Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

That Neurodiversity is becoming an issue

360 replies

mamainlove · 25/09/2022 21:05

Sorry about the thread title:

I have been umming and arrring posting this thread. I'm not able to be speak about this with family/friends (due to lack of knowledge about the area) and some colleagues, as I may seem like a monster if I shared my views.

But I currently work as a speech and language therapist for NHS. The Neurdiversity trend has really changed our practice which I feel may be detrimental to our young people with ASD.

To point out. The support for neurodiverse peopje is minuscule. Children with ASD receive the least amount of provision and if you have a co-morbid conditions, even less so as it's about changing the environment and not about specialist interventions.

Currently, my team are scrapping some of the "typical" interventions that children with ASD usually receive. The idea behind this is that we shouldn't be using interventions that follow a neurotypical path.. for example, if a child with ASD likes to stim with cars, we shouldn't change this (agree) but we shouldn't model and try to teach the children functional play skills, imaginative play, turn taking, "social skills", conversations as that is neurotypical expectations.

I am happy that there is an awareness of neurodiversity but I'm worried that there's a harm in reducing services for children with ASD. A little bit frustrated with the team as it appears that we all have to conform and it's making me reconsider my career choice.

I'm not sure how I could go around this or is the problem with me?

OP posts:
mamainlove · 27/09/2022 21:04

@5zeds

It appears to be a common place for a child, with significant language difficulties, to be given a diagnosis of a Learning Disability, without proper assessment. I have come across many reports which state the child she 'learning difficulties' but not report from an Ed psychologist or assessment to asses the learning needs, have been undertaken.

OP posts:
5zeds · 27/09/2022 21:03

Seeing them for direct therapy would immensely improve their language disorder. The whole 'well we need to teach them functional skills in the everyday environment' is more or less just treating their social communication difficulties aka 'Autism' but not the language disorder- it may have some impact but you won't see a huge impact. Children with a comorbid language disorder (depending on severity) do require intense, tailored and direct therapy to remedy or improve their language disorder.
this is my experience too, but I am aware that my young person has a very severe language disorder and so I don’t know how sensible it is to generalise our experience.

mamainlove · 27/09/2022 21:02

I feel a bit sad reading comments by SALT's like @Neurodiversespeechies. Have you not read the up to date research on treating and regimes for language disorders? There is a saying, mainly for children with Down Syndrome but I think I've read the same thing for ASD, that they need at least 2 years of 1:1 direct therapy in order for it to generalise in their everyday environments.

OP posts:
mamainlove · 27/09/2022 20:58

Neurodiversespeechies · 27/09/2022 18:59

No, what I’m saying is, in order to support those non verbal teenagers with autism, the approach I will take is different and will often not involve what you perceive as ‘direct therapy’.

in order to make progress and develop functional communication skills those teenagers need to be in a home and school environment where they are provided opportunities to practise their communication within everyday activities. Good quality coaching for parents and school staff is what will achieve this.

Seeing them 1:1 for ‘direct therapy’ would not achieve functional communication skills that would generalise to every day activities.

The type of autism they have, combined with their learning difficulties means they need to be supported in a very specific way. Thanks to that support they are making progress.

Seeing them for direct therapy would immensely improve their language disorder. The whole 'well we need to teach them functional skills in the everyday environment' is more or less just treating their social communication difficulties aka 'Autism' but not the language disorder- it may have some impact but you won't see a huge impact. Children with a comorbid language disorder (depending on severity) do require intense, tailored and direct therapy to remedy or improve their language disorder.

OP posts:
mamainlove · 27/09/2022 20:54

@Lovelyricepudding

So you consider Autism as a condition that needs treated, like anxiety? In this situation I would say they were an autistic person who needs to be treated for anxiety. If they had learning disabilities and autism as well as anxiety then I would say they are an autistic LD person who needs treated for anxiety. In both cases their anxiety treatment needs to be tailored to the person. You cannot discount their autism or their LD whilst treating their anxiety. Or treat them the same as someone or have only one of LD and autism

Do I think Autism needs to be treated? My analogy was quite simplistic and it depends whether you see Autism as a disability vs difference or both. But you may have an Autistic child who... I don't know.. need support navigating and understanding different social situations or recognising/figuring out emotions and that same Autistic individual has anxiety. What I am saying is that I would treat both conditions wherever lies their difficulty. However, whatever treatment I give of course would affect my style of therapy in which I have to take into account the persons Autism/LD- therefore therapy is individualised and personalised.

But what usually happens in services- including SALT. If you have an Autistic individual who has mental health needs, some services would deny the referral from Autistic patients as their Autism is seen as the main culprit for their mental health needs and if they have some support with their 'Autism' then that will solve the mental health needs ifyswim.

whatever and Ifyswim. I think we are on the same page but probably I'm not explaining myself well.

OP posts:
5zeds · 27/09/2022 19:17

Out of curiosity have all these individual teens been given cognitive tests they can access or is it assumed they have these difficulties in addition to their communication disability and autism?

5zeds · 27/09/2022 19:13

I’m sorry I appear to have used a term that means something more specific than I intended. I meant “delivered for that individual” not what I think you mean which I gather is “direct therapy” means coaching of that individual???

Neurodiversespeechies · 27/09/2022 18:59

No, what I’m saying is, in order to support those non verbal teenagers with autism, the approach I will take is different and will often not involve what you perceive as ‘direct therapy’.

in order to make progress and develop functional communication skills those teenagers need to be in a home and school environment where they are provided opportunities to practise their communication within everyday activities. Good quality coaching for parents and school staff is what will achieve this.

Seeing them 1:1 for ‘direct therapy’ would not achieve functional communication skills that would generalise to every day activities.

The type of autism they have, combined with their learning difficulties means they need to be supported in a very specific way. Thanks to that support they are making progress.

5zeds · 27/09/2022 18:06

Hmmm I’m not sure what you’re trying to communicate @Neurodiversespeechies are you saying you think nonverbal autistics don’t need as much input from salt because you won’t see them communicate independently but only with focused training for their support workers?

goldfinchonthelawn · 27/09/2022 18:06

AntlerRose · 25/09/2022 21:22

I think learning how a conversation works is a useful skill for a child who might not pick it up naturally.

I dont mean 'nice weather today' but role playing and rehearsing buying something in a shop or order a meal.

Is that the type of thing you mean you are stopped from doing?

I agree. I think there's an important differentiation between encouraging children to mask and teaching them things they don;t pick up instinctively. DS (ASD) is now an adult and is always asking me "How do you know if someone...?' He just doesn't pick up non verbal cues but that doesn't mean he doesn't want to interact socially and fit in. Ideally without masking but with sufficient learned behaviour which he has chosen to learn.

Neurodiversespeechies · 27/09/2022 18:00

5zeds · 27/09/2022 16:10

You cannot discount their autism or their LD whilst treating their anxiety. Or treat them the same as someone or have only one of LD and autism. I think what makes me uncomfortable is that the speech and language practitioners seem to be treating the other comorbidities rather than the language disorder. How can we have people who’s primary difficulty is verbal communication being given no direct therapy? I think it’s always been a pretty poor offering but agree with the OP that the idea that you shouldn’t help because it’s squashing ND is unhelpful.
I don’t think many actually have any idea what it’s like to live unable to even say yes or no, or use a name, or a verb, or a pronoun, or past tense. I think there is an assumption that these individuals don’t have anything to say or contribute and have some blanket condition called “learning disability”. That isn’t correct. They could be as able, thoughtful, or brilliant as you on your best day.

I think what’s also confusing you here is that a ‘primary difficulty with verbal communication’ may not mean a child needs or could benefit from direct therapy.

non- verbal children aren’t always the ones that can benefit most from ‘direct therapy’. I have spent this afternoon in a classroom of preverbal teenagers with ASD coaching the adults in the class on how to support 3 of them to use iPads to communicate. For these three teenagers the biggest difference I can make is getting their environment right so they are getting opportunities to practise their communication skills in functional situations throughout the school day. While their main difficultly may be that they don’t speak their other difficulty (autism) means they would struggle to generalise those skills into a classroom if I taught them in a stand-alone therapy session.

Tomorrow I will be doing direct therapy with kids. Those kids can speak but have speech sound difficulties. I can work on those difficulties in sessions and, because it’s their only difficulty, they will be able to generalise those improvements in their speech into there everyday life.

Speech therapy isn’t about giving the most support to the seemingly most needy child. It’s about giving them the support that will actually make a difference in everyday life and not just in therapy sessions.

5zeds · 27/09/2022 17:05

@Lovelyricepudding sorry if you read it that way, I meant the exact opposite.

Lovelyricepudding · 27/09/2022 17:04

5zeds why are you conflating learning disability with being non-verbal? They are very different things.

5zeds · 27/09/2022 16:10

You cannot discount their autism or their LD whilst treating their anxiety. Or treat them the same as someone or have only one of LD and autism. I think what makes me uncomfortable is that the speech and language practitioners seem to be treating the other comorbidities rather than the language disorder. How can we have people who’s primary difficulty is verbal communication being given no direct therapy? I think it’s always been a pretty poor offering but agree with the OP that the idea that you shouldn’t help because it’s squashing ND is unhelpful.
I don’t think many actually have any idea what it’s like to live unable to even say yes or no, or use a name, or a verb, or a pronoun, or past tense. I think there is an assumption that these individuals don’t have anything to say or contribute and have some blanket condition called “learning disability”. That isn’t correct. They could be as able, thoughtful, or brilliant as you on your best day.

Lovelyricepudding · 27/09/2022 15:51

So in essence you do have to treat the two conditions. For example, a person may have ASD and anxiety. I'm not just going to treat the difficulties with the ASD as intervention would only resolve the difficulties the individual has with their Autism and would not make impact with the anxiety- it may help a little but you won't see much or any impact. The person would also need tailored intervention for anxiety.

So you consider Autism as a condition that needs treated, like anxiety? In this situation I would say they were an autistic person who needs to be treated for anxiety. If they had learning disabilities and autism as well as anxiety then I would say they are an autistic LD person who needs treated for anxiety. In both cases their anxiety treatment needs to be tailored to the person. You cannot discount their autism or their LD whilst treating their anxiety. Or treat them the same as someone or have only one of LD and autism.

mamainlove · 27/09/2022 13:45

Lovelyricepudding · 27/09/2022 07:36

So examples on this thread of trying to separate LD and autism in people with comorbid conditions, or minimise their LD.

30% of people with LD have autism - this isn't a missed diagnosis where they are really actually highly intelligent. They actually do have LD. Nor can you separate and treat the two separately. Look at LD through an autistic lens? What about looking at autism through a LD lens? Where comorbid ND conditions exist they exist within a single person and they interact. They are not separate conditions but different aspects of the whole. And that person needs treating as a whole.

Well... I'm simplistic terms and it is a bit confusing but they are two (or more) different conditions occurring within the same being/same time as that is what a co morbidity is.

So in essence you do have to treat the two conditions. For example, a person may have ASD and anxiety. I'm not just going to treat the difficulties with the ASD as intervention would only resolve the difficulties the individual has with their Autism and would not make impact with the anxiety- it may help a little but you won't see much or any impact. The person would also need tailored intervention for anxiety.

However, with an individual who has Autism and anxiety, it may affect my style of treatment of what I would typically use for a person w/o Autism who has anxiety. So maybe CBT won't be useful, but I may explore different approaches, using visuals, different modes of delivering information, I may look into animals assisted therapy. But this would not affect the dosage of the intervention I deliver..

The above is very common as to why people with Autism/Autistic people are denied services or lack of. Their comorbidity conditions (I.e. depression, mental health, LD, language disorder, dyspraxia etc) are not properly treated or explored as services feel that Autism is the culprit.

OP posts:
mamainlove · 27/09/2022 13:32

So you feel that the non-verbal aspect is a direct result of autism, rather than a co-morbid language disorder?

It is a co morbidity and it's not a causal relationship (I.e. she is non verbal because she has Autism) but having a primarily social communication difficulty (Autism) does make you more likely to have anxiety, mental health, speech and language difficulties etc. because of the overall nature of the condition (how the brain process sensory information and longitudinal difficulties with social communication, interaction etc). Sort of like a domino affect.

OP posts:
Crunchingleaf · 27/09/2022 11:21

@NoYouSirName I found your post interesting as you are coming from this from a couple of perspectives both ND and as a parent of ND children.
Masking is an interesting subject all be it tempers can get flared. Many of us behave differently in different environments. Kids tend not to want to stand out especially when teenagers and I observe the same with my own son. The older he has gotten the more important it is to him to be one of the lads. The teenage need to fit in is a developmental phase that thankfully eases off as you move out of those teenage years.
I get the impression that masking means different things to different people. Sometimes people seem to mean not being able to stim is masking, however if you actually were to ask parents of autistic children and teenagers how many of them are actually discouraged away from this this. For others masking seems to mean everything they say and do when outside the house.
Some consider therapy to teach masking and others describe masking as a natural behaviour done by everyone that can. It honestly makes parenting a teen who wants desperately to fit in and have friends very tricky.

NoYouSirName · 27/09/2022 10:55

*I find it frustrating that Autistic Adults want to disconnect away from people who have Autism and a co-morbid condition (I.e: they are not purely Autistic and it's their LD causing issues).

I've said before on this thread and I'll say it again you can have a minimal verbal child/adult who has non verbal average intelligence and thus the ASD is the primarily reason.

Also, most tests are not equipped to capture the true intelligence of children/adults who are minimally verbal hence why a huge number of children with ASD (who are minimally verbal) are just diagnosed as having LD's without a thorough assessment of their true intelligence.*

I don’t want to disconnect myself from non verbal autistic adults. I’ve found this thread really interesting as well as having my brain totally fried by it, trying to understand and assimilate all the different perspectives.

So you feel that the non-verbal aspect is a direct result of autism, rather than a co-morbid language disorder?

One of my children (likely autistic, no formal diagnosis) has situational mutism. She is non verbal outside the home. Her speech is normal with us at home. I have considered that to be comorbid anxiety rather than a result of autism… but I’m open to changing my understanding.

NHS SALT wouldn’t see my child at all. Said it was anxiety related rather than functional speech and that it was a Camhs issue. She saw a private SALT who introduced a small steps programme, which did help her. I’m glad she could access that. Her own goal is to attend mainstream school even though we are happy for her not to and even wonder whether it’s in her interests. She wants to become a doctor and I hope she can. Academically she is able. She will need to be able to speak to people to do that. There are only so many adjustments that can be made… she will at least need a way of communicating with patients.

My understanding of my own neurodivergence has changed massively in the five years since my first diagnosis of autism (followed later by adhd). It will no doubt evolve and change further.

I don’t consider myself better placed to speak for non verbal autistic people than their own parents. I do have autism in common with them even though their support needs aren’t all the same. We will have things in common. If any of my children were completely non verbal I would also fight for the things that would improve their lives. Nothing I’ve said is meant to suggest that it’s wrong to do that.

I think understanding of autism amongst professionals has a long way to go and I don’t agree with reward and punishment based systems that reward neurotypical behaviour. I feel that they cause untold internal stress for an autistic person.

i also observe in my neurodivergent kids that they don’t want to stand out, they try to blend in and that doesn’t come from me.

It is complicated. But as an autistic adult, I have never coped with work until diagnosed and adjustments made. I have communication and sensory needs that need to be met before I can do a job despite high academic intelligence. My grades at school were excellent but my mental health was poor. My efforts to fit in led me to feel defective and ‘wrong’, and led to self harm, eating disorders, mood disorders, suicidal behaviour, even mild psychotic symptoms. Masking can cause immense stress.

So it’s all really complicated. I’ll be name changing soon as this is so outing.

Pinchpot · 27/09/2022 10:18

Changingnames20 · 27/09/2022 01:55

@BadNomad The neurodiversity movement is actively attacking many forms of therapies, with very little to back this up except a lot of frenzied ‘it’s making them neurotypical’. That they are now attacking even speech therapy shows how extreme it has got. Professionals and researchers are now more concerned about appeasing the ideology than the child sat right in front of them.

…and neurodiversity it is doing nothing to support parents who are fighting even for the therapies that are ‘acceptable’ (which is less and less because there is now less research into what helps - neurodiversity is clamping down on anything that isn’t wholly positive and affirming).

The neurodiversity movement is also actively encouraging such a broad definition of autism that self diagnosed people are welcomed, and diagnostic criteria have been subjected to fierce criticism and so the diagnosis itself means less and less for people like my son. It has a direct impact. There is also less ‘room’ as there are now lots of people who would never have been diagnosed - and if they were it would be recognised that they had a very different presentation in Asperger’s. If you think these are similar you really haven’t met many ‘classic’ autistic people.

So on at least 4 counts the neurodiversity movement is actively restricting the tiny pool of services that did exist - and giving them the excuse not to do those that did.

At least before the neurodiversity ideology there was space for parents like me to unite, to fight for better services, and for people to understand.

So I am someone who is really quite angry at the neurodiversity movement and the negative impact it is having for my son. It’s very real and tangible.

It’s a great shame as if the movement had put those most severe in the forefront and actually really listened to them and their parents, and were humble enough to admit that no, not everyone is the same, and yes some kids really are more severe. And that the diagnosis is meant to reflect a degree of severity and difficulties with functioning and therefore access effective support. But however this isn’t about classic autism at all or my son at all. Sadly.

You said everything I wanted to say .

Thank you

Crunchingleaf · 27/09/2022 10:10

Why cant we strive for a society that makes small changes that benefit others. It really doesnt harm NT to have ear defenders in the classroom, or to have a child ricking in school. Does it really matter if Bob doesnt make eye contact with sam?

I have a teenage autistic son. His experience of Therapy is not the same as those older then him. He has never been encouraged in any setting to make eye contact, he need for movement has been accommodated in such a way not to disturb his class mates, kids who need ear defenders use them.

He has needed help along the way with communication and social skills. He struggles to make friends but really likes having friends. I think it’s wrong to decide for pre verbal or non verbal kids that actually they have a communication difference and not recognise it as a disability so that therapy isn’t warranted for that child.

Lovelyricepudding · 27/09/2022 08:33

It is also important to remember neurodivergent doesn't just mean autism. Neurodivergent includes:
Dyslexia, dyspraxia, dyscalculia, autism, add, adhd, fasd, cerebral palsy, epilepsy, learning disability, high IQ, stroke, dementia, aquire brain injury, schizophrenia, BPD, genetic syndromes, attachment disorder. It could also be said to include depression or left-handedness.

Shtfday · 27/09/2022 08:26

@Neurodiversespeechies

Yes, this is good explanation.
The rewarding eye contact i see so often and it really doesnt sit right.

Neurodiversespeechies · 27/09/2022 08:07

Have name changed for this as my colleagues and I seek out social media posts like this….

As a neurodiverse salt this is an issue very close to my heart.

My feeling is it’s all about balance. We’ve overused PECS for years and I’m not convinced it leads to real functional communication and it can be distressing for certain children (due to the withholding items). Therefore where I can see an alternative is going to work (eg core boards) I’ll choose to introduce that over pecs.

having said that pecs still has its place in my practise and I’m glad that my trust allows me to use to clinical judgement and use it with children where it will still be useful. I will also be using my clinical judgement to stop using pecs with those children if they don’t make progress or are upset by it.

The same goes for intensive interaction and attention autism. I will continue to use these where they don’t cause distress for the child. Not only to benefit the child themselves but also to ensure they are experiencing fun play and learning experiences that are autism friendly and allow the adults who work with them to build positive relationships with them. I so often go into classrooms where ASD children aren’t experiencing the positives of school because adults have no idea how to engage with them at their level.

OP’s comment about not using visual timetables has confided me. Visuals are there to add much needed structure reduce the anxiety of not knowing what’s coming next rather than to try and force a child into doing anything.

The only things that are a down right now for me are things like targeting eye contact, not talking about special interests at all or things like imaginative play where the child is not (and possibly never will be) developmentally ready for it.

I really hope it’s possible to be a neurodivergent affirming speech therapist without being rigid on what tools we use or don’t use. It’s about finding what’s best for each child, family and educational setting.

5zeds · 27/09/2022 07:42

@BadNomad Btw us "HF autistics" aren't naturally "HF". Our ability to interact with the world is something we have learned from being shat on by the world. I think you are talking about a different definition of HF to me. In my posts when I talk about HFA I am talking about autistic individuals who had delayed/disordered language and IQs in the normal to above normal range. The autistics you are describing I don’t think are the same population.