the time you can just be your normal autistic self without shame and feeling dysfunctional. NT Awareness training or something.

But instead, we try to train autistic people to look and act like they're NT so they can survive in this world. It's fucked up.

TooHotToRamble · 27/09/2022 01:03

Shtfday · 26/09/2022 23:14

It was once considered a fantasy to expect ramps and wheelchair access it is now a legal requirement. Always perfect of course not but a marked improvement.

It wasnt that long ago that being Gay resulted in being crimilised and punished. Now it is an accepted part of life.

In wales children caught speaking wales would be humiliated by being made to wear a wooden sign around their neck and physically punished.

Many things that once were" just they way it is " and thankfully the world has adapted.

Why cant we strive for a society that makes small changes that benefit others. It really doesnt harm NT to have ear defenders in the classroom, or to have a child ricking in school. Does it really matter if Bob doesnt make eye contact with sam?

No, but when an autistic child wants but can't maintain any friendships that's a much bigger issue. My child went being lonely and unhappy to thriving following social skills and other support.

It's all well and good hoping the world will change for you and maybe it will over time, my child didn't have time to wait for that. He needed to know how to navigate the world he is in right now.

And tbh I can't see how people form friendships changing any time soon. People want to spend time with people whose company they enjoy. And they want those relationships to be relatively easy. People don't want to have to work at friendships. I can't see that changing ever.

TooHotToRamble · 27/09/2022 00:46

I dread to think where my autistic DS would be now without support developing social communication and other skills. It's not about masking, it's about teaching skills that autistic children struggle to just "pick up" from typical social interaction. I found things that NT children would learn from the reactions of others he needed to be explicitly taught. It would be going autistic children a massive disservice to remove that support because it's a "difference" and "not a disorder".

As Russell Barkley says about ADHD: you can't argue for support and funding and additional services at the same time as saying that ADHD is a super power and not a disorder. This kind of rhetoric really harms ND people.

As you say it looks like this is already starting to be used as an excuse to remove services.

TimeforZeroes · 27/09/2022 00:21

You are asking the person with supposedly “impaired communication” to change their communication to make the person with supposedly “unimpaired communication “ feel better, without expecting the person with the supposedly better communication to change at all.

Such a good point @Awayyego and perfectly illustrative of how it’s the minorities who are forced to shoulder the labour for assimilating.

LivingMyBestLie · 27/09/2022 00:08

Totally irrelevant when all you get is two assesments per year and a referral to online tools.

NHS SALT provision is a joke. So whether or not toys are changed is totally irrelevant to the outcomes for the child

5zeds · 27/09/2022 00:01

When I read autistic perspectives o dont see anythibg to suggest they are disconecting from autistics with other conditions. Quite to opposite but you have to be open to really try amd see the world through the autistic lense and yet many people on this thread have said that’s their experience. Perhaps it’s YOU who needs to see the world through an autistic lense. Are you seeing non-verbal or minimally verbal autistics in your spaces? Why not?

user1477391263 · 26/09/2022 23:48

Why cant we strive for a society that makes small changes that benefit others. It really doesnt harm NT to have ear defenders in the classroom, or to have a child ricking in school.

Well, isn't it lucky that nobody's actually suggesting that people can't wear ear defenders, then?
The conversation here is about an increasing tendency to not bother about stuff like language therapy or play therapy for children who would really benefit from this.

Shtfday · 26/09/2022 23:14

It was once considered a fantasy to expect ramps and wheelchair access it is now a legal requirement. Always perfect of course not but a marked improvement.

It wasnt that long ago that being Gay resulted in being crimilised and punished. Now it is an accepted part of life.

In wales children caught speaking wales would be humiliated by being made to wear a wooden sign around their neck and physically punished.

Many things that once were" just they way it is " and thankfully the world has adapted.

Why cant we strive for a society that makes small changes that benefit others. It really doesnt harm NT to have ear defenders in the classroom, or to have a child ricking in school. Does it really matter if Bob doesnt make eye contact with sam?

user1477391263 · 26/09/2022 23:01

To fit a square peg in a round hole you have to shave parts of the person away this is damaging to the person. If you make the hole square through the amazing thing is both the square and the round peg will fit.

This ignores the fact that even neurotypical people typically modify their behaviors and actions to suit their surroundings and society, and parents teach neurotypical children to do this as well.

The naturalistic fallacy has already been discussed on this thread.

Swipe left for the next trending thread